Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 15:03

See today’s Daily Mail screeching headline which links SNP and Labour politicians (apparently) having one too many drinks on a flight

Blame the messenger then, rather than rightly calling out those who actually got drunk on a flight

notimagain · 11/11/2021 14:29

Long story short, the right wing press has turned what used to be a shared but also quiet and personal act of remembrance of WW1 and WW2, into a modern day screaming political hate

If you choose to see it that way then that’s your choice…

Personally I don’t agree at all the idea the tales almost enforced wearing of Poppies we are hear about but OTOH some here really need to take the blinkers off/drop the prejudice.

Some people, perhaps many, decide to wear the poppy, red, white or whatever for personal reasons that have nothing to do with their politics, or patriotism, faux or otherwise.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 14:23

As a young person in the late 80s and 90s I fully supported wearing the poppy. Sadly the last twenty years has seen elements of the twisted British media adopt Remembrance Day and the Poppy as a vehicle to bash basically anyone who isn’t politically right wing. See today’s Daily Mail screeching headline which links SNP and Labour politicians (apparently) having one too many drinks on a flight ... with disrespecting Remembrance Day and “disrespecting the armed forces” and ... look basically If you Voted Labour You Are Evil and Not a Patriot....
Long story short, the right wing press has turned what used to be a shared but also quiet and personal act of remembrance of WW1 and WW2, into a modern day screaming political hate match against people who do not shout loudly enough in support of the military and have the cheek to hold some left wing ideals and question some aspects of military spending. So Sadly, many people now choose not to wear the poppy, as they do not want to stand with this horrible finger pointing and politicization by association. (that’s before even opening a discussion on the morally dubious nature of many of Britain’s recent military campaigns).

Washingtonirving79 · 11/11/2021 14:10

Christ. I dread hearing the lame-arse excuse of 'people who died for our freedom'. The poppy refers to the fields of Flanders (WWI); an Imperial spat between royal cousins. Nothing to do with freedom whatsoever.

More recently, it's been hijacked by pro-war, jingoistic loons. Grim, faux patriotism.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 14:09

I will continue to support our servicemen even when I hate the decisions our government makes
Cos they’re just doing their jobs and they might get killed cos there’s a war going on? Just following orders? That argument doesn’t have a very honorable history. Shouldn’t you look at the right/wrong of what they’re doing rather than the fact that you share a passport with them?

Crunchymum · 11/11/2021 14:02

YABU for sending your kids to a school where you worry a different colour poppy could be a trigger for them to be picked on Shock

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 14:00

Finally, Putin is expansionist by nature
Russia would say exactly the same about the West. Take a look at the last few hundred years history of, say, Britain and Germany for starters. Look at the US military bases circling the globe. Look at the expansionist ambitions of the EU. Russians don’t see us as “the good guys”

notimagain · 11/11/2021 14:00

The Poppy has lost its meaning and for a subset of right leaning people is an expression of love for the country armed forces

It hasn’t lost it’s meaning for me and I suspect many other non right leaning people.

Personally for me it’s an expression of remembrance for the three close friends and maybe another dozen or so not so quite close colleagues of mine who lost their lives in the Cold War, killed in training, to prevent it going “hot”… and as somebody said upthread in that context - you’re welcome.

Pacmann · 11/11/2021 13:58

@dreamingbohemian

That's true *@dropitlikeitsloth* but you don't need a large standing army to defend against cyber warfare.
Good job we don't have a large standing army anymore then I guess. Do you think the military has personnel who work do cyber stuff?
SnackSizeRaisin · 11/11/2021 13:57

Red poppies are to symbolise those who died to allow us to have thoughts like yours. If they hadn’t sacrificed their lives where would we be now?

Unfortunately their deaths were largely pointless and unnecessary. World war 1 was about nothing. World war 2 was avoidable. None of the wars since have been about anything that would have affected us directly. Poppy day enables justification of pointless warfare which is why I disagree with it.

LampLighter414 · 11/11/2021 13:54

The Poppy has lost its meaning and for a subset of right leaning people is an expression of love for the country armed forces and in not wearing one you are deemed a traitor to the country and a dangerous person indeed.

The media, politicians and celebs all put on the act and play along to enhance their image.

