Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want 5 year old around a dangerous dog breed...

106 replies

ponyclub1234 · 10/11/2021 13:28

My 5 year olds best friends family have got an American Bulldog, a huge dog that looks like pure muscle, they want DD to go for a play date but I am not comfortable with her being around this dog, expecially in light of the recent news story about the 7 year old killed by his friends American pitbull. I know they are not used to raising this type of breed either and will not have been responsible in socialising / training it correctly.

How can I politely decline on this basis??
I know theres no point making an excuse as they'll just ask to rearrange but I don't want to create conflict as I do get on with her mother and we are around each other a lot.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Iamanicepersonreally · 12/11/2021 12:57

Just be honest with them. No way in the world would I let my 5 year old child be around that dog

Welshiefluff · 12/11/2021 12:54

For God's sake people will continue to say its not the breed but let's all get real here it is. Its always the bully breeds that kill children. Its always these types of dog that are aggrssive and untrained

Here here

There have been so many occasions where they are not looked after properly. The problem with this breed is its capability of killing , rather than how the dog will behave if looked after properly. Much like we ban guns because they have the capability of killing in the wrong hands and have no real benefit to society.

There is clearly an issue where we the average person is unequipped to own and look after these big powerful dogs and as such more restriction should be put in place.

You frequently get dog owners who say my dog is a loveable scamp and has never bitten anyone which might be true until the first time they bite somebody and in which case it may be too late.

Bigger breeds have more capability to injure and kill, I bet there are loads of other dogs attacks daily that do not make the news because generally nobody dies from a Toy Fox Terrier getting a bit shirty. Compare this to the result of a Rottweier or American bulldog who could easily overpower an adult.

Remove the dogs that can be the most dangerous in the wrong hands and you remove most of the problem.

catgirl1976 · 12/11/2021 12:46

YANBU at all. I would not let DS go to a home with that sort of dog and I love dogs. Even if they shut the dog away it only takes a second.

Just say you are sorry but you are not comfortable with the dog and they can have a play date at yours instead. If they don’t understand that then I don’t think it’s a friendship you’d want to encourage any way.

Welshiefluff · 12/11/2021 12:32

American bulldogs aren’t banned breeds. They were bred as farm dogs similar to collie dogs

They are still natural fighting dogs and can be very large. In the wrong hands they can be very dangerous.

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 12/11/2021 09:45

@Branleuse

Im wary of children with my staffie tbh despite the fact she is soppy and loves children, but i always watch like a hawk
Yes. My bull terrier has always proven calmer with small children and old people - we live between a nursery and a few sheltered housing schemes.

But there's no way in hell I will ever relax my vigilance. He's a dog!

And that's all anyone need ponder before making any decision about visiting A N Other.

Why do people want to own these dogs Which dogs?

A Heinz? A specific breed? A dog on the dangerous breed list? A dog they can train to be aggressive? Big dog? Teacup dog?

SpookyPumpkinPants · 12/11/2021 09:24

@Boopeedoop

I used to have an English mastiff, and as soppy as he was I understood friends discomfort with his size. He was always in a separate room with a solid wooden door when friends children were present.

Have a conversation with them, they may have a similar rule?

They are gorgeous dogs! I'd love one, but need to move to a bigger house first!!!
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 12/11/2021 08:57

I love dogs, but I wouldn’t want a child anywhere near one of those. And TBH I’d seriously suspect the common sense of anyone acquiring that sort of breed when they have children. Or even when they don’t, to be frank.
I’d just be honest and say you’re not happy with your child being around a dog of that type, and suggest their child coming to you instead - assuming that that’s possible.

Fomomofo · 12/11/2021 08:54

Why do people want to own these dogs

FOJN · 12/11/2021 08:53

The question to ask yourself is, "am I more worried about offending this person than I am about my child's safety?"

You're not comfortable with it, you do not need to justify it.

Branleuse · 12/11/2021 08:48

Im wary of children with my staffie tbh despite the fact she is soppy and loves children, but i always watch like a hawk

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 11/11/2021 13:52

Its always the bully breeds that kill children. Its always these types of dog that are aggressive and untrained. No. It really isn't.

Despite all the hard boys and girls owning all sorts of bullies and training them to be mean, they do not make up the majority of breeds that kill, kids or adults.

It's that kind of misinformation that leads to all sorts of stupidities - inlcuding teh number of hard boys and girls owning all sorts of bullies and training them to be mean.

And OP doesn't even have to consider the dog breed, she just says no!

2bazookas · 10/11/2021 20:48

Just politely, firmly tell them the truth. You don't trust that breed of dog around children so can't let your child visit their house, ever.

