Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
TheFairyCaravan · 11/11/2021 08:29

@butterpuffed

Why a poppy? Why not some other flower?

I have always known it to be a poppy as the colour represents the blood shed by so many people to keep us safe.

You’re wrong. The red poppy has nothing to do with the blood shed. It’s to represent the red poppies growing in Flanders Fields
beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 08:29

OP you may find the following very well researched you tube video useful and informative for yourself, your chlildren and as a resource

D4NS · 11/11/2021 08:28

There are 365 days in a year

1 of those days commemorates the end of the First World War.
1 of those days commemorates casualties of all wars.

They are a political statement when worn on 11th Nov/Remembrance Sunday. How many people wear White Poppies on the other 363 days, especially 19th Sept (World Peace day?)

Iraq was illegal… but that isn’t the serving military personnel’s fault. They could hardly down tools and walk home when it was declared illegal.

Cam77 · 11/11/2021 08:26

Red poppies are to symbolise those who died to allow us to have thoughts like yours. If they hadn’t sacrificed their lives where would we be now?

They also raise considerable funds for servicemen and women who protect us and our country

The first bit is why everyone used to support wearing of poppies.
The second bit is why many people now find it questionable. I don't want to support what British forces (to take just two recent examples) were doing in Afghanistan and Iraq. Tens of thousands of civilian deaths at our hands, in Afghanistan and for what. In Iraq, hundreds of thousands.

IARTNS · 11/11/2021 08:24

^Why poppies for Anzac Day
The red poppy has become a symbol of war remembrance the world over. People in many countries wear the poppy to remember those who died in war or are serving in the armed forces. In many countries, the poppy is worn on Armistice Day (11 November), but in New Zealand it is most commonly seen on Anzac Day, 25 April.^

GraceandFrankie · 11/11/2021 08:23

I refuse to wear a poppy because I refuse to support Britain’s role in its illegal wars, namely the death and destruction it left behind in Iraq. The poppy has also been hijacked by the far right, which also makes me uncomfortable. Unfortunately what started as a simple way to honour the dead in the world wars has been manipulated into something else.

notimagain · 11/11/2021 08:21

@Franklyfrost

..and don’t want to give money to veterans of recent wars (I’m thinking especially of the illegal Iraq war which was clearly morally wrong from the start).

So are you blaming the veterans themselves for the Iraq war, or in some way they personally should still suffer the consequences of a decision made by politicians?

butterpuffed · 11/11/2021 08:20

Why a poppy? Why not some other flower?

I have always known it to be a poppy as the colour represents the blood shed by so many people to keep us safe.

BessieFinknottle · 11/11/2021 08:19

@Justcallmebebes

I think you need to go back to your history books and also realise how offensive many people find this. I'm proudly wearing my red poppy today in memory of my grandfather and great uncles who all fought in the wwii. Not all of them surviving.

Lest we forget

The problem is the red poppy symbolises different things to different people. It's not just the world wars, it's all conflicts the British army were involved in. The charity presently supports retired army personnel. Even while acknowledging and appreciating the sacrifice made by so many in WWI and II, not everybody considers the British army a force for good. Most Irish people don't, for example. And today in Britain wearing a poppy has, in some situations, become not really a choice, but a requirement. And that's a problem.
IARTNS · 11/11/2021 08:18

Yabu to think that people wear red poppies because they 'agree with the concept of war'

this

Franklyfrost · 11/11/2021 08:17

We wear white poppies to remember all victims of war. I think it’s important not to celebrate killing or nationalism and don’t want to give money to veterans of recent wars (I’m thinking especially of the illegal Iraq war which was clearly morally wrong from the start).

3luckystars · 11/11/2021 08:15

I’m sure there were people in the war who didn’t agree with the concept either.

Prattypitel · 11/11/2021 08:15

@ SexyNeckbeard.your comment shows,you have very little understanding of german history.I had grandparents/parents who had to flee from a populist government.their traumatising experience has taught me to be very very weary of any onset of governments who tell lies,are corrupt and disrespect others in general.No, Boris Johnson is not a Hitler,but if you would know more about history,you would not have made your remark.I know british people,who recognised the potential danger.Just wearing any colour poppy is pointless,unless you know the history and always be weary of the start of something very horrible.

dreamingbohemian · 11/11/2021 08:12

The United States has Memorial Day on May 28th. It honors the men and women who have died in service during war or peace times. We wear the red poppy on that day.

I'm American, I never saw anyone wear a poppy until I moved to the UK. So this is not an issue there. Btw Memorial Day is not the 28th.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 08:12

@Justcallmebebes

I think you need to go back to your history books and also realise how offensive many people find this. I'm proudly wearing my red poppy today in memory of my grandfather and great uncles who all fought in the wwii. Not all of them surviving.

Lest we forget

My father, passed away now, was in the Royal Air Force and I respect his choices.

At home in Wales there were wreaths laid at the cenotaph, some red and some white.

In the silence, at the eleventh hour in the grief and memories I think people understood each other.

