Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think we need MPs who can earn £1million a year

196 replies

Lovelyricepudding · 09/11/2021 16:44

I don't know what the answer is but AIBU to think we need people who companies think it is worth paying £1million a year as MPs? The quality of most of our MPs is pretty rubbish and £82k a year is not a salary to attract big-hitters of the calibre we need. It sounds like Geoffrey Cox QC may have spent too little time focused on MP work and it is obviously wrong for MPs to benefit from external work gleaned due to their role as an MP. But how do we attract the most capable people into parliament when they can be so successful outside parliament?

OP posts:
Elwynne · 11/11/2021 09:31

Are we part of a tory focus group by answering? If so goody because I'd like to say no, we need people who are 100% committed to being an mp and not lining their own pockets. We can't sleaze our way out of the country's current issues, we need people who are passionate about the UK and helping the people who live here attain the best possible life.

Missmissmiiiiiiiiisss · 11/11/2021 09:23

Personally I’m in favour of very high pay for MPs (more like £150k as standard) because you do have an insane amount of press/internet stuff to deal with. You probably need a nanny due to the hours and splitting between constituency and west minister.

BUT then have extremely extremely strict rules that stop second jobs and consultancy etc once you leave until at least 5 years after.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/11/2021 09:18

I equate high salaries with overpaid dickheads tbh.

I’ve never met one person a high salary who l respect.They just have an over inflated sense of self importance. It’s that that gets them the high salary not their ability.

PurBal · 11/11/2021 03:56

*calibre. But we’re not looking for someone who can be Jeff Bezos. We’re looking for people who want to make a difference and make the country a better place.

PurBal · 11/11/2021 03:54

I think we need MPs who see their job as a vocation rather than being in it for the money. I agree that the pay is hardly going to attract the high calibration people but surely that’s not what it’s about? Rishi has a high net worth but I get the impression he really sees his job as vocational. Paying MPs is still a relatively new thing.

rrhuth · 11/11/2021 03:17

If you pay more, better people are more likely to want to work for you Define 'better people' Hmm

rrhuth · 11/11/2021 03:15

@Animood

I guess what I'm saying is paying more is a good investment if we get the right people for the job.
The word 'if' is doing a lot there. Paying more wouldn't ensure we got the right people. It would ensure we got different people, but those new people would potentially crowd out some of the very good people currently interested, and replace them with worse people.

It is myopic to see current/previous salary level as automatically indicative that someone has the qualities required to make a good MP.

What we need is a fair salary, coupled with very strong anti-corruption rules. Would profoundly affect who would apply if we had stronger rules on corruption, IMO for the better, but suspect Tory constituency chairs would find selection hustings changed.

RobertaFlack · 11/11/2021 00:58

Yes I do equate high salaries with high calibre candidates. If you pay more, better people are more likely to want to work for you.

Is there any evidence for this?

Animood · 11/11/2021 00:09

@montysma1

So you equate high salaries with attracting high calibre people. I equate it with attracting greedy ones.
Yes I do equate high salaries with high calibre candidates. If you pay more, better people are more likely to want to work for you.

You might not like it, but it's true.

And the country is in such a mess we need the best of the best.

Lovelyricepudding · 10/11/2021 23:59

Also the civil service is there to implement the government's agenda. So in setting that agenda MPs must be able to understand all the issues involved - including the competing priorities of civil servants.

OP posts:
Lovelyricepudding · 10/11/2021 23:55

MPs are representing constituents - to do that they have to understand the issues that their population faces, and represent that to Parliament in order to enact change.
I would argue that the MPs greatest skill is to listen, empathise, and understand. But ultimately it’s a vocation, not a profession.

I disagree. For a start they are not simply representing their constituents - they have been elected because of their own political views so are representing those. They are elected to make decisions not just to defer to their constituents and to govern the whole country. Many decisions will negatively impact on constituents eg increasing taxes on the wealthy, not increasing benefits, increasing investment in a deprived area in a different constituency, not given a contract to a local manufacturer whose product is inferior.

A CEO/chair of a large organisation would be more familiar with cost-benefit analysis and considering the opportunity costs of actions. They will have experience of interacting on a global scale and the problems therein. They should have an understanding of supply chains, personnel issues, economics, operating at scale, the impact of legislation, of assessing large amounts of information and understanding new complex problems.

We don't elect MPs to be backbenchers - we elect them to be government ministers.

