Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
Everanewbie · 11/11/2021 12:26

@IntermittentParps

If not persuaded, then, well, the people we are honouring fought and died for your right to disagree. Just as I, and others have the right to feel, and express that we find white, or any other colour poppies disrespectful and inappropriate. OK, so there's your answer. I wasn't suggesting wearing a white poppy to 'deliberately cut out the charitable donation to the RBL, or to appear different'. I find those suggestions insulting and offensive.
I find the white poppy offensive, but there we go. There is no right to not be offended.

I don't advocate forcing you to wear a poppy, or donate to the RBL, I don't have that right. Nor do I have the right to force you to remove your white poppy if you choose to wear one, or silence your voice expressing why you make that choice.

But I do have the right to tell you that I think you're wrong, and that I disagree with your views and choices, and that I find them highly disrespectful, ungrateful and inappropriate. And I'm using this forum to do so.

Pacmann · 11/11/2021 12:22

Unfortunately Armistice and Remembrance days create a focus on the honourable side of wars (thinking about the sacrifice of those that die) and unfortunately a dangerous minority latch on to them as a symbol of false patriotism and jingoism. Which in itself encourages people to consider war as often necessary, which it very rarely is.

So because a very very small minority of right wing nutters have allegedly used the symbolism of red poppies (not seen it myself) no one should bother? Behave.

DameAlyson · 11/11/2021 12:19

WW1 should never have been started, it was a pointless and unnecessary war.

The UK didn't start it. We could perhaps have stayed out of it, if we'd been prepared to ignore our treaty obligations to a small country that was invaded and its civilian population subjected to atrocities.

SilverBirchWithout · 11/11/2021 12:04

[quote Owlmeow]@SilverBirchWithout how do you think both world wars would have ended if no one was sent to fight? Do you think no one would have been maimed or injured?[/quote]
WW1 should never have been started, it was a pointless and unnecessary war. WW2 was an exception and I agree it was necessary, however historians believe that the rise of Hitler and the nazi party was a direct result of WW1.
Some wars are indeed necessary, but unfortunately time and time again politicians fail to understand the direct and indirect consequences of their actions, failing to consider what will happen after the war is ‘won’. War is very very rarely the correct answer to a political impasse.
Many of us could see the consequences of the Iraq war, and Afghanistan. If as much effort (& indeed remembrance) was put in to the aftermath and peace we would need far fewer wars.
Unfortunately Armistice and Remembrance days create a focus on the honourable side of wars (thinking about the sacrifice of those that die) and unfortunately a dangerous minority latch on to them as a symbol of false patriotism and jingoism. Which in itself encourages people to consider war as often necessary, which it very rarely is.

FlickerBeat · 11/11/2021 12:03

[quote elbea]@PinkPlantCase today’s armed forces keep you safe every single day from threats that you have absolutely no awareness of.

Wearing a poppy isn’t just remembering the sacrifice of people that died 100 years ago, it’s about remembering people like Guardsman Matthew Talbot who died in Malawi whilst protecting elephants from poachers. It’s remembering Pte Watson-Pickering who died on Salisbury Plain just a few weeks ago. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of soldiers currently serving in Estonia on a peacekeeping mission to stop Russia annexing Estonia. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of the soldiers that left their families for months on end during the pandemic to serve this country in a time of need.

The white poppy belittles their sacrifices, on their website it says the white poppy is to ‘…challenge attempts to glamorise or celebrate war.’ Remembering and acknowledging people’s sacrifices isn’t celebrating war.[/quote]
today’s armed forces keep you safe every single day from threats that you have absolutely no awareness of

100% agree. So many people simply do not understand. And I say this as someone whose OH currently serves (though not army).

BessieFinknottle · 11/11/2021 11:46

I agree completely lottiegarbanzo.

lottiegarbanzo · 11/11/2021 11:45

What I find really, truly astounding here, is the number of people who seem to believe that their particular interpretation and use of the poppy symbol is the only interpretation and use of that symbol, or the only valid one.

The poppy's symbolism is complex, has changed a great deal over time and is read differently in different places.

Anyone who is not at least aware of that (not necessarily knowledgeable, just aware) is not really in a position to take part in a discussion on the symbolism of the poppy.

