Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that recruiter CCed all candidates going to job interview

115 replies

Ygritte84 · 09/11/2021 16:07

Two emails were sent with the complete list of candidates in CC, with names and email addresses. Total breach of confidentiality, right?

I work in a small industry and people know each other. I will cross some of these people in my job.

Feeling very annoyed and also starting to doubt myself seeing the competition!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IamnotSethRogan · 13/11/2021 07:48

Urgh it's done now and it's really not a massive deal..complaining or getting someone in trouble seems a bit petty.

It's happened a few times where we've received emails that Cc'd instead of BCC'd people in. Some absolute knob replied all once saying "I hope you have reported this to ICO"

A. It's was a fucking boring email about some small change in the company, a few companies basically just saw eachothers email addresses (who cares really?)
B. By replying all, he'd basically done the same thing so needed to report himself
C. The ICO would not give a fuck

Memyselfandfood · 13/11/2021 07:38

The recruiter has no idea if anyone else has noticed! There’s a good chance other candidates will be complaining when they have their interviews!
I would def bring this up op.

name3958 · 11/11/2021 16:24

@GiltEdges the ICO will not listen to the OP until she has exhausted the complaints procedure, whilst it is a breach it is does not meet the ICO threshold so it is extremely unlikely they will get involved at this stage, they will if the subject is not happy with how it's been handled but she is not at that stage yet. She needs to formally complain, in writing.

veryouting2021 · 11/11/2021 16:11

I work in recruitment in a large company.

Report to the ICO. They will investigate with the agency and work with them to improve their processes.

CharityDingle · 11/11/2021 15:53

@ShagMeRiggins

When you notified her of this, do you have a record of it? If not, send a quick email to say something like, just following up after our conversation where I brought your attention to the email, can you confirm that this is being looked into as it is the second time it has happened. Just be polite, but then you have written evidence they were informed.

That’s intelligent and professional advice from Bookworm20.

So many forms of communication these days are designed not to leave a digital trail. It’s disastrous for businesses (and personally, but that’s another thread).

I had also mentioned putting it in writing to the individual and/ or the data protection officer of the company if the recruiter works in a company.
ShagMeRiggins · 11/11/2021 15:41

When you notified her of this, do you have a record of it? If not, send a quick email to say something like, just following up after our conversation where I brought your attention to the email, can you confirm that this is being looked into as it is the second time it has happened.
Just be polite, but then you have written evidence they were informed.

That’s intelligent and professional advice from Bookworm20.

So many forms of communication these days are designed not to leave a digital trail. It’s disastrous for businesses (and personally, but that’s another thread).

GiltEdges · 11/11/2021 14:04

Yes but you don't go to the ICO until you've exhausted the company's complaints procedure, the ICO will not engage with you if all you can evidence is one conversation on the matter.

Not true. A data breach is nothing like a complaint. Anyone can report a breach to the ICO irrespective of the dealings they’ve had with the organisation who caused it.

And in terms of the ICO’s response, it will really be determined by how negatively the OP (and others) have been impacted by the incident and potentially whether the company has ever been reported for similar breaches in the past, which would indicate a more systemic issue with their policies/practices/staff training around data protection.

Don’t presume they just because it’s one “small” incident this time that the regulator won’t be interested. Companies have been fined for very similar transgressions, where the impact on data subjects had been significant enough.

hannsmum · 11/11/2021 12:03

@IWentAwayIStayedAway

I would hit REPLY ALL and wish everyone good luck! Major feck up
😂😂😂😂👍
daimbarsatemydogsbone · 11/11/2021 12:02

There is a theme to this and the threads about why no-one ever hears back from recruiters.

Too much is being left to individuals to do by hand.

There are hundreds of software systems that can be used for recruitment - there is no reason and no excuse for anyone in 2021 to be typing or even copy and pasting e-mail addresses into an email.

name3958 · 11/11/2021 11:59

No, of course not, but they'll have a register of complaints and should investigate if a particular organisation has lots of complaints made against it as it is a clear sign of bad practice.

Yes but you don't go to the ICO until you've exhausted the company's complaints procedure, the ICO will not engage with you if all you can evidence is one conversation on the matter.

idontlikealdi · 11/11/2021 11:42

I'd let the company know - they might want to changer recruitment firms.

user1497207191 · 11/11/2021 11:35

@name3958

Do people really think every breach has to be reported to the ICO? Do you have any idea how many years it would take the ICO to investigate EVERY breach that's ever occurred?!
No, of course not, but they'll have a register of complaints and should investigate if a particular organisation has lots of complaints made against it as it is a clear sign of bad practice.
Pedalpushers · 11/11/2021 10:21

The ICO wouldn't fine a company for an accidental email cc', they would just send them an email of their GDPR guidance and tell them they shouldn't do it again.

