Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel like this

143 replies

giraffes2021 · 09/11/2021 23:29

So me and DP been together 8 years 2 young children

I now work 3 days a week so he's main earner, not married, I pay nursery which is like £800 for 2 kids and my own bills such as car insurance fuel etc DP pays for mortgage etc.
Obviously he has a lot more disposable income than me, he's a bit more sensible than me always has money in the bank he's always been the higher earner. If I need money I ask etc and he'll give me money but it's just a crappy feeling always having to ask or say I need money for x y z or just not being in a position to be able to put a bit of cash aside. Obviously my income has dropped as I only do 3 days - isn't it just a shitty feeling as a woman or am I overthinking ?

OP posts:
Merryoldgoat · 10/11/2021 18:39

What I hate is the ‘lol - aren’t I silly’ tone. Urgh.

billy1966 · 10/11/2021 16:38

@Flouts1

So let me get this right Your not married Your not on the deeds You work part time You feel like you don’t have enough money but your DP has plenty and you have to ask for money

Your DP owns the house
He is self employed
He benefits from the childcare you do at home on the days your not at work

Trust me he knows exactly what he is doing
He is protecting his interest in his house
He’s not stupid he has a live in housekeeper childminder cleaned & cook and someone to share his bed with .
And it’s not costing him anything because he would have to pay to live somewhere

If you question him about the house getting married or going on the deeds I bet he will get defensive
If he does then you know he is completely aware of what your position is and I expect he won’t budge on it

If you split up at the moment you walk away with nothing apart from what is yours
He’s self employed so don’t count on child support
Honestly I really wish schools could teach some of this shit to kids
You have literally no more rights to anything he has than a complete stranger in the street would

Great post.

I cannot believe how utterly naive some women are on here.

Somehow these men ALWAYS manage to pay the morgage.

FFS wake up🙄

PicsInRed · 10/11/2021 15:44

My God.

ChristmasJumpers · 10/11/2021 13:50

Others have already suggested it but DH and I put our salaries into a joint account which pays for the mortgage, bills, a mobile phone and car each (and petrol). We each have our own bank accounts that we send an equal amount of "spending money" to.

We get the same amount of spending money regardless of who earns more. At the moment it's me, previously I earned a lot more while DH went back to uni for a year. In the future DH will likely be the breadwinner as he now has a career with good prospects and we're TTC so I might go back to work part time after maternity. It works really well, neither of us ever feels we have a higher financial burden or less security.

picklemewalnuts · 10/11/2021 13:25

For goodness sake do the registry office marriage. You can have a big celebration later if you both want one, but marriage takes care of all the big issues in one sweep.

At the moment, you have no financial protection should you split up.

If he died, you could be cut out of the funeral arrangements- that happened to a MNetter after a long, long relationship. You also wouldn't have any right to his death benefits.

You and his children need you to be married for all sorts of boring but essential reasons!

User527294627 · 10/11/2021 13:19

@giraffes2021

I didn't go on the mortgage due to stamp duty but I know that if I said I wanted to go on it he wouldn't have any issues we only did it in his name out of easiness. He would also have a deed and a will made up I guess it's something I need to get done ASAP and a will

Re marriage DP isn't keen on the whole wedding idea he said he'd be quite happy for me to just change my name haha or a registry office how romantic
Conversations need to happen

Amazing how many men 'just aren't keen' on getting married when not doing so benefits them financially at the expense of their partner.
Cocomarine · 10/11/2021 13:08

@giraffes2021

I didn't go on the mortgage due to stamp duty but I know that if I said I wanted to go on it he wouldn't have any issues we only did it in his name out of easiness. He would also have a deed and a will made up I guess it's something I need to get done ASAP and a will

Re marriage DP isn't keen on the whole wedding idea he said he'd be quite happy for me to just change my name haha or a registry office how romantic
Conversations need to happen

It’s not about romance.
Dixiechickonhols · 10/11/2021 13:06

You sound very naive OP.
If he dies intestate then yes children inherit but the logistics of dealing with that when you don’t have access to bank account and aren’t his next of kin aren’t straightforward.
No bereavement support payments (widows allowance) or money towards funeral.