No promises , reassurances or conditions will change your decision.

Little Friend can come to yours in stead.

Arren12 · 10/11/2021 20:46

For God's sake people will continue to say its not the breed but let's all get real here it is. Its always the bully breeds that kill children. Its always these types of dog that are aggressive and untrained.

Of course there are incidents involving other breeds and aggressive other breeds but the vast majority are big muscley bully dogs. Saying and claiming otherwise is utter rubbish.

These are not good pets. They are dangerous. I'm absolutely sick of one in my neighborhood that I have reported again and again. Its a matter of time before it kills someone. Its already attacked someone. Its brother who lived in the same house almost killed someone but because this dog didn't do the actual bite this time its been allowed home.

Its likely these breeds have shit owners. Like in my neighborhood. never propeely walked and untrained.

Saw another American bully puppy being walked yesterday. It was pulling the owner along while she meekly said stop Zeus. I was walking with my dog and child and it was pulling towards us. Owner looked offended when I gave them a wide bearth.

I have a large dog who is soft as butter. Spot on obedience and temprement. Id trust her with anyone and with my life but im not stupid and she is out when we have unknown children around. I do like dogs in general. Hell would freeze over before I let my dc in a house with a bully breed and I'd not be ashamed to say so.

MrsSkylerWhite · 10/11/2021 20:37

Just tell her, don’t want child playing in a house with a bloody great big, scary looking dog.

dangermouseisace · 10/11/2021 20:36

If you don’t feel comfortable with the dog, decline.
My sister was horrendously attacked age 8 by a dog at her friends (she survived with severe physical and psychological scars). My sister was just running about playing with her friend, and the dog attacked her.
If you don’t have confidence in the owner or the dog, don’t take the risk. Go with your gut instinct.

Maddy456 · 10/11/2021 20:35

I would be exactly the same as you - absolutely no way my child would be going to that house at all.

Memyselfandfood · 10/11/2021 20:33

Aren’t American pitbulls banned in the U.K., or strictly regulated? They’re notorious for unprovoked attacks on children

Yes but these people don’t have a pitbull Hmm
This is not a banned breed…

Every few years it’s a different dog that people jump on. Years ago it was rotties, then it was staffies, now pittbulls.
It’s bad owners.
Ive been bitten multiple times, never buy the large dogs i’ve been around, but by the yappy little ones.
Still have the scars from them.

Mommabear20 · 10/11/2021 20:22

YANBU! We have dogs (terrier breeds) but they too are very defensive of DC. I don't think any good parent or dog owner would mind you declining in this basis as long as you're honest about it being the dog that's your problem. I certainly don't mind if people would rather we meet out somewhere rather than coming here. We chose to get dogs but not everyone else wants to be around them.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 10/11/2021 20:16

Banned breeds:
Japanese Tosa
Brazilian filiera or something like that
Dogo Argentino
Pitbull terrier

liveforsummer · 10/11/2021 20:16

You'd be very hard pushed to find a whippet, say, or a small spaniel who had seriously hurt (or worse) a child (especially a child older than a toddler/baby)

I'm sure spaniels are one of the most common dogs to have bitten, whippets can be nervy and not always ideal around strange children. There have been plenty incidents of babies and children seriously hurt or killed by small dogs

funinthesun19 · 10/11/2021 20:15

Why would people lie about the reason for not wanting to be around this type of dog ?

Some owners go all weird and offended. I guess it’s to try and avoid the fall out.
But yes, I don’t think people should lie like it’s some taboo to say you don’t want to be around someone’s dog.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 10/11/2021 20:14

@FateHasRedesignedMost

I’d just say I wasn’t happy with my child being around a dog of that size and breed.

Aren’t American pitbulls banned in the U.K., or strictly regulated? They’re notorious for unprovoked attacks on children.

Sadly there’s still an underground market for dog fighting, betting and breeding. Pitbull types (often American pitbulls with false papers to pass them off as staff crosses) are a popular fighting dog.

American pitbulls are banned however there are several legal breeds that get mistaken for them. American Bulldogs (different breed) are legal.
BoredZelda · 10/11/2021 20:11

I don't mind if someone asks me to put the dog away. They never do though

I’d ask. Generally people are shitty about it though!

liveforsummer · 10/11/2021 20:11

Are you sure it’s an American pit bull? I thought they were banned in the U.K…

She didn't say it was an American pitbull. She said it was an American bulldog. I know several. All soft friendly dogs (to humans) but I still understand why op is concerned

BoredZelda · 10/11/2021 20:10

Claim allergies. If you go anywhere near the “dogs are dangerous” discussion, it will not end well.