Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like this

143 replies

giraffes2021 · 09/11/2021 23:29

So me and DP been together 8 years 2 young children

I now work 3 days a week so he's main earner, not married, I pay nursery which is like £800 for 2 kids and my own bills such as car insurance fuel etc DP pays for mortgage etc.
Obviously he has a lot more disposable income than me, he's a bit more sensible than me always has money in the bank he's always been the higher earner. If I need money I ask etc and he'll give me money but it's just a crappy feeling always having to ask or say I need money for x y z or just not being in a position to be able to put a bit of cash aside. Obviously my income has dropped as I only do 3 days - isn't it just a shitty feeling as a woman or am I overthinking ?

OP posts:
LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 10/11/2021 10:21

[quote giraffes2021]@HollowTalk I know when you put it like that. But then again if I needed money he would give it me but I guess that's beside the point [/quote]
You know right now he'd do that. No one knows the future. Do you have some equivalent assets in your name? You say you

SomebodysMum · 10/11/2021 09:57

You say the car costs and fuel are your personal costs.

Do you by any chance use your car and your fuel, that you have paid for, to take your children to the childcare that he also benefits from?

RacketeerRalph · 10/11/2021 09:45

I'm not a fan of Al finances being pooled (e.g both being paid in to a joint account) BUT I do think joint accounts are useful for the payment of household bills.

For example: I'm paid 50% of what DH is paid, so we have added up ALL household bills - this includes childcare and this is paid from a joint account. We both pay in to the joint account based on our income; DH pays 75% of the total, I pay 25% this means we BOTH have disposal income, money for saving etc. I recommend it as a way to keep independence but share the burden of family costs.

Cocomarine · 10/11/2021 09:43

[quote giraffes2021]@HotToddyColdSauvignon how do I need to protect myself if something happens to him? Would it not just go to the children ? [/quote]
Statistically you’re far more likely to split up than him die young.

But say he dies - don’t you know?

It’s the usual triumvirate then:

  • not married
  • not on deeds of house
  • not a beneficiary of his will
Darbs76 · 10/11/2021 09:33

One you’re not on the house deeds, big concern. Two working part time affects your pension, and as you’re not married you won’t be entitled to a share of your partners pension if you split. Pension he’s built from working full time whilst you’re doing more childcare and reducing the childcare bill. To protect yourself you need to get married.

tiggerwhocamefortea · 10/11/2021 09:30

The childcare bill should either be split or paid by the higher earner (I'm the main earner and I pay our astronomical childcare bills)

That being said you said you only do 3 days because you want to spend time with your children therefore that comes with a financial price of having less spending money than the one who works full time (out of necessity to enable the other to work less days)

User527294627 · 10/11/2021 09:28

Sorry, have just seen you do say you're not married. You have to resolve this before it becomes a nightmare for you.

User527294627 · 10/11/2021 09:28

OP you are so, so vulnerable here.

I assume you aren't married, because you call him DP not DH. And you don't own your house - it's in his name and he pays the mortgage. And you work part time, because you have young kids.

If he broke up with you tomorrow you would have no home, no share of his pension, no right to financial compensation for your loss of earnings in going part time, no right to any share of assets. All this despite the fact that you are subsidising his career by working part time so you can provide childcare.

You either need to get married to protect your position, or you need to return to full time work and start putting aside money as a fund for if it all goes tits up, or you need to demand completely shared finances including shared home ownership, with a separate bank account for your savings.

Never mind romantic notions of not 'assuming the relationship will fail'. Mumsnet is rife with stories of women just like you who are left destitute because their relationships fail and they don't have a right to the life they helped finance by providing free childcare.

Act now to protect yourself and your kids. If your partner is a decent person who loves you he will see how wrong it is to expect you to continue to be this vulnerable for his benefit.

00deed1988 · 10/11/2021 09:21

I earn around 4 times as much as my DH, he is part time (3 days a week) to work around me. All our wages go in joint account that pays all the bills, joint and separate (apart from credit cards) and household stuff plus birthdays and Christmas. I then put some into a separate savings account (LISA as we currently rent) and then the remaining is split between the two of us. Our credit cards are paid out of our separate money. That way everything is equal. He gave up a lot for me to retrain and get a better job that I love and extra earning potential. He stays at home with the kids. I would never expect him to lose out while I had money sitting there.

MLMshouldbeillegal · 10/11/2021 09:13

Not married.
No joint account.
Not on the house.

Hmm

Jeezo woman, sort yourself out.

Valeriane · 10/11/2021 09:13

It comes around again and again because women are taught to get a husband and have children and once they've done that to be content with their lot.

Merryoldgoat · 10/11/2021 09:10

Why does this conversation come around again and again and again every few months!?

More like every bloody day!

