Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that recruiter CCed all candidates going to job interview

115 replies

Ygritte84 · 09/11/2021 16:07

Two emails were sent with the complete list of candidates in CC, with names and email addresses. Total breach of confidentiality, right?

I work in a small industry and people know each other. I will cross some of these people in my job.

Feeling very annoyed and also starting to doubt myself seeing the competition!

OP posts:
Dollywilde · 11/11/2021 08:56

That’s exceptionally poor. Making the mistake isn’t a sackable offence, but not abiding by GDPR regulations (ie her response) 100% is.

I agree that you should report to the recruiter’s firm and the ICO. I would also want to know if I were the company offering the job - that’s not a recruiter I would use again (again, not because of the mistake but the response).

CharityDingle · 11/11/2021 08:45

I know of a situation where failure by a HR person to use bcc led to payouts to at least one person, and probably more. It was all within one company, where people were applying for a redundancy package. This was always confidential to the person applying. At most, they would mention it to their direct manager.

It was blamed on a 'junior' in HR, that everyone who applied received a cc'd email instead of bcc'd. This guy threatened action, and was given a payout on top of his redundancy.

I would be unhappy with the recruiter's response, OP, and I would be putting it in writing to them, or to their data protection officer, if they work as part of a recruitment company. It would make me wary of future dealings with them. I know anyone can make a mistake but that's a pretty serious one. And the recruiter should be a bit more up to speed, with GDPR, imo, if dealing with data in a daily basis.

Best of luck with the interview/ job hunt.

name3958 · 11/11/2021 08:42

*didn't BCC I mean

name3958 · 11/11/2021 08:41

@Badbadbunny you don't need to explain data protection law to me, I work in data protection, from what the OP has described it isn't a serious breach (there could be further context of course). It's a breach, it should be reported, OP has a right to complain, but that doesn't mean it's met the ICO threshold. The kind of BCC breaches that go to the ICO is where the applicants special category data is exposed, for example an AIDS charity accidentally BCC'd, I'm sure you can understand why that meets the threshold by comparison.

Scardanelli · 11/11/2021 08:37

@Sugarbellaella

That would be a sackable offence where I work!
I think sacking someone for what is likely to be a genuine mistake is far worse than making the mistake.

Anyone who accidentally does this is likely to be so mortified that it's not a mistake they would make twice anyway, so sacking is hardly appropriate.

OP, you may have all kinds of qualities and experience that the other applicants don't have.

I would say absolutely nothing until after the event.

Badbadbunny · 11/11/2021 08:32

@name3958

I am not satisfied with this. The recruiter should definitely report the incident to the ICO, not try and forget it ever happened!

To be fair with the information given it doesn't sound like it's met the threshold for needing to report it to the ICO, yes they should internally report but it's not a serious breach. That said if you think the recruiter hasn't reported it at all internally and you're not satisfied, go through their complaints procedure. Only when you've exhausted that is it appropriate to escalate it yourself to the ICO.

Of course it's a serious breach. Job applications are supposed to be confidential. Personal data, including names & email addresses is protected by law. Leaks of this data could jeopardise someone's current job if their employer finds out they've been applying for other jobs or it could jeopardise a marriage/relationship if a partner finds out about job application they've not been told about. It's the whole point of the GDPR to protect personal information.

Just because it's not banking details doesn't mean it's not a serious breach.

C8H10N4O2 · 11/11/2021 08:16

@Ygritte84

Just to clarify:

The recruiter is separate from the company advertising the job. So her mistake does not reflect badly on the company itself.

Oh but it does. I use recruitment agencies in conjunction with internal recruitment team, particularly for specialist roles. Our recruitment team oversee all communication conducted on our behalf and the agencies sign up to our protocols.

I would question the future employer's attitude to data and privacy if they don't ensure when using third parties they are paying to gather personal data.

They also potentially leave themselves open for a grievance/appeal on the process as you could quite legitimately say you spotted a risk issue, raised it and the recruiter didn't like that and you then didn't go forward (if that happened).

name3958 · 11/11/2021 08:16

I am not satisfied with this. The recruiter should definitely report the incident to the ICO, not try and forget it ever happened!

To be fair with the information given it doesn't sound like it's met the threshold for needing to report it to the ICO, yes they should internally report but it's not a serious breach. That said if you think the recruiter hasn't reported it at all internally and you're not satisfied, go through their complaints procedure. Only when you've exhausted that is it appropriate to escalate it yourself to the ICO.

name3958 · 11/11/2021 08:10

Yes that's a data breach, but I'd love to know who I was up against at an interview, I always try to spy the names on the visitor book when I go 😂😂

bumblingbovine49 · 11/11/2021 08:06

I have just read your update. Sorry that is worse. I think I would have to tell the company about the very poor response of the recruiter . It is very difficult to know whether to do that before or after you know about the job but my instinct would be to wait until after

bumblingbovine49 · 11/11/2021 08:02

@Ygritte84

Also feeling on a bit of a downer - I thought I was perfect for the job, but there are older people in the pool with many more years of experience.

I would have rather not have known and gone in all pumped up!

