Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Red v white poppies

364 replies

Malhao · 11/11/2021 00:33

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SammyScrounge · 17/11/2021 21:33

@Runningupthecurtains

Are people really suggesting that a charity whose purpose is to support veterans stops supporting veterans because they served after 1945? A few years ago DH was facing potential posting to either help with ebola crisis or to be dealing with refugees in an area where ISIS were highly operational and would have loved to get ahold of British service personnel to behead. Fortunately on that role of the dice he got a UK backfill post while some other poor buggers got to risk life and limb doing humanitarian work. Presumably they wouldn't be deemed worthy of RBL support (even though they had never set foot in Ireland or Iraq). Even in this country there are spells when DH isn't allowed to drive home in uniform because there are creditable threats to military personnel but he is still expected to wear it when helping with covid logistics or flooding.
It is a national disgrace that members of the Armed Forces cannot wear their uniforms in public with pride. What have we come to?
LoveFall · 13/11/2021 00:45

I thought some of you may appreciate the news story about poppies in Canada.

www.cbc.ca/news/canada/thunder-bay/centennial-anniversary-remembrance-day-poppy-1.6243950

BessieFinknottle · 12/11/2021 23:38

Sincere thanks for your post and for your understanding too MrsSkylerWhite. I do agree, very much so.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/11/2021 23:19

BessieFinknottle

I’m embarrassed to say I hadn’t considered Northern Ireland when I posted my personal comment.

That’s a whole, different and incredibly complicated story that I have no personal knowledge of. I have no understanding of what the red poppy means to people there. To me, it represents World Wars One and Two but to you, clearly something very different.

Thank you for your understanding of my feelings.

I hope we can both agree that this world will be a much better place if we could all, finally, come together. We’re all human and approaching a time when nationality, allegiances and religion will mean nothing. If COP has shown us nothing else, hopefully it’s shown us that.

MindyStClaire · 12/11/2021 23:03

@mustlovegin

I can see where you are coming from BessieFinknottle, being from Northern Ireland, but it's likely not every single poster tantrumming over a poppy upthread is.
Tantrumming is a very insulting way of putting it. Many posters have a different view to yours. That's allowed, even if it's not for a reason you deem acceptable.
mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 22:57

I can see where you are coming from BessieFinknottle, being from Northern Ireland, but it's likely not every single poster tantrumming over a poppy upthread is.

BessieFinknottle · 12/11/2021 22:40

Again, Northern Ireland is part of the UK @dropitslikeitsloth. I think it gets forgotten.

JollyJoon · 12/11/2021 22:38

@BessieFinknottle
Give the respect you expect to be shown

BessieFinknottle · 12/11/2021 22:35

@MrsSkylerWhite
My post upset you and I'm sorry for that. If you read my other comments here you will see that I absolutely understand and respect why people want to honour the dead of the world wars.

I have two problems with the red poppy though.
Firstly, it supports the British military (I do not). I am Irish. The poppies are sold here too, though there is much less demand for them. Irish people died in the world wars and we would wish to honour and remember them and the others. However, supporting the British army, that side of the poppy campaign, is different. My grandad fought the British in the Irish War of Independence. My grandmother was terrorised as a child by English soldiers searching their house on numerous occasions, bayonets through the ceiling, you can imagine.

I think, for an Irish person (and remember NI is part of the UK, I think that gets forgotten sometimes), buying a poppy is a little like a British person being asked to buy a charity flower in memory of the dead of the world wars, when that charity supports German military personnel. I suspect many British people would be in complete agreement with honouring the dead and their sacrifice, while wondering why on earth they should support the German army? Maybe I'm wrong about that.

Secondly, it has become a requirement to wear them, you are judged in the UK (at least in some settings) if you do not. The Northern Irish footballer James McClean has repeatedly received abuse and death threats for refusing to wear the poppy, for example. He's originally from Derry where the British Army opened fire on civilians on Bloody Sunday in the 1970's. Again he has said if it were just about remembering the dead of the world wars he would wear one. But to him, and me, and many others it's about more than that.

People see the poppy differently, it symbolises more than one thing, and as a pp said, its meaning has changed over time too and how it's read can depend on where in the UK you live.
.
Again, I'm sorry for upsetting you by not supporting the poppy. I genuinely mean no disrespect to your grandfather and gradfather-in-law. If it only meant supporting those who sacrificed so much in the world wars I would buy it without question.