Daily mail link but gives you an idea.
www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-7334313/amp/I-never-felt-marriage-important-day-Paolo-died.html

Obviously there are ways to protect not just marriage but you need to discuss with him and address.

Flouts1 · 10/11/2021 13:04

Tell him you want to get married
Tell him you will be happy with a registry office wedding
Forget the romance romance means fuck all if you split up and have a suitcase of clothes to your name and a tiny baby :

There is nothing romantic about getting married and signing a legal contract in which you are happy to share everything you own with your partner in sickness and in health 😂

Marriage is the important bit it’s a legal contract between two people .
A Wedding is just a big party and a shit load of money spent on other people .
I am always amazed how intelligent independent women fall for this shit from their partners

So tell him you want to get married ASAP
Don’t mention the house because he may then start saying you only want to marry me to your hands on my house

But If he disagrees, gets defensive, wants to put it off because he now wants a big wedding - which may will never happen you will have your answer he knows exactly what he is doing and it’s not in your best interest
As his partner you have absolutely no say over anything financially
Your children do - but you won’t even get the house if he dies

choli · 10/11/2021 13:04

Go back to work full-time and split all the bills 50/50. You will feel much better.

Mischance · 10/11/2021 13:01

When we got together my OH and I opened a joint account and everything went into that. We spent as we needed and only discussed with each other if it was a big spend about which we needed to take a joint decision.

I could not bear having to ask for money.

It was swings and roundabouts as there were times when I earned more and times when he did - it all balanced out.

Dixiechickonhols · 10/11/2021 12:57

Please wake up and protect you and your children. There’s a useful guide on CAB re difference between cohabitation and marriage.
You’ve fallen into trap of paying for donkey work (childcare) and him paying for assets (house)
If you split he’s got a house and you’ve got nothing. He’d only have to pay cm.

aNewYorkerInLondon · 10/11/2021 11:57

For our budget we did a spreadsheet with all of our regular expenses, everything we could think of, even the gym fees. Then we looked at each of our incomes and subtracted that amount from the total to see our extra each month. That leftover divided by 2 is roughly what we each have as disposable income each month. The money for the regular budget is direct deposited from each of us into one account, split by proportions of who makes more, then the disposable income goes into our individual accounts.

So basically say our income overall is 60/40, we also split the regular expenses 60/40 and have an equal amount each of what's left to save or spend as we see fit.

It works for us.

Also, for additional color, there have been times when I've been the higher earner and times when he has been, and we always balance our the budget this way. The higher earner always covers a higher share of the joint expenses, proportional to earnings.

Valeriane · 10/11/2021 11:47

Well that sounds simple enough then. Tonight tell him you want a registry mariage and ask him for a date. Although isnt there something about assets you have before marriage not being split in the event of a separation? (Not married hopefully someone else will know)

Alieninmybody · 10/11/2021 11:24

You don't seem to realise that he's calling all the shots.
If he loves you and values your relationship he will want to protect you. He will want you to be safe and secure especially if anything happens to him.
My husband earns a high wage, mine is low. Everything has always been pooled together. I am solely named as benefactor on all his death in service and share benefits, he insists on having extra life insurance for himself as I would not have his earning potential should the worst happen.

By leaving yourself vulnerable you're also leaving your children vulnerable. Get yourself on the mortgage, then discuss joint accounts and pooling the income.
You've got to be prepared that the person you love could shaft you, it does happen to people unfortunately.

Samhradh1 · 10/11/2021 11:22

@giraffes2021 I also didn’t go on our mortgage for financial reasons but he proposed the day we moved in and we were married within 6 months so I would have equal security of our home.

I would just do a registry office wedding then. That will solve lots of your issues if you also then got a joint account for bills etc set up and equal spending money.

Good luck.

DontWiltMySpinachPlease · 10/11/2021 11:12

Joint accounts are excellent because everything becomes family money and since it's family money, you're less likely to be frivolous with it because it's not just your disposable income.

DH and I have one account, I am the main earner and all our income goes into the account, with a set amount also going into a joint savings account.

