Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why ppl make fatphobic comments?

434 replies

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 14:30

While out for coffee with a good (slim) friend who I love dearly, she made a nasty comment about an overweight couple sitting next to us who were enjoying some cake. Something along the lines of "I'm sorry that makes me sick, they are killing themselves". I pointed put to her that the people she was so disgusted by weren't that much larger than me, so why would she say that? She got a bit flustered and then gave various "but you carry it well" "you're tall" "you're not even that fat" I wasn't even particularly hurt just found it interesting that she would think that would be an OK thing to say especially to someone who is fat.

I am 35 and I am fat, (about 3 stone overweight(, I have 2 kids a lovely husband and a happy life. I enjoy running but also enjoy my food would I like to be slimmer? absolutely! but I am pretty happy the way I am. 10 years ago I was very slim but drank to excess smoked and was very unfit and unhealthy and I am 100% happier now than I was then.
But it got me thinking about similar comments over the years, slimmer friends who put on 3lbs complaining to me about how disgustingly fat they looked.

So I suppose my question is.... if you are one of those people who say these things why do you say them? No judgement just interested to hear the other side of the coin

OP posts:
Findingthelight1 · 10/11/2021 17:39

im obese, only ever been in hospital to have my children

So... the health risks of obesity aren't real because they haven't hit you personally (yet?)
My sister would have said the same as you. She had no health conditions at all due to her weight- until she suddenly died. At which point the postmortem report unfortunately was all too clear on what damage had - invisibly - been done to her body.

LettertoHermoine · 10/11/2021 17:36

@Maverickess I am sorry if I upset you, I really didn't mean to come across like that. I just wanted to get the point across that healthy food is possible timewise and moneywise. That's all.

Mindset is a different matter entirely and reading your post above I see where you are coming from. I apologise for my choice of words because they were out of order.

hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 17:36

Night work really is horrific for your metabolism and health.

Even the sleep you get will not be regulating your hormones properly as it is totally against the circadian rhythm that is built into all of us.

I do sympathise, really I do. You have said in pp that you don't want to give up night work, which is admirable but I do think you can't do this forever, it will literally kill you. And if you don't pay extra attention to things like nutrition, you will continue to feel like shite.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 17:29

@hamstersarse and @LettertoHermoine

I never really struggled with my weight until 10 years ago when I started permanent nights, which was a choice between no job and permanent nights due to childcare.
I have never really been a 'foodie' and always active, I don't drive and I rode 4/5 times a week (a friend's horse that I look after in return for riding until he retired before anyone picks me up on that!) I would put weight on, but easily dropped it again by doing a bit more/eating a bit less. I ate because I was hungry mainly, I do love my food but it wasn't a priority then and it didn't cause me an issue. I had to stay a good weight in order to ride and if I went through a period when I started putting on, it was easy enough to get it back off. I've never been slim, but I am tall and back then at least, muscular and fit. I wouldn't have stayed on the horse if I wasn't!
I gained a lot of weight through pregnancy because I couldn't do a lot of the activity I was used to, but again managed to shift it when I could go back to it.
The difference was I worked days, and therefore although busy wasn't constantly fighting my instinct to sleep or turning my body clock one way and then the other week in, week out - which is exhausting and takes it's toll on your physical health in more ways than just what you eat.

The change came as I got further into my years of nights and sleeping became more of a priority than it ever had been before, I feel jet lagged permanently.

What I've tried to explain is that this 'lifestyle' is what's led to me eating the way I do, and that lifestyle is through necessity of earning a living and being able to sustain that. I've not said it's all someone else's fault, I've not said it's not because of the choices I make, I've explained why I make the choices I do and been told they're 'just excuses', bullshit and a cop out.

People claim to want fat people to own it, well I am by explaining the reasons I make my choices, yet I'm still being dismissed, belittled and mocked. Do you really want fat people to own it, explain? Or do you just want to judge, feel justified in that judgement and make your own excuses to justify that judgement and attitude so you don't feel like you're being horrible for the sake of it, and therefore a much better person than a fatty could ever be?

DerbyshireMama · 10/11/2021 17:29

For the vast vast vast majority of people, being fat is a choice. I think it's ridiculous how we're expected to tiptoe around it with euphemisms such as "plus sized", "larger people" and the daftest of all, "curvy".

People like to make all sorts of excuses for being fat but until relatively recently it was unusual to see a fat person. Why are there so many now? Because it's become socially acceptable.

Letting yourself become fat shows a complete lack of respect or appreciation for your body. Usually it's a result of laziness, ignorance, greed or unhappiness. None of which are enviable qualities.

Also, let's not pretend "fatphobia" is a one way street. How often do you hear things like "real women have curves", "body like a teenage boy" or "only dogs like bones"?

