Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To trick someone into eating vegan?

205 replies

Idonthatevegans · 09/11/2021 15:24

Please read my question before getting into a debate about veganism. That isn't really what it is about. It has no impact on my life if someone is a vegan or not, do what you wish.

I got into a discussion with someone recently, and found out that people are often surprised when they find out that there was no meat in the beef pie/ spag bol etc she served. And she gets a kick of that fact they couldn't tell the difference. Honestly I couldn't really, not in something like a spag bol.

I have however, tried quorn a few times in my life, with AWFUL results. I am in the bathroom within 1 hour and very sick for a day after. A 100% vegan meal without meat substitutes ya I'm 100% ok with. But if someone says I made beef pie, I would take them at their word. If I knew the person was vegan I would probably enquire if it was real meat only because I know how awfully I react to it. But if I didn't know that person was a vegan I would take it at face value. Yes it happens every so often I get offered tea around a friends aunt who we popped into or something like that.

To me, a vegan passing of something as meat to people who don't know and can therefore make up their own mind is as bad as me putting chicken stock into veg soup and telling someone it is vegan friendly. Ya the vast majority in both cases won't know the difference in taste or after affect. But both people have been denied the option of having their own choice. One has been tricked into thinking they are eating meat, one has been tricked into thinking they are not. I know there are hugely different moral implications there but both have been tricked when they should not have been.

I really don't want to this to break into a vegan/ non vegan debate. That is all that I got back on my last chat. The person wouldn't actually answer my question about tricking someone, just kept on a barrage of info about how vegan is amazing and that anyone who eat meat was the devil incarnate.

BTW - it's not something I would often say I am allergic to as I usually take how food is called at their face value.

I simply want to know:

AIBU - she can call her pie beef pie, even if it is not beef pie.

YANBU - you should know what you are eating. If it's called beef pie well of course you would expect it to be beef pie

OP posts:
CalamariGames · 09/11/2021 16:55

I agree from an allergy point of view that you should not trick people. I also don't think people will be converted to veganism just because a meat substitute tastes as good as meat. A lot of people who eat meat think its healthier than meat substitute products.

Chloemol · 09/11/2021 16:52

YANBU. I react to quorn

I would expect my vegan friends to tell me what they have used in the same way I would tell them

godmum56 · 09/11/2021 16:52

@MurielSpriggs

It's not really the same as putting chicken stock in soup which you're claiming is vegan. I don't know anyone who has an ethical objection to eating vegan food. In fact I don't think it would be possible to construct one. It's more like serving up cheap cava as champagne and only owning up after everyone has said how nice it is.
no but I have an ethical objection to being lied to about what I am eating. I cannot digest many things which are standard in vegan diets, and others make me live in the loo.
NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 09/11/2021 16:52

@whatatimetobealive

Also lentils, my dh has a deathly allergy to lentils and they are used in a lot of vegan dishes.
He had a severe reaction as a child and has to carry an epipen around with him since.

Choosea · 09/11/2021 16:50

I know this isn't what you asked but Quorn mince isn't vegan as it contains egg!

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 09/11/2021 16:50

I would need to know as I have a nut allergy and nuts are used a lot in vegan food.

BarbaraofSeville · 09/11/2021 16:49

@lazylinguist

I am confused about people who claim that they can't tell the difference between substitutes and meat.

Me too. MIL once made bolognese with quorn for all of us (FIL is pescatarian but she normally makes something separate for him). It was horrible (her meat bolognese is lovely) and it gave me awful indigestion. I have no problem with not eating meat - I could pretty easily be vegetarian- but all the meat substitutes I've tried have been not very nice.

Me three. The taste and the texture is all wrong.

I eat meat and a wide range of meat substitutes and like both. Vegan alternatives to burgers and sausages are softer and usually have a slightly different flavour. Same for Quorn mince. Chicken style quorn is probably the closest in nuggets, but I could probably still tell.

But I still think you should be honest about what you're serving because you don't always know about other people's allergies, intolerences etc.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 09/11/2021 16:49

You don't have to cook a meat dish but you should be honest about what's in the meal so that the person knows it's a meat substitute.
It would piss me off if someone lied, like seriously what is the point? Vegans would be up in arms if you fed them a meat dish without telling them the truth.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 09/11/2021 16:49

Back in the day before quorn, I was mates with a very evangelical vegan. He made chili with tvp to prove just that point for a byo type party. No one knew who made it.And stood there smugly whilst all these pissed up students ate it. (Honestly! They were hungry and drunk, they would have eaten anything)Including me, the coeliac. Honestly I thought I was going to turn inside out.

PleasantBirthday · 09/11/2021 16:48

It's weird and controlling, in my opinion. I would assume food cooked by a vegan wouldn't use animal products or by products but lying directly to someone about what they're eating is very strange behaviour.

Europilgrim · 09/11/2021 16:48

You should never trick someone into eating anything. And surely nobody really thinks that vegan spag bol tastes like meat!

Bluemoononkentucky · 09/11/2021 16:48

It is very wrong to trick someone into eating meat substitutes.

Physical reactions are not at all rare. Quorn state it can cause problems for some people on every supermarket product page, for instance.

I try vegetarian/vegan foods regularly and bloody hell, do some of them lay waste to my body.

