Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why ppl make fatphobic comments?

434 replies

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 14:30

While out for coffee with a good (slim) friend who I love dearly, she made a nasty comment about an overweight couple sitting next to us who were enjoying some cake. Something along the lines of "I'm sorry that makes me sick, they are killing themselves". I pointed put to her that the people she was so disgusted by weren't that much larger than me, so why would she say that? She got a bit flustered and then gave various "but you carry it well" "you're tall" "you're not even that fat" I wasn't even particularly hurt just found it interesting that she would think that would be an OK thing to say especially to someone who is fat.

I am 35 and I am fat, (about 3 stone overweight(, I have 2 kids a lovely husband and a happy life. I enjoy running but also enjoy my food would I like to be slimmer? absolutely! but I am pretty happy the way I am. 10 years ago I was very slim but drank to excess smoked and was very unfit and unhealthy and I am 100% happier now than I was then.
But it got me thinking about similar comments over the years, slimmer friends who put on 3lbs complaining to me about how disgustingly fat they looked.

So I suppose my question is.... if you are one of those people who say these things why do you say them? No judgement just interested to hear the other side of the coin

OP posts:
Maverickess · 10/11/2021 15:11

That's a cop out. A pick up and eat chicken salad, throw on some scrambled eggs, a tuna wrap, a chicken fillet and baked potato.

You are talking MINUTES for any of those.

Yep, my life experiences are a cop out. I can't afford to be eating chicken breasts love 🤣 and I'm sure you'd be real happy if I neglected your family members care and they came to harm so I can rustle that delight up at work 🙄

SueSaid · 10/11/2021 15:10

'people don't actually want to help, or save the NHS or 'educate' they want to judge and they want to be able to justify that judgement by feeling the person judged deserves it.'

I have an opinion on an overeater in the same way as I have an opnion on a heavy drinker. Pity and puzzlement that they always have reasons why its not their fault.

I don't make unkind comments irl, but on a chat forum where we repeatedly hear 'we can't help it', it needs saying that yes, yes you can.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 15:08

I'm cash poor too, that pastry likely costs a £1 and I don't have to cook it, which adds cost.

I do hear what you're saying and I know these things myself, and do do them, however fully awake and rational me makes very different choices to sleep deprived , aching, nauseous and hangry me! I'll have a bowl of porridge before my first shift for example, and a banana - my last it's what I can grab because I just don't have the energy left and probably haven't got much or any of the decency stuff left.
As does rushed off my feet trying to balance other people's needs me, where I don't come last, I don't factor at all, so a handful of biscuits or a sweet strong coffee is more beneficial to me being present and delivering than a salad or similar (and that's not being woe is me that's just the facts of what's expected of me)

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 15:06

@JaniieJones I can't speak for all fat people but I can speak for me. I put on a lot of weight when I had Binge Eating Disorder. I have not binged in 2 years but also have not dieted (on the advice of my ED therapist) I am still 3 stone overweight but have stayed the same weight for the last 2 years. I "could" lose weight but it would inevitably result in a spiral back into ED so for me being overweight, while not ideal, is the lesser of 2 evils. This is my lived experience, you might see me in a coffee shop and think " fat mess she should eat less" but you don't know me or my life so why judge at all?

OP posts:
LettertoHermoine · 10/11/2021 15:06

@Maverickess

Why would you be more tired if you were living a healthy lifestyle.

Because shopping, preparing and cooking from scratch takes time out of the already broken and restricted day time sleep I get. A pick up and eat food takes a lot less time than a meal I need to prepare and cook, and that time accumulates. I lose around 10 hours of sleep a week, every week because of trying to sleep during the day. Every half an hour is precious.
I prioritise that because I have to in order to keep a roof over my head and to be able to function at work. You do get stuck in the sugar/carb highs and lows that happen, I eat much healthier and feel better when I'm holiday from work and in a normal pattern, but the fact is I'm already not leading a healthy lifestyle before you factor in food. So yes, it's convenience but I guess my point is that I am making the choice of convenience because it's the lesser of two evils, not because I'm lazy or greedy.

That's a cop out. A pick up and eat chicken salad, throw on some scrambled eggs, a tuna wrap, a chicken fillet and baked potato.

You are talking MINUTES for any of those.

hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 14:58

@Maverickess

Why would you be more tired if you were living a healthy lifestyle.

Because shopping, preparing and cooking from scratch takes time out of the already broken and restricted day time sleep I get. A pick up and eat food takes a lot less time than a meal I need to prepare and cook, and that time accumulates. I lose around 10 hours of sleep a week, every week because of trying to sleep during the day. Every half an hour is precious.
I prioritise that because I have to in order to keep a roof over my head and to be able to function at work. You do get stuck in the sugar/carb highs and lows that happen, I eat much healthier and feel better when I'm holiday from work and in a normal pattern, but the fact is I'm already not leading a healthy lifestyle before you factor in food. So yes, it's convenience but I guess my point is that I am making the choice of convenience because it's the lesser of two evils, not because I'm lazy or greedy.

