Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to want another baby at 45

239 replies

Mushroomlover · 10/11/2021 20:18

We have two DC aged 16 and 13. About 10 years ago DH and I had a talk about whether we wanted any more. He said he was happy to do whatever I wanted and I said what I thought at the time, which is that I was very happy with two.

However for the last year I have found myself longing for another baby. I'm struggling to know whether this is really what I want or just a response to a sort of early-onset empty nest syndrome I've been feeling (my DC are still at home, than goodness, but I'm really aware that they won't be forever). I also don't have any sense of what my odds would be of getting pregnant at this age. I'm in good health (bit overweight but can diet) and no signs of perimenopause. Is there any way I can check my fertility?

Wondered whether anyone had been through this?

OP posts:
Megalameg · 11/11/2021 10:38

@LittleDandelionClock

Way to compare Mothers in their 40’s to victims of child abuse. Real classy.

Many women in their 40’s have raised healthy happy babies all throughout history and in the present. Calm down.

UsedUpUsername · 11/11/2021 10:34

EXACTLY what I said. And of course the situations would be different as a pp said, but if we are talking about NATURE here, then why not have babies at 9 or 10 too, because NATURE DICTATES it? If we can have them at 45, then theoretically, we should be able to have them at 9 or 10

A woman deciding at age 45 that she wants a baby is not the same thing. Nature still allows it in some cases, unlike with, say, a post-menopausal woman.

Why would you compare this to child sexual abuse where there is no agency?

LittleDandelionClock · 11/11/2021 10:29

@JudgementalCactus

If you weren’t meant to be able to have kids at 45 then you wouldn’t be able to have a baby at 45.

Wow, this is beyond stupid! Confused
Should girls aged 9 or 10 have babies just because they started menstruating too?!

EXACTLY what I said. And of course the situations would be different as a pp said, but if we are talking about NATURE here, then why not have babies at 9 or 10 too, because NATURE DICTATES it? If we can have them at 45, then theoretically, we should be able to have them at 9 or 10..

What I (and you) said, is no more dumb or daft that than what @Megalameg said.

JudgementalCactus · 11/11/2021 10:26

@UsedUpUsername

So if you think that because nature dictates it's OK to have a baby at 45, (because we are still producing our last few eggs, and we are able to have a baby,) then I can only surmise that you think it's OK for girls to have babies at the age of 9 or 10, because it IS possible if a girl has started her period

Wtf one of these is not like the other …

No, that's exactly what that argument amounts to. That if it's naturally possible then it's perfectly OK. Which is immensely stupid.
JudgementalCactus · 11/11/2021 10:24

If you weren’t meant to be able to have kids at 45 then you wouldn’t be able to have a baby at 45.

Wow, this is beyond stupid! Confused
Should girls aged 9 or 10 have babies just because they started menstruating too?!

UsedUpUsername · 11/11/2021 10:23

So if you think that because nature dictates it's OK to have a baby at 45, (because we are still producing our last few eggs, and we are able to have a baby,) then I can only surmise that you think it's OK for girls to have babies at the age of 9 or 10, because it IS possible if a girl has started her period

Wtf one of these is not like the other …

LittleDandelionClock · 11/11/2021 10:06

@Megalameg

There’s nothing crazy about this at all. If you weren’t meant to be able to have kids at 45 then you wouldn’t be able to have a baby at 45. Yes the chances of difficulties increases but they’re still not that high.

If you really are dead set on it I’d give it a shot and see what happens. Since you are 45, if you do have difficulty conceiving, I’d just accept it isn’t meant to be as you probably don’t have time for lengthy methods of intervention anyway.

This is a case of 'just because you CAN do something, that doesn't necessarily mean you SHOULD.

Female humans are able to physically have babies as soon as they start to menstruate. Some girls start at 9 or 10.

So if you think that because nature dictates it's OK to have a baby at 45, (because we are still producing our last few eggs, and we are able to have a baby,) then I can only surmise that you think it's OK for girls to have babies at the age of 9 or 10, because it IS possible if a girl has started her period.