TheFairyCaravan · 11/11/2021 08:11

@BessieFinknottle

If it was just about remembering the fallen soldiers of WW1 it would be one thing. It's not. It raises money to support present-day army veterans.
A couple of months ago when Afghanistan was falling due to the allied forces pulling out there was thread after thread saying that our army should stay to keep the Taliban under control. I said at the time to give it a couple of months and there’d be posts saying “I’m not buying a poppy, they support today’s soldiers”.

This country is strange. People bang their gums about not wanting an armed force, they don’t want to support them and god forbid their kids ever want to join up. Yet as soon as there’s a crisis, the very same people are volunteering them to do the dirty work that they want nothing to do with.

What do you think would happen if we didn’t have people who were happy to join up? Your precious kids would be made to, that’s what. So be grateful that people like my husband did, and my son has, hey?

SparklyDino · 11/11/2021 08:10

@Valeriane

You can wear a white poppy if you like but just be aware that most people will be thinking 🙄

These people are muppets. They have no idea what a red Poppy symbolises. Look at me all woke and wanting peace wearing my white poppy.

The red poppy does not glamourise war at all, ask any vet or serving military if they want peace!

The white poppy just makes me so angry. Ask yourself this White Poppy Wearers -

Why wear it now? Why not choose another time of year?

Why a poppy? Why not some other flower?

And finally do you even know where you're money is going or are you so desperate to jump on the woke bus you haven't bothered to check?

I seriously could not be friends with someone who wore a white poppy.

dropitlikeitsloth · 11/11/2021 08:08

@MLMshouldbeillegal

Red poppies are absolutely not pro war. They are to remember the fallen

This with bells on. It's not "isn't war great". I will wear my poppy - a red one - today to remember all those people who went away to War and didn't come back.

Poppies are red. They are not white, or purple.

I agree. Not in recent times, but in two world wars, the soldiers didn’t choose to fight they were drafted. I do a lot of family history work and recently came across several civilians who died when their house was hit. So I see the red poppy as remembering those who lost their lives, soldiers and civilians.
Justcallmebebes · 11/11/2021 08:06

I think you need to go back to your history books and also realise how offensive many people find this. I'm proudly wearing my red poppy today in memory of my grandfather and great uncles who all fought in the wwii. Not all of them surviving.

Lest we forget

MLMshouldbeillegal · 11/11/2021 08:05

Red poppies are absolutely not pro war. They are to remember the fallen

This with bells on. It's not "isn't war great". I will wear my poppy - a red one - today to remember all those people who went away to War and didn't come back.

Poppies are red. They are not white, or purple.

Groovee · 11/11/2021 08:04

We do a lot of work in the school I work in as we are a school with 2 barracks in the catchment. Many of our families are forces families. We have close links with Lady Haig's poppy factory and have taken nursery children to visit and learn. Today will be poignant at 11am in the school.

MrsDrSpencerReid · 11/11/2021 08:00

@Prattypitel

No other country in the world is doing this poppy thing.However,Britain is a country that is quite ready to involve itself in a war.I find the whole thing totally baffling.And why do we have a populist government now,when we are proud to have fought off a populist leader in the 2,world war???
We wear them in Australia!

My son is in 6th grade, they learnt about the red, white and purple poppies last term and the different things they stand for.

He wore a red poppy to school today and led the school’s Remembrance Day service as school captain, which included the meaning of the poppies in his speech (written by the school)

Every year they always do Remembrance Day activities that usually include making paper poppies and learning about them.

MilduraS · 11/11/2021 07:58

[quote Unhomme]@MilduraS

You mean the Troubles on Northern Ireland, which is a different country to Ireland?[/quote]
I'm from Ireland and where I grew up it was all called Ireland. That's not really the post of this thread though so let's not derail it.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 07:54

Women's Cooperative Guild in 1930s. Women (mums) who had lost sons in the wars.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 07:53

Found the link which points to the Women's CooperThe Symbolism of the White Poppy in Britain
9 November 2021 by @swanseahistory
The interwar period brought a wave of cultural change, and the white peace poppy was a fringe commemorative symbol that exemplified these changes. The white peace poppy was organised and sold by the Women’s Cooperative Guild, typically working-class women who had lost multiple family members to the Great War and sought to exercise their newly found democratic rights. Introduced in 1933 and sold from 1934, the white poppy stood on a pacifist platform, propagating the idea that society should actively remember all victims of war, in order to ensure that a total war would not break out again. It is important to note that the concept of the white peace poppy did not seek to overtake, replace, or cause any offence to the Haig Fund in 1933 when it was proposed to be sold alongside the Flanders poppy. However, its mere suggestion, to a militarist culture, was immediately viewed as an ‘insult’ and a challenge. This led to strong opposition and resentment toward the white poppy and the women proposing its distribution. The opposition came from militarist sections of society, as well as from sections of society that dared not offend the establishment that had secured victory in 1918 and soldiers had sacrificed for the war.ative Guild in the 1930s. Quote from Swansea History:

And link to the site for more:
history.swansea.ac.uk/?p=399