Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex DH and maintenance

35 replies

LatteLover12 · 09/11/2021 18:55

ExH and I have had a private arrangement for child maintenance since we split 6 years ago.

At first it was £300 then £250, then £220 and most recently £193 pcm.

This month he has taken off another £50 because he 'bought x a couple of t-shirts' for one of the boys.

This isn't the first time he's done this. Anytime he buys our boys anything he reduces my monthly payment and I've had enough.

He contributes nothing beyond this eg school uniform/trips etc.

I don't believe he's been paying me enough anyway but this month is the last straw.

AIBU to resolve this via CMS?

AIBU to tell him I will no longer deliver our two children to him on a Friday night (eow, 30 mile round trip).

Any tips gratefully received.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
2catsandhappy · 11/11/2021 14:52

Good for you op! Really well done, that took alot of courage.
Let him do the Sunday drop off.

The hassle of getting dc ready for Monday will focus his mind.
If he brings them back late, do not bat an eyelid. Don't say a word. Just 'whoo boys, yay, lets get that bath running'
He will realise that being an ass bringing them back late will eat into his own personal weekend time. The lateness will stop.
I speak from experience.
And one more time. Really well done. I never had your courage.

WickedWitchOfTheTrent · 11/11/2021 14:41

Well done op. It simply takes everything out of your hands and puts the emphasis firmly in his lap. If he tries to have a go, simply say 'going via the cms ensure that you pay what's required, ensures the dc get the required amount, and protects us both' say it again and again and again

Also, there's no way I'd be dropping the dc off to him. I think when we first leave a person like this, we are still hard wired to 'help' I fell into that trap and would ferry the dc around whilst my ex paid and did the bare minimum. After a while I stopped. Which means now, the dc are at school he collects them from school on a Friday and brings them home on a Sunday. So once the dc are at school on Friday i can have a long weekend away with friends and don't have to worry. It's bliss.. my ex also threatened to keep the dc on a Sunday, so I called his bluff, ok no worries, you'll have to come and get their uniforms for school etc etc. funnily enough they came back Sunday as normal. It's about control

AnneLovesGilbert · 11/11/2021 14:30

Well done.

TheFormidableMrsC · 11/11/2021 14:27

@LatteLover12

Just a quick update, I've just applied to CMS.

Hands are shaking but I've done it! Thank you all so much x

💪🎉
Lasair · 11/11/2021 13:48

Good for you!

LatteLover12 · 11/11/2021 13:36

Just a quick update, I've just applied to CMS.

Hands are shaking but I've done it! Thank you all so much x

OP posts:
LatteLover12 · 10/11/2021 20:53

@ShadowsInTheDarkness thank you ❤️

OP posts:
ShadowsInTheDarkness · 10/11/2021 08:00

Hi OP. I was in a very similar position to you and recently switched to CMS. You can do it online which is easier as they are notoriously awful about phones. They won't get involved unless you can show missed payments, I applied 3 times with evidence of reduced payments and they rejected it each time. So what I did the last time was use their calculation of what I should have been getting each month and put together a letter with spreadsheet showing the reduced payments as missed payments - so for eg. If I was owed £400 a month and he had paid £100 a month I wrote that out as
Jan - £100 running total - -£300
Feb - £100 towards debt (missed payment) running total -£600
March - £100 towards debt (missed payment) running total -£900 etc.
Then once I had the total of the debt for the financial year I divided that by the amount he was meant to pay per month - so say it was £2000 divided by the 400 per month = 5 missed payments.

You'll need to submit the application online and ask for collect and pay. Tick the missed payments box for why and then attach a letter setting it out as above as your evidence along with a bank statement showing all the payments he has made for the financial year.

They've been absolutely shit in terms of communication but brilliant in getting my money back. In our case they did an attachment of earnings order. My ex was also abusive and used the money as a means of control so I made sure that his anger was directed at CMS by saying that I had just asked them to calculate how much they thought he should be paying, that they'd asked for loads of info to make the calculation, including bank statements to show payments and that what they did after that was nothing to do with me. I even had a moan with him about how hard it is to get hold of someone on the phone. I would do similar if you fear him kicking off.

It's been brilliant abs now I know that the money can't be used against me I feel completely empowered to stand up to him about other things. The feelings of fear abs control have gone. I really hope that the same can happen for you and that you can get to a place where you are free from the fear.

It took 3 months for them to pay me anything but they clawed back £4000 of debt which was amazing.

Good luck. You got this.

TheFormidableMrsC · 10/11/2021 07:52

OP, if he's employed (rather than self employed) a claim via CMS should be fairly simple. I'd start a claim definitely. I had to do this to stop my ex using maintenance to control or punish me (his words).

If he moved, travelling is down to him. Not you. You have to stand up to him.
If he's going to be an arse it's pretty easy to obtain a child arrangements order. I managed that without a solicitor. This will set out an order that he has to abide by.

Don't let him bully you any longer. I am so sick of reading posts like this about men like him. Good luck Thanks

LatteLover12 · 10/11/2021 07:38

He literally does nothing for them. He doesn't even feed them in a Sunday afternoon before he returns them.

