Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
BiBabbles · 12/11/2021 09:32

Red poppies have a heritage and wearing one remembers all those who have lost lives to conflict.

And white poppies have British heritage too - they've been around since 1933. The whole 'are red poppies being co-opted/losing their meaning/too militaristic/too British focused' and 'are white poppies insulting/ignorant/smug/worth firing someone over' and making complaints about the issues with the organizations involved have been around decades - that could be said to be part of heritage too.

This year just added the whole 'Pull the Pin' rum incident to the discussion.

Flossy05 · 12/11/2021 07:36

@Cam77 I wasn’t talking about the aims of the RL, I was talking about the SYMBOLISM of the red poppy which IS remembrance and hope for future peace. The RL website says so “ Our red poppy is a symbol of both Remembrance and hope for a peaceful future.”

I have no idea what your DM rant is referring to because I don’t read that garbage.

Prattypitel · 11/11/2021 19:28

@beigebrownblue.I completely agree with you.

Dilbertian · 11/11/2021 19:25

@SnackSizeRaisin

Red poppies are to symbolise those who died to allow us to have thoughts like yours. If they hadn’t sacrificed their lives where would we be now?

Unfortunately their deaths were largely pointless and unnecessary. World war 1 was about nothing. World war 2 was avoidable. None of the wars since have been about anything that would have affected us directly. Poppy day enables justification of pointless warfare which is why I disagree with it.

As a Jew I'm quite glad that Britain did not avoid war by grovelling to Hitler.
Helicopterlife · 11/11/2021 18:49

@MilduraS

The poppy isn't just about remembering ww1 and ww2 veterans. If it was, I wouldn't feel so conflicted about wearing one. It's supports every British soldier who has been involved in a conflict since the world wars. That includes the soldiers who were involved in the troubles in Ireland.
That’s disgraceful if so!
beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 18:25

I know that Snacksizeraisin makes a good point.

Action wasn't taken when it should have been . World War two case in point.

No, I don't believe 'we' tried hard enough when it mattered.

Eleganz · 11/11/2021 18:20

@SnackSizeRaisin

Red poppies are to symbolise those who died to allow us to have thoughts like yours. If they hadn’t sacrificed their lives where would we be now?

Unfortunately their deaths were largely pointless and unnecessary. World war 1 was about nothing. World war 2 was avoidable. None of the wars since have been about anything that would have affected us directly. Poppy day enables justification of pointless warfare which is why I disagree with it.

What would the world look like now if we had avoided WWII? We did try, appeasement failed. Six million Jews died at the hands of the Nazis, I wonder how many more it would have been if appeasement had succeeded?

Wear whatever colour poppy you like, but I think it is best to leave off the idea that all alternative histories where wars were not fought would necessarily have been better.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 18:01

[quote SlamLikeAGuitar]@beigebrownblue you do know that majority during WWI and WWII weren’t conscripts right? They weren’t there by choice Hmm
And as for modern wars: I made the choice to join the army at 16. I grew up on the breadline, with a poor education and even poorer employment prospects. The army offered me qualifications I otherwise wouldn’t have gained, it offered me job security - a pay check at the end of every single month with no questions asked, it offered me a roof over my head, 3 square meals a day. So yes, I chose it. But no one actively chooses to go to war, watch their friends die, get seriously injured. I didn’t go out on patrol one day, watch some kids playing football in a field and think “I’m going to be picking shrapnel out of that 3 year old’s back in a few hours - sounds like a fun day out!” Hmm
Speaking from experience, and the general consensus among my ex-colleagues, the “bigger picture” generally doesn’t enter our headspace when it comes to the crux of it. We go where we are told to go, Do what we are told to do and just try to make it back with ourselves and our mates all in one piece.
It’s only really in recent months with the news coming out of Afghanistan, and another 9 years of growing up behind me that I’ve asked myself the questions “What was it for?” and “What was the point?”.[/quote]
Thank you. I'm not stupid.

My own father described the forces as 'the poor man's university'. he joined.

but that doesn't mean he would not have appreciated having a choice.
In an area of multiple economic deprivation where he grew up.

Some people would use the term 'canon fodder'.
And I wouldn't stop short of that.

Don't be patronising.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 17:55

Rhetorical question I asked.
I'm aware of the historical background of all this. Thanks.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 17:54

@mustlovegin

So would someone explain exactly what it is the 'freedom' that the soldiers went to war for?

If you didn't have this freedom you would realise what it means pretty soon, I can assure you.

The fact that you even need to ask this question speaks volumes

Excuse me. I have a knowledge of history. And I do know what I am talking about.
Cryalot2 · 11/11/2021 17:44

Red poppies have a heritage and wearing one remembers all those who have lost lives to conflict. The rbl supports both living victims and famlies of those who lost loved ones.

It has been symbolic since 1921 if I am right and has worked. Why try and change it.

No one likes wars, but sadly they do happen, so why try to change something that is part of our heritage.

I would personally feel I was not honouring those who we remember if I wore a poppy by a different coulour. The red shows respect.

Maybe there should be a peace day to lay white flowers.

bg21 · 11/11/2021 17:37

educate yourself a little more

Prattypitel · 11/11/2021 17:28

@SnackSizeRaisin

Red poppies are to symbolise those who died to allow us to have thoughts like yours. If they hadn’t sacrificed their lives where would we be now?

