Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To trick someone into eating vegan?

205 replies

Idonthatevegans · 09/11/2021 15:24

Please read my question before getting into a debate about veganism. That isn't really what it is about. It has no impact on my life if someone is a vegan or not, do what you wish.

I got into a discussion with someone recently, and found out that people are often surprised when they find out that there was no meat in the beef pie/ spag bol etc she served. And she gets a kick of that fact they couldn't tell the difference. Honestly I couldn't really, not in something like a spag bol.

I have however, tried quorn a few times in my life, with AWFUL results. I am in the bathroom within 1 hour and very sick for a day after. A 100% vegan meal without meat substitutes ya I'm 100% ok with. But if someone says I made beef pie, I would take them at their word. If I knew the person was vegan I would probably enquire if it was real meat only because I know how awfully I react to it. But if I didn't know that person was a vegan I would take it at face value. Yes it happens every so often I get offered tea around a friends aunt who we popped into or something like that.

To me, a vegan passing of something as meat to people who don't know and can therefore make up their own mind is as bad as me putting chicken stock into veg soup and telling someone it is vegan friendly. Ya the vast majority in both cases won't know the difference in taste or after affect. But both people have been denied the option of having their own choice. One has been tricked into thinking they are eating meat, one has been tricked into thinking they are not. I know there are hugely different moral implications there but both have been tricked when they should not have been.

I really don't want to this to break into a vegan/ non vegan debate. That is all that I got back on my last chat. The person wouldn't actually answer my question about tricking someone, just kept on a barrage of info about how vegan is amazing and that anyone who eat meat was the devil incarnate.

BTW - it's not something I would often say I am allergic to as I usually take how food is called at their face value.

I simply want to know:

AIBU - she can call her pie beef pie, even if it is not beef pie.

YANBU - you should know what you are eating. If it's called beef pie well of course you would expect it to be beef pie

OP posts:
Mrsjayy · 09/11/2021 16:29

How can you not tell if it's Quorn or a substitute there is a definite difference I mean people must know?

PinkiOcelot · 09/11/2021 16:29

I’m up all night vomiting if I eat Quorn so wouldn’t be happy with that at all.
Your friend is an arse! Would she like to eat meat products unwittingly? I doubt it!

Idonthatevegans · 09/11/2021 16:29

Hi, wow lots of responses on here! She didn't do this to me, she isn't a friend just someone I was friends with on FB, we both happened to comment on a Christmas chocolate ad which went down an awful rabbit hole. I as a rule normally don't comment on anything to do with vegans, but felt I had to point out to her she shouldn't trick people into thinking they are eating meat.

I don't know the particular circumstances, just that she said she has and that they don't know the difference so why don't they eat it. She wasn't the first person I've seen to say similar things.

With regards to telling people I am intolerant/ allergic before going to their house for dinner. It really has never been an issue for me. I have a sister who is vegi but often cooks meat for her family so if she said it was beef pie I would believe her. If I was going to another vegetarians house I would tell them I am allergic to quorn. It just doesn't seem to be a common issue. Unlike my niece who will have to tell people for the rest of her life that she is coeliac

In general though if someone said I'm making chicken curry, or beef pie or something that is usually meat I wouldn't see the need to tell them. I've had two awful reactions, but each time I feed it to myself (tried once at about 18, again after about 10yrs to see if the intolerance had lifted, it had not).

OP posts:
AliceMcK · 09/11/2021 16:28

@BelleOfTheProvince

I'd be surprised at someone who was being cooked for by a vegan thinking they're going to get meat.

As a vegan, trust me, you do not want people unused to cooking meat cooking it for you. Guaranteed food poisoning.

I just find this a little hard to believe it would come up.

But I would echo what another poster has said that if you have intolerances you should be mentioning them anyway.

A meat eater without intolerances is not really equivalent to 'tricking' a vegan into eating meat. Most non vegan people don't not eat vegetables due to ethical reasons.

It's just a really weird situation that I can't imagine happening organically.

The only thing I have experienced that has come close is when I've made vegan treats for work. Label them, but people ignore anyway. Lots of bitching about sausage rolls, but polished off my cupcakes pretty quick.

Disagree, my DB and his entire family are vegan. My SIL would make meat dishes for her DF when he was alive, she’s also used cooked meat for other family members. How is cooking meat any different to cooking something else, if you don’t know how to cook it, look it up.

My SIL choose to put her beliefs aside to make sure her DF was eating properly in the last couple of years in his life. He wouldn’t eat meals on wheels and although he would respect her beliefs at her house she didn’t think it right to force vegan meal on him full time, so when she choose to make his meals for him she made food she knew he would eat.

Floralnomad · 09/11/2021 16:27

YANBU mainly from an allergy POV , but quite honestly I’m not sure how someone can’t tell the difference between meat and meat substitute as I’ve tried a few and can definitely tell the difference . My daughter accidentally got given a vegan meatball starter in Zizzi instead of a gluten free option and you could tell just by looking at it , and it was revolting.

ravenmum · 09/11/2021 16:26

I didn't realise soy was a common allergen - good to know. I have more problems with dairy, so regularly use non-dairy alternatives and would never even think to mention it. I'll have to watch out there's no soy next time, I guess.

