Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
Unhomme · 11/11/2021 07:53

@MilduraS

You mean the Troubles on Northern Ireland, which is a different country to Ireland?

Mantlemoose · 11/11/2021 07:52

OP I applaud you for thinking outside the box, a rarity these days! However to clarify, the red poppy represents remembrance the British Armed Forces,. The white poppy represents all victims, military and civilians of all and aims to stop the exclusion of non armed forces from Remembrance events. So yes given these reasons I always wear s white poppy too.

notimagain · 11/11/2021 07:52

@Prattypitel

No other country in the world is doing this poppy thing.However,Britain is a country that is quite ready to involve itself in a war.I find the whole thing totally baffling.And why do we have a populist government now,when we are proud to have fought off a populist leader in the 2,world war???
The poppy is used in outside of the UK in some other parts of Anglo Saxon influenced world out of respect for the fallen.

FWIW many here in France will be wearing a bleuet (Cornflower) whilst attending sad ceremonies at war memorials up and down the country.

And can I be the n’th one here to point out poppies/bleuets are not worn to glorify war, far from it.

vanessafrance.wordpress.com/2019/11/10/cornflowers-and-poppies-symbols-of-world-war-i/

Howmanysleepsnow · 11/11/2021 07:52

The white poppy can be seen as dishonouring those who died in wars. By all means, make your political statement, but choosing to do so on a day dedicated to remembering these people is at best insensitive to the family and friends of those who died. I know people who fall into this category and would be hurt and angry to see a white poppy intruding on this occasion.

FOJN · 11/11/2021 07:52

There is really no need to phrase it in terms of red versus white.

I agree, they really don't contradict each other. For me its about acknowledging the cost of war, remebering those who paid and hoping for peace.

PurpleParrotfish · 11/11/2021 07:50

@Aurora791

The poppy is a visual reminder of the scale and impact of war and why we must never let death and destruction on that scale happen again. It’s particularly relevant now more than ever because we’re losing those generations who lived through ww2 (and ww1 already) and so their legacy and impact will dim from living memory. ‘We will remember them’ says it all really for the reason we wear them.
If the red poppy always meant this and only this then no one would object to it. But anyone can see the lines get blurred sometimes, moving away from from ‘what a terrible thing to war is’ to ‘support our armed forces’ and patriotism. Especially when organisations like the BBC enforce compulsory poppy wearing. The white poppies were first made in the 1930s as a response to greater military involvement in the ceremony at the Cenotaph rather than it all being about grieving families. OP, you could send your children in with both. They can explain that the white poppy commemorates all victims of war, including civilians, and of all nationalities. Personally I think that this is very important, remembering that it’s not just ‘our brave heroes’ who suffer from war.
Arrowheart · 11/11/2021 07:47

Red poppies are the furthest thing away from supporting war. They are a symbol to remember. Why does everything have to be turned and twisted into something else???

Heruka · 11/11/2021 07:47

@MilduraS

The poppy isn't just about remembering ww1 and ww2 veterans. If it was, I wouldn't feel so conflicted about wearing one. It's supports every British soldier who has been involved in a conflict since the world wars. That includes the soldiers who were involved in the troubles in Ireland.
And that’s part of the debate. The British army have done terrible things in their history, including in Ireland, of course. For some of us, the red poppy symbolism ignores the British army’s terrible history in some countries and celebrates the more honourable parts of its history.
beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 07:46

If you choose to wear white, red or both together, it helps to let the school know your views (and those of your kids) and facilitate discussion in and out of school.

That is what schools are supposed to be for. Learning.

Lordamighty · 11/11/2021 07:45

Wearing a red poppy does not mean you agree with concept of war, what an odd thing to take from it.
Which charity does the money from white poppies go to?

alwayswrighty · 11/11/2021 07:45

This argument comes up every year.

The red poppy is in remembrance of not just the service personnel that lost their lives in WW1 and WW2, it is also every service personnel that have lost their life in every conflict since.

I have had first hand experience of how the RBL help military or ex military personnel. They do really good work, so I support them (but you have to go back about 125 years at least in my family to lose a military link).

Howshouldibehave · 11/11/2021 07:44

Maybe you would be better off home-schooling if the school have got things so dreadfully wrong.

Lochroy · 11/11/2021 07:44

Thoroughly disrespectful. Please do your research.

WaltzingBetty · 11/11/2021 07:43

@Malhao

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

Well I'm not sure you should be explaining poppies to your children either as you clearly don't understand the symbolism
beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 07:42

www.ppu.org.uk/remembrance-white-poppies

FuzzyPuffling · 11/11/2021 07:42

I was spat on in the street for wearing a white poppy.
My late father, a conscript for 6 years in WW2, would never wear a red poppy. Nor will I.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 07:42

Many people do wear white poppies on Rememberance day.
Some of us choose to wear both a read poppy and a white poppy.
There is really no need to phrase it in terms of red versus white.

Along with wars there is suffering. Suffering of all kinds, both of the kind where people die from the arms and the weapons used and the suffering which was real of those that have been persecuted and thrown into prison for their refusal to bear arms, such as conscientious objectors.

The best schools, state and otherwise have a discussion about this. Very topical as there are usually over fourty wars going on in the world.
Peace Pledge Union already mentioned. I understandwww.ppu.org.uk/remembrance-white-poppies
also white poppies were a Women's Cooperative initiative. Here is a link to part of the history:

picklemewalnuts · 11/11/2021 07:41

The red poppy highlights the cost of war. The people who never came home. The families who mourn them. Those who were injured. How can it be wrong to support those families?

I couldn't disagree with you more. There's nothing about glorifying war involved.

MilduraS · 11/11/2021 07:39

The poppy isn't just about remembering ww1 and ww2 veterans. If it was, I wouldn't feel so conflicted about wearing one. It's supports every British soldier who has been involved in a conflict since the world wars. That includes the soldiers who were involved in the troubles in Ireland.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 11/11/2021 07:38

@Prattypitel

No other country in the world is doing this poppy thing.However,Britain is a country that is quite ready to involve itself in a war.I find the whole thing totally baffling.And why do we have a populist government now,when we are proud to have fought off a populist leader in the 2,world war???
I wear a red a white and a blue cornflower badge. The white I bought in Belgium at a Flanders memorial, the blue at Thiepval where it’s the French memorial flower. We used to wear poppies in Australia.
Dilbertian · 11/11/2021 07:38

When I learned that the British government knew about the concentration camps but refused to bomb or disrupt them, I refused to wear the poppy. I was outraged and disgusted. But eventually I understood that this was not what the poppy represented. Had the men and women of the British AF not given their lives in these conflicts, I would not have my right to be openly Jewish protected in law. I would not be fully accepted as a member of society. I would not even be alive.

I wear the poppy now.

WildExcuses · 11/11/2021 07:37

How old are your kids? Do they really understand or have you just told them your thoughts and they’ve ‘agreed’ with you?

My kids wear a red poppy and a purple one to also remember the animals efforts.

I don’t particularly agree with war, but that’s not what the red poppy symbolises so I wear one.

BessieFinknottle · 11/11/2021 07:37

Also it's not a problem for people to wear them, not at all. It's the expectation that everyone does, no matter their background, that's the problem.

EvilPea · 11/11/2021 07:37

I wear my red poppy to remember the fallen and injured soldiers who sacrificed their life so we can have a better future.

I wear a purple poppy for the fallen animals who sacrificed their life

KathleenWho · 11/11/2021 07:36

I imagine the young men who had no choice but to go war would like to not believe in the concept of war
The poppy remembers them and raises money for them. It's not a celebration of war