Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that recruiter CCed all candidates going to job interview

115 replies

Ygritte84 · 09/11/2021 16:07

Two emails were sent with the complete list of candidates in CC, with names and email addresses. Total breach of confidentiality, right?

I work in a small industry and people know each other. I will cross some of these people in my job.

Feeling very annoyed and also starting to doubt myself seeing the competition!

OP posts:
Mummyoflittledragon · 11/11/2021 07:07

With that response, you could report to the ICO. Idk if you’re case would be taken seriously. But there is no recognition of the possible impact to you and your future career prospects.

As for older more experienced people applying. This doesn’t mean you’re less likely to be the best fit. Some companies prefer candidates they can educate and mould.

GiltEdges · 11/11/2021 06:33

@Ygritte84

OK so I spoke with the recruiter today and told her in a very matter-of-fact way about her mistake. She apologised, but said no one else had noticed and she didn't feel like apologising to the other candidates as this could make them aware of the mistake.

I am not satisfied with this. The recruiter should definitely report the incident to the ICO, not try and forget it ever happened!

I work as a Data Protection Officer, so data breaches are my area of expertise.

From the point you notified the recruiter of the data breach (and that absolutely is what this is) the company has an obligation to investigate and assess the severity of what’s happened to decide if it needs to be reported to the ICO (presuming UK) within 72 hours. It’s unlikely to be the recruiter him/herself who would do this, but there should be a process for them to report the incident to their internal data protection representative/team to undertake the investigation. I’d suggest going back to the recruiter and asking if this has been done.

In terms of what’s actually happened, it’s worth bearing in mind that companies are only required to inform the ICO of an incident if it poses a “high risk” to the rights and/or freedoms of individuals and the assessment of high risk is obviously somewhat subjective. In the situation you describe, what risk do you believe there is to yourself and the other candidates from the breach having occurred? You need to be able to articulate this and tell the recruiter why you’re so concerned. Alternatively, if you think they’re unlikely to do anything, then there’s absolutely nothing stopping you from reporting the incident directly to the ICO. Contrary to a PP’s advice, you’re not required to exhaust any internal processes with the company to resolve the issue first; this is a data breach incident, not a complaint. If you decide to report to the ICO, you really need to hammer home the impact you feel the incident could have on you/your career.

gofg · 11/11/2021 06:24

Accidentally clicking cc instead of bcc is a sackable offence? Like straight to dismissal? Wow

Exactly - I'm glad I don't work where that poster works!

It was an error, shouldn't have happened but it did. I can't see what all the fuss is tbh.

BritInUS1 · 11/11/2021 06:19

Contact the recruitment company and ask for the details of the Data Protection Officer and report it to them

TopCatsTopHat · 11/11/2021 05:53

It's good the recruiter is not an employee of the company, all you need to do is alert the company their recruiter if choice is breaching gdpr and introducing problems into the process in a casual manner (given their attitude to your pointing it out) and they should bin them off pretty sharpish/for all future recruitment and feel grateful to you.

Glitteryone · 10/11/2021 23:38

Fuck that is not okay! Definitely complain, you can bet you won’t be the only one.

TopCatsTopHat · 10/11/2021 15:19

That's terrible the company should be alerted this recruiter is dying this, responding poorly and also jeopardising their recruitment process a cohort of candidates so closely linked all being aware they are competing with one another could have all kinds of repurcussions

Haus1234 · 10/11/2021 14:22

That is terrible of the recruiter! Also, everyone will have noticed, there is a big difference in appearance between an email to one person vs to fifty people!

Werehamster · 10/11/2021 14:20

Ah this is a hard one, it would make me sound like a bit of a snitch during a first interview!

I don't think so. I think most companies would be glad to be made aware of the problem as it could cause a lot of issues for them.

Ygritte84 · 10/11/2021 14:19

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

Sorry I mean the company know about the recruiter.
Ah this is a hard one, it would make me sound like a bit of a snitch during a first interview!
OP posts:
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/11/2021 14:15

Sorry I mean the company know about the recruiter.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 10/11/2021 14:15

@Ygritte84

Just to clarify:

The recruiter is separate from the company advertising the job. So her mistake does not reflect badly on the company itself.

Gosh the response was awful!! I'd let the recruiter know.
Ygritte84 · 10/11/2021 14:10

Just to clarify:

The recruiter is separate from the company advertising the job. So her mistake does not reflect badly on the company itself.

