Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think we need MPs who can earn £1million a year

196 replies

Lovelyricepudding · 09/11/2021 16:44

I don't know what the answer is but AIBU to think we need people who companies think it is worth paying £1million a year as MPs? The quality of most of our MPs is pretty rubbish and £82k a year is not a salary to attract big-hitters of the calibre we need. It sounds like Geoffrey Cox QC may have spent too little time focused on MP work and it is obviously wrong for MPs to benefit from external work gleaned due to their role as an MP. But how do we attract the most capable people into parliament when they can be so successful outside parliament?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lovelyricepudding · 16/11/2021 23:19

Ted27 that is where we are now but the pay arrangements were not set up on that basis. How many are now 'professional politicians' whose only career has been politics? What is that spilt between parties? I think MPS should all have had a career of some sort outside politics.

OP posts:
Pascal80 · 16/11/2021 21:44

No. You are making an assumption that the best people, or ''most capable'' as you put it - will be those who are motivated by money. They aren't. The opposite is true.

Ted27 · 16/11/2021 15:29

@Lovelyricepudding

but most MPs don't have second jobs.

The register of interests shows that 148 MPs spent some time on a ‘second job’ between January 2020 and August 2021, of which 114 were Conservatives MPs and 20 Labour MPs

many local authorities now also pay fixed allowances. Coventry pays a basic allowance of £14,490 each and an extra 'special responsibility allowance' for roles such as cabinet members, deputies or committee chairs.

Lovelyricepudding · 16/11/2021 10:01

I will repeat again. Being an MP is not the same as having a highly paid career, it is not a “job”. MPs are not employees. So equating their position with a salaried job is just silly. It’s false equivalency.

That is true, that is also why they have jobs; historically they are not second jobs - they are just their jobs. Which is also presumably why ministers are paid more - not just responsibility but to reflect the fact that the increased time commitment stops them doing their 'real live' job. Same with councillors.

OP posts:
Sinthie · 12/11/2021 22:21

Taken from a Daily Mail article in 2010 when striking firefighters were criticised for taking second jobs:
“ A spokesman for London Mayor Boris Johnson said: ‘The minor changes we are seeking to the current shift patterns are perfectly reasonable to anyone exclusively working in a single profession. We would urge the firefighters to call off their strike and re-engage in negotiations.’

Conservative MP Philip Davies said: ‘The firefighters ought to start to live in the real world at a time when many people are grateful to hang on to their one job, otherwise they will lose any support that they had from the public.’”

Iggly · 12/11/2021 20:44

@user1471447863

Defiantly very bitter people here.

If you think most high paying positions let just any old chancer swan in and do sod all you are mistaken. Hight pay comes with expectation that you provide value - a company is buying you to make them money. If you are not capable of making them the amount of money they expect you will very quickly be encouraged to progress your career elsewhere.

I also see the usual gripes of 'they get expenses on top of that big salary'. It's very clear that many have never had a job where they had responsibility to go spend money on things they needed to do their job.
You wouldn't expect to be sent on a course, go book a train and a hotel for 4 nights etc and not turn in an expenses claim to get those costs back would you? Why on earth would you expect an MP to be any different?

Are you or have you ever been in a high paying position?

I will repeat again. Being an MP is not the same as having a highly paid career, it is not a “job”. MPs are not employees. So equating their position with a salaried job is just silly. It’s false equivalency.

And fwiw, I’ve earned more than an MP and it wasn’t actually that hard.

Ozanj · 12/11/2021 13:59

I think we need to attract more young people, ethnic minorities who weren’t born in the UK. and women into politics not the 10% who don’t understand 99.9% of the problems of most normal UK residents.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 12/11/2021 13:53

@user1471447863

Defiantly very bitter people here.

If you think most high paying positions let just any old chancer swan in and do sod all you are mistaken. Hight pay comes with expectation that you provide value - a company is buying you to make them money. If you are not capable of making them the amount of money they expect you will very quickly be encouraged to progress your career elsewhere.

I also see the usual gripes of 'they get expenses on top of that big salary'. It's very clear that many have never had a job where they had responsibility to go spend money on things they needed to do their job.
You wouldn't expect to be sent on a course, go book a train and a hotel for 4 nights etc and not turn in an expenses claim to get those costs back would you? Why on earth would you expect an MP to be any different?

Oh, and I might be bitter about the various scams MPs are allowed to run, but I am not jealous - I have earned more than an MP for some time now.
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 12/11/2021 13:51

@user1471447863

Defiantly very bitter people here.

If you think most high paying positions let just any old chancer swan in and do sod all you are mistaken. Hight pay comes with expectation that you provide value - a company is buying you to make them money. If you are not capable of making them the amount of money they expect you will very quickly be encouraged to progress your career elsewhere.

I also see the usual gripes of 'they get expenses on top of that big salary'. It's very clear that many have never had a job where they had responsibility to go spend money on things they needed to do their job.
You wouldn't expect to be sent on a course, go book a train and a hotel for 4 nights etc and not turn in an expenses claim to get those costs back would you? Why on earth would you expect an MP to be any different?

I've had a lot of roles where I claimed a lot of expenses.

Not one of them would have paid a very large amount of tax free expenses for me to go and live near my permanent and regular workplace, and all the associate travel.