LettertoHermoine · 10/11/2021 17:01

@Maverickess

No, I am trying to make the point that is it just as easy to have something healthy instead of making excuses that you can't.

I would never judge someone on how they look or comment on their size, I will however comment when someone makes excuses that don't stand up. Why eat something cheap that makes you feel like shit and puts weight on you when you can eat something cheap that makes you feel good and doesn't put weight on you.

Had you said you prefer to eat the crap food I would not have commented but using the excuse of time or money is bullshit. Sorry.

To quote yourself back at you, BULLSHIT and a cop out.

You're making excuses to justify your judgement of someone because they carry extra weight. I didn't say I prefer to eat the crap good, I said I do it through convenience because of the other aspects of my life and that balancing them out, nutrition is not a high priority compared to having to keep up the pace at work (and therefore my job) and getting enough sleep to enable me to do that.
I've explained my priorities and why, and what other things influence them. And also that nutrition isn't the only factor in my general health.
If you don't agree, you don't agree but don't try and make excuses for your shitty, derogatory attitude by telling me about my self and my life.

I didn't say you said you prefer to eat the crap food, read my post again. I said HAD you said you prefer to eat crap food I wouldn't have commented.

My point was and still is that it is as easy to eat healthy food as it is to eat crap food if you are using time and money as a factor. You have the choice of what to eat and you choose to eat what you eat and that is totally your choice but don't make out that it is because of money or time because that is not the case. You came on and gave a lot of reasons of why you eat Greggs with the shift you are doing and myself and others have simply argued that there are other choices that you could make should you choose to. It's simple.

hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 16:57

@Maverickess

The problem with separating out all these aspects of health and wellbeing into very separate streams is that they are actually all very connected.

For example, sleep. That is clearly for multiple reasons a priority for you and rightly so. But you will get better sleep if you eat nutritious food. You will sleep better if you get a bit of exercise.

I personally think there are 4 things to think about when you want to maximise your everyday energy - food/nutrition, sleep, exercise/movement and stress management.

And the problem is, you can't drop one and expect the others to compensate. It's more about little moves in each one to create a general upward trajectory.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 16:48

No, I am trying to make the point that is it just as easy to have something healthy instead of making excuses that you can't.

I would never judge someone on how they look or comment on their size, I will however comment when someone makes excuses that don't stand up. Why eat something cheap that makes you feel like shit and puts weight on you when you can eat something cheap that makes you feel good and doesn't put weight on you.

Had you said you prefer to eat the crap food I would not have commented but using the excuse of time or money is bullshit. Sorry.

To quote yourself back at you, BULLSHIT and a cop out.

You're making excuses to justify your judgement of someone because they carry extra weight. I didn't say I prefer to eat the crap good, I said I do it through convenience because of the other aspects of my life and that balancing them out, nutrition is not a high priority compared to having to keep up the pace at work (and therefore my job) and getting enough sleep to enable me to do that.
I've explained my priorities and why, and what other things influence them. And also that nutrition isn't the only factor in my general health.
If you don't agree, you don't agree but don't try and make excuses for your shitty, derogatory attitude by telling me about my self and my life.

PasstheBucket89 · 10/11/2021 16:21

@Sudokuzebra absolutely, very important points im obese, only ever been in hospital to have my children.

any of those examples are costing the nhs far more than me.

SueSaid · 10/11/2021 16:02

'It's one of the last acceptable prejudices'

Oh no no no, I beg to differ. All unhealthy lifestyles are frowned upon nowadays. You must've be so defensive like the op. I see you too have reasons for your weight. How about changing the record and having a list of how you plan to tackle it rather than a list of why you can't?

P.s hcps will keep bringing it up in the say way they encourage smokers fo stop. It's their job.

Graphista · 10/11/2021 15:57

It's one of the last acceptable prejudices - alongside mental illness unfortunately

I would be far from impressed with your friends attitude actually and in your shoes I'd be dropping the friendship. Not just because it was a fat-ist comment but because she thinks she has the right to judge others based on a snapshot of their lives and thought you would be sympathetic to her view - I'd find the latter the most offensive part actually

Being overweight is a complex issue. I'm overweight myself these days (trying hard to not be, I've lost weight recently but have hit a plateau) but I've also been extremely slim and had nasty comments directed my way inc school bullying because of that, I've been accused of being anorexic by hcps etc which couldn't have been further from the truth!

I now get crap from hcps about being overweight even when the thing I am discussing with them has NOTHING to do with that!

I know people who are overweight who are otherwise physically very healthy (inc myself to a degree) and I know very slim people who have appalling physical health and partake in very unhealthy habits (mainly smoking) extremely hypocritical of those people to judge fat people

I think it’s about othering, a lack of empathy and an inability to accept that it’s ok for people to be different.