It would be good to let the recruiter know so that they can follow their in-house GDPR guidance, which will probably be just to report it to their data officer.

name3958 · 11/11/2021 10:18

@DGRossetti indeed, but people are advising it'll go to the ICO when it is very unlikely that it needs to, and worst still telling her to report to the ICO before she's even exhausted the complaints process for the company.

DGRossetti · 11/11/2021 10:16

@name3958

Do people really think every breach has to be reported to the ICO? Do you have any idea how many years it would take the ICO to investigate EVERY breach that's ever occurred?!
Of course not every breach needs to be reported. That's what the companies internal GDPR investigation is there to determine.

So where's the companies investigation documentation ? (Hint: Just saying "It's not serious", isn't good enough).

Of course the real problem is people learning of data breaches. If they didn't know about them, they wouldn't have to worry. (I am Geoffrey Cox, and you can claim your five pounds Grin)

name3958 · 11/11/2021 09:48

Do people really think every breach has to be reported to the ICO? Do you have any idea how many years it would take the ICO to investigate EVERY breach that's ever occurred?!

Bookworm20 · 11/11/2021 09:47

Its a data breach and now they are aware of it they have to investigate, including notifying anyone whose details were involved and contact the ICO within 72 hours of being notified by you, if a possible breach has occured. They don't need all the facts first, as they candidate the ICO once they have investigated further.
To dismiss it saying she doesn't want to draw attention to it. Wow, that is shocking.
I would report the ICO yourself. Think of what the impact/risk this breach has for you. You say there is someone else in that list who works for your company. So potentially they could inform your company you were applying for another job, as you could them. Which if you dont get the new job, could it cause you issues at your current work?
Things like that.

Its not up to you to make sure this recruiter informs their DPO or whoever should deal with things like this. But her attitude is shocking. Clearly some training is in order there!

When you notified her of this, do you have a record of it? If not, send a quick email to say something like, just following up after our conversation where I brought your attention to the email, can you confirm that this is being looked into as it is the second time it has happened.
Just be polite, but then you have written evidence they were informed.

newtb · 11/11/2021 09:40

Unfortunately, the GDPR, and the Data Protection Act aren't worth the paper they're written on. Yet another piece of legislation drafted and voted in by people with PPE degrees and no knowledge of the real world.

Back in the 1980s TSB had to make changes to their database about the way customer information was held due to increasing numbers having more than 1 cheque account, among other things.

A meeting was held with the Registrar in Wilmslow who said that the bank could not hold customer names and addresses in the computer database.

How the hell he thought he got his bank statement sent in the post, I have no idea. Probably he had hand written statements on vellum or something, or banked with Gringotts. He was 'persuaded' to learn the error of his ways.

Many items sold can be in default of legal regulations but it's impossible to prosecute the manufacturer because of poor wording and drafting of the legislation which is in conflict with the statutory regulations.

As a pp has said, make your feelings known before the interview. You've got the interview - if they didn't think you could do the job, you wouldn't have got that far.

Good luck

name3958 · 11/11/2021 09:37

Massive GDPR breach - they could get into real trouble and pay a big fine over this. Launch a complaint.

Hmm
billy1966 · 11/11/2021 09:26

Awful.

The recruiter has just advertised to you all that ye are all actively looking for a new position elsewhere.

Just awful.

What a cowboy outfit response.

Wholly unprofessional.

silverbubbles · 11/11/2021 09:26

The recruiter has messed up. If it bothers you that much and you want to get the recruiter into trouble you need to inform the company you are interviewing with (as they are employing the services of the recruiter).

But the cats out the bag anyway and everyone is in the same boat.

Don't let this get in the way of going for the job - good luck with the interview!

Direwolfwrangler · 11/11/2021 09:22

Similar to @name3958 I also work in the field of data protection. From the perspective of the ICO this is a breach but not a serious one. It would be extremely surprising if any follow-up action was taken.

The recruiter’s response is really poor, however. I would expect them to at least set out what procedures they have in place to reduce risk of recurrence, training etc. Where I work this would not be a sackable offence but there would be an investigation.

Good luck at interview OP.

Tilltheend99 · 11/11/2021 09:13

Yes that is a breach of data protection laws and you should make a complaint to first to the recruiter and then to the ico www.gov.uk/data-protection/make-a-complaint

Noodella18 · 11/11/2021 09:08

Massive GDPR breach - they could get into real trouble and pay a big fine over this. Launch a complaint.

SpinachIsAGatewayDrug · 11/11/2021 09:03

The police once did something similar with a crime I'd provided evidence for. Someone stealing handbags and selling them on. They sent an email to everyone who had bought one of these bags from eBay and given them a statement, with their email addresses visible.

Shock