I do hear you.

I guess I'm always a bit flummoxed as how successful marketeers have been in convincing people that their food is 'convenient'.

For example, it takes me 4.5 minutes to cook a steak. Full of iron, Vit B12

It has just this minute taken me 4 minutes to fry some whitebait (£2.70 frozen from Morrisons)

It would take me maybe 7 minutes to cook an omelette

All those meals are packed full of nutrients and are so quick and 2/3 are very very cheap. Also if you eat good nutritious food, you have more energy and also do not get cravings / hanger.

I just feel like you are a marketeers dream, thinking you aren't able to cook well when you are time poor.

CounsellorTroi · 10/11/2021 14:49

[quote hamstersarse]@CounsellorTroi

This has a summary of the research on processed oils www.jeffnobbs.com/posts/death-by-vegetable-oil-what-the-studies-say

We should not be eating them in the quantities we are - but if you try to remove them from your diet, it is literally almost impossible.[/quote]
Interesting, thank you.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 14:43

@JaniieJones

'People will take responsibility for whatever they want it's not for you to demand'

Yes but it's a chat forum and you've brought it up to discuss, no?

Reread your posts, full of denials and excuses. Why do overweight people find it hard to say yeah I eat too much and I really shouldn't it's my fault.

And why do other people feel the need to label fat people's real life, lived experiences as 'excuses'? And dismiss them?

Because we've already been pre judged, and found wanting, that's why and people don't actually want to help, or save the NHS or 'educate' they want to judge and they want to be able to justify that judgement by feeling the person judged deserves it.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 14:37

And 'healthier' convenience foods are often not healthier at all, and far more expensive.

SueSaid · 10/11/2021 14:37

'People will take responsibility for whatever they want it's not for you to demand'

Yes but it's a chat forum and you've brought it up to discuss, no?

Reread your posts, full of denials and excuses. Why do overweight people find it hard to say yeah I eat too much and I really shouldn't it's my fault.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 14:36

Why would you be more tired if you were living a healthy lifestyle.

Because shopping, preparing and cooking from scratch takes time out of the already broken and restricted day time sleep I get. A pick up and eat food takes a lot less time than a meal I need to prepare and cook, and that time accumulates. I lose around 10 hours of sleep a week, every week because of trying to sleep during the day. Every half an hour is precious.
I prioritise that because I have to in order to keep a roof over my head and to be able to function at work. You do get stuck in the sugar/carb highs and lows that happen, I eat much healthier and feel better when I'm holiday from work and in a normal pattern, but the fact is I'm already not leading a healthy lifestyle before you factor in food. So yes, it's convenience but I guess my point is that I am making the choice of convenience because it's the lesser of two evils, not because I'm lazy or greedy.

hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 14:23

Satisfying my hunger and getting enough sleep to function are my primary concerns because no one's going to give a shit if I make a mistake because I'm tired due to trying to live a healthier lifestyle now are they? It's all about the productivity.

Why would you be more tired if you were living a healthy lifestyle.

I think the point, although to be fair it wasn't kindly delivered, is that a Greggs won't give you the nutrition you need to be healthy and have lots of energy. It is essentially nutritionally defunct. A calorie is not a calorie when it comes to long-term health and wellbeing.

Marylou2 · 10/11/2021 14:22

Fat phobia is endemic in our society. I've been 60lbs overweight for about 20 years. I dieted and exercised during lockdown while WFH and lost the weight. Wasn't prepared for the reaction of friends and colleagues I hadn't seen. Ranged from extreme jealousy to adulation as though I'd won the Nobel peace prize. Horrified to think what they must have been thinking all these years. The worst/best thing was being put on a management programme at work. I wondered why I was always overlooked as my performance was clearly better than colleagues who were recommended for the course. Well now I know. It's because I was fat. To be fair I might regain the weight but it's given me a big peek behind the curtain of fat discrimination.

EnigmaCat · 10/11/2021 14:12

YANBU I wouldn't mention someone elses weight in earshot unless they mentioned it first, very rude and somewhat cruel.
However, if I see someone who is severely under or overweight, it surprises me how they are still alive.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 14:10