Merryoldgoat · 10/11/2021 09:08

I’m not sure if you’re being purposely naive for effect but you and your children are in a very vulnerable position.

Read the relationship boards if you need a wake up call.

Regarding money - equal surplus is very easy, even with varied salaries.

Total up all of your outgoings including nursery, food, stuff for kids.

Deduct this from your total earnings for the month.

Whatever’s left you split.

My figs for illustration:

Our salaries total £5k take home

Outgoings total £4100

So we’re left with £450 each for whatever we like.

We just transfer however much of our earnings that leaves us with £450, so DH transfers £2550 and I transfer £1550

If one of us earns less or more it doesn’t matter.

Noimaginationforaun · 10/11/2021 08:54

I think you really need to sit down and have a conversation with your DP. I don’t understand why you have to ask for money?
I work 3 days a week whilst DH is full time. We just have a joint account and a joint savings. All our wages goes in, all the outgoings go out and whatever is left is for us? I honestly thought that was normal. It would be completely unfair to split everything 50/50 when I don’t earn the same! I can’t imagine DH ever being comfortable with me asking for money? We just share!

BunsOfAnarchy · 10/11/2021 08:51

Oh my OP.

You need to sort this ASAP. I'm not saying you'll split but you should always look at your financial situation a lot closer if you have children and are finding yourself depending on a partner now.

STBXH and I did the same. He paid mortgage bills etc. I paid childcare. I wasn't on the mortgage.
We split and luckily no contest and I got my share from house sale (initially I put a hefty deposit in which would have amounted to what he paid for mortgage over 3 years)

However. I still pay childcare. Full childcare. I havent lived with him in 2.5 years and yet because it was always my job to 'only pay childcare' I'm now paying my own rent, bills and 700 a month on childcare. As well as food, dance classes, every single item of clothing for my child.

I shot myself in the foot. And I'm still chasing him to start putting towards childcare and he won't (twat)

I understand its 'fair' but it isn't. It should come out of a joint pot, where you know if anything goes gits up, you won't find yourself financially ruined or unable to provide for your kids.

You should probably add your name to the house now too.

giraffes2021 · 10/11/2021 08:49

@HotToddyColdSauvignon how do I need to protect myself if something happens to him? Would it not just go to the children ?

OP posts:
HotToddyColdSauvignon · 10/11/2021 08:42

Dear god Shock

Not married, and not on the house deeds. But you have children. What happens tomorrow if you / him walks out of the relationship? What happens if (god forbid) he’s hit by a bus!? You have absolutely no protection whatsoever.

Why does this conversation come around again and again and again every few months!?

backtolifebacktoreality · 10/11/2021 08:41

We share our money. We have a joint current account and credit cards (no separate ones). All our money goes in and then everything comes out of it. We also have a joint savings account and if we have more than we need in our current account we transfer it to our savings account!

Cocomarine · 10/11/2021 08:36

🤦‍♀️ when is MN going to introduce a dedicated board for these?

See that house that you sold with no equity? Bet it would have had equity in it now (from house price inflation and mortgage payments) if you’d decided that it was the house in your name that would be kept.

The proportion of bills is one way to do it, as described above. But that can still leave the higher earner with more disposable income. Which I don’t think is inherently unfair - everyone can make their own choices. But with two young children, it’s not what I would consider fair. Total all income. Deduct all outgoings - remembering that everyday things bought for children need to be included - deduct a joint savings amount - and split the rest 50/50. Personally I’d had a joint account for anything but bills - so that 50/50 spends would go to different individual accounts.

giraffes2021 · 10/11/2021 08:08

@dustofneptune but then I guess it's a discussion of what's left over and sharing that between us fairly

OP posts:
giraffes2021 · 10/11/2021 08:07

@dustofneptune I have just done your calculations and based on all our bills etc I am paying just shy of £200 less than I should!! Haha

OP posts:
Fomomofo · 10/11/2021 08:06

If I'm looking after our kids then I expect to share the salary of the parent of those kids, all money in a joint account for equal access

giraffes2021 · 10/11/2021 08:02

@Moonface123 I will very much return to work full time when childcare etc isn't thrown into the mix. I'm not back peddling I guess I'm just surprised at the responses. We have had the conversation re joint finances before etc we just never acted on it, he always gives me the money that I need or ask for so I was just thinking that maybe I was feeling stupid for asking etc.
I didn't have any money from my property there wasn't any equity.

OP posts:
bert3400 · 10/11/2021 07:51

Do you still own your own property OP? This is very important, if you don't you could be thoroughly screwed if your relationship breaks down.

Moonface123 · 10/11/2021 07:48

Your kind of back peddling now OP.
Would you consider going back to work full time, or prefer to keep things as they are?