Human females are able to get pregnant at 9 or 10 if their periods have started, so surely it's OK to have babies at 9 or 10 then yes?

As I said, just because you CAN do something, that doesn't necessarily think you SHOULD.

CarrotVan · 11/11/2021 09:56

I was that baby. My kids are having to deal with the reality of very old grandparents meaning my time is torn between two sets of caring responsibilities. My older parents had no connection with younger parents at school. They didn't encourage friendships or do playdates or classes because it was all too exhausting. In short it sucked and still sucks. Multigenerational suckage

TopCatsTopHat · 11/11/2021 09:52

JudgmentalCactus agree! Wow, imagine playing fast and loose with your dh's life against his clear expressed wishes. What an abuse of trust. Shock

zafferana · 11/11/2021 09:50

@TuftyMarmoset

Do you really want a 14 /15yo when you're 60?
This is the kicker for me. Having a baby at 45 - not ideal - but okay women have always had babies in their mid-40s and they managed. But what about as that DC grows up - how do you and your DH feel about going through GCSEs and A Levels again when you're in your 60s? What about funding university when you're that age? What about your plans for retirement? Do you and your DH want to travel, downsize, retire early? You'll be child-rearing long into your 'grandparent' years, so is that what you want - to have a DC in your home, needing your financial, practical and emotional support until you're at least 65?
JudgementalCactus · 11/11/2021 09:42

@0nlyMe

I felt the same way, a little younger than yourself but kids similar age. I was discussing this with dh who was dead against it, listing all the cons pp have said. My heart would say go for it but head said definitely don’t. I wasn’t looking at it through rose tinted lenses, that’s for sure. But then…number 3 came along anyway. I do now regret having a third (I was lax with contraception thinking whatever is meant to happen, will happen). It’s a massive adjustment having no time to do anything for myself. Marriage on the rocks. Second special needs dc pretty much neglected. Fed, bathed, but doesn’t get any extra time from me.
Wow! Did your husband know you were being lax with contraception? Did you give him the opportunity to figure out more reliable contraception for himself? If not, that was an immensely selfish move on your part. No wonder your marriage is on the rocks.
Mushroomlover · 11/11/2021 09:36

Thanks so much, everyone. Thank you especially to people who shared their experiences of difficulties and tragedies- I really appreciate you sharing something so personal.

Very interesting to see how many people have experienced this and that it might be a hormonal response to approaching menopause. That definitely puts my feelings into a bit of context.

I know a lot of older mums (including mums with children the same age as mine who are 60+) and I'm not worried at all about people thinking I'm a granny Grin. I'm also in quite a good position practically in terms of finances and space etc but obviously that's a minor issue compared to the major issue of actual ability to have a baby. My DC would love it, at least in theory (they may not enjoy the practicalities so much but at least they'd start from a position of positivity).

Lots to think about so thank you. I'll have a chat with DH. I think it's unlikely I'd want any sort of intervention so it may be that it's so unlikely to happen as not to be worth much thinking about.

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 11/11/2021 09:12

@user1471462428

My two friends who were in their 40’s when they had their babies would have claimed they loved it then but it is a very different matter 10 years on. Both have started having health problems, both struggle to keep up with pre teen boys who want to play football, ride bikes and go climbing. They worry about the future and paying for university. My ex mil had an accidental pregnancy in her forties and she has struggled with her physical and mental health ever since, gestational diabetes turned into type 2 diabetes and the sleepless night coincided with menopause which has left her unable to sleep 20 years on.
I have a friend who was the first one in one of my social groups to have children in her 20s. She ended up with gestational diabetes then type 2 diabetes. She has a family history of type 2 diabetes.

I also have a family history of type 2 diabetes. I had my baby when I was 43. I didn't have gestational diabetes and I haven't got type 2.

Since my 20s - before my friend had her children- I knew I had to keep active and keep my weight under control.

Waxonwaxoff0 · 11/11/2021 09:05

I do think YABU as you already have 2 children.

