Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Singapore not giving free treatment to anti-vaxxers

270 replies

Whose · 10/11/2021 20:04

stops paying for Covid treatment for people who are unvaccinated by choice | The Independent" www.independent.co.uk/asia/southeast-asia/singapore-free-covid-treatment-unvaccinated-b1954077.html?amp

AIBU to think this fair enough?

Currently, unvaccinated persons make up a sizeable majority of those who require intensive inpatient care, and disproportionately contribute to the strain on our healthcare resources,

(Those who haven't had the vaccine because they medically can't are excluded from this)

OP posts:
OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/11/2021 11:30

I don't think anti-vaxxers should be denied treatment as such, but they certainly shouldn't be prioritised. I.e. if there's an anti-vax covid patient and a heart attack victim both waiting for an ICU bed, then I think the heart attack victim should get the bed. Likewise for waiting for an ambulance, etc what if the heart attack victim was a red meat red wine every night, no exercise paedophile and the non vaxxer had a heart condition that made them fearful of the enlarged heart link with the vaccine hence they hadnt had it?

user1497207191 · 11/11/2021 11:25

I don't think anti-vaxxers should be denied treatment as such, but they certainly shouldn't be prioritised. I.e. if there's an anti-vax covid patient and a heart attack victim both waiting for an ICU bed, then I think the heart attack victim should get the bed. Likewise for waiting for an ambulance, etc.

ItsSnowJokes · 11/11/2021 11:20

@MissTrip82

I’m an ICU dr.

I find this disgusting. Entirely unethical.

If we don’t offer free treatment to everyone who’s contributed to their own illness….we’d treat hardly anyone for free.

There is also, IME, a very strong correlation indeed between poor levels of education and anti-vaxx views. I’m not interested in punishing people because they have had significantly less education that I’ve had.

The day I start judging patients like this is the day I leave medicine. I’ll know I’ve become a deformed soul.

They don't have universal free healthcare in Singapore. There is no NHS out there. You are missing that point entirely. With the system they have they have given free health care for covid treatment from the beginning. Now they are saying you won't get it free if you are unvaccinated. You will still get treatment, they are not withholding treatment, you will just have to pay or use your insurance.
twelly · 11/11/2021 11:11

I was referring to this policy being adopted in the UK - Singapore makes its own rules and therefore the system is different

Owlmeow · 11/11/2021 11:08

@twelly

I think treatment should still be provided for people even if they did not have the vaccine - the vaccine is not compulsory people are free to make their own decisions, we don't know the reason behind every person who has decided not to vaccinate. If it was decided not to vaccinate then this would set a precedent - so not treating those who drink alcohol for alcohol related illnesses, not treating those who are overweight where this has caused their illness
But there they treat no one for free, aside from covid which was an exception.
twelly · 11/11/2021 11:06

I think treatment should still be provided for people even if they did not have the vaccine - the vaccine is not compulsory people are free to make their own decisions, we don't know the reason behind every person who has decided not to vaccinate. If it was decided not to vaccinate then this would set a precedent - so not treating those who drink alcohol for alcohol related illnesses, not treating those who are overweight where this has caused their illness

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/11/2021 11:05

I do think there should be punishments including jail time and revoking of professional titles/qualifications for some of the people at the pinnacle of the misinformation that's out there. They have cost a lot of lives totally impossible, you'd have to trace back the source on the internet

Owlmeow · 11/11/2021 11:04

@MissTrip82

I’m an ICU dr.

I find this disgusting. Entirely unethical.

If we don’t offer free treatment to everyone who’s contributed to their own illness….we’d treat hardly anyone for free.

There is also, IME, a very strong correlation indeed between poor levels of education and anti-vaxx views. I’m not interested in punishing people because they have had significantly less education that I’ve had.

The day I start judging patients like this is the day I leave medicine. I’ll know I’ve become a deformed soul.

Okay but you realise they don't have universal healthcare there anyway, right?
Mreggsworth · 11/11/2021 11:04

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

This is about a country without an NHS. It's a country where you are expected to take some financial responsibility for your health, and has made one exception for covid, they are now back tracking as all that financial support is going to those who have decided not to take precautions to vaccinate themselves and it isnt a sustainable model for them.

SusieBob · 11/11/2021 11:02

@Juniper68

You are aware you can still carry covid when vaxxed?
Yes, we know, not least because on every thread discussing COVID someone will pop up and smugly declare it as if it's some sort of trump card.

The vaccine significantly reduces the risk of catching, spreading and becoming seriously ill. That's pretty crucial.

lunar1 · 11/11/2021 11:00

Given that they don't have free healthcare as standard I think it's fair enough. Treatment is a benefit for people who have had the vaccine.

It wouldn't work with the NHS as it's built upon 'free at the point of delivery'

The majority of the population make choices that aren't ideal, we don't punish people for those decisions.

I do think there should be punishments including jail time and revoking of professional titles/qualifications for some of the people at the pinnacle of the misinformation that's out there. They have cost a lot of lives.

SusieBob · 11/11/2021 11:00

@MissTrip82

I’m an ICU dr.

I find this disgusting. Entirely unethical.

If we don’t offer free treatment to everyone who’s contributed to their own illness….we’d treat hardly anyone for free.