And for a subset of left leaning people, Poppy wearing can only mean you are one of the far right Britain first types.

I just stay out of it altogether nowadays.

The focus of this country should be make sure we don't get involved in any future wars or bombing etc of other countries. That will be a true lesson learned.

PlanDeRaccordement · 11/11/2021 13:53

@notimagain

Agreed, although the Russians aren’t Soviets anymore. I brought in the Russian threat because @dreamingbohemian states (among other things)

“The UK is not going to be attacked by another state as long as it has nuclear weapons, the Second World War will not be repeated. Its biggest threat is domestic terrorism but military force is not the only, or even the best, way to combat that.”

When in fact, nuclear weapons deter nuclear war, not all war. So, you can’t disband your Armed Forces and depend on a couple hundred nukes to deter all potential attacks. And the biggest military threat to the U.K. is not domestic terrorism but Russia according to British security experts.

@dreamingbohemian seems to be implying in all their posts that there is no real need for Armed Forces.

SlamLikeAGuitar · 11/11/2021 13:53

@OhGiveUp exactly that.
Look at WWII - bar the SS and other kill squads who either volunteered or were hand selected for that particular job, both sides were just a bunch of terrified, conscripted kids in way over their heads, doing whatever they had to do in order to make it home alive. That’s the crux of it.
They deserve the basic respect of being remembered without anyone feeling the need to make it about their own political or moral leanings.

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 13:48

attack on Europe and the U.K. is and will be in the future, with cyber warfare

Cyber attacks and physical attacks are not mutually exclusive. They can both happen and we need to be prepared for both

notimagain · 11/11/2021 13:41

If you are going to keep bringing the Russian threat into it then it’s worth being aware militarily The Soviets “pushing” at the borders, even the UK ones, with flights and other assets has gone on since the fifties, there was a lull post the wall coming down but I gather it has slowly ramped up again in recent years…

The Warsaw Pact has gone, the risk of one of the Soviet Shock Armies charging over the IGB all bombed up on a Friday night are, putting it gently, much reduced..Putin will keep niggling away with his proxies on places like the Polish Border and will no doubt exert political pressure, and can apply pressure though things such as energy supply. ..agree with the comment about cyber attack..He’s not going to be invading the Uk anytime soon.

Now, whether the UK has a standing army, airforce or navy large enough to actually provide protection against any credible threat is another matter…I think one for another thread.

And finally with regard to “nukes”, there’s a danger of over reliance on them and the lack of a large standing army/navy/Air Force means a chance of having to go back to the days of NATO’s trip wire strategy..and that doesn’t bear thinking about….

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 13:37

SlamLikeAGuitar Flowers

OhGiveUp · 11/11/2021 13:29

@SlamLikeAGuitar Very well put. I couldn't agree more.
I wear a red poppy in rememberance of all the fallen and I'm German. ( My DH is British and a veteran )

PlanDeRaccordement · 11/11/2021 13:26

“(Russia) is extremely unlikely to ever launch a large-scale attack or invasion of the UK because 1) it does not have the capability to launch an amphibious conventional invasion, 2) the UK has second-strike capability thanks to its submarines, i.e. even if Russia nuked the UK it could not destroy all the subs and these would launch nukes at Moscow and St Petersburg, 3) I mean why??”

  1. They have been closing the gap on amphibious assault since 2008 and new ships and equipment will be completed by 2026. In addition, their airborne assault capability is very strong. Invasion can be done by sea and air.
  1. Everyone (who matters) has second strike capability, which is why no country is going to use a nuclear bomb. Which is why wars and invasions still have happened since WWII but with only conventional weapons. My point is that nuclear capability is not a deterrent for war, it’s a deterrent for nuclear strikes only.
  1. Why? Does it matter? Usually the reasons for a war are written by the winners afterwards to justify it. Don’t forget Russia also assassinated people on English soil with the Salisbury poisonings.
www.express.co.uk/news/politics/1373865/russia-news-vladimir-putin-world-war-3-royal-navy-rusi-defence-english-channel

Im not saying Russia is currently likely to attack Britain. Merely that the threat exists and that if U.K. had zero military, zero defence and if NATO had collapsed...they would then be likely to. The British Armed Forces are absolutely necessary as a deterrent protecting the U.K. from conventional wars. Finally, Putin is expansionist by nature, he has annexed the Crimea and is in the midst of doing the same in the Ukraine...90,000 Russian troops are massed on the border right now. Putin is also doing massive expansion into the arctic.

SlamLikeAGuitar · 11/11/2021 13:20

I’m a veteran, married to a serving soldier and come from a long line of soldiers before me.
The notion of “pro-war” in my eyes is utter bollocks in itself. No one who finds themselves in the position to be looking war directly in the face is “pro-war” Hmm - personally I was pro-“let’s just get out of this in one piece”.
I have my own difficult emotions surrounding my service, the things I did, the things I saw, the friends and colleagues I lost back then, and the friends who’ve taken their own lives since. It’s a clusterfuck of emotions and thoughts that I’m not sure I’ll ever be able to straighten out so that they make sense. But all of that has no relevance to the basic principles of wearing a red poppy and Remembrance Day in general. It’s not about political leanings, morals or personal feelings about war. It’s about remembering the people who died in horrendous ways, far away from home so that you and people like you can sit and spout of about pacifism on the internet without a care in the world Hmm
So yeah. In short: YABVU.

dreamingbohemian · 11/11/2021 13:19

That's true @dropitlikeitsloth but you don't need a large standing army to defend against cyber warfare.

Eskarina1 · 11/11/2021 13:07

My grandmother was a life long committed pacifist and one of the most caring and compassionate people I know. She turned 18 during the final months of the 2nd world war and volunteered in Germany afterwards in the "clean up" of concentration camps. I remember her telling me even that didn't change her beliefs, even to stop that there needed to be a peaceful solution.

The only time I ever remember seeing her angry was the year my mum bought us white poppies. She was deeply, personally, offended by them, to her they dismissed the memory of those she lost. It's been 30 years and I still remember her reaction.

dropitlikeitsloth · 11/11/2021 13:04

Targeted*

dropitlikeitsloth · 11/11/2021 13:04

[quote dreamingbohemian]@Plan
Russia certainly poses a range of challenges for the UK but it is extremely unlikely to ever launch a large-scale attack or invasion of the UK because 1) it does not have the capability to launch an amphibious conventional invasion, 2) the UK has second-strike capability thanks to its submarines, i.e. even if Russia nuked the UK it could not destroy all the subs and these would launch nukes at Moscow and St Petersburg, 3) I mean why?? Why would Russia invade the UK? It’s completely different to anything Russia is doing in its historical sphere of influence. All of the small-scale things that Russia is now doing to the UK are designed to push back against what it sees as British interference, they are not prelude to invasion.

Apologies for the derail but I do think it’s important to push back against the idea that Britain faces the same kinds of threats and potential wars as in 1914 or 1939, and that the armed forces will have to respond in a similar way. The world has changed[/quote]
Russia’s attack on Europe and the U.K. is and will be in the future, with cyber warfare. And that doesn’t just mean hacking government and infrastructure but targeting social media campaigns using bot factories to influence opinion and stir up anger. The U.K. and Europe is a threat to the current administration, if we are divided we are weaker.

dreamingbohemian · 11/11/2021 12:50

@Plan
Russia certainly poses a range of challenges for the UK but it is extremely unlikely to ever launch a large-scale attack or invasion of the UK because 1) it does not have the capability to launch an amphibious conventional invasion, 2) the UK has second-strike capability thanks to its submarines, i.e. even if Russia nuked the UK it could not destroy all the subs and these would launch nukes at Moscow and St Petersburg, 3) I mean why?? Why would Russia invade the UK? It’s completely different to anything Russia is doing in its historical sphere of influence. All of the small-scale things that Russia is now doing to the UK are designed to push back against what it sees as British interference, they are not prelude to invasion.

Apologies for the derail but I do think it’s important to push back against the idea that Britain faces the same kinds of threats and potential wars as in 1914 or 1939, and that the armed forces will have to respond in a similar way. The world has changed

IntermittentParps · 11/11/2021 12:35

I don't really know what you're arguing about now but OK, fine, that's nice.

Swipe left for the next trending thread