OP posts:
LordEmsworth · 10/11/2021 13:59

I really don't understand why people are saying wait before complaining. I would want to know that a potential employer will deal with issues like this. Anyone can make a mistake, it's how you deal with it that matters!

I mean, do it politely, constructively and discreetly but I couldn't go and work somewhere with a slapdash culture, I'd need to know that mistakes get fixed...

Ygritte84 · 10/11/2021 13:52

OK so I spoke with the recruiter today and told her in a very matter-of-fact way about her mistake. She apologised, but said no one else had noticed and she didn't feel like apologising to the other candidates as this could make them aware of the mistake.

I am not satisfied with this. The recruiter should definitely report the incident to the ICO, not try and forget it ever happened!

OP posts:
Ygritte84 · 09/11/2021 20:43

It's a silly mistake, I know, however:

  • It happened TWICE on two different days.
  • No apology email has been sent
  • It is massively awkward because everyone on the list is connected in one way or another, for example a guy works for my same organisation

I am speaking tomorrow with the recruiter on the phone and I have decided to politely ask her if she is aware of what happened.

OP posts:
MrsCardone · 09/11/2021 20:20

I would tell them. Discretely.

I did this once. I was emailing a large group of people, some very high profile including a royal person. Their email addresses should have gone in BCC but for some reason WHICH WAS VERY UNLIKE ME I put them in the To section.

As soon as I was made aware, I recalled the message then emailed everything who had read it, apologising profusely.

These things happen.

Pascal80 · 09/11/2021 20:13

Carbon copy instead of blind copy - a stupid but serious mistake to make and a serious breach of Data Protection. Every company has a person assigned Data Protection Manager. They are responsible.

cowburp · 09/11/2021 18:48

@RaisinFlapjack

Reply and flag it now - not in a complaining way, just inform them. I’d be fuming but the mistake can’t be undone and raising a complaint may not help you at this stage.

No doubt an error but a serious GDPR breach nevertheless.

Yes I'd do this. Also good luck for the job role. Ignore the list, you could be just what they are looking for.
2020isnotbehaving · 09/11/2021 18:45

I’ve had this happen for community organisations they least had Grace email soon after and ask if you haven’t yet opened previous email to delete or delete with apologises. It should be confidential with your personal information yes accidents happen but needs some action to be taken. If anything it shows you are aware of the issue and how serious this is I would 100% email them and point it out.

BigPyjamas · 09/11/2021 18:42

I would politely flag it. Although someone else probably has.

I'd expect a sincere apology.

We would never email all participants at once, everyone gets individual emails. I disagree that 'it's an easy mistake to make' it absolutely shouldn't be because better procedures should be in place and the person sending should always double check. It isn't a typo, it's a serious breach of privacy, GDPR and could have serious consequences for those involved.

I would consider this a warning scenario, and if it were my team I'd want to know ASAP so I could ensure it never happened again.

Sugarbellaella · 09/11/2021 18:38

Yes - my boss says the idea of someone doing it gives him sleepless nights. We all know that you triple check any correspondence going out to multiple clients/ candidates to make sure it’s in bcc. It was the same in another industry I worked in pre GDPR.

FolornLawn · 09/11/2021 18:33

@NatMoz

Amused by some of the comments here.

You can't just complain to the regulator without speaking to the organisation first, the organisation needs to be given an opportunity to rectify the breach and if they aren't even aware then that's not going to happen is it!

If you remain dissatisfied with the steps they have taken to contain the breach, then you can escalate but you do need to provide evidence of your original conversations with the org.

It is an easy mistake to make but it won't have been intentional. Let them provide you with validation of their long term remedial measures to prevent it happening again.

How can they rectify it though? It’s already been sent and read. Maybe they could use one of those memory wipers from Men In Black?
KimmyKimdoo · 09/11/2021 18:17

Ps my sister once emailed her CV to her own boss 😂 she was typing an email out, applying to a job elsewhere and her boss relied to another to read and.. well she somehow messed up. Luckily her boss found it funny.

KimmyKimdoo · 09/11/2021 18:15

Where I work, everyone knows everything about any interviews at all. I’m always suprised people in other sectors manage to keep things like that quiet! Would you have found out who the other candidates were at interview anyway?? Or would you never have found out at all?