@FreeBritnee

I also judged this morning when I saw a fat person in the car outside Greggs wolfing down some huge pastry with a hot drink whilst sat in their car. For me it’s because I’ve been there and I know how deeply unhappy I was at the time. I was sitting drinking a chamomile tea and occasionally ours eyes would meet. Perhaps they knew I was judging. I don’t know. It doesn’t seem like the right food to eat early in the morning but what do I know.
Exactly, what do you know? That person could well have been me after a 12 hour nightshift where I've had no chance to eat anything because it's too busy and I have half an hour to kill before my bus home, my back is in bits, I feel sick and I have that level of tiredness that only comes with forcing your body to not just be awake but active by any person's standards during the night. I can clock up 20,000 steps between midnight and 8am - but clearly the exercise itself isn't enough because I'm still overweight. Satisfying my hunger and getting enough sleep to function are my primary concerns because no one's going to give a shit if I make a mistake because I'm tired due to trying to live a healthier lifestyle now are they? It's all about the productivity. It kind of proves the point though that I'm judged for being lazy, because of the excess layer of fat around my body, on sight, when actually I work 40-50 hours a week in an active job that is essential to society. One recurring theme when getting help for my weight has always been to stop working permanent nights because of the increased risk of things like cancer, obesity, heart disease and stroke - but if we all do that who's going to do the roles that are essential to the country that need to be done at night? Someone has to, and therefore someone has to accept the increased health impacts that it has.
hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 14:07

@HereticFanjo

It's internalised hatred. People who hate fat people often have an inner 'greedy pig' that's desperate to get out. They spend their lives suppressing it and resent people who don't because some part of them recognises that greed / hunger and is terrified of giving in to it. The mental energy it takes must be enormous.
The way this is written sounds quite resentful in itself however I think there is something about this.

It is well known that 'obese behaviours' are quite contagious and we don't necessarily want to be around people who might 'take us off track', even if we do this sub consciously.

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 14:06

@JaniieJones People will take responsibility for whatever they want it's not for you to demand. If someone says they have an eating disorder, or medical condition who am I to disagree or doubt them. I wouldn't doubt someone who told me they had depression or MS or any other illness.
I would want to be seriously narcissistic to think I know their body / health better than them.

OP posts:
SueSaid · 10/11/2021 14:00

'Very very few people are fat by "choice'

'This rhetoric is what’s so bloody harmful. Yes they are, they absolutely 100% are. Is it a choice that’s been influenced by other factors? Sure, it can be, just like being an alcoholic or drug addict can be. But we don’t tell addicts that it’s out of their control, that they don’t have a choice. We instead encourage them to take responsibility.'

This! I have every sympathy for someone fat and miserable but the denial and blame shifting on this thread is staggering. Take some responsibility, admit that you are an overeater for whatever 'reason' and instead of saying 'yeah but no but medical and genetic reasons' etc say 'I eat too much, I am obese and I want to change'. Only then will you actually come up with a plan and then maybe stick to it.

RealBecca · 10/11/2021 13:49

@Claralaura completely agree, there is no need for comments of judgement, there is a huge difference between saying im trying to lose a few pounds so that i can fit into something i want to wear" compared to "im a massive piggy" which implies anyone larger is/should think they are also piggy. No need to hurt feelings x

EinsteinaGogo · 10/11/2021 13:37

@Ryannah

Greed is unpleasant. When people comment negatively on fatness they’re really commenting on greed and lack of self control.

How do you know the couple in question we're greedy?

Ozanj · 10/11/2021 13:33

@Gilead

Don’t Overeat a tad simplistic *@Ozanj*, I’m overweight. I have been on steroids for a significant period of time. They cause weight gain and redistribute fat so you end up with what’s known as moon face. But you judge me on my weight, I’ll judge you on attitude.
A star next to a sentence means you are correcting a line or part of a line in the previous post. Read that post to get what I’m saying.
trancepants · 10/11/2021 13:33

@Naunet But we don’t tell addicts that it’s out of their control, that they don’t have a choice. We instead encourage them to take responsibility.

We actually literally do. The basis of a lot of the most popular addiction treatments is that the addict is in fact helpless in the face of their addiction. And then strangely enough, recovery rates for addicts are extremely low. Addiction "treatments" were pretty much the first to encourage lack of accountability in terms of what you do to yourself.

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 13:31

@RealBecca good point but there is a difference in saying "I want to lose weight so I'm starting a diet" rather than saying "I'm disgustingly fat, I can't believe I let myself get so gross so I'm going on a diet" when the person you are saying it to is bigger than you that's a bit nasty I think. But you know your friend better than me and I'm sure you wouldn't say anything that you know would hurt them.

OP posts:
RealBecca · 10/11/2021 13:24

I never comment on others.

But i do say to overweight friends when i want to lose weight. We both have the capability to lose weight if we want to so why should i moderate talking about something that affects me. Which might sound mean on the face of it but actually if i wanted to smoke less why couldnt i say that to someone who smokes? Why should i assume someone overweight is sensitive about it and wants to lose weight when plenty of people are happy as they are?

HereticFanjo · 10/11/2021 13:24

It's internalised hatred. People who hate fat people often have an inner 'greedy pig' that's desperate to get out. They spend their lives suppressing it and resent people who don't because some part of them recognises that greed / hunger and is terrified of giving in to it. The mental energy it takes must be enormous.