Dixiechickonhols · 09/11/2021 16:25

It’s wrong not to tell. Some people are allergic or have reactions - Quorn is banned in Canada I think. If she says it’s beef pie then it should be beef.
DD’s old school did this. I couldn’t understand why she wasn’t eating spaghetti Bolognese or cottage pie and enquired as she ate them at home. They were using Quorn to avoid need to do halal meals (about 1/3 school wanted halal). To be fair menu didn’t say beef on menu but it explained why dd didn’t like taste/texture. They stopped it as it wasn’t popular with children.

Pigeoninthehouse · 09/11/2021 16:24

I'm a long time veggie, most people I know are aware, so its not something I could pull off, even if I wanted.
As long as someone's checked for any allergies, which you should anyway if you are cooking for someone, I don't see the harm in feeding someone veggies, most meat eaters would be eating veggies in their diet anyway, so I can't see the problem with it.

Plotato · 09/11/2021 16:23

@RedHot22

YANBU

although, most quorn isn’t vegan anyway

Was going to say exactly this! People always talk about quorn in vegan discussions but until very recently I don't think a single thing in their range was vegan and a lot still isn't - contains egg.
BobLemon · 09/11/2021 16:23

What a tediously immature thing to do

EverdeRose · 09/11/2021 16:22

YANBU

I'd happily eat a veggie or vegan meal, but wouldn't touch quorn for similar reasons to you and would be furious if I was served something that would make me ill.

Pedalpushers · 09/11/2021 16:22

I think lying to people about what is in their food is a recipe for disaster whatever form it takes.

Barkalot · 09/11/2021 16:22

@EvenRosesHaveThorns

Top tip - feeding a vegan meat and pretending it isn't is NOT equivalent to vice versa, as you claim. Anyway, if you were being fed by a vegan, you would assume it was too!
Yes but if you didn't know the person was vegan and they presented something as a "beef pie" I think it's fairly normal to go ahead and assume they mean actual beef.

Also what is the difference between this and feeding a vegan meet? Can you explain why it's not the same?

jb7445 · 09/11/2021 16:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Barkalot · 09/11/2021 16:20

No one should be "tricking" anyone into eating anything.

RunningFromInsanity · 09/11/2021 16:19

@VickyEadieofThigh

She's hardly Sweeney Todd...
Grin
MintJulia · 09/11/2021 16:19

Anyone who lies intentionally when giving food to someone else is an idiot. All it would take is a bad allergic reaction to end up on a manslaughter charge because it was knowingly done.

Perhaps you could explain that to your 'friend'.

FeatheredHope · 09/11/2021 16:19

I thinks it’s only reasonable to be honest with people about what you are feeding them. For safety reasons alone.
I suspect she would be hugely unimpressed if someone fed her beef whilst telling her it was a veggi spag bol.

Noeuf · 09/11/2021 16:18

I’m vegan and intolerant to Quorn, didn’t realise and had 8 weeks of throwing up, becoming so ill until we realised. You should always tell people the truth about what you’re cooking or offering if they ask or if there might be some identification issue.

EvenRosesHaveThorns · 09/11/2021 16:17

My partner (meat eater) complains when I tell him if something is a fake meat substitute as he enjoys the feel of eating it more if it's meat and even when he 9 times out of 10 enjoys the substitute, to telling him before or after actually disappoints him... so no trigger earnings in this house

Squirrelblanket · 09/11/2021 16:15

*food

Squirrelblanket · 09/11/2021 16:15

I don't think you should lie about what is in good you are serving people, whether they are vegan, vegetarian or omnivore.

I was watching an old episode of Come Dine with Me yesterday where a contestant cooked a fully vegan menu full of substitutes e.g. cheese made from coconut oil, pulled jackfruit etc. The other guests were politely complimentary to her face (as they should be) but in the secret scoring she did really poorly. In her interviews she just kept trilling on about how she was 'opening their minds' about vegan food and so on and it struck me that this is what you hear from vegans a lot.

But a lot of people HAVE tried vegan food and just don't like it, or prefer food with meat in it. Is it really so hard to understand that some people like different things? Confused

EvenRosesHaveThorns · 09/11/2021 16:15

Top tip - feeding a vegan meat and pretending it isn't is NOT equivalent to vice versa, as you claim. Anyway, if you were being fed by a vegan, you would assume it was too!

PinkKecks · 09/11/2021 16:13

I think people should know what they are eating, but if I was going to a friend's house for dinner, I would make sure they knew in advance if there was anything I didn't/couldn't eat, so if she is unaware of your dietary requirements/restrictions then it is your responsibility to make it known.

If, for example, I made spaghetti bolognese with quorn mince, I probably wouldn't specify to guests that it was quorn. I've been vegetarian for 30+ years so I dont specifically say "quorn spag bol" in the same way a meat-eater wouldn't say "beef spag bol". It isn't about tricking someone, it is just the shorthand that you use in your own home in day-to-day life to describe the usual meals you create.

DrSbaitso · 09/11/2021 16:09

I haven't eaten meat for many years, but I remember it and veggie mince really does taste different.

I've found that meat eaters, if they're going to have a vegetarian bolognese, usually prefer one with firm dark lentils, brown or green, than veggie mince. It still tastes very different to a beef one, of course, but it's not trying to taste the same; it's just a different palette of flavour. They seem more inclined to accept it as an alternative meal and it doesn't seem to disappoint them the way an earnest fake does!

Swipe left for the next trending thread