Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to want another baby at 45

239 replies

Mushroomlover · 10/11/2021 20:18

We have two DC aged 16 and 13. About 10 years ago DH and I had a talk about whether we wanted any more. He said he was happy to do whatever I wanted and I said what I thought at the time, which is that I was very happy with two.

However for the last year I have found myself longing for another baby. I'm struggling to know whether this is really what I want or just a response to a sort of early-onset empty nest syndrome I've been feeling (my DC are still at home, than goodness, but I'm really aware that they won't be forever). I also don't have any sense of what my odds would be of getting pregnant at this age. I'm in good health (bit overweight but can diet) and no signs of perimenopause. Is there any way I can check my fertility?

Wondered whether anyone had been through this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NoraEphronsNeck · 08/03/2022 12:21

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

JanisMoplin · 08/03/2022 11:46

Do think about the expense and emotional labour of DC as teens or young adults. In my experience, bringing up younger kids was much easier. I have two, one has had a very hard time as a YA in the pandemic. I have had a lot of unforeseen medical and educational expenses as a result. If I had had three, I would have collapsed. I simply didn;t foresee how much support they would need with uni, A Levels, mental health, and nearly everything else. OFC I didn't foresee a pandemic.

Benjoir · 08/03/2022 11:22

Isn't this a very common thing that women who about are to start their menopause go through? I've heard this happening to SOOOOOOOO many women this age.
L

Nicewarmsocks · 08/03/2022 11:13

New to Mumsnet but had nearly the same question as the OP. Nearing 45, 2 kids over age 10. Have wanted a baby for 3 years now but keep agonising over whether to do it. Waiting hasn't made it better.

To those who say "Get a kitten," that's what my husband suggested 3 years ago when I first brought up having a 3rd baby. Horrible decision. At 3, that cat still wakes us at night more than a 3 year old would do by now, and she's a constant daily reminder of the baby I wanted but didn't have. A cat is nothing, nothing like a child.

To those who say "The horror, someone might think I'm the grandmother," I suppose we all have different insecurities. Mine are more career-success-related. But I have trouble imagining a situation where I'd feel bothered by someone thinking I'm a grandmother.

To those who say, "Think of the freedom you're giving up. What about going out in the evenings?"---maybe that's my problem. I don't go out. Maybe I'm weird, but I'm kind of an introvert and always found it more stressful than not to go out with people so I've hardly ever done it, even as a young adult. My husband's the same way. All I've ever really wanted is my career and children. (I've wanted my current career since I was a young child, and spent years getting the advanced degrees and training to do it.) But over time I've found I feel much more fulfilled by the time I spend with my children than the time I spend working.

My husband now says he'd be happy to try to have a baby if that's what I want. Even our kids say they're on board if that's what I want, but I'm still really worried about how it would impact them and how it would impact the new child.

Puppylovetheycallit · 16/11/2021 19:40

I believe this is called ‘the last fling of the ovaries.”
I felt the same. I still sometimes do. A puppy cured me of the extreme broodiness and reminded me of how much hard work dependent living things are! I truly had forgotten and totally rose tinted it! Now he is a lovely adult dog, he provides the exact weight and feeling of a lovely baby!!! He is also about 100K cheaper than a third baby!
Wishing you all the best whatever you decide OP. 🙂

Antonia2021 · 16/11/2021 19:21

@PyongyangKipperbang

Actually, saying that, it DOES still happen but it fucking well shouldnt.

I assume @Antonia2021 that you dont know that ovarian cancer can present as the menopause, for example?

Actually , NICE guidelines state you don’t need tests to diagnose peri/menopause
PyongyangKipperbang · 15/11/2021 23:04

Actually, saying that, it DOES still happen but it fucking well shouldnt.

I assume @Antonia2021 that you dont know that ovarian cancer can present as the menopause, for example?

PyongyangKipperbang · 15/11/2021 23:02

Why did it take two years to work out it was meno at 48 though? Isn’t that a given at that age ?

It used to be "oh its just The Change dear..." . And thats why a lot of women died of horrible cancers because their symptoms were written off due to their age. Thank goodness that it doesnt happen anymore. I am 48 and going through the menopauses tests and I am thankful for it.

cushioncovers · 14/11/2021 20:13

My grandmother had two more children later on in her marriage at the age of 42 and 43 years old. (She already had 4 older children) By time she was 53 she bitterly regretted it and it showed in her parenting.