Unfortunately their deaths were largely pointless and unnecessary. World war 1 was about nothing. World war 2 was avoidable. None of the wars since have been about anything that would have affected us directly. Poppy day enables justification of pointless warfare which is why I disagree with it.

👍
Prattypitel · 11/11/2021 17:27

@Washingtonirving79

Christ. I dread hearing the lame-arse excuse of 'people who died for our freedom'. The poppy refers to the fields of Flanders (WWI); an Imperial spat between royal cousins. Nothing to do with freedom whatsoever.

More recently, it's been hijacked by pro-war, jingoistic loons. Grim, faux patriotism.

👍
mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 17:22

So would someone explain exactly what it is the 'freedom' that the soldiers went to war for?

If you didn't have this freedom you would realise what it means pretty soon, I can assure you.

The fact that you even need to ask this question speaks volumes

SlamLikeAGuitar · 11/11/2021 17:22

@beigebrownblue you do know that majority during WWI and WWII weren’t conscripts right? They weren’t there by choice Hmm
And as for modern wars: I made the choice to join the army at 16. I grew up on the breadline, with a poor education and even poorer employment prospects. The army offered me qualifications I otherwise wouldn’t have gained, it offered me job security - a pay check at the end of every single month with no questions asked, it offered me a roof over my head, 3 square meals a day. So yes, I chose it. But no one actively chooses to go to war, watch their friends die, get seriously injured. I didn’t go out on patrol one day, watch some kids playing football in a field and think “I’m going to be picking shrapnel out of that 3 year old’s back in a few hours - sounds like a fun day out!” Hmm
Speaking from experience, and the general consensus among my ex-colleagues, the “bigger picture” generally doesn’t enter our headspace when it comes to the crux of it. We go where we are told to go, Do what we are told to do and just try to make it back with ourselves and our mates all in one piece.
It’s only really in recent months with the news coming out of Afghanistan, and another 9 years of growing up behind me that I’ve asked myself the questions “What was it for?” and “What was the point?”.

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 17:21

Imagine a poor television presenter lost his/her poppy in the dressingroom before appearing live on TV

He would be lent another poppy by one of his/her decent and well-meaning colleagues. That's what would happen (though not amongst your circle it seems)

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 17:15

And before anyone starts on at me. My grandad died in Ypres in the trenches.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 17:13

So. The reasons why people are losing their lives nowadays include the following:

  1. One in 5 kids are in poverty and their parents make choices about whether to eat or not.
  2. The NHS is in crisis - staff are burned out. They shouldn't be asked to work fifty sixty hours a week.
  3. There is a shortage of carers for older people and younger people.
  4. There aren't even enough ambulances to go round. Front page news. and if it weren't front page news most people where I live know that you could die waiting for an ambulance if you got ill as there is a two hour wait.

So. Yes, I'm sorry these people lost their lives, but not, not, not so that 'we' could 'live'.

Something not right there.
NHS was founded for a reason.
My own mother was in the first NHS TB ward. Ever.
That was a pandemic.

And she lived through the wars.
But she never had to live though home schooling. No funds for even a dentist appointment.

So would someone explain exactly what it is the 'freedom' that the soldiers went to war for?

No offence to their memory at all, but perhaps we should recall what it is that they considered they were fighting for in the first place?

If not a health system to help those in need?
Or schools that run properly?

Prattypitel · 11/11/2021 16:48

@KurtWilde.Imagine a poor television presenter lost his/her poppy in the dressingroom before appearing live on TV.you can bet a million,the right wing press would have a screeching headline on the front page the next day.I remember,the first time someone was wearing a white poppy:all hell broke loose.

KurtWilde · 11/11/2021 16:32

@mustlovegin

in no other country are people so hysteric about wearing a poppy

Why do you say people are hysterical? That's very offensive

@Prattypitel I'm not seeing any hysteria.
mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 16:24

in no other country are people so hysteric about wearing a poppy

Why do you say people are hysterical? That's very offensive

Prattypitel · 11/11/2021 16:19

@lescompagnonsdeloue.what I meant was,in no other country are people so hysteric about wearing a poppy.Do you wear other badges too,charities you donated too?I just dont need to wear a badge that I donated to a particular charity.I see the poppy similar to what happened to the english flag.some right wingers have taken it on.for me,its not what you wear on your coat,its what you wear in your heart.I dont have a problem at all,if people want to show the poppy.I recent,when people comment why I dont wear a poppy.

lescompagnonsdeloue · 11/11/2021 15:46

@Prattypitel

No other country in the world is doing this poppy thing.However,Britain is a country that is quite ready to involve itself in a war.I find the whole thing totally baffling.And why do we have a populist government now,when we are proud to have fought off a populist leader in the 2,world war???
I think what is really baffling is the sweeping statement that no other country does this. It's like you are down on Britishness whilst simultaneously claiming to be unique. There's nothing special about having the poppy as a symbol, other countries do too. In France, they picked the cornflower as a symbol.
ohtwatbollocks · 11/11/2021 15:14

I don't wear a red poppy because I love war though. I wear it because people like my great grandad sacrificed themselves so I can be alive today.

Swipe left for the next trending thread