Runningupthecurtains · 12/11/2021 22:22

Are people really suggesting that a charity whose purpose is to support veterans stops supporting veterans because they served after 1945?
A few years ago DH was facing potential posting to either help with ebola crisis or to be dealing with refugees in an area where ISIS were highly operational and would have loved to get ahold of British service personnel to behead. Fortunately on that role of the dice he got a UK backfill post while some other poor buggers got to risk life and limb doing humanitarian work. Presumably they wouldn't be deemed worthy of RBL support (even though they had never set foot in Ireland or Iraq). Even in this country there are spells when DH isn't allowed to drive home in uniform because there are creditable threats to military personnel but he is still expected to wear it when helping with covid logistics or flooding.

LoveFall · 12/11/2021 22:21

We wear red poppies in Canada. I have never seen a white one.

I have worn a poppy and participated in Remembrance Day my whole life.

To me, the poppy is indeed a symbol of peace, its importance, and the awful cost of war.

It is not a symbol of British colonialism to me, at all.

Yesterday a number of rude and disrespectful antivaxers disrupted Remembrance Day ceremonies in a number of places.

It makes me despair.

dropitlikeitsloth · 12/11/2021 22:12

@mustlovegin

I know it's natural for British people to want to support their army, but there are many people living in the UK from places where British soldiers were the invaders, a colonial power, and a destructive force. They have absolutely no wish to support the British army

Why can't we wear a poppy in our own country? Because other people have decided to come and live here and benefit from everything that it entails?

Ridiculous beyond belief.

I know, Britain is so fucking awful isn’t it, yet these people all come to live here and better their lives, benefitting off all this colonial wealth. So hypocritical.
mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 22:01

I know it's natural for British people to want to support their army, but there are many people living in the UK from places where British soldiers were the invaders, a colonial power, and a destructive force. They have absolutely no wish to support the British army

Why can't we wear a poppy in our own country? Because other people have decided to come and live here and benefit from everything that it entails?

Ridiculous beyond belief.

mustlovegin · 12/11/2021 21:57

Well said MrsSkylerWhite

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/11/2021 21:23

Incredibly embarrassed now. Edward did not lose his life in World War Two, Paul did. Forgive me got cross/sad/angry and messed their names up.

They were both loved young men though, despite my gin-inspired rant, and we will remember them forever.

MrsSkylerWhite · 12/11/2021 21:17

BessieFinknottle

People here are mistaken if they think wearing red poppies aren't a political and divisive symbol. I know it's natural for British people to want to support their army, but there are many people living in the UK from places where British soldiers were the invaders, a colonial power, and a destructive force. They have absolutely no wish to support the British army.“

We buy our poppies in remembrance of my grandfather, Edward, who served in the First World War, joined up at 16, gassed at the Battle of the Somme at 17, then served as a Fire Warden during the London Blitz during World War Two.

We also wear them in remembrance of my husband’s German grandfather, Paul, who fought and died in World War Two.

I’m 58 and can still remember Edward. He was a lovely grandad, a gentle soul, who grew the most spectacular dahlias in his south London garden. My mum, born in October, 1939, told me that he screamed at night for as long as she could remember. That was just her dad, who was the most beautiful soul she ever knew.

Mr husband, obviously doesn’t remember his grandad, he died before he was born. His mother does, though. He grew the family’s vegetables in their garden in Heilbronn and played the accordion. He taught my husband’s mother, too as a very little girl.

These gentle men, who I know would have been friends in better times, were not imperialists or war-mongers. They did what they were convinced by “their betters” that fthey had to do, for their families first and foremost.

World War One was a f**king disgrace, we can all agree on that - now. Edward didn’t know that, though. He did what, as a simple, working man (child, by today’s standards) his “superiors” told him he must do and for that he lost his life and my MIL her father.
Edward did what any man would do and was completely justified. World War Two was, I think anyway, one of the few justifiable wars in human history. People were fighting for hearth and home (a lot more besides but that would need the whole of Mumsnet) and I for one are still incredibly proud of them and what they did for the generations who came after them.

I don’t know from your post if you are a British born person, live overseas or are a naturalised British citizen.

I suppose that doesn’t really matter actually.

If you live here and benefit from our freedoms and democracy (yes, it’s imperfect but we have a semblance of it, at least) then you owe an enormous debt to those faceless young men who died in their millions to give you what you have now.

We wear our red poppies with love and pride and will do so until we die.

beigebrownblue · 12/11/2021 20:39

And as I've already said, my grandad died in the trenches.
So I know.

beigebrownblue · 12/11/2021 20:22

Ricetwisty

In response to your comment

did I think they were 'fighting to protect the NHS'.

My response

They were fighting to maintain a civilised society, where the sick and needy weren't exploited and were cared for.

So YES. I believe they were.

As I may have said my mum was in the first TB NHS ward. She had lived through the war, was married to a service man and their values were those of the NHS originally created.

Free at the point of need.

So yes, I do.

They were fighting for the values of the NHS as it was originally created.

Who did you fight for?

HappyDays40 · 12/11/2021 19:30

I wear a poppy to commemorate the memory of beautiful man I ever had the privilege to know. My grandfather who was a gunner in Montgomery's 8th army in Egypt and Palestine. He hated the army but went and survived due to conjunctivitis, his brother who loved the army stayed to look after him as his sight was at risk. His regiment got wiped out crossing on a boat. Conjunctivitis meant that my grandmother got both her sons home safely. He had four children and I am thankful for every day that this kind beautiful soul graced my life. It is for him I wear it and still cry at his memory.

BessieFinknottle · 12/11/2021 19:29

Care to elaborate @toconclude?

Ricetwisty · 12/11/2021 19:04

@beigebrownblue

So. The reasons why people are losing their lives nowadays include the following:
  1. One in 5 kids are in poverty and their parents make choices about whether to eat or not.
  2. The NHS is in crisis - staff are burned out. They shouldn't be asked to work fifty sixty hours a week.
  3. There is a shortage of carers for older people and younger people.
  4. There aren't even enough ambulances to go round. Front page news. and if it weren't front page news most people where I live know that you could die waiting for an ambulance if you got ill as there is a two hour wait.

So. Yes, I'm sorry these people lost their lives, but not, not, not so that 'we' could 'live'.

Something not right there.
NHS was founded for a reason.
My own mother was in the first NHS TB ward. Ever.
That was a pandemic.

And she lived through the wars.
But she never had to live though home schooling. No funds for even a dentist appointment.

So would someone explain exactly what it is the 'freedom' that the soldiers went to war for?

No offence to their memory at all, but perhaps we should recall what it is that they considered they were fighting for in the first place?

If not a health system to help those in need?
Or schools that run properly?

Do you think they were fighting to protect the NHS?
toconclude · 12/11/2021 18:55

@Mybalconyiscracking

Oh dear God, learn some history will you?
This. Applies to so many situations and opinions I find. ..
BessieFinknottle · 12/11/2021 18:20

A bit harsh turnaroundtime. Though of course it's a privilege to live in peace, you don't have to be very privileged or spoilt to think that war is nearly always a bad idea.

The red poppy just means remembrance for some, a way of honouring the dead and their sacrifice.
But others, while supporting the remembrance aspect of the poppy, believe wearing it means showing your support for the British military. (The Royal British Legion who sell the poppies are a charity that support military personnel, both active and veterans.) This is a step too far for some, for a variety of reasons.

Another concerning issue is that wearing the red poppy has, in certain circles at least, become an obligation and no longer a choice.

turnaroundtime · 12/11/2021 16:57

@Malhao

AIBU to be unimpressed that the staff at school are trying to sell my kids red poppies without explaining the symbolism behind them?

I don't agree with the concept of war and am contemplating sending them in wearing white poppies (I've explained the difference to them and they both agree with the principles behind the white poppies) but wonder if they'll get picked on for standing out?

Oh bless. You don't agree with the concept of war. How adorable that your privileged little life has allowed you to think that war is a concept one can choose to agree or disagree with. You are so unbelievably ignorant that it's offensive
MrsSkylerWhite · 12/11/2021 09:36

SexyNeckbeard

Prattypitel
No other country in the world is doing this poppy thing.However,Britain is a country that is quite ready to involve itself in a war.I find the whole thing totally baffling.And why do we have a populist government now,when we are proud to have fought off a populist leader in the 2,world war???

“This has to be one of the most stupid comments I've ever seen on MN and I've been around here a long time”

Yep.