Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why ppl make fatphobic comments?

434 replies

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 14:30

While out for coffee with a good (slim) friend who I love dearly, she made a nasty comment about an overweight couple sitting next to us who were enjoying some cake. Something along the lines of "I'm sorry that makes me sick, they are killing themselves". I pointed put to her that the people she was so disgusted by weren't that much larger than me, so why would she say that? She got a bit flustered and then gave various "but you carry it well" "you're tall" "you're not even that fat" I wasn't even particularly hurt just found it interesting that she would think that would be an OK thing to say especially to someone who is fat.

I am 35 and I am fat, (about 3 stone overweight(, I have 2 kids a lovely husband and a happy life. I enjoy running but also enjoy my food would I like to be slimmer? absolutely! but I am pretty happy the way I am. 10 years ago I was very slim but drank to excess smoked and was very unfit and unhealthy and I am 100% happier now than I was then.
But it got me thinking about similar comments over the years, slimmer friends who put on 3lbs complaining to me about how disgustingly fat they looked.

So I suppose my question is.... if you are one of those people who say these things why do you say them? No judgement just interested to hear the other side of the coin

OP posts:
Naunet · 10/11/2021 19:39

Just as I got to our meeting point a man looked at me and said "oh are you out for some exercise? Good for you. Well done." He didn't say anything to my friend (a size 10). She let rip at him. Condescending prick. No wonder us "fatties" don't bother doing any exercise

I just wanted to add something on this. I agree that what he said is wrong, 100%, but all women get comments on their body from random men, constantly. Just because a woman has a man screaming “nice tits” at her, it’s not any better. It still makes her feel shit. Women who jog get this a lot, it’s intimidating and puts a lot of us off.

I’m not saying this to try to make out like what he said was no big deal, but more to explain that we sadly have to learn not to give a fuck about these comments or we’d all be hiding away!

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 19:32

I reported it. I think the bizarre transphobic rant should be enough to justify the closure. I'll think twice before posting such a divisive topic in future.

OP posts:
PasstheBucket89 · 10/11/2021 19:25

most people report their own thread.

LettertoHermoine · 10/11/2021 19:21

[quote Maverickess]@hamstersarse

I know all the stats around shift and night working, I'm living them (I don't mean to sound rude there btw) but I didn't really have a choice up until about 2 years ago when I started to think of getting off nights and back to the right side of the clock. I'm sure I don't need to spell out what started 2 years ago almost and the strain that's caused and continued to cause in social care. I'm good at my job, I'm seen as a safe pair of hands - especially at night and I've hung on and hung on through loyalty I guess. You're right, it's taken a massive toll on me, in more than just my clothes size, much more and I'm looking for a job to go back onto days and sort my health out before it really starts to bite. I can only go on days in my current place if there's a position available, and I am struggling to find the hours I need on days anywhere else in one place, it's looking like I'll need to stay longer or split working between two places - which no one is keen on wrt to covid.

@LettertoHermoine
Thank you. As you said it wasn't what you were saying because I do understand and appreciate that, and know what it's causing and I also know why I make those choices, and that's all I was trying to explain. I earn a few pennies above nmw, and there's not a lot of choices for shopping here that's accessible and cheap for budgets, especially when you factor in 50 hours on nights that leave me one day to do everything before it starts again - I need to work those hours to keep it all together. They're not excuses for why I'm overweight, they're the outcome of what needs to happen right now and how my priorities have changed. As I said in a pp on my first night I'm all good intentions and fruit, by the last it's literally whatever I can lay my hands on, can afford and needs the least amount of effort to stop me feeling hungry, what it is just doesn't factor half the time and if it does I'm too tired to care.

Fat people are often defensive because we face those kinds of words in judgement every day and it gets wearing and there's a constant barrage of negative language around it that gets turned into advice and concerns with an innocent edge when challenged.

Ultimately if fat shaming people (using terms like 'shovelling' it in, being lazy, having no self discipline, greedy, excuses etc with a negative overtone) actually worked, then there'd be far less fat people around wouldn't there. It doesn't work because we still have an obesity crisis, I'm not blind, I can see that, but maybe we need to start thinking that this is about more than just eating 50 Gregg's in a day because you're lazy and greedy and start looking at the reasons why it's happening in the first place.[/quote]
@Maverickess I have learned a lot today. I honestly mean that. Thank you for taking the time to explain especially after I had been so rude.

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 19:21

Yeah it really is bringing out the worst of humanity. How do I get it set to closed?

OP posts:
PasstheBucket89 · 10/11/2021 19:07

it might be an idea to have this thread closed its potentially very triggering to people suffering from Binge Eating disorder, especially with cuz fat people can't eat there obese, massive and wolfing down 20 donuts Hmm

it's sad op you had good intentions

I hope you are proud such small minded pig ignorant morons Sad

ThisThreadCouldOutMe · 10/11/2021 19:02

I went for a walk today, my usual weekly meet with my friend.