I agree

I've also noticed the kinda people most likely to make such comments are also the types I would not have been surprised in past eras if they had made racist or homophobic comments - it's the kind of person THEY are rather than the kind of person they're denigrating is

@Ryannah still not appropriate to comment or indeed even think. It's nobody else's business - few people are perfect enough they can criticise others without there being a hint of hypocrisy

@WillyWollyWandy have you ever been overweight yourself? An awful lot of assumptions in your post I find it very telling you claim to have no fat friends

I think it has roots in misogyny as it is most often directed at women

I'd agree with that too

Possibly ageist too.

Yep! Especially coming from youngsters who haven't yet had a pregnancy or ageing hormones to deal with

It is unfortunate that their struggle is so outwardly visible compared to say, someone who smokes, someone who drinks, someone who can't hold down a job for whatever reason, someone who has a gambling problem, a damaging shopping habit, a caffeine addiction, can't get up on time, has a messy house. Or literally ANYTHING that people struggle with but don't seem to get judged in the same way as being disgusting and lazy.

Well said

Tbf the smokers pay for their nhs treatment and more with all the tax they pay on their fags.

That's a myth actually. They pay part of it but it isn't enough to totally cover it. Also doesn't cover the costs of harm inflicted on passive smokers. I'm a lifelong asthmatic and when I lived at home with 2 smoking parents it was most definitely much worse and I needed a lot more treatment for the asthma, chest infections etc.

People looking at me can see I am overweight

What they cannot see is that:

I am on 3 medications that are life saving but which also contribute to that

That I have an invisible physical disability that affects my mobility and ability to exercise formally

That I have a severe mental illness which needs to be carefully managed with regards to food and eating as it can tip over into an Ed

That I may have an under active thyroid as I suspect but which I have been unable to get a test for as yet because apparently "crazy patients" are never physically I'll Hmm

I've got as far as 4pm yesterday I'll add more later

ohtwatbollocks · 10/11/2021 15:57

@WillyWollyWandy

Ok you asked.. I would never dream of commenting about someone’s weight. But I do inwardly judge people who are fat because for the fast majority of people, notwithstanding those with thyroid issues and other health conditions, there is no need to be fat. If you eat healthily and exercise, even only having a walk a day, you will not be fat. So if a person is fat, I assume they’re lazy and eat junk food to excess. They may argue that they don’t, citing gym sessions etc. However if they accounted for every calorie that goes in, and that includes finishing the kids’ dinner, the hugely calorific takeaways and wine, it would easily outweigh the output. It isn’t rocket science. But as I said, I’d never actually say this to a fat person, albeit I don’t really know any fat people. I do know anecdotally that people struggle with their weight. But some willpower and discipline should fix the issue. I also presume however, that for some larger people, there are mental issues at play which leads to comfort eating etc. No idea what the answer is. Counselling?
You're right some willpower would fix it. But that's not as simple as that. I SHOULD move more and eat less. I'm not going to pretend I'm fat because of health conditions, I'm fat because I have appalling self control and I eat to excess because when I have severe depression I'm trying to fill a void in me. I also eat to 'punish' myself so to speak. Do I want to live like this? No. Is it as easy as 'shall I just eat less?' Also no. I don't smoke, I don't drink at all, but I have a self destructive behaviour that I am struggling to control that I would love to do something about but I'm struggling.
LettertoHermoine · 10/11/2021 15:51

[quote Claralaura]@Maverickess yes to everything!!! Sure a boiled chicken salad might be healthy but hardly what you'd crave at 4am after working physically all night and not getting much sleep during the day with kids etc you are naturally going to choose the quick tasty option. Anyone that gets that worked up about what other people eat cannot possibly be happy in themselves.[/quote]
I don't care what other people eat, knock yourself out and eat 50 Greggs a day, that is your decision and your prerogative BUT do not try to make out you don't have the time or the money to have something healthy and blame your weight on that.

DaisyDreaming · 10/11/2021 15:47

The only people I know who feel sick at others bodies or seeing people eat things like cake are those with major body issues and eating disorders themselves

LettertoHermoine · 10/11/2021 15:45

@Maverickess

Absolute BULLSHIT. 2 chicken fillets are £1.90 in Tesco. You buy a pastry with no nutritional value that makes you feel like shit for £1.

Hmm, if only everywhere had a Tesco. And seriously, why so much venom? Feeling the need because I've admitted I'm fat and I need putting in my place?

Boil a 95p chicken breast the night before work, throw it in with a salad or some wholewheat pasta and there is a dinner for very cheap but nutritious. Buy a tin of tuna for 79p and put it on a wrap. Take 2 mins.

I don't need your recipes thanks.

Like I said..a complete cop out.

Believe what you like if it means you can justify your shitty attitude towards other people because of the way they look and nothing else.

No, I am trying to make the point that is it just as easy to have something healthy instead of making excuses that you can't.