I tried some vegan sausage rolls last week. Absolutely lovely.
Bunged me up, did not shit for 6 days. Sorry if TMI there.

I adore Quorn Southern Fried Burgers on a brioche but, damn, they give me terrible abdominal gut cramps and the runs.

Week before I tried a Pukka minced steak and onion vegan pie. Again gorgeous, nicer than the meat one. I was fine with that one.

I actually think it's worse to trick someone into eating substitutes than tricking them into eating meat because, although morally repugnant to feed a veggie/vegan meat, meat is unlikely to cause painful health related reactions.

To, even temporaily, cause someone pain so you can go, "see, I told you so" about faux meat is vile behaviour.

Barkalot · 09/11/2021 16:46

@Alltheprettyseahorses

It's not tricking someone not to feed them a dead animal! As a guest you are responsible for informing your host of any allergies, it's not like going to a sandwich shop.
It is if that person is allergic to the substitute. You shouldn't be calling something a beef pie if it's not actually a beef pie.

If someone said "heres a beef pie" I wouldn't automatically think to say 'im allergic to Quorn by the way'.

ancientgran · 09/11/2021 16:46

@MurielSpriggs

It's not really the same as putting chicken stock in soup which you're claiming is vegan. I don't know anyone who has an ethical objection to eating vegan food. In fact I don't think it would be possible to construct one. It's more like serving up cheap cava as champagne and only owning up after everyone has said how nice it is.
I think it is worse, is anyone allergic to chicken stock?
mrsm43s · 09/11/2021 16:45

@Alltheprettyseahorses

It's not tricking someone not to feed them a dead animal! As a guest you are responsible for informing your host of any allergies, it's not like going to a sandwich shop.
Of course its tricking someone to say "this is a beef pie" and give them a quorn pie! Why not be honest?
mrsm43s · 09/11/2021 16:44

Of course its not OK to trick people into eating anything they'd prefer not to eat. Yes to allergies (I have issues with Quorn and Soy, so I'd suffer if they'd been snuck in), but actually its just general twattish behaviour to try to trick people to prove a point and shove your views down their throat.

And no-one, except a vegan, thinks that meat substitutes taste like meat. They're just too polite to tell you how awful your food tasted. It is always, always better to cook a naturally vegan/vegetarian menu than to use substitutes of any kind. I'd far rather have just a bread roll and a large portion of side salad than eat a quorn spag bol (and my stomach would like me more for it too!).

CecilyP · 09/11/2021 16:41

Someone made us a quorn bolognese and we were very polite and said it was nice but we could most definitely tell the difference. Plenty of meals are vegan and you don’t have to pretend they are something they are not. If you are substituting with a common allergen then you should make people aware of what are serving.

Alltheprettyseahorses · 09/11/2021 16:41

It's not tricking someone not to feed them a dead animal! As a guest you are responsible for informing your host of any allergies, it's not like going to a sandwich shop.

Idonthatevegans · 09/11/2021 16:41

@MurielSpriggs

It's not really the same as putting chicken stock in soup which you're claiming is vegan. I don't know anyone who has an ethical objection to eating vegan food. In fact I don't think it would be possible to construct one. It's more like serving up cheap cava as champagne and only owning up after everyone has said how nice it is.
@MurielSpriggs No of course no one has an objection morally to eating vegan food, a lot of meat eaters diets are made up of vegan food without any though, eg 1/2 my plate tonight will be veg, 1/4 rice, 1/4 beef

My point is labeling/ purposely telling someone that they are eating beef when in fact it is not beef is wrong.

Just as it would be wrong for me to claim my soup was vegan friendly even if I knew it wasn't.

OP posts:
Doubledoorsontogarden · 09/11/2021 16:39

It’s wrong, I would t do it. Also I now know where my diarrhoea came from, made quorn bolognese, I can the link now and will avoid it

apalledandshocked · 09/11/2021 16:37

I'm sure there was a case like this in America where someone fed their flatmates vegan food and one of them was hospitalised due to an allergic reaction (I think to the quorn or soy) and it ended with the person who cooked the food being sued and I think a criminal record... Obviously there were specific factors in that case, and it was America - but I still think its a foolish thing to do. Also, there's a difference between cooking for someone and them assuming that its got meat/cream/whatever in and specifically telling someone its not meat. If someone was cooking a beef dish for me it might not occur to me to tell them quorn makes them violently ill because why would it be in there...

HelloTreeWindow · 09/11/2021 16:34

YANBU some people are really allergic to Quorn.

BunsOfAnarchy · 09/11/2021 16:31

I'd be pretty annoyed.
I'd like to be told that it's a substitute. Wouldn't stop me from eating it, I'd always give it a try.
However I'm not down with anyone lying to me or potentially causing me to sit on the loo for 8 hours overnight when their substitute doesn't sit well with me!

Mrsjayy · 09/11/2021 16:31

Well there is that does she say she's eating something different?

ravenmum · 09/11/2021 16:29

I'm a long time veggie, most people I know are aware, so its not something I could pull off, even if I wanted.
Yes - I don't get this. If this woman goes on about being vegan so much, won't people guess that the food she's eating is not actually beef? Or does she actually go to the lengths of cooking something separate for herself?

Swipe left for the next trending thread