Neither of us take the piss with it, the only accounts we have separately are a credit card each as it's the only thing we have to keep Christmas/ birthday purchases secret from one another!

giraffes2021 · 10/11/2021 11:11

I didn't go on the mortgage due to stamp duty but I know that if I said I wanted to go on it he wouldn't have any issues we only did it in his name out of easiness. He would also have a deed and a will made up I guess it's something I need to get done ASAP and a will

Re marriage DP isn't keen on the whole wedding idea he said he'd be quite happy for me to just change my name haha or a registry office how romantic
Conversations need to happen

OP posts:
PheasantsNest · 10/11/2021 10:57

How have you allowed yourself to be in such a vulnerabilities position? He's taking you for a fool and you are allowing him.

VividGemini · 10/11/2021 10:52

So it goes to your children.. what then? How will the mortgage get paid?

Samhradh1 · 10/11/2021 10:46

@Flouts1

So let me get this right Your not married Your not on the deeds You work part time You feel like you don’t have enough money but your DP has plenty and you have to ask for money

Your DP owns the house
He is self employed
He benefits from the childcare you do at home on the days your not at work

Trust me he knows exactly what he is doing
He is protecting his interest in his house
He’s not stupid he has a live in housekeeper childminder cleaned & cook and someone to share his bed with .
And it’s not costing him anything because he would have to pay to live somewhere

If you question him about the house getting married or going on the deeds I bet he will get defensive
If he does then you know he is completely aware of what your position is and I expect he won’t budge on it

If you split up at the moment you walk away with nothing apart from what is yours
He’s self employed so don’t count on child support
Honestly I really wish schools could teach some of this shit to kids
You have literally no more rights to anything he has than a complete stranger in the street would

This is very well said. You have been very foolish @giraffes2021

I would also be interested to see what your DP would say about you going on the deeds to the house. I also suspect he won’t want you to.

Restart10 · 10/11/2021 10:45

Op I agree with everyone here. You are very vulnerable here, very. You need to have a talk with him regarding finances and what is fair to YOU. He seems to have convinced you that you are getting a good deal here but you are not. I'm pt, with 1 DC and dh is a very high earner. We have a joint account that we equally use. In 15 years my dh hasn't asked me once what I spend on. If you sit down and work it out for yourself, you actually are doing far more than you should.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 10/11/2021 10:42

[quote giraffes2021]@HotToddyColdSauvignon how do I need to protect myself if something happens to him? Would it not just go to the children ? [/quote]
It's more complex than that. Does he have a will? Pension fund? Pre marriage stbxh couldn't have had me as the beneficiary of his superannuation without it being in his will, same with the house he owned then. We didn't bother,

marriage came before DC so I had more legal protection then.

Even if the house is willed to his children how would that work? How would you provide for its upkeep? How would you be able to transfer the mortgage into your name if your DC owned the asset? This is assuming his family didn't make a claim on his estate and leaving aside the statistically much more likely risk, seperation. Five years ago I would have been completely confident stbxh and I would be together till one of us died. We had been together 15 very happy years at that point. I'm glad we made decisions while deeply in love that protected me and our DC. Stbxh has become someone that would absolutely screw me over if he could. I no longer recognise him.

Flouts1 · 10/11/2021 10:33

So let me get this right
Your not married
Your not on the deeds
You work part time
You feel like you don’t have enough money but your DP has plenty and you have to ask for money

Your DP owns the house
He is self employed
He benefits from the childcare you do at home on the days your not at work

Trust me he knows exactly what he is doing
He is protecting his interest in his house
He’s not stupid he has a live in housekeeper childminder cleaned & cook and someone to share his bed with .
And it’s not costing him anything because he would have to pay to live somewhere

If you question him about the house getting married or going on the deeds I bet he will get defensive
If he does then you know he is completely aware of what your position is and I expect he won’t budge on it

If you split up at the moment you walk away with nothing apart from what is yours
He’s self employed so don’t count on child support
Honestly I really wish schools could teach some of this shit to kids
You have literally no more rights to anything he has than a complete stranger in the street would

Lavender24 · 10/11/2021 10:26

I worked out a proper household budget a couple of months ago cause I ended up paying more due to me being the one who does the food shopping.

I worked out our total joint income, then worked out what percentage of that income was his and what percentage was mine. Then I added up our total outgoings for the month and figured out what percentage we should each we paying based on what percentage we contribute to the total household earnings. I did it on an excel spreadsheet so it added it all up for me and it's easy to change things on it if anything changes,