Antonia2021 · 13/11/2021 19:22

@Dragongirl10

Yep, l get it, at 45 l wanted another baby, (I have two dcs) At 48 l hit menopause although l didn't know what was happening to me, Total mind numbing exhaustion Excrutiating joint pains brain fog Severe night palpitations every night (thought l could be having a heart attack) inexplicably unable to sleep Plantar facitis so badly l could barely walk.

It took 2 years and a plethora of medical tests to establish menopause, and another 2 years to get HRT right...

But,
l am still nowhere near the energetic woman l was in my early forties, and l have two (admittedly fab) teenagers who need me plus elderly parents...There is no way l could manage a third younger child nor would it be fair to them.

Please think very carefully, yes you may sail through menopause and have no other caring responsibilities, but there is still a world of difference between how you feel in your 50s compared to your fourties.

You are blessed with two children already, and the yearning gallops off into the distance when you hit the menopause.

Why did it take two years to work out it was meno at 48 though? Isn’t that a given at that age ?

Agree though - things change v fast after 45!

MsTSwift · 11/11/2021 17:20

Surely the opposite is true and climate aware people who limit their families are more likely not less to be more careful in other areas of life too? Plus having numerous kids who all need houses cars plastic wrapped food and have kids of their own is surely far more impact than the odd long haul flight!

Thecurliestwurly · 11/11/2021 15:38

[quote TaraRhu]@Thegreenray Prince Harry and Megan are fairly good examples of people who claim to care about the planet enough to only have two kids but regularly jet around.

I don't believe a many of the people that claim not to want kids for the planet. I think they say it as a)it's fashionable b) it's more socially acceptable than saying you don't want them (especially for women) c) many are young and have no idea whether they want them or not d) stave off the annoying pity face from people that have kids.

[/quote]
I saw an article on the BBC website earlier that said the richest 1% in the world are responsible for the same amount of CO2 emissions as the poorest 50%. So it isn't the amount of people, just the way we consume.

Dragongirl10 · 11/11/2021 15:19

Yep, l get it, at 45 l wanted another baby, (I have two dcs)
At 48 l hit menopause although l didn't know what was happening to me,
Total mind numbing exhaustion
Excrutiating joint pains
brain fog
Severe night palpitations every night (thought l could be having a heart attack)
inexplicably unable to sleep
Plantar facitis so badly l could barely walk.

It took 2 years and a plethora of medical tests to establish menopause, and another 2 years to get HRT right...

But,
l am still nowhere near the energetic woman l was in my early forties, and l have two (admittedly fab) teenagers who need me plus elderly parents...There is no way l could manage a third younger child nor would it be fair to them.

Please think very carefully, yes you may sail through menopause and have no other caring responsibilities, but there is still a world of difference between how you feel in your 50s compared to your fourties.

You are blessed with two children already, and the yearning gallops off into the distance when you hit the menopause.

TaraRhu · 11/11/2021 15:08

@Thegreenray Prince Harry and Megan are fairly good examples of people who claim to care about the planet enough to only have two kids but regularly jet around.

I don't believe a many of the people that claim not to want kids for the planet. I think they say it as a)it's fashionable b) it's more socially acceptable than saying you don't want them (especially for women) c) many are young and have no idea whether they want them or not d) stave off the annoying pity face from people that have kids.

Thegreenray · 11/11/2021 14:38

@NanaPorsche

My friend/colleague had two children in her 40s. Her last conceived at 45 - she was 46 when she gave birth.

She had three daughters already (same husband) youngest was 18 yrs. She had another daughter at 43 and then a son. The older girls had gone to universities and did not return home to stay.

She's 67 - all her children have left home, they are all very successful education/careers and now she is childminding several primary school aged grandchildren. Her family have kept her young and fit. She is a remarkable lady - she absolutely adores her family life. She retired this year - we worked at the same primary school for years.

I think those people moaning about the planet and reducing family size to 1 child are the ones taking several long haul flights a year/having massive carbon footprints.

My friend has never been abroad and she's really proud of that. Always holidays within the UK.