'I use it to show this'. Ok then. That's one person's anecdote. No less, no more.

BlueBellsArePretty · 11/11/2021 11:33

I don't see the red poppy displayed at other times other than on relevant monuments. I'm not sure what you are referring to exactly

@mustlovegin are you not on any social media? A sizeable proportion of those sharing their quite odious views will have their profiles decorated with poppies.

IntermittentParps · 11/11/2021 11:30

If not persuaded, then, well, the people we are honouring fought and died for your right to disagree. Just as I, and others have the right to feel, and express that we find white, or any other colour poppies disrespectful and inappropriate.
OK, so there's your answer. I wasn't suggesting wearing a white poppy to 'deliberately cut out the charitable donation to the RBL, or to appear different'. I find those suggestions insulting and offensive.

BessieFinknottle · 11/11/2021 11:28

There is no expectation or obligation to wear a red poppy, that’s freedom of choice for you, something those who died in The world wars sacrificed themselves for.

Bet you anything though that if push came to shove and god forbid there is another war and we are invaded NI, and any other areas concerned, would be more than happy to have the support of the British Army to get rid of the invaders

@Chloemol

There is that expectation I'm afraid. Lots of the posters on here have said as much. The OP and her children will be judged if they don't wear red poppies and judged if they wear white ones instead.

As far as Ireland goes, the invaders were the British. And no, it's not ancient history.

Yellow85 · 11/11/2021 11:25

As a child of an army veteran I wear my poppy proudly. I’ve seen first hand many of my DH’s fellow veterans turn to alcohol, struggle with depression and PTSD and the monies raised from poppy sales have personally supported them. I hung in a few quid for them. They didn’t join the army because they loved war, for the most part they joined because they were guaranteed to be fed.

Wear a poppy, don’t wear a poppy, but everything else aside I suppose anyone who is helping these folks.

Everanewbie · 11/11/2021 11:18

@IntermittentParps

So why do you need a white poppy if you feel that a proper one expresses your feelings? Is it to deliberately cut out the charitable donation to the RBL, or to appear different?

A white poppy is not not 'proper'.

There is judgement of people who don't wear a red one, which I object to and which is the reason I would not wear one.

Ok, maybe 'original', 'conventional', 'RBL' even 'red'. Whatever term you'd prefer me to use.

I suspect I agree with you in terms of so called 'poppy fascism' where people/businesses feel obliged to show their support. I don't agree with that because it loses its meaning if you're forced into it. If people don't agree with the cause and the symbolism I would personally try to discuss the matter and win them over to my way of thinking with the history, the symbolism, and what it means to me and the veterans that I had the honour of knowing.

If not persuaded, then, well, the people we are honouring fought and died for your right to disagree. Just as I, and others have the right to feel, and express that we find white, or any other colour poppies disrespectful and inappropriate.

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 11:18

it has instead been coopted by the far right

In your head. The 'white poppy' lot are the ones politicising the symbol

in the other 51 weeks of the year it is displayed by those very comfortable in expressing their pro establishment, pro military, pro Brexit, anti immigration, racist and misogynistic views

I don't see the red poppy displayed at other times other than on relevant monuments. I'm not sure what you are referring to exactly

FOJN · 11/11/2021 11:18

It's possible to oppose a government's decision to send our troops into conflict whilst being grateful to our servicemen at the same time, they don't make the decision to be put in harm's way. I would imagine those most strongly opposed to war are the people most at risk of dying in one and the people who care about them.

People are free to perceive poppies as political and divisive but they are not free to tell others what their motives are for wearing one. I will continue to support our servicemen even when I hate the decisions our government makes.

The UK is not going to be attacked by another state as long as it has nuclear weapons, the Second World War will not be repeated.

I'd take a look at developments in China.

Aurora791 · 11/11/2021 11:16

Believe me, nobody who has served recently would say that the death of young men (and women btw) is glorious, but there is certainly honour in their actions, as long as you separate the politics of the conflict (which is a political decision) from the actions of those who volunteer to serve (and have no say in whether that is UK flood defences, covid ambulances, supply chain Lorry driving, or deployments overseas).