OP posts:
montysma1 · 10/11/2021 23:35

So you equate high salaries with attracting high calibre people.
I equate it with attracting greedy ones.

Animood · 10/11/2021 23:00

I guess what I'm saying is paying more is a good investment if we get the right people for the job.

Animood · 10/11/2021 22:59

We need the best people to run the country, and I'm sorry but £82,000 does not reflect their importance and responsibility. Country is a mess and we need the best people to sort it out. To get the best people we need to pay good salaries.

To put it in perspective, I earn just shy of £82,000. Early 30s and I work 4 days a week. Not in London. My jobs a piece of piss compared to being an MP.

Compare that to long hours, public exposure and tricky issues they have to deal with. Plus most MPs are significantly older than me.

I know £82,000 seems like a lot but a MPs salary has got to be compared to professional jobs based in London with a similar amount of responsibility.

Drivingish · 10/11/2021 21:50

@lemmein - *Why though? Why should MPs be so shielded from everyday expenses the rest of us have to suck up? Why do people think they deserve such high rewards for something that surely should be considered a vocational role that you'd do for the benefit of your community/country, rather than your own personal benefit? Lots of public services are staffed by people who do their jobs for minimal rewards, some even voluntary, why is it so incomprehensible that MPs could do the same?

Do you remember Cameron's 'Big Society'? The tories wholeheartedly supported the working classes helping out for the good of the community, why is it different for them?

Actually blows my mind how many people's solution to Tory corruption is pay them more - the UK has such an ingrained serf mentality.

Besides, Johnson's childcare bill alone could bankrupt the country*

I absolutely have no serf mentality, especially to the Tories, I'd happily let them live on bread and water tbh but an MP unable to pay their rent or having to sort out childcare issues because they can't afford reliable childcare is not going to be any good to the people they're supposed to be serving, even if those are problems the rest of us have. That's why I'd pay generous expenses but very little besides - so they'd have childcare and bills sorted so they could get on with the job but no money for lavish holidays and all the other trimmings. If they want the luxuries they'll have to do an amazing job to get their bonus (if I was working out the bonuses for Boris's cronies I doubt any senior Tory would receive one so far).

mswales · 10/11/2021 21:44

This bizarre suggestion is based on two fundamental misunderstandings: first that we live in a meritocratic society where pay levels correlate with skills and competence, and second that being a good MP requires the same type of skills and competencies as being a corporate executive. Both completely false.

mellongoose · 10/11/2021 21:30

I would argue that the MPs greatest skill is to listen, empathise, and understand. But ultimately it’s a vocation, not a profession.

This is true.

There are quite a few inaccuracies in this thread, however. MPs do not get paid more for sitting on a committee, only if they chair it. Most committee chairs have been senior or cabinet ministers.

Iggly · 10/11/2021 16:22

@Lovelyricepudding

That’s not sorted by paying MPs more - it’s sorted by improving education of the population.

My point was not that MPs should be paid more but rather that we need MPs of the sort who are capable of demanding large salaries in private life due to there experience, knowledge and expertise. We need better MPs. In reality nearly everyone with the skill set needed would either earn more in their current job or earn less as they are altruistically giving their skills and time.

My point about literacy was one of representation. It is not reasonable to suggest that current illiteracy should be represented amongst MPs even though a proportion of the voters are illiterate.

Again, I disagree.

There’s an inherent assumption in your statement that commanding a higher salary makes you better qualified but you haven’t really set out what those skills are exactly.

MPs are representing constituents - to do that they have to understand the issues that their population faces, and represent that to Parliament in order to enact change.

MPs have a lot of architecture around them to help them do their job in terms of legislation etc. They also have a lot around them when it comes to governing.

I would argue that the MPs greatest skill is to listen, empathise, and understand. But ultimately it’s a vocation, not a profession.

And that’s why equating it to the corporate world makes no sense to me.

There are plenty of people on average salaries with fantastic skills who would make fabulous MPs. They don’t command high salaries - because money is not the only way in which you measure worth.

Lovelyricepudding · 10/11/2021 14:47

I don't mean illiteracy secondary to dyslexia etc I meant more broardly about use and comprehension of language. Though just as an example. Perhaps criminality would be a better example. A proportion of the electorate are convicted criminals who have served long sentences. They do not need to be represented in parliament even though MP's still represent these individuals and their families. (I know - some may say criminals and shysters are well represented!)