MPs expenses are NOT subject to the same taxation regime as the rest of us.

Animood · 12/11/2021 13:45

@EnglishGirlApproximately

There isn't a chance that my MP would be earning anything like his current salary in the private sector. Not only is he an MP, he is a district Councillor and leader of the county council despite his entire life experience being two failed attempts at getting a degree, then actually getting one and a brief stint as an entry level recruitment consultant. He is utterly unqualified for any of his positions but is currently loudly defending MPs having second jobs. High payments for 'consultancy work aren't for experience or expertise, they're for access.
Well exactly my point!

This is why we need to attract better candidates!

rrhuth · 12/11/2021 02:56

Timely article which explains it's not what you know but who you know www.theguardian.com/money/2021/nov/12/disadvantaged-graduates-earn-half-as-much-as-privileged-peers-in-first-job

RobertaFlack · 12/11/2021 02:29

Probably bitter because of their own failures in life and they aren't capable of earning more

I have a book recommendation for you

us.macmillan.com/books/9780374289980/thetyrannyofmerit

noblegiraffe · 11/11/2021 22:56

You wouldn't expect to be sent on a course, go book a train and a hotel for 4 nights etc and not turn in an expenses claim to get those costs back would you?

Tbh in teaching I’ve also paid for the course.

But when it comes to expenses, people don’t forget the duck house crap. Our current Education Secretary is still referred to as ‘Warm Horse’.

user1471447863 · 11/11/2021 22:52

Defiantly very bitter people here.

If you think most high paying positions let just any old chancer swan in and do sod all you are mistaken. Hight pay comes with expectation that you provide value - a company is buying you to make them money. If you are not capable of making them the amount of money they expect you will very quickly be encouraged to progress your career elsewhere.

I also see the usual gripes of 'they get expenses on top of that big salary'. It's very clear that many have never had a job where they had responsibility to go spend money on things they needed to do their job.
You wouldn't expect to be sent on a course, go book a train and a hotel for 4 nights etc and not turn in an expenses claim to get those costs back would you? Why on earth would you expect an MP to be any different?

HaroldSteptoesHorse · 11/11/2021 18:48

If I could get paid for lecturing on x topics I would or get paid for turning up every now and then to a super important (utterly shit) board meeting I would. Alas I’m in that position

Iggly · 11/11/2021 17:18

@Animood

I guess what I'm saying is paying more is a good investment if we get the right people for the job.
It is not a job. It’s a vocation.
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/11/2021 13:05

No I’m not in the least bitter, I’m very happy with my financial state.

Every boss I’ve had a been a bellend. It got better when l went into public services, but there were a lot of highly paid bellends there too.

I’m just not in the least bitter. It doesn’t even come into it

EnglishGirlApproximately · 11/11/2021 10:10

Having said that about my own terrible MP I am generally in favour of paying them a good salary on the proviso that norther work is allowed while serving as an MP.

Mouseonmychair · 11/11/2021 10:07

Gosh there are some very bitter responses on here!

Probably bitter because of their own failures in life and they aren't capable of earning more.

EnglishGirlApproximately · 11/11/2021 10:03

There isn't a chance that my MP would be earning anything like his current salary in the private sector. Not only is he an MP, he is a district Councillor and leader of the county council despite his entire life experience being two failed attempts at getting a degree, then actually getting one and a brief stint as an entry level recruitment consultant. He is utterly unqualified for any of his positions but is currently loudly defending MPs having second jobs. High payments for 'consultancy work aren't for experience or expertise, they're for access.

Animood · 11/11/2021 09:51

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

It’s not bitter, it’s just true.
What do you mean when you say "high salary"?
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 11/11/2021 09:47

It’s not bitter, it’s just true.

Animood · 11/11/2021 09:44

@Elwynne

Are we part of a tory focus group by answering? If so goody because I'd like to say no, we need people who are 100% committed to being an mp and not lining their own pockets. We can't sleaze our way out of the country's current issues, we need people who are passionate about the UK and helping the people who live here attain the best possible life.
Ideally yes you're right.

Back in the real world I think lots of people have great ideas about the country and think about being and MP. Would love to make a difference and make changes.

Then they look at the negatives: media scrutiny, travel to London, online threats and abuse, having to deal with Boris, the responsibility, long hours.

Then they look at the salary and think... fuck it. Not worth it!

Animood · 11/11/2021 09:40

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow

I equate high salaries with overpaid dickheads tbh.

I’ve never met one person a high salary who l respect.They just have an over inflated sense of self importance. It’s that that gets them the high salary not their ability.

Gosh there are some very bitter responses on here!
Animood · 11/11/2021 09:38

@RobertaFlack

Yes I do equate high salaries with high calibre candidates. If you pay more, better people are more likely to want to work for you.

Is there any evidence for this?

I think the evidence is there in professional jobs everywhere. If jobs are better paid then there is more competition for those jobs, meaning a wide range of people apply and the employer can choose the best person.

If a job is poorly paid, the employer kind of has to take who they can get, in the knowledge that the person may not be the best person they can get, but accepts they are the best they can afford.

I'm not really talking about nhs jobs or public sector jobs because that's different but in the private sector this is true.

Swipe left for the next trending thread