The armed forces are essentially a massive insurance policy. You hope to god you don’t need them, but in time of crisis, no matter what that crisis is, they are there to help, regardless of their own individual political persuasion. Like another poster rightly said, saying ‘gentle hands’ (which essentially equates to diplomacy) sometimes doesn’t work, and where would we be without an armed forces then.

BlueBellsArePretty · 11/11/2021 11:13

For the most part the red poppy is no longer just a symbol of remembrance for the fallen, it has instead been coopted by the far right. In the week running up to remembrance it may be used by those genuinely wanting to remember the dead soldiers and their sacrifice but in the other 51 weeks of the year it is displayed by those very comfortable in expressing their pro establishment, pro military, pro Brexit, anti immigration, racist and misogynistic views.

Chloemol · 11/11/2021 11:12

[quote elbea]@PinkPlantCase today’s armed forces keep you safe every single day from threats that you have absolutely no awareness of.

Wearing a poppy isn’t just remembering the sacrifice of people that died 100 years ago, it’s about remembering people like Guardsman Matthew Talbot who died in Malawi whilst protecting elephants from poachers. It’s remembering Pte Watson-Pickering who died on Salisbury Plain just a few weeks ago. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of soldiers currently serving in Estonia on a peacekeeping mission to stop Russia annexing Estonia. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of the soldiers that left their families for months on end during the pandemic to serve this country in a time of need.

The white poppy belittles their sacrifices, on their website it says the white poppy is to ‘…challenge attempts to glamorise or celebrate war.’ Remembering and acknowledging people’s sacrifices isn’t celebrating war.[/quote]
@BessieFinknottle

This with spades on

Chloemol · 11/11/2021 11:11

@BessieFinknottle

People here are mistaken if they think wearing red poppies aren't a political and divisive symbol. I know it's natural for British people to want to support their army, but there are many people living in the UK from places where British soldiers were the invaders, a colonial power, and a destructive force. They have absolutely no wish to support the British army.

@BessieFinknottle

Tosh. Wearing a red poppy is not making a political statement, nor is it divisive. Millions wear the poppy, attend parades etc to remember those who sacrificed their lives and those millions include people from the very many different nationalities who live in this country, including those were the British were ‘ invaders, a colonial power and a destructive force’

Time has moved on, I suggest you do

Northen Ireland is part of the UK, @Chloemol.
I can assure you that wearing a red poppy is divisive there.

Why do you think the footballer James McClean gets in trouble every year for this?

The poppy represents support of the British army as well as being a memorial of the dead of the world wars. That's the problem, it means more than one thing.

I've no issue with people wearing a poppy if they choose btw, but dislike the obligation and expectation that you must.

@BessieFinknottle

There is no expectation or obligation to wear a red poppy, that’s freedom of choice for you, something those who died in The world wars sacrificed themselves for.

Bet you anything though that if push came to shove and god forbid there is another war and we are invaded NI, and any other areas concerned, would be more than happy to have the support of the British Army to get rid of the invaders

Owlmeow · 11/11/2021 11:09

@SilverBirchWithout how do you think both world wars would have ended if no one was sent to fight? Do you think no one would have been maimed or injured?

ArcherDog · 11/11/2021 11:08

[quote elbea]@PinkPlantCase today’s armed forces keep you safe every single day from threats that you have absolutely no awareness of.

Wearing a poppy isn’t just remembering the sacrifice of people that died 100 years ago, it’s about remembering people like Guardsman Matthew Talbot who died in Malawi whilst protecting elephants from poachers. It’s remembering Pte Watson-Pickering who died on Salisbury Plain just a few weeks ago. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of soldiers currently serving in Estonia on a peacekeeping mission to stop Russia annexing Estonia. It’s acknowledging the sacrifices of the soldiers that left their families for months on end during the pandemic to serve this country in a time of need.

The white poppy belittles their sacrifices, on their website it says the white poppy is to ‘…challenge attempts to glamorise or celebrate war.’ Remembering and acknowledging people’s sacrifices isn’t celebrating war.[/quote]
Absolutely this.

I bet these people ‘against war’ were the same people who were angry when the forces left Afghanistan last month, and wanted them to stay and evacuate more people.

SilverBirchWithout · 11/11/2021 11:07

@Lifeisaminestrone

I’m finding this thread on Rememberance Day wholly inappropriate.