You have absolutely no reason for thinking that people who recognise that having children has a big environmental effect are those who fly long distance. That statement is nonsensical.
strivingtosucceed · 11/11/2021 14:11

My parents had a third when I was 17 and let me tell you, I definitely resent them for it. My teenage and university years (i lived at home for uni) were spent taking care of my sibling and I lacked a lot of support from my parents at the time.

I don't really have a relationship with them because I live away from them now, and it's very possible that they could lose both parents in their mid 30s. Think very carefully OP.

Siameasy · 11/11/2021 12:33

I’m 45 and say no frigging way. Why would you go back to that?! I had my first and only at 38 and that was hard enough. Start a new hobby or endeavour with all your lovely free time.
I have also experienced crazy sex drive around ovulation and DH and I did discuss a second when DD started school (I was 43 and we decided against it).

fournonblondes · 11/11/2021 12:23

Assuming you are good parents it is 18 years at least of commitment. You will have a child/ preteen during your menopause. It would be a hard pass for me but each to their own.

onlyreadingneverposting8 · 11/11/2021 12:09

I had a baby at nearly 45, 4 yr gap to my next. No different. Not more tired. I exercise a lot...probably knock out over 20,000 steps a day. I have 9 children living at home. 2 are adults. Teenagers, tweens etc. you're as old as you feel..except your fertility. I had no problem getting pregnant but had 3 miscarriages before conceiving my almost 1 yr old.

Thecurliestwurly · 11/11/2021 11:12

This thread is well advanced now but I will add my message to the OP. I had my first at 32 and second at 37. I'm knackered. My son is still waking in the night at 3 and is having issues with his speech which means lots of running around with appointments as well as FT work/looking after other primary aged child (who isn't that demanding as a teenager). I think biology sometimes makes you want more babies, but it needs to work in your life. You might not get an easy baby either. Both of mine weren't, but the second is on another level!

What about your parents (haven't RFT, so sorry if you have addressed this). Mine could potentially start needing my help in about 10 years/maybe sooner. You might even have grandkids to think about too. My DH became a grandparent quite young unexpectedly. It happens.

Do you work FT OP? Holding down a FT job with a baby and teenagers is going to be hard.

I recommend getting a puppy or a cat. It might fill the void a bit.

UsedUpUsername · 11/11/2021 11:11

@JudgementalCactus

Why needlessly compare it to child sex abuse?

To show how weak an argument "but nature intends you to* is, obviously!

That’s not what she said.

Do you think there’s something wrong with a 45 year old woman having a baby?

JudgementalCactus · 11/11/2021 11:02

Why needlessly compare it to child sex abuse?

To show how weak an argument "but nature intends you to* is, obviously!

UsedUpUsername · 11/11/2021 10:57

But I mean... the way nature intended it to be and how it was for thousands of years is for women to be perpetually either pregnant or breast-feeding from the time they first start menstruating. Just because something is "natural" and possible doesn't make it right

There’s no right or wrong with having a baby in your mid 40s. If you are able, then it’s a matter of personal choice. I think PP argument was that if nature still allows you to conceive, why not give it a go if your personal situation allows for it?

Why needlessly compare it to child sex abuse?

JudgementalCactus · 11/11/2021 10:49

[quote Megalameg]@LittleDandelionClock

Way to compare Mothers in their 40’s to victims of child abuse. Real classy.

Many women in their 40’s have raised healthy happy babies all throughout history and in the present. Calm down.[/quote]
But I mean... the way nature intended it to be and how it was for thousands of years is for women to be perpetually either pregnant or breast-feeding from the time they first start menstruating. Just because something is "natural" and possible doesn't make it right.

Therefore, nature allowing it doesn't automatically make it sensible. Which refutes your whole argument.

NanaPorsche · 11/11/2021 10:39

My friend/colleague had two children in her 40s. Her last conceived at 45 - she was 46 when she gave birth.

She had three daughters already (same husband) youngest was 18 yrs. She had another daughter at 43 and then a son. The older girls had gone to universities and did not return home to stay.

She's 67 - all her children have left home, they are all very successful education/careers and now she is childminding several primary school aged grandchildren. Her family have kept her young and fit. She is a remarkable lady - she absolutely adores her family life. She retired this year - we worked at the same primary school for years.

I think those people moaning about the planet and reducing family size to 1 child are the ones taking several long haul flights a year/having massive carbon footprints.

My friend has never been abroad and she's really proud of that. Always holidays within the UK.