OP posts:
Lovelyricepudding · 10/11/2021 14:39

That’s not sorted by paying MPs more - it’s sorted by improving education of the population.

My point was not that MPs should be paid more but rather that we need MPs of the sort who are capable of demanding large salaries in private life due to there experience, knowledge and expertise. We need better MPs. In reality nearly everyone with the skill set needed would either earn more in their current job or earn less as they are altruistically giving their skills and time.

My point about literacy was one of representation. It is not reasonable to suggest that current illiteracy should be represented amongst MPs even though a proportion of the voters are illiterate.

OP posts:
Sian73 · 10/11/2021 14:08

@Washingtonirving79

OP, do you understand that most/all of these particular individuals (Patterson, Duncan Smith, Grayling) would be unlikely to earn the basic MP's salary in the real-world, let alone the additional salaries they're drawing?

Cox is in trouble because he was getting paid by the BVI to effectively act as an informant and lobbyist on tax-evasion legislation, not as legal counsel.

I don't exaggerate when I say that IDS, Grayling et al would struggle to obtain and keep a middle-managers' job. They're life-long grifters, chancers and liars (look at IDS fabricating his CV for evidence).

Just seen this ... it's a very accurate observation.
Sian73 · 10/11/2021 14:05

@Voord

Why any sensible person with an established career, in any walk of life, would go into politics is beyond me. You need an overwhelming desire to serve the public and/or a hide like a rhino to even contemplate it. I work with lots of talented and committed professionals who would make MPs; none of them would touch it with a barge pole.
You need an overwhelming desire to serve the public

There are plenty of people that have this desire. What about teachers, doctors, nurses - the list must go on and on ...

None of these professions are highly paid. People work long hours and have to have thick skin. We don't offer them grander salaries do we?

The talented committed professionals you know who wouldn't touch MP work with a barge pole are perhaps after the money and more selfish rewards instead. So they wouldn't make good MPs would they?

Washingtonirving79 · 10/11/2021 13:52

OP, do you understand that most/all of these particular individuals (Patterson, Duncan Smith, Grayling) would be unlikely to earn the basic MP's salary in the real-world, let alone the additional salaries they're drawing?

Cox is in trouble because he was getting paid by the BVI to effectively act as an informant and lobbyist on tax-evasion legislation, not as legal counsel.

I don't exaggerate when I say that IDS, Grayling et al would struggle to obtain and keep a middle-managers' job. They're life-long grifters, chancers and liars (look at IDS fabricating his CV for evidence).

Iggly · 10/11/2021 13:27

Sorry, hit post too soon. To carry on - you refer to a wide spread illiteracy problem. That’s not sorted by paying MPs more - it’s sorted by improving education of the population.

I don’t want MPs who are motivated by money. Just how greedy do they need to be, earning a salary which takes them well above the average wage plus all of the additional amounts that they can earn?

MPs are not employees and shouldn’t be treated as such. We should be looking at MPs who do a good job and wonder how that came to be. And, I bet you, it wasn’t the ones who felt the need to earn millions elsewhere because their MPs salary was “chicken feed”.

People don’t go into politics because it’s an absolutely impossible thing to do unless you wangle your way in via a main political party. Not because it doesn’t pay enough!

Iggly · 10/11/2021 13:23

@Lovelyricepudding

Iggly the government are drawn from the pool of MPs so that pool of MPs need to be capable. At the moment there are 360 MPs in the governing party and 123 of them have ministerial responsibilities - 22 in the cabinet and 14 unpaid. Many other MPs have committee roles. Junior ministers and new backbench MPs will also represent the pool of individuals 'training up' for more senior roles. Fewer opposition MPs have these responsibility but if they had gained a majority or entered a coalition then they would have so they need to be capable too.

The remaining backbench MPs still have a duty to scrutinise legislation, bring forth amendments and ultimately vote for or against so they must be capable of understanding the implications and unintended consequences of that legislation.

A not insignificant proportion of the population are barely literate. I expect MPs to have an understanding of this, issue with education and problems faced by these individuals. But I also expect all MPs to be highly literate.

Capable of what exactly?

They don’t scrutinise legislation - they have committee support staff to do that for them. They also have constituency support staff as well. Who spend hours and hours pouring over this stuff for them. Otherwise we’d just want an army of MPs who were lawyers.

Why does giving them more money mean that they’ll be better at it? They get more money for additional responsibilities already