Just as I got to our meeting point a man looked at me and said "oh are you out for some exercise? Good for you. Well done." He didn't say anything to my friend (a size 10). She let rip at him. Condescending prick. No wonder us "fatties" don't bother doing any exercise.

logsonlogsoff · 10/11/2021 18:59

God, this thread is depressing.

PasstheBucket89 · 10/11/2021 18:58

I'm so sorry to hear about your sister

the point I'm making as a previous poster made is that it's often disingenuously used as a stick to beat overweight people with, too many assumptions are made.

UnsuitableHat · 10/11/2021 18:57

I think some people are very preoccupied with weight and project their anxieties or whatever onto other people. As ppl have said it’s also a last acceptable prejudice and something very visual you can use to criticise another person and make assumptions about their lifestyle, thus reassuring yourself that you are better.

Maverickess · 10/11/2021 18:57

@hamstersarse

I know all the stats around shift and night working, I'm living them (I don't mean to sound rude there btw) but I didn't really have a choice up until about 2 years ago when I started to think of getting off nights and back to the right side of the clock. I'm sure I don't need to spell out what started 2 years ago almost and the strain that's caused and continued to cause in social care. I'm good at my job, I'm seen as a safe pair of hands - especially at night and I've hung on and hung on through loyalty I guess. You're right, it's taken a massive toll on me, in more than just my clothes size, much more and I'm looking for a job to go back onto days and sort my health out before it really starts to bite. I can only go on days in my current place if there's a position available, and I am struggling to find the hours I need on days anywhere else in one place, it's looking like I'll need to stay longer or split working between two places - which no one is keen on wrt to covid.

@LettertoHermoine
Thank you. As you said it wasn't what you were saying because I do understand and appreciate that, and know what it's causing and I also know why I make those choices, and that's all I was trying to explain. I earn a few pennies above nmw, and there's not a lot of choices for shopping here that's accessible and cheap for budgets, especially when you factor in 50 hours on nights that leave me one day to do everything before it starts again - I need to work those hours to keep it all together. They're not excuses for why I'm overweight, they're the outcome of what needs to happen right now and how my priorities have changed. As I said in a pp on my first night I'm all good intentions and fruit, by the last it's literally whatever I can lay my hands on, can afford and needs the least amount of effort to stop me feeling hungry, what it is just doesn't factor half the time and if it does I'm too tired to care.

Fat people are often defensive because we face those kinds of words in judgement every day and it gets wearing and there's a constant barrage of negative language around it that gets turned into advice and concerns with an innocent edge when challenged.

Ultimately if fat shaming people (using terms like 'shovelling' it in, being lazy, having no self discipline, greedy, excuses etc with a negative overtone) actually worked, then there'd be far less fat people around wouldn't there. It doesn't work because we still have an obesity crisis, I'm not blind, I can see that, but maybe we need to start thinking that this is about more than just eating 50 Gregg's in a day because you're lazy and greedy and start looking at the reasons why it's happening in the first place.

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 18:57

@awesomekilick yeah none of us know why people eat the food they do. In my case in the height of bingeing I would have easily eaten 12 donuts and a coke in under a minute you prob wouldn't have saw me do it because I did it in secret but i would inhale them, literally so fast I wouldn't even taste it. I'd be so ill I couldn't move afterwards and when I finally came round the guilt and shame would set in which then lead to more bingeing. The only way I found to stop the cycle was to stop dieting and restricting food. Now I'm hyper aware of the invisible struggles people may have so when I have a moment where I find myself judging I stop myself and think that if I lived their life I might be exactly the same.

OP posts:
KrispyKremeDream · 10/11/2021 18:51

'Chubby person' that should've read.

KrispyKremeDream · 10/11/2021 18:49

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

QueenofKattegat · 10/11/2021 18:35

I also judged this morning when I saw a fat person in the car outside Greggs wolfing down some huge pastry with a hot drink whilst sat in their car. For me it’s because I’ve been there and I know how deeply unhappy I was at the time. I was sitting drinking a chamomile tea and occasionally ours eyes would meet. Perhaps they knew I was judging. I don’t know. It doesn’t seem like the right food to eat early in the morning but what do I know

The language in this post is just vile. Fat people can never be eating, can they. It's WOLFING. It isn't a pastry, it's a HUGE pastry. Why the need to add the bit about your chamomile tea? Simple answer - you did it to convey your superiority.

awesomekilick · 10/11/2021 18:32

[quote Claralaura]@JaniieJones by just looking at a fat person how on earth can you possibly know why they are fat? You cannot possibly know why.
Very very few people are fat by "choice". You don't know that if you had their physical and mental health and lived experience that you wouldn't be exactly the same way.