Thank you all for your comments, I feel much more empowered reading them all. I've only put up with it this long because I've learned it's easier to keep the peace and I never wanted the kids to feel stuck in the middle.

Even if the money wasn't increased it's legally enforceable I think so if he dicks around with the amount again I can complain (although I hear you loud and clear that CMS are shit).

I'll be contacting them tomorrow (when I'm not at work).

OP posts:
HugeAckmansWife · 09/11/2021 22:22

But why should she share the pick ups and drop off? He doesn't share any of the other 95%? This is a huge bug bear of mine. Because the travel to and from is between the two parents and often is a bigger journey than the day to day it seems to be an assumption that its fair to share this chore, but if the RP does every other damn thing, why should they also have to do 50% of the nrps tiny little bit of parenting?

Newmumatlast · 09/11/2021 21:21

Share drop off and pick ups (you pick up Sunday) and go through CMS. Reducing money is ridiculous. We bought my stepdaughter clothes all the time when she needed them - at one point a whole new wardrobe worth. Never did we reduce the monthly sum. To me, that maintenance is for the general things required but it has to be anticipated that there will be extra things required at times which exceed the routine planned for bills

FreedFromHomeSchooling · 09/11/2021 20:29

Go through the CMS, agree that you drop off & he drops them back.

Bananarama21 · 09/11/2021 20:24

Hes a disgrace disgrace it's a control thing. Go through cm and stop dropping the dc off.

Gliderx · 09/11/2021 20:21

CMS. Don't know why you haven't already. You have more patience than I would.

I wouldn't drop off/pick up either. He's not going to keep them given how little he can be arsed to do for them. Besides anything else, presumably he has to be at work on Monday so it's an empty threat.

HugeAckmansWife · 09/11/2021 19:52

See its that sort of shit with the clothes that makes me have zero sympathy for the 'well what does he earn'? responses. Leaving aside the fact that less than £200 pm for 2 kids (or even 1) is utterly pathetic, he's clearly just dicking about and trying to point score. To the pp who said contact and maintenance aren't linked, no they are not. As in, you can't withdraw contact because they don't pay. However, if one adult is giving another the run around and being a dick, the other adult does not just have to meekly say 'oh OK then'. I'm all for not weaponising kids, absolutely but there are limits to it when one side is taking the absolute piss. The op is raising the kids, doing all the day to day. Literally all. He does fuck all. If he is going to be as petty as this over clothes, I think she is perfectly entitled to work to rule too... Its HIS contact, so HE can make it happen.

ANameChangeAgain · 09/11/2021 19:40

Just to add, if you are concerned he won't bring them back, make sure you also get a formal agreement in place that names you as the resident parent. Make sure that it specifies contact arrangements along with who drops off and picks up and what time.

LatteLover12 · 09/11/2021 19:38

Thanks @Theunamedcat I've asked him not to buy things as they both have plenty of clothes. He just ignores me though and claims that the clothes they arrived with weren't suitable or didn't fit.

He once reduced my payment by £21 for some new shorts as he claimed our youngest arrived without any. There were two pairs of brand new shorts in the bag with the tags still on. He still reduced my money.

OP posts:
LatteLover12 · 09/11/2021 19:35

Thanks so much everyone.

He recently started a new job and although he's not a high earner buy any stretch of the imagination the £193 would equate to him earning between £18 - £19k. He's 43 and has worked in his industry for 20+ years.

He was on £26,000 when we divorced. I am the higher earner but he used to take all my money.

I'll see if I can get the Friday/Sunday switched over.

OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 09/11/2021 19:32

Go through cms and when you get the kids back perhaps get advice on how to formalise arrangements if you feel he won't return them

Its unlikely you will be able to suddenly stop doing the driving as you have set a precedent by doing it for so long

In the meantime ask him to not bother buying them clothing if he is going to Dock the maintenance by text get it in writing so you have evidence that's what he is doing because it's financial abuse

AnneLovesGilbert · 09/11/2021 19:30

£193?! What a bizarre amount.

CMS immediately. And you don’t have to tell him if you know he’ll kick off. They’ll do that.

Taking money off for clothes is beyond pathetic, what a total fucking loser.

I’m so sorry for what you’ve been through as well Flowers

Get the full amount your children are owed. And on the off chance it does go down, unlikely, at least he won’t be reducing it for clothes. Twat.

IncompleteSenten · 09/11/2021 19:28

I'd go through CMS and say he will have to do the pick up on a Friday and you'll collect them on a Sunday.
If you do it the other way he'll probably turn round on a Sunday saying I'm not bringing them, you fetch them or they stay here. At least with him collecting he either does it he doesn't but he can't mess you about re them coming back to you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 09/11/2021 19:27

Go through CMS. Making arbitrary deductions of his own is not on.

cowburp · 09/11/2021 19:26

@Royalbloo

Whether he is reasonable or not depends entirely on how much he earns.
The deduction of the cost of t-shirts he's willingly bought them has nothing to do with how much he earns. He can't just decide to spend the money he gives OP for food on tshirts.
BackBackBack · 09/11/2021 19:24

I'd carry on taking them if he brings them back. If you are worried about him keeping the kids then it's worth getting a residence order if you don't already have one.

Definitely go through CMS for maintenance.