I know in theory this had breached GDPR but I personally would be delighted to know who else is being interviewed. Knowledge is power. And even if you don't get the job how can knowing who else is up for interview possibly adversely affect you ? I just don't get it. I will understand that you now feel more anxious because you are aware of who the competition is but going for a job interview is always nerve wracking, or it should be anyway, how is knowing who else is going making that worse?

The issue about names being shared and possibly getting back to current employers of the applicants is a much more serious worry than candidates knowing who else is being interviewed so I am not saying they haven't messed up as they have but I also agree with others that if you want the job you need to complain politely and accept any remedy/ apology in good grace otherwise you might as well not go to the interview

ThinWomansBrain · 11/11/2021 08:01

a charity was fined £10k last week for not using BCC - report the incident to the organisatio's Data Controller.

I once had to do a "test" for a potential role alnogside all of the other candidates; bumped in to the person I'd had a brief handover from when I covered his former role because he'd been "asked to leave" - embarassing; I was still doing that role.
He was later on the other end of a phone call with a colleague, and said the company had decided not to fill the role "yes" replied the colleague, "they offered it to ThinWomansBrain, but she turned it down"

GiltEdges · 11/11/2021 07:59

@1309username

If you only have 72 hours, I’m not sure you can wait to find out if you have the job. I’ve personally had so many interviews when it took them a while to get back to me.

Also, if you wait too long, I think it minimises your complain.

While they’ll have to admit it was a wrong thing to do. They’ll also be like ‘well, it didn’t bother you so much if you were happy to wait a week to complain ‘.

The OP doesn’t only have 72 hours. The recruiter has 72 hours from the point they were notified of the breach.
andyoldlabour · 11/11/2021 07:58

GiltEdges

Definitely the best reply on this thread. Bearing in mind the reply the OP received, I would probably be reporting it to the ICO, in fact I would have taken that route first, as the OP has now outed themselves.

Belledan1 · 11/11/2021 07:56

I do bcc alot internally alot with my job if chasing people if not done a certain task. It is easier to type all the names in the to section as the auto email address comes up automatically and does not in bcc. I then paste it all over to another email in bcc in case I accidentally press send.

Ellmau · 11/11/2021 07:56

no one else had noticed

How would they know? They meant you were the only one who had reported it to them , which is not the same thing.

DGRossetti · 11/11/2021 07:52

Wow stop being so over dramatic. Can you honestly say hand on heart you have never ever made a mistake in your job?

Maybe sky diving is not for you then.

Fairyliz · 11/11/2021 07:50

Wow stop being so over dramatic. Can you honestly say hand on heart you have never ever made a mistake in your job?
Probably some admin assistant on not much more than minimum wage rushing to get a job done.
So you know the other candidates, isn’t it possible that you would have seen some of them at interview anyway?
No ones died, been hurt or even lost 50p yet posters are acting like it’s the end of the world.
No wonder everyone is suffering from stress and anxiety now if they over react like this.

Switch82 · 11/11/2021 07:48

A definite GDPR breach. Go on the recruiter’s website at the bottom or somewhere will be a Privacy policy - detailed on there will be the person you need to contact when there is a breach.

I would also ask for another recruiter to represent you.

HotChoc10 · 11/11/2021 07:48

That's so bad! Not quite the same but when I interviewed for my current job I took a sneaky look at the sign in sheet and looked up some of the names afterwards... There were people with decades more experience and seniority than me but I interviewed well (for once!) and got it. If you weren't a serious contender they wouldn't be interviewing you. 1

DGRossetti · 11/11/2021 07:45

She apologised, but said no one else had noticed and she didn't feel like apologising to the other candidates as this could make them aware of the mistake.

GDPR doesn't work like that.

She had 72 hours to investigate the breach and report to the ICO if required. Part of that involves notifying anyone whose details were compromised - in this case the other candidates.

The ICO is thataway -> ico.org.uk/for-organisations/report-a-breach/

1309username · 11/11/2021 07:32

If you only have 72 hours, I’m not sure you can wait to find out if you have the job. I’ve personally had so many interviews when it took them a while to get back to me.

Also, if you wait too long, I think it minimises your complain.

While they’ll have to admit it was a wrong thing to do. They’ll also be like ‘well, it didn’t bother you so much if you were happy to wait a week to complain ‘.

Dyrne · 11/11/2021 07:23

Maybe it’s because I work in regulation; but I would actually look favourably on someone that politely reported a GDPR breach and explained the steps that needed to be taken.

Everyone is very twitchy about GDPR at the moment and the company may be grateful to have it pointed out to them and see you as someone who has a good knowledge of regulation and is looking to protect the company.

cowburp · 11/11/2021 07:17

Depends on the role and line of work. If it's data protection officer they'll be impressed you reported it.

ShagMeRiggins · 11/11/2021 07:09

@BritInUS1

Contact the recruitment company and ask for the details of the Data Protection Officer and report it to them
How would that help, though? The breach wasn’t performed by anyone in the company.

OP is this recruiter a one person operation? If there’s a recruitment company, perhaps raise it with them. Or speak again to the recruiter.

Clearly nothing can be done to change what’s happened—unless she can recall the emails and send again in proper form—but that ship has probably sailed. But she still owes everyone an apology at the very least.