There is also, IME, a very strong correlation indeed between poor levels of education and anti-vaxx views. I’m not interested in punishing people because they have had significantly less education that I’ve had.

The day I start judging patients like this is the day I leave medicine. I’ll know I’ve become a deformed soul.

The difference being that Singapore doesn't have universal healthcare. The two situations are in no way compariable.
LovelaceBiggWither · 11/11/2021 11:00

The state I live in has just brought in that unvaccinated people are not allowed to visit hospitals unless it is end of life emergency or childbirth. It's really unclear if this means they are not allowed to 'visit' a hospital as an outpatient. Public hospital care is free here but it's also unclear if they are going to be banned from private hospitals.

I'm hoping the premier clarifies this and soon because I find the idea of people not being able to access care a bit horrifying. Even if I think they should be getting vaccinated.

Juniper68 · 11/11/2021 10:59

You are aware you can still carry covid when vaxxed?

Mreggsworth · 11/11/2021 10:58

@MissTrip82

We arent talking about the UK though where all healthcare is free. I don't think this rule would work in the UK for that reason. This is about a country that made a free health care for covid exception, all they've done now is add in that they now must be vaccinated to access their free covid healthcare .Which is reasonable.

I don't know much about Singapore but it doesnt strike me as a place that would allow people to die and not have healthcare, I presume people would be treated just given a bill to deal with afterwards.

Which, is pretty much the scenario those without insurance or money to pay upfront would be in for any type of medical emergency, covid or not.

SickAndTiredAgain · 11/11/2021 10:55

If we don’t offer free treatment to everyone who’s contributed to their own illness….we’d treat hardly anyone for free.

Singapore doesn’t treat anyone for free (except vaccinated people with covid).

I’d be extremely anti this being introduced in the UK and I don’t think it would be. But in Singapore, I assume this is just a step towards them eventually removing the free treatment for covid in general for everyone, which was brought in as an exceptional thing. I doubt they’ll continue funding treatment for this when they don’t fund anything else.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/11/2021 10:54

Being obese, drunk or high on drugs isn't contagious though no but it takes up a health service that is already under strain, it can risk other people's lives if you drink drive etc

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 11/11/2021 10:53

Mreggsworth so why not just refuse all medical treatment to all unvaccinated then- they are saying its ok as long as you can pay. That's like ULEZ, if the issue is diesel cars just ban them, dont make them ok for the rich only.

And I'm sure much of our NHS treatment goes on reckless people: car crashes/ Heart attacks/ abortions when contraception is free....

user1497207191 · 11/11/2021 10:53

@ColinTheKoala

No I don't think it's fair enough unless you extend it to obese people, those who abuse alcohol and drugs, those who drive recklessly and endanger their own and other peoples' lives - ultimately you could even extend it to those who break their legs ski-ing or twist an ankle running.

Where does it end? I can see the logic, but it's a very dangerous slippery slope. Either you provide care or you don't.

Being obese, drunk or high on drugs isn't contagious though.
Juniper68 · 11/11/2021 10:50

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

SO BASICALLY ITS OK TO BE AN ANTIVAXER AS LONG AS YOU AREN'T POOR!!! Well this is a terrifying slope the world is going down, bullying the poor, moral judgements on who gets to work and who gets medical treatment. Everyone who supports this should be ashamed - and yes Im vaccinated and happy to be!
^^This with bells on.

What a terrible world we're living in.

MissTrip82 · 11/11/2021 10:46

I’m an ICU dr.

I find this disgusting. Entirely unethical.

If we don’t offer free treatment to everyone who’s contributed to their own illness….we’d treat hardly anyone for free.

There is also, IME, a very strong correlation indeed between poor levels of education and anti-vaxx views. I’m not interested in punishing people because they have had significantly less education that I’ve had.

The day I start judging patients like this is the day I leave medicine. I’ll know I’ve become a deformed soul.

Porcupineintherough · 11/11/2021 10:46

I think most of the world's poor would be delighted to get free medical treatment which is generally unavailable to them @OnlyFoolsnMothers Most of them havent been offered a vaccine either.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/11/2021 10:46

@Lockheart

No, sorry. I don't agree with anti-vaxxers in any way but nor do I believe healthcare should be withheld because we disagree with others moral choices. Doesn't matter if it's vaccinations, organ donations, blood donations, what charities you donate to or what companies you work for. Accessible healthcare is either a basic right or it is not. I would hope we all agree it is.
I can’t agree that refusing the vaccine for no medical reason is a ‘moral’ choice. More likely a stupidity/ignorance choice IMO, usually fuelled by anti-vax crap on social media.
Mreggsworth · 11/11/2021 10:45

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

They arent targeting the poor. The government just arent prepared to continue footing the bill for peoples poor decisions to not get vaccinated. If you are worried about being seriously Ill from covid but cant afford the medical bills, just get the vaccine. Sorted!

They have stated it's the unvaccinated taking up most of the resources now, considering how easily avoidable that is it makes sense for them to impose this rule.

DumplingsAndStew · 11/11/2021 10:38

I think it sounds fair, though I've not looked at details indepth.

They aren't removing free healthcare for unvaccinated as such; they are offering free healthcare for those who are vaccinated.