Comedycook · 11/11/2021 09:05

Oh I see what you mean....I thought you meant the older kids could help look after the younger one!

RedWingBoots · 11/11/2021 09:05

All the PPs saying you will be mistaken for their Gran at school plus out and about obviously live in an area were most parents are under 35.

I live in an area were most parents are older. If you look like a parent and you are under 30 or just simply look it you get shit. I only realised this when I went to a baby group when other mums were refusing to talk to a younger mum. (She was lovely most of the rest of them were stuck up.)

Likewise with children's activities like soft play it's the younger parents who get the dirty looks.

Btw I'm 46 with a 3 year old. I refuse to have anymore children because I don't want twins plus my child has a half-sibling. Anyway if you have a maternal family history of women having children in their 40s - like I have - you probably will be ok.

UsedUpUsername · 11/11/2021 09:04

@Comedycook

In this case there are older siblings that will be better placed to help

Why should they?!

I actually was answering to the question about children of older parents being burdened with their elder care—it’s a concern, but in this case, she also has two older children better able to assist her in old age.
bumbleymummy · 11/11/2021 08:49

@Tal45

I think it would be selfish OP IMO, if you had no children I could understand but you already have 2. What about becoming a foster parent if you feel like you're going to miss having children around?
This is a good idea and worth looking into. We know people who fostered in their late 50s/60s. It was lovely for them and the children.
user1471462428 · 11/11/2021 08:46

My two friends who were in their 40’s when they had their babies would have claimed they loved it then but it is a very different matter 10 years on. Both have started having health problems, both struggle to keep up with pre teen boys who want to play football, ride bikes and go climbing. They worry about the future and paying for university.
My ex mil had an accidental pregnancy in her forties and she has struggled with her physical and mental health ever since, gestational diabetes turned into type 2 diabetes and the sleepless night coincided with menopause which has left her unable to sleep 20 years on.

Tal45 · 11/11/2021 08:41

I think it would be selfish OP IMO, if you had no children I could understand but you already have 2. What about becoming a foster parent if you feel like you're going to miss having children around?

bumbleymummy · 11/11/2021 08:41

@bonfireheart

With any decision like this I find sitting down and why down thoughts help
  • why its good idea to have baby 3
  • why it's not a good idea to have baby 3
Use this to decide, using head more than heart.

Your age
The age gaps
How baby would fit in with work...family...lifestyle...size of house...finances
How old you would be when child left school
Your general health - physical n mental
Hubby on board?
Both DC on board?

All of these! It can be wonderful to have another baby but you may be surprised at how much a younger child at a different development stage can change the family dynamic. Things that you can enjoy with your older children at the moment can be harder eg outdoor pursuits/cinema/theatre trips etc - you may not be in to those things though! Just worth a thought.
Udouhun · 11/11/2021 08:38

At 45 you're unlikely to carry a healthy baby to term. Those are the statistics. I wish they weren't because I'm in my 40s and would love another baby but facts are facts.

Megalameg · 11/11/2021 08:35

@statetrooperstacey

There are literally many tests mothers can take to see if it’s likely they will have a special needs child - and in most cases it’s still not that likely. The risks presented by older sperm are minuscule and over represented on this site bizzarely because some women here like to pretend men suffer serious fertility ageing issues too when their risks are practically negligible - so they give bad advice to women which isn’t practically true or helpful at all.

BigYellowHat · 11/11/2021 08:07

Nah, don’t do it. Your kids are at a great age and you’re just getting close to when you’ll have complete freedom. You don’t want to start all over again, surely. Plus, will you feel bad that a new baby doesn’t have a sibling who is close in age? I’m loving it now my son is 18. We have a totally different relationship and I couldn’t imagine doing the whole baby/toddler/school thing again.

SmileyClare · 11/11/2021 08:04

I sometimes feel like this Op. I'm mid forties.

I sober myself up by reframing it as "Do I want to parent a teenager when I'm a pensioner?"

I might be a grandmother in ten years and so might you. I'm trying to embrace this stage of life rather than looking back fondly at the baby years of motherhood. Smile