Fat shaming and diet culture doesn't work to make people thin, if it did there wouldn't be so many people overweight. Shaming them hasn't worked so maybe we could give empathy and kindness a try[/quote]
If I see someone massive, coming out of Greg's with a four pack of donuts and they're one down before they've even left the shop, and a full fat come to wash it down with, then yea I have a pretty good idea of why that person is fat. Because they are eating high calorie low nutrient food. What I don't know and wouldn't judge, is WHY they are eating that food. But yes I do think, if someone is really fat, over a size 24 or something, "blimey, they're fat". @

QueenofKattegat · 10/11/2021 18:27

When I see obese people, I notice, but I am not judgey judgey about it - I am more in despair for them. I imagine how shit they most probably feel about it, helpless. I read a lot of accounts on here about that sort of feeling

Been reading this thread and none of it is surprising. The same tired old bullshit but this comment takes the fucking biscuit.

Please, please save your despair and pity for this fat person. I'm happy, very happy. Maybe you could direct your despair somewhere more appropriate?

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 18:27

@Draggondragon sorry I'm lost how is "mental health" a "preventable disease"?

OP posts:
NotMyCat · 10/11/2021 18:16

I'm fat. Size 16 and 5ft 10
I don't judge anyone because TBH I don't really notice/think about people like that. I might think oh nice bag/like that dress/wonder how she gets her hair like that but I'm too busy hating my own body!
I also vowed I wouldn't do it after sitting watching TV with colleagues and the whole programme was bitching about what people looked like

Claralaura · 10/11/2021 18:12

Just to clarify I would have been just as horrified if my friend had said "real women have curves", "body like a teenage boy" or "only dogs like bones".... commenting on people's bodies is just out of order. As is offering "advice" without being asked.

OP posts:
Prattypitel · 10/11/2021 17:54

@Draggondragon

I was far at around 100kg. I had surgery and list 42kg. Try lifting that and see what your heart and joints suffer. I had PCOS and thyroid but also was so depressed about how I looked and how I was treated I took action. Now I am thin I take care of myself and have learned to use the available tools to not be fat. Lifer isn't perfect but it's a hell of a lot better. So yes, I do judge people a bit in a sort yourself out kind of way. It isn't something you can't change and being morbidly obese is unhealthy. On a forum that advises people never to bother the doctor or go to A and E, surely it's OK to say also don't burden yourselves and the NHS with preventable diseases like hips, knees, diabetes, stroke, heart attack and mental health???
Congratulation, enjoy your lighter life.You are a wonderful example for many people.
KrispyKremeDream · 10/11/2021 17:52

@Draggondragon

I was far at around 100kg. I had surgery and list 42kg. Try lifting that and see what your heart and joints suffer. I had PCOS and thyroid but also was so depressed about how I looked and how I was treated I took action. Now I am thin I take care of myself and have learned to use the available tools to not be fat. Lifer isn't perfect but it's a hell of a lot better. So yes, I do judge people a bit in a sort yourself out kind of way. It isn't something you can't change and being morbidly obese is unhealthy. On a forum that advises people never to bother the doctor or go to A and E, surely it's OK to say also don't burden yourselves and the NHS with preventable diseases like hips, knees, diabetes, stroke, heart attack and mental health???
I'm not sure I agree than mental health is comparable to overeating etc. A lot of MH issues stem from childhood and upbringing.
Prattypitel · 10/11/2021 17:51

It is generally accepted that Drug addiction, Alcoholism, Chainsmoking, Gambling etc are things that harm a person.I never understand,why pointing out that Obesity will harm a person too, is suddenly called fat shaming.I know, every addicted person will have their story, it just seems,that people who massively overeat have a particular strong defense mechanism.

Draggondragon · 10/11/2021 17:47

I was far at around 100kg. I had surgery and list 42kg. Try lifting that and see what your heart and joints suffer. I had PCOS and thyroid but also was so depressed about how I looked and how I was treated I took action. Now I am thin I take care of myself and have learned to use the available tools to not be fat. Lifer isn't perfect but it's a hell of a lot better. So yes, I do judge people a bit in a sort yourself out kind of way. It isn't something you can't change and being morbidly obese is unhealthy. On a forum that advises people never to bother the doctor or go to A and E, surely it's OK to say also don't burden yourselves and the NHS with preventable diseases like hips, knees, diabetes, stroke, heart attack and mental health???

hamstersarse · 10/11/2021 17:41

"Sleep deprivation has such serious outcomes that “the World Health Organisation has classed any form of night-time shift work as a probable carcinogen."

@Maverickess

I know you need to work. But it sounds like this is really taking a toll on you now.