Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To trick someone into eating vegan?

205 replies

Idonthatevegans · 09/11/2021 15:24

Please read my question before getting into a debate about veganism. That isn't really what it is about. It has no impact on my life if someone is a vegan or not, do what you wish.

I got into a discussion with someone recently, and found out that people are often surprised when they find out that there was no meat in the beef pie/ spag bol etc she served. And she gets a kick of that fact they couldn't tell the difference. Honestly I couldn't really, not in something like a spag bol.

I have however, tried quorn a few times in my life, with AWFUL results. I am in the bathroom within 1 hour and very sick for a day after. A 100% vegan meal without meat substitutes ya I'm 100% ok with. But if someone says I made beef pie, I would take them at their word. If I knew the person was vegan I would probably enquire if it was real meat only because I know how awfully I react to it. But if I didn't know that person was a vegan I would take it at face value. Yes it happens every so often I get offered tea around a friends aunt who we popped into or something like that.

To me, a vegan passing of something as meat to people who don't know and can therefore make up their own mind is as bad as me putting chicken stock into veg soup and telling someone it is vegan friendly. Ya the vast majority in both cases won't know the difference in taste or after affect. But both people have been denied the option of having their own choice. One has been tricked into thinking they are eating meat, one has been tricked into thinking they are not. I know there are hugely different moral implications there but both have been tricked when they should not have been.

I really don't want to this to break into a vegan/ non vegan debate. That is all that I got back on my last chat. The person wouldn't actually answer my question about tricking someone, just kept on a barrage of info about how vegan is amazing and that anyone who eat meat was the devil incarnate.

BTW - it's not something I would often say I am allergic to as I usually take how food is called at their face value.

I simply want to know:

AIBU - she can call her pie beef pie, even if it is not beef pie.

YANBU - you should know what you are eating. If it's called beef pie well of course you would expect it to be beef pie

OP posts:
OneTC · 09/11/2021 15:50

The vegan aspect is a total non issue

Giving people food they're not expecting to eat can be a big problem though

MurielSpriggs · 09/11/2021 15:50

@toastofthetown

People should be honest and upfront about what they are serving, though when vegans have prepared meals for me, I assume the food will be vegan.

I am confused about people who claim that they can't tell the difference between substitutes and meat. I haven't eaten meat in over ten years, and still feel mince substitutes lack any depth of flavour and the texture is off-putting. People are polite and simply won't say 'this is terrible, I think something is wrong here' even though they can tell the dish isn't right. The only thing to say when someone serves you a meal 'this is lovely, thank you very much'. And I think people confuse that politeness with their guests being genuinely fooled. I feel similar when people online say they serve their sugar free beetroot brownies and no-one can tell the difference.

This is spot on! Our vegan friend is very keen to give us vegan ice cream, vegan creme brulé etc, while enthusiastically telling us it's at least as nice as the "real thing". We feel honour-bound to go along with it. But strangely no one else chooses this stuff at anyone elses house when there's a choice of something with diary fat in it Grin
Sn0tnose · 09/11/2021 15:48

I think anyone who is lying to someone about what food they’ve served them, for whatever reason, is an irresponsible, selfish arsehole.

I end up eating quite a lot of vegan food as my DB and SiL are vegans. I also lie through my back teeth and pretend that I can’t taste the difference in meat substitutes. I can; it’s vile, both in taste and texture and I struggle to swallow it unless I’ve covered it in baked beans or ketchup. Whoever told your friend they couldn’t tell the difference is either lying to be polite, or they have defective tastebuds!

madisonbridges · 09/11/2021 15:47

If I were going to someone's house for a meal and I had a serious allergy like yours, I would tell them in advance. That's only fair, isn't it? If I'd gone to the trouble of making you a quorn (and it's not cheap) pie and then you said, that you couldn't eat it, I'd be pretty fed up.

MoltenLasagne · 09/11/2021 15:46

I've got nut allergies and I'm intolerant to a whole load of other food. I've twice ended up very sick from people pulling this stunt. I don't understand the mentality of bare faced lying to someone about what they're eating. It's immoral and just plain stupid.

toastofthetown · 09/11/2021 15:43

People should be honest and upfront about what they are serving, though when vegans have prepared meals for me, I assume the food will be vegan.

I am confused about people who claim that they can't tell the difference between substitutes and meat. I haven't eaten meat in over ten years, and still feel mince substitutes lack any depth of flavour and the texture is off-putting. People are polite and simply won't say 'this is terrible, I think something is wrong here' even though they can tell the dish isn't right. The only thing to say when someone serves you a meal 'this is lovely, thank you very much'. And I think people confuse that politeness with their guests being genuinely fooled. I feel similar when people online say they serve their sugar free beetroot brownies and no-one can tell the difference.

MurielSpriggs · 09/11/2021 15:41

PS If you're allergic then it's really up to you to ask to know everything that's in a dish. It would be quite possible for something legitimately called beef pie to be crammed full of prime beef, but still have some Quorn in it.

BelleOfTheProvince · 09/11/2021 15:41

I'd be surprised at someone who was being cooked for by a vegan thinking they're going to get meat.

