Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Agree with Money Saving Expert?

196 replies

backtolifebacktoreality · 10/11/2021 23:08

Martin Lewis said this a few years back. I think it's very very true!

"Christmas has become a retail festival and it shouldn't be. Christmas should be joyous but causes some people unhappiness, debt and worry. Many people feel obliged to buy gifts for others that they know they won't use, with money they don't have, and cause themselves stress they don't need ... The gift of giving can be selfish as it can mis-prioritise people's finances and create a financial burden. If you give a gift to someone they're effectively forced to buy you one back ... It's time for us to get off this gift giving treadmill. Sometimes the best gift is releasing others from the obligation of having to give to you. Let's work together to ban unnecessary Christmas presents ... (However, if you feel you want to give something) Do a Secret Santa or give to charity instead".

OP posts:
Forgothowmuchlhatehomeschoolin · 11/11/2021 08:14

Been saying to my sister for years just go and buy yourself something you want that you wouldn't normally buy and l will do the same.
But she whines and says she wants to get me something - just creates another job and seems daft to go and get each other something, or sending each other a link to what we want when we could just get something for ourselves when we see it.
Mum and l have set a £20 limit.
Last year was bliss not having any of this hassle.

Lordamighty · 11/11/2021 08:09

Secret Santa for our family, so just one present to buy instead of lots. It’s so much better, I wish we had done it years ago.

jetadore · 11/11/2021 08:07

Yabu, the economy relies on endless, excessive consumption of tat. Do you want the staff of b&m, Tesco, smyths out of work? Fuck the landfill/environment! If everyone took this approach where would the precious capitalism be?

Sprostongreen21 · 11/11/2021 08:04

He is right. The amount of money spent at Christmas is crazy. Some of the amounts on here on Christmas threads are just wow.

I love Christmas, Christmas for us is all spending time together. We don't get that much normally. We do gifts but small amounts or cash for older kids. We don’t go mad on spending mainly cos my family mostly can’t afford it. I’ve never gone into debt for Christmas and everyone gets something they like or would use. I reuse gift bags where I can.I buy a few extra baubles for the tree but keep what we have. I don’t replace decorations just add to.

I buy some treat food in gradually from now but there’s only two of us so it’s probably about £25 I still work Christmas so there is not days on end of sitting at home eating.

GoodnightGrandma · 11/11/2021 08:01

I absolutely agree with this.
The amount my DH spends on his family is disgusting. I only have a DM to buy for, and I but her nice, special food and make up a hamper. She uses it all, and it lasts a while so I feel it’s worth it.
DH buys expensive stuff for his family that puts us into debt. There is no talking to him about it, it’s what he wants to do.
His family members are all retired on good private pensions, if they want something they buy it themselves. We don’t even see these people, they live around the country.

lazylinguist · 11/11/2021 08:00

We buy within our means, for adults as well as kids, never buy random tat just for the sake of it, and use wishlists, so nobody ever gets anything they don't want. The stuff the adults buy for each other is often books or clothes - things which will be used, and which the recipient would otherwise buy for themselves at some point.

BigYellowHat · 11/11/2021 07:58

The best Christmas DH and I had was a couple of years ago when it was just us. We had steak and chips for lunch and just snuggled up on the sofa all afternoon watching movies. We’d agreed to only spend a small amount on each other and didn’t buy any other presents, apart from for our kids (who were all with their other parents for the day and we had them on Boxing Day) Fond memories.

Theline · 11/11/2021 07:55

I agree as well.

Thankfully found it very easy to stop Christmas gifts with most people. DH keeps saying he will have the conversation with his parents, but never does.

At other times, I now stop and really think whether or not my urge to give someone a gift is selfish, and it often is, so I stop myself.

TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 11/11/2021 07:52

Yep definitely agree, we're doing well to cut back I think, but it still feels wasteful when DS gets loads of tat for giftings sake!

Pixxie7 · 11/11/2021 07:47

I agree in principle but I buy gifts because I actually enjoy giving gifts, not because I expect getting anything back.

Beautiful3 · 11/11/2021 07:39

When his message first came out it prompted us to stop buying presents for everyone. We only buy for our children. I'm so glad we did, because we are on a low income and present buying was putting us in the red.

BarbaraofSeville · 11/11/2021 07:39

@HugeAckmansWife

I particularly hate all those specially made 'box gift sets' that you see in supermarkets, Boots etc. They should call it 'gifts for people you don't know that well but need a wrapped thing at work / the playgroup / the PTA etc.'
They should ban those. No-one would buy a standard Dove or Lynx body spray and shower gel from the supermarket as a gift, but encasing it in unnecessary packaging and doubling the price somehow makes it OK? I don't think so.
BarbaraofSeville · 11/11/2021 07:36

YY OP. He's been doing the no unnecessary presents pact for years, well before 2018, possibly as far back as after the 2008? crash when a lot of people were out of work so couldn't afford to spend money they didn't have on things no-one wanted or needed.