I would never judge someone on how they look or comment on their size, I will however comment when someone makes excuses that don't stand up. Why eat something cheap that makes you feel like shit and puts weight on you when you can eat something cheap that makes you feel good and doesn't put weight on you.

Had you said you prefer to eat the crap food I would not have commented but using the excuse of time or money is bullshit. Sorry.

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 15:45

@Maverickess yes to everything!!! Sure a boiled chicken salad might be healthy but hardly what you'd crave at 4am after working physically all night and not getting much sleep during the day with kids etc you are naturally going to choose the quick tasty option. Anyone that gets that worked up about what other people eat cannot possibly be happy in themselves.

OP posts:
hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 15:43

@Maverickess

You’re right

It’s a vicious circle, the worse your nutrition, the less energy you have, the less energy you have, the more junk food you consume. And on it goes

I do think night shift is catastrophic for your health though so you really are fighting a battle there

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 15:41

[quote hamstersarse]@Maverickess

This is going to sound harsher than it’s meant to but you keep using the word lazy…..am I allowed to say that it does sound lazy that you would rather eat a greggs than whip up an omelette?

I think what you are actually saying is you don’t prioritise nutrition[/quote]
You can say what you like, it might sound lazy I agree but it's a decision taken with many other factors to consider not just nutrition.
No, I don't prioritise nutrition, but not because I don't want to or because I can't be bothered, but because other things suffer when I do and ultimately they're more important to me. You don't have to agree with that, but then you don't have to live with the concequences either do you?

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 15:37

Absolute BULLSHIT. 2 chicken fillets are £1.90 in Tesco. You buy a pastry with no nutritional value that makes you feel like shit for £1.

Hmm, if only everywhere had a Tesco. And seriously, why so much venom? Feeling the need because I've admitted I'm fat and I need putting in my place?

Boil a 95p chicken breast the night before work, throw it in with a salad or some wholewheat pasta and there is a dinner for very cheap but nutritious. Buy a tin of tuna for 79p and put it on a wrap. Take 2 mins.

I don't need your recipes thanks.

Like I said..a complete cop out.

Believe what you like if it means you can justify your shitty attitude towards other people because of the way they look and nothing else.

hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 15:37

@Maverickess

This is going to sound harsher than it’s meant to but you keep using the word lazy…..am I allowed to say that it does sound lazy that you would rather eat a greggs than whip up an omelette?

I think what you are actually saying is you don’t prioritise nutrition

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 15:33

It's the topic of the thread, different opinions get aired.

The topic of the thread is why people feel the need to make fatphobic comments. And as usual it's turned into fat people having to justify their existence because others don't like looking at them. Because in reality how does me being a couple of stone overweight affect anyone else? Any more than anyone elses life choices or demands affect anyone else?
Fat people are an acceptable target and people tie themselves in knots to justify that targeting when really it's no more than self gratification.

LettertoHermoine · 10/11/2021 15:33

@Maverickess

That's a cop out. A pick up and eat chicken salad, throw on some scrambled eggs, a tuna wrap, a chicken fillet and baked potato.

You are talking MINUTES for any of those.

Yep, my life experiences are a cop out. I can't afford to be eating chicken breasts love 🤣 and I'm sure you'd be real happy if I neglected your family members care and they came to harm so I can rustle that delight up at work 🙄

Absolute BULLSHIT. 2 chicken fillets are £1.90 in Tesco. You buy a pastry with no nutritional value that makes you feel like shit for £1.

Boil a 95p chicken breast the night before work, throw it in with a salad or some wholewheat pasta and there is a dinner for very cheap but nutritious. Buy a tin of tuna for 79p and put it on a wrap. Take 2 mins.

Like I said..a complete cop out.

SueSaid · 10/11/2021 15:25

@PleasantBirthday

it needs saying that yes, yes you can

Why does it though? And why is this your responsibility?

It's the topic of the thread, different opinions get aired.
Maverickess · 10/11/2021 15:16

@JaniieJones

'people don't actually want to help, or save the NHS or 'educate' they want to judge and they want to be able to justify that judgement by feeling the person judged deserves it.'

I have an opinion on an overeater in the same way as I have an opnion on a heavy drinker. Pity and puzzlement that they always have reasons why its not their fault.

I don't make unkind comments irl, but on a chat forum where we repeatedly hear 'we can't help it', it needs saying that yes, yes you can.

Thing is I'm not saying I can't help it, I'm explaining the reasons behind it and that they're not simply q case that I'm greedy and lazy which is being said, in response I'm being told I'm making excuses, it's a cop out, and met with pity and puzzlement. Which kind of proves the point it's about the person who comments feelings about their judgement and justification of that far more than the fact I'm a bit fat.
PleasantBirthday · 10/11/2021 15:13

it needs saying that yes, yes you can

Why does it though? And why is this your responsibility?