As a vegan, trust me, you do not want people unused to cooking meat cooking it for you. Guaranteed food poisoning.

I just find this a little hard to believe it would come up.

But I would echo what another poster has said that if you have intolerances you should be mentioning them anyway.

A meat eater without intolerances is not really equivalent to 'tricking' a vegan into eating meat. Most non vegan people don't not eat vegetables due to ethical reasons.

It's just a really weird situation that I can't imagine happening organically.

The only thing I have experienced that has come close is when I've made vegan treats for work. Label them, but people ignore anyway. Lots of bitching about sausage rolls, but polished off my cupcakes pretty quick.

gogohm · 09/11/2021 15:40

You should be honest with what you are serving to people in case of allergies. Admittedly I sneak veg into the (adult) kids meals because they are fussy but I know their lack of allergies!

caoraich · 09/11/2021 15:39

I'm vegetarian and wouldn't be happy about this. Others have mentioned that it could have been beef mixed with quorn and still been "beef".

I am OK with small amounts of soy. Large amounts give me GI upset, but generally I don't tell people I have an allergy as a wee bit of soy won't hurt me and I wouldn't choose to eat a soy burger. I'd be pretty upset if someone tricked me into eating soy by telling me it was something else!

MurielSpriggs · 09/11/2021 15:39

It's not really the same as putting chicken stock in soup which you're claiming is vegan. I don't know anyone who has an ethical objection to eating vegan food. In fact I don't think it would be possible to construct one. It's more like serving up cheap cava as champagne and only owning up after everyone has said how nice it is.

HeartsAndClubs · 09/11/2021 15:38

I’ve lost track of the number of vegans who’ve posted here saying “it’s highly unusual to be allergic to meat substitutes” even though a huge number of posters are incredibly intolerant to them. I thin it justifies their position on being vegan in some way.

Quorn is revolting anyway but either way lying to someone to trick them into eating something they actively wouldn’t choose to just so you can get a kick out of it is fucked up. If someone did that to me I would feel compelled to covertly feed them a pie with beef, and meat stock, inside a lovely all butter pastry case and then laugh heartily when they declared it to be delicious. Grin

Fomomofo · 09/11/2021 15:36

I like vegan food but not like quorn at all

AnCailleachOiche · 09/11/2021 15:35

Yanbu I like to know what I am eating and also if the diner had an allergic reaction.... your mate could be up on a manslaughter charge.

VickyEadieofThigh · 09/11/2021 15:33

She's hardly Sweeney Todd...

negomi90 · 09/11/2021 15:33

I'm a vegan. Saying its a beef pie when its not is lying. But lots of people being heathy or on budgets or for their own reasons may mix beef mince with other things like soya mince.
So while she lied at that's not ok. If you are sensitive to certain things you need to declare it. What she gave you could have been a beef pie if she'd mixed a bit of beef into it, while using all the same other ingredients and only a tiny bit of beef. It would still have caused you the same effects.
So yes she shouldn't have called a beef pie if it had no beef, but you could still have been in trouble with a beef pie.

JackieChiles · 09/11/2021 15:33

You are totally right OP. You can’t do a bait and switch thing with someone’s food.

The only thing I will say is that if you have food intolerances you should always ask because you never know what random stuff someone throws into a recipe. Beef pie could be full of beef but the person had an extra thing of Quorn so decided to throw that in. Obviously the person should tell you if there is anything unexpected in a dish but I don’t think people think about it that much.

Ryannah · 09/11/2021 15:33

Not telling people what they’re eating is a massive issue in terms of allergies and intolerances, and is actually illegal in restaurants now.

Jessicabrassica · 09/11/2021 15:32

I think I'd ask if there was anything somebody couldn't eat before cooking for them. As a vegetarian I expect the same courtesy. I think lying about ingredients is deceitful and potentially dangerous.

ShirleyPhallus · 09/11/2021 15:32

I know people say that people can’t tell the difference but you really really can. I eat plenty of veggie foods but veggie mince really lacks the depth of a proper meat bolognese

LolaSmiles · 09/11/2021 15:31

YANBU and it's frankly weird when adults seem to get bizarre kicks out of sneaking food past people.

HarrietsChariot · 09/11/2021 15:31

YANBU, misleading someone as to what they are eating is wrong. What she's doing is no different to her slipping bacon into a Jewish person's meal or tipping vodka into someone's drink when you know they're a recovering alcoholic.

Hoppinggreen · 09/11/2021 15:29

My DD struggles to breathe if she eats Quorn and it gives me the shits so it’s really bad to try and pass it off as meat and vice versa

ABCeasyasdohrayme · 09/11/2021 15:29

I actually had a vegan try this with me a few years ago.

I had to quiz him about what the food was made of due to an allergy and sensed something was wrong because he couldn't lie for shit.

Apparently he had simply wanted to prove I could be a vegan.

I asked him what his thoughts would have been if I used animal products and tricked him into eating them, it was completely different apparently.

Smug, arrogant, sanctimonious bastard, if I wanted to be vegan I would be.

Mumoblue · 09/11/2021 15:29

You never know what people are allergic to/intolerant of. Tricking someone into eating or drinking something when they think they’re having something else is stupid and wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread