Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why ppl make fatphobic comments?

434 replies

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 14:30

While out for coffee with a good (slim) friend who I love dearly, she made a nasty comment about an overweight couple sitting next to us who were enjoying some cake. Something along the lines of "I'm sorry that makes me sick, they are killing themselves". I pointed put to her that the people she was so disgusted by weren't that much larger than me, so why would she say that? She got a bit flustered and then gave various "but you carry it well" "you're tall" "you're not even that fat" I wasn't even particularly hurt just found it interesting that she would think that would be an OK thing to say especially to someone who is fat.

I am 35 and I am fat, (about 3 stone overweight(, I have 2 kids a lovely husband and a happy life. I enjoy running but also enjoy my food would I like to be slimmer? absolutely! but I am pretty happy the way I am. 10 years ago I was very slim but drank to excess smoked and was very unfit and unhealthy and I am 100% happier now than I was then.
But it got me thinking about similar comments over the years, slimmer friends who put on 3lbs complaining to me about how disgustingly fat they looked.

So I suppose my question is.... if you are one of those people who say these things why do you say them? No judgement just interested to hear the other side of the coin

OP posts:
Naunet · 10/11/2021 10:10

@DeadButDelicious

Okey dokey, I've watched the video and had a quick scroll through their channel and it seems that they have a very clear agenda, their channel blurb states that quite clearly actually, they like to 'react and refute arguments made in the fat acceptance community' which is fine, I suppose, everyone needs a hobby. But these videos are clearly being made from a point of view of fat as unhealthy and a result of eating too much (not saying that's wrong btw, that is one factor, my argument would be it is not the only factor or even the main one is some cases) and the clips used will be chosen to illustrate that point and as such are not evidence of obesity being 'glamourised'. As far as the mainstream media goes, the one that we all consume daily, the message is very clear, fat is bad.
Well like I said, I don’t have tiktok anymore so had to find something there, but here’s another that I’ve seen before and explains the issues well
DeadButDelicious · 10/11/2021 10:06

Okey dokey, I've watched the video and had a quick scroll through their channel and it seems that they have a very clear agenda, their channel blurb states that quite clearly actually, they like to 'react and refute arguments made in the fat acceptance community' which is fine, I suppose, everyone needs a hobby. But these videos are clearly being made from a point of view of fat as unhealthy and a result of eating too much (not saying that's wrong btw, that is one factor, my argument would be it is not the only factor or even the main one is some cases) and the clips used will be chosen to illustrate that point and as such are not evidence of obesity being 'glamourised'. As far as the mainstream media goes, the one that we all consume daily, the message is very clear, fat is bad.

Tyrantosaurus · 10/11/2021 10:05

I'll also add- it's because I'm thin I can empathise with bigger people:

I had the opposite experience at school where I tried hard to gain weight by overeating. Hardly anything changed so actually, I understand that it's not as simple as "losing weight".

I hate the trope that thin people (actually thin, not just average) are all bitches when many of us grew up being bullied for being bony and lanky-

Tyrantosaurus · 10/11/2021 10:01

@Crossfitwidow

I assume most slim people think fat people are repulsive. If they don't say it out loud they are probably thinking it.
Nah this is definitely not true

My mum is a size 18, clinically obses and always used to insult other big women. Whether strangers or her friends. They were the same size or smaller than her!

My brother and I, not overweight at all, thought it was bad. He would sometimes tell her not to say things.

It's not about the weight of the criticiser. It's just an inherent need to feel superior regardless of size!

awesomekilick · 10/11/2021 09:58

I wonder if it's a subliminal response to fear about resources. If we are all a desert island then the person who ate more of the limited food than was fair, would be disliked. So unconsciously we react to obese people as tho they are taking more than their fair share.

I'm fat, have been obese, and I judge others. I wish, I didn't but I do.

SueSaid · 10/11/2021 09:54

'Just be kind and don't comment that's my opinion.'

I am kind and don't comment, but I think it as do most people.

Do you think we shouldn't advise smokers to stop or drinkers to drink less incase we offend them or do you actually recognise that whatever excuses people have obesity is still a massive public health problem that we need open honest discussions out, albeit without insults of course. The stigma needs to go, people need to stop taking it personally and like smokers accept they are doing harm to their body and others will judge.

Naunet · 10/11/2021 09:54

[quote Claralaura]**@Naunet* you may not agree that making a negative comment about someone who has an eating disorder or mental illness is not the same as other bigotry but let's just agree not that my friend is an @rsehole* and its not OK to comment on people's bodies.[/quote]
Oh yes, reframe my opinion more to try and make me look unreasonable 😂

Of course prejudice against disabilities is real, I said as much in my first post. But if you’re claiming all fat people are mentally ill, that is a big statement that you need to back up.

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 09:52

@Naunet you may not agree that making a negative comment about someone who has an eating disorder or mental illness is not the same as other bigotry but let's just agree not that my friend is an @rsehole and its not OK to comment on people's bodies.

OP posts:
Claralaura · 10/11/2021 09:48

@JaniieJones that's actually not true. It's what many slim people think but actually there are a number of physical economic and social factors that affect weight gain it's actually not all about "will power". For most people it's not a choice. Firstly diets don't work for most people, 90% of all people who lose significant weight gain it back within 5 months and 80% of those gain back an extra 14lbs. If this cycle continues over a lifetime it leads to insulin resistance and further weight gain. Even if we all ate the same amount and moved the same amount we would all have different bodies. So the focus should be on healing people's relationship with food and they key to that is not commenting on people's body, anyone suffering from an eating disorder will tell you how incredibly damaging it is to hear someone commenting on their body. Well meaning comments can often lead to a relapse and further weight loss/ weight gain. Just be kind and don't comment that's my opinion.

OP posts:
Naunet · 10/11/2021 09:43

[quote Claralaura]@Naunet There are many women who don't find sexist remarks offensive..... but just because one person feels that way doesn't mean that its not bigotry or not offensive.

If you made a negative comment to a person who was disabled, or suffering from any physical or mental illness that is just as nasty as any other bigotry.
My friend didn't know the lives of the people she commented on, they could have had any invisible mental or physical illness but she made a negative comment about their bodies based on her phobia of fat people. It was most certainly fatphobia.[/quote]
Your friend was a rude arsehole, but that doesn’t make “fatphobia” a thing. If I had a full face tattoo and then couldn’t get I employed, would that be tattoophobia?!

DeadButDelicious · 10/11/2021 09:41

[quote Naunet]So it's all over TikTok, but you don't have TikTok because it's a 'dumpster' fire and therefore cannot provide any evidence of your claim. So your 'proof' of obesity being 'glamourised' (on TikTok) means very little really doesn't it?

Oh I’m sorry, I thought I was speaking with an adult who had access to Google and could look these things up themselves if they had any genuine interest. But here, let me play mummy for you:

[/quote] If you say you have evidence, then the onus is on you to provide it. Which you have done now, so thank you, I'll go and watch that. 👍🏻
Viostep · 10/11/2021 09:39

I am overweight due to pcos. It is not due to being lazy or greedy.

Funnily enough, getting pregnant seemed to temporarily reverse the effects of my pcos. I ate the same amount of food as before, with the same activity level, and yet the weight fell off. I couldn't believe it!! Is this what it's like for "normal" people?
I ate my usual 1200-1500 calories a day and actually was able to lose weight instead of just maintain it.

Sadly it didn't last. My baby is 5 months old and I weigh more than I did when I was heavily pregnant. I hate it and will continue to pursue weight loss, and hope I succeed in spite of everything.

Naunet · 10/11/2021 09:39

So it's all over TikTok, but you don't have TikTok because it's a 'dumpster' fire and therefore cannot provide any evidence of your claim. So your 'proof' of obesity being 'glamourised' (on TikTok) means very little really doesn't it?

Oh I’m sorry, I thought I was speaking with an adult who had access to Google and could look these things up themselves if they had any genuine interest. But here, let me play mummy for you:

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 09:37

@Naunet There are many women who don't find sexist remarks offensive..... but just because one person feels that way doesn't mean that its not bigotry or not offensive.

If you made a negative comment to a person who was disabled, or suffering from any physical or mental illness that is just as nasty as any other bigotry.
My friend didn't know the lives of the people she commented on, they could have had any invisible mental or physical illness but she made a negative comment about their bodies based on her phobia of fat people. It was most certainly fatphobia.

OP posts:
SueSaid · 10/11/2021 09:36

'addiction is not a choice. Mental illness is not a choice. Eating disorders are not a choice'

Yes but with respect many aren't addicted, many don't have eating disorders, this is typical enabling behaviour. It is an inconvenient and unpopular truth on mn but many/most just eat far too much because they like it. We could all do that but we don't all want to be fat.

Ozanj · 10/11/2021 09:35

[quote Naunet] It is estimated that 20-26% of the world’s women of childbearing are diagnosed with pcos at some point in their reproductive years. This doesn’t include the women diagnosed after menopause (pcos doesn’t go away after we stop being able to bear children) or those who aren’t formallyndiagnosed so a lot of experts think, globally 40-50%+ of women might have had it at some point in their lives

health.clevelandclinic.org/can-polycystic-ovary-syndrome-make-gain-weight/[/quote]
That’s the US number obtained from cdc, not global. Pcos rates are the highest in Asia and are climbing.