Of course everyone who feels this way have probably been pissing in the wind for the last decade or so because, if anything it's much worse now, but now we've got a lot more awareness of the impact of waste and overconsumption on the environment, so it should be easier to scale back, but it doesn't feel that way.

I agree with the suggestion that, for adults, no gifts should be exchanged and everyone should buy themselves a present. You still get to talk about it and show it off during family gatherings and everyone gets what they want/need and sets their own budget and money isn't wasted on stuff that will end up unused in cupboards or sent to charity.

Plus no disappointment about lack of or unsuitable gifts from DHs and MILs and no stressing about either buying gifts for the in laws because you know your DH won't bother, or leaving it to him and getting grief from MIL and SIL because he did nothing.

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 07:35

Also, I understand some of the best people were homeless at Christmas...and born in a barn...

beigebrownblue · 11/11/2021 07:34

Read the local council newsletter and it said that Christmas wrapping paper can't be recycled as it has coatings on it.

So, I'm aiming for the gifts I do give to be wrapped in nice, new tea towels that can be used.

PooWillyNameChange · 11/11/2021 07:11
  • doesn't need not needs!
PooWillyNameChange · 11/11/2021 07:10

I agree @Hollyhead. If we all spend £20 on some shit the other person needs we may as well just all burn £20.

If you find something wonderful and know it will bring someone joy and no obligations thats something else entirely.

PooWillyNameChange · 11/11/2021 07:08

I agree with him. If it's stretching you financially you shouldn't do it - anyone who cares about you wouldn't want that. If it's tat you're giving just because of social obligation you shouldn't do it - bad for the planet, waste of time and your own resources.

I despair when I see people flogging those plastic covered hot chocolate kits in cheap mugs because that's exactly the kind of thing that ends up in the bin or charity shop. And boots 3 for 2 as mentioned.

We send cards to older friends and family (those over 70 who may be hurt if we didn't), and that's it.

Hollyhead · 11/11/2021 07:08

I would like a return to a truer sense of gift giving. I LOVE buying gifts, however only when - I find something I know the recipient would love (this doesn’t always conveniently fit in with the time frame of Christmas/birthday), I can afford it, and that it doesn’t mean I have to receive one back. It’s the reciprocation arrangements that take the joy out of the whole thing for me, it makes it too transactional.

HugeAckmansWife · 11/11/2021 07:02

I particularly hate all those specially made 'box gift sets' that you see in supermarkets, Boots etc. They should call it 'gifts for people you don't know that well but need a wrapped thing at work / the playgroup / the PTA etc.'

Nothavingfunrightnow · 11/11/2021 06:48

My boyfriend's daughter is a young adult and is determined to buy everyone gifts despite me trying to persuade her not to get me or my son anything. She earns minimum wage.

So, I'm stuck. She has another sister who is not bothered and has mental health problems and has not (been able to?) thank me for gifts I'd previously given her

I feel that I can't avoid getting the two young women small gifts, but I'd really rather not. At least it's only a few people. When I read what other people have done, like remortgaging homes for Christmas, I am at a loss for words. Stupid doesn't begin to describe it!

OP, YANBU!

Mamanyt · 11/11/2021 00:54

Once we outgrew Father Christmas/Santa Claus in our extended family, we did Secret Santa, and all gifts had an upper price limit. Sure took the pressure off!

boatyardblues · 11/11/2021 00:26

We cut right back on the arms race several years ago by mutual consent. In our extended family we pull names out of a hat for adults so you only buy for one other adult, max. £50 budget. We all buy for the kids but a sensible amount and club together for more expensive items. Everyone talks to their giftee to get a wishlist or steer on preferences so there is no tat and wastage. It works really well and we focus on being together instead of stressing ourselves out buying stuff we don’t want or need.

TheLeadbetterLife · 11/11/2021 00:16

My family stopped doing presents, it is all pointless. My in laws love sending each other (and me) tat though, but I don’t get involved at all. It’s my husband’s problem and he can’t summon the courage to nip it in the bud. If he wants to buy tat for them and put my name on the card, fine.

I’m not sure I even agree about giving that many presents to kids either (I give my nephews a bit of pocket money). Surely it’s just setting them up for a lifetime of tat-expectations that they’ll have to break out of themselves? All the guff you read about the magic in their eyes on Christmas morning when they see the pile of presents - surely it’s just greed? Why encourage it?

And yes, humbug.

I do actually love Christmas, just not all the aspirational bullshit. A couple of weeks off work, peaceful evenings in by the fire, a twinkling Christmas tree and a cheese board. That’ll do.

Wingedharpy · 11/11/2021 00:08

We don't buy for anyone, haven't for years, and no-one buys for us.
We don't buy for each other either - not after the "plastic handbag incident"!Grin

Swipe left for the next trending thread