We are remembering those who lost their lives or livelihoods who fought with fear and courage.

A number of these comments are inappropriate.

It is not about the politics of war but the individuals on both sides involved.

So are we not permitted to think about all those who didn’t feel courage? Seriously, there is nothing courageous about sending young people to be killed, maimed, or mentally scarred. Bleeding out on the bare ground crying out for their mother in some pointless ill-conceived conflict. My great uncle died in WW1 at the age of 21, his body never traced, yes I remember him, and the waste of his life. My grandfather never recovered mentally from his experiences in WW1 and eventually committed suicide which emotionally scarred my mother. Death in war is nothing to do with courage. I find your comments offensive actually.
mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 11:07

The white poppy belittles their sacrifices, on their website it says the white poppy is to ‘…challenge attempts to glamorise or celebrate war.'

Utterly fed up of the 'let's challenge everything' mob

Owlmeow · 11/11/2021 11:07

@PlanDeRaccordement

it's hard to imagine a scenario where another state attacks the UK homeland in a serious way, knowing that there would be not only a significant conventional response, hopefully a much bigger NATO response, and the possibility of escalation to nuclear war.

@dreamingbohemian. Actually the U.K. is concerned about Putin and Russia. That’s why Johnson has increased your nuclear stockpile from 120 war heads to 260. Mostly submarine, not ICBMs. Russia has been “testing” the U.K. of late. Russian war ships have deviated from channel shipping lands and cruising into U.K. waters forcing U.K. to scramble military ships to “escort” them. Russian fighter jets have similarly cheekily flown into U.K. airspace and again UK has scrambled jets to escort them away. Russia controls the natural gas supply necessary to heat UK homes...which is a critical infrastructure weakness.

If it came to it and Russia attacked the U.K., you would be overwhelmed quite quickly. Their navy far outnumbers yours as does their army and air forces. The nuclear deterrent isn’t much of one as Russia could easily kill everyone in the British isles in less than an hour with their nuclear weapons. So U.K. is not going to launch anything nuclear at Russia as they’ve made it clear to do so would result in the “assured total destruction” of the U.K.

The only thing holding them off is probably the US being a close ally who has shown they will defend the U.K. if needs must. Which is why Russia has been interfering in US and U.K. elections with an end goal of disrupting that relationship, along with their other geopolitical goals.

Haha do you actually believe the crap you spout? Surely not!
IntermittentParps · 11/11/2021 11:06

So why do you need a white poppy if you feel that a proper one expresses your feelings? Is it to deliberately cut out the charitable donation to the RBL, or to appear different?

A white poppy is not not 'proper'.

There is judgement of people who don't wear a red one, which I object to and which is the reason I would not wear one.

PlanDeRaccordement · 11/11/2021 11:03

it's hard to imagine a scenario where another state attacks the UK homeland in a serious way, knowing that there would be not only a significant conventional response, hopefully a much bigger NATO response, and the possibility of escalation to nuclear war.

@dreamingbohemian. Actually the U.K. is concerned about Putin and Russia. That’s why Johnson has increased your nuclear stockpile from 120 war heads to 260. Mostly submarine, not ICBMs. Russia has been “testing” the U.K. of late. Russian war ships have deviated from channel shipping lands and cruising into U.K. waters forcing U.K. to scramble military ships to “escort” them. Russian fighter jets have similarly cheekily flown into U.K. airspace and again UK has scrambled jets to escort them away. Russia controls the natural gas supply necessary to heat UK homes...which is a critical infrastructure weakness.

If it came to it and Russia attacked the U.K., you would be overwhelmed quite quickly. Their navy far outnumbers yours as does their army and air forces. The nuclear deterrent isn’t much of one as Russia could easily kill everyone in the British isles in less than an hour with their nuclear weapons. So U.K. is not going to launch anything nuclear at Russia as they’ve made it clear to do so would result in the “assured total destruction” of the U.K.

The only thing holding them off is probably the US being a close ally who has shown they will defend the U.K. if needs must. Which is why Russia has been interfering in US and U.K. elections with an end goal of disrupting that relationship, along with their other geopolitical goals.

Swipe left for the next trending thread