SueSaid · 10/11/2021 09:32

'Making negative comments about people's bodies'

If you see someone drunk and making an arse of themselves don't you think Jesus someone tell them to drink less, without considering they may have mh problems and this is how they cope? Or see a smoker puffing away in the pouring rain making themselves stink and think urgh what a disgusting habit? It is ok to have negative opinions on people's very unpleasant and unhealthy lifestyles. Yes we don't say it to their faces but to think it and comment to a friend quietly is ok.

DeadButDelicious · 10/11/2021 09:32

@Naunet

Can you provide links? Simply stating it's on tiktok isn't providing evidence that obesity is being glamourised

That said it all depends on what your definition of 'glamourised' is, are they saying 'Be fat! It's great! It's so healthy, trendy and sexy' or are they saying 'I'm fat and I love my body/happy in the skin I'm in' or are they simply not hiding their fat bodies? Showing off outfits they feel nice in?

No because I don’t have tiktok, it’s a dumpster fire, but I’m sure you can find some videos on there if you look. I’m sure there is content about showing off outfits and feeling good - why would I ever have a problem with that? The ones I have a problem with are those that claim being fat is healthy,, spreading misinformation about how being obese doesn’t endanger anyone’s health, or slagging off celebrities who have lost weight like they’re traitors etc.

So it's all over TikTok, but you don't have TikTok because it's a 'dumpster' fire and therefore cannot provide any evidence of your claim. So your 'proof' of obesity being 'glamourised' (on TikTok) means very little really doesn't it?

I'm sure if I look I could find videos about a lot of things, including people getting upset about celebrities losing weight. My lived experience and the experience of other fat people and the very clear message sent out by society as a whole however is that being fat is not the ideal. The voices shouting about how awful being fat is are much louder than the ones saying the opposite.

Lavender24 · 10/11/2021 09:31

I'm not sure sure, I think what a PP said is perhaps true and is stems from people's own insecurities. I also think it has something to do with overweight people being seen an weak and lacking self control. Or taking up more resources then they need? I'm not saying this is my view btw and I think what she said was harsh.

I know slim people aren't looked down on in the same way but people can be just as quick to make rude comments about weight. I am very short and have a petite frame with small boobs and I've actually found in my workplace that the overweight people are very quick to make rude "jokes" about my body ie saying I am flat chested and look prepubescent. But I know if I made a "joke" about their bodies it would not go down well.

Naunet · 10/11/2021 09:30

[quote Claralaura]@Naunet no need to get defensive I'm simply replying to your comments that being fat is a "choice" and fatphobia is not the same as other bigotry because being fat is a "choice"[/quote]
It’s not the same and it’s seriously offensive that you keep suggesting it is.

I used to be fat. I was fat because I ate too much, that’s a fact. I would NEVER have dared suggest that any negativity I received was in any way similar to racism, homophobia, sexism etc. It’s disgusting to suggest it is.

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 09:29

@JaniieJones addiction is not a choice. Mental illness is not a choice. Eating disorders are not a choice. Making comments at any group of people who are vulnerable is really nasty whether it's those suffering from eating disorders, physical illness, addiction or mental health issues. To make a negative comment about anyone like that is just the same as any other bigotry.

OP posts:
Claralaura · 10/11/2021 09:26

@Naunet no need to get defensive I'm simply replying to your comments that being fat is a "choice" and fatphobia is not the same as other bigotry because being fat is a "choice"

OP posts:
SueSaid · 10/11/2021 09:26

'Making negative comments about people's bodies whether it's their skin colour, disability, height or size is akin to any other bigotry.'

No it isn't and again it is incredibly offensive to group obesity criticism in with racism and disability slurs. No one can change their ethnicity or their disability.

Obesity is like smoking and heavy drinking, people will judge. You keep saying you're fine with your weight but your defensive attitude would suggest you are anything but. Stop excusing and enabling.

Naunet · 10/11/2021 09:23

[quote Claralaura]@Naunet as I said making negative comments about people's bodies whether it's their skin colour, disability, height, thinness or fatness is akin to any other bigotry in my opinion.
You might think that fat people get up every day and choose to remain fat but often that is completely untrue. Making a negative comment about someone who may is likely suffering from a physical or mental illness is most definitely fatphobia. The kindest thing to do is not comment on people's bodies at all.[/quote]
Yeah sure, paint me as an evil person who hates and shames fat people, despite me clarifying my position many times already 🙄

Naunet · 10/11/2021 09:23

It is estimated that 20-26% of the world’s women of childbearing are diagnosed with pcos at some point in their reproductive years. This doesn’t include the women diagnosed after menopause (pcos doesn’t go away after we stop being able to bear children) or those who aren’t formallyndiagnosed so a lot of experts think, globally 40-50%+ of women might have had it at some point in their lives

health.clevelandclinic.org/can-polycystic-ovary-syndrome-make-gain-weight/