Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why ppl make fatphobic comments?

434 replies

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 14:30

While out for coffee with a good (slim) friend who I love dearly, she made a nasty comment about an overweight couple sitting next to us who were enjoying some cake. Something along the lines of "I'm sorry that makes me sick, they are killing themselves". I pointed put to her that the people she was so disgusted by weren't that much larger than me, so why would she say that? She got a bit flustered and then gave various "but you carry it well" "you're tall" "you're not even that fat" I wasn't even particularly hurt just found it interesting that she would think that would be an OK thing to say especially to someone who is fat.

I am 35 and I am fat, (about 3 stone overweight(, I have 2 kids a lovely husband and a happy life. I enjoy running but also enjoy my food would I like to be slimmer? absolutely! but I am pretty happy the way I am. 10 years ago I was very slim but drank to excess smoked and was very unfit and unhealthy and I am 100% happier now than I was then.
But it got me thinking about similar comments over the years, slimmer friends who put on 3lbs complaining to me about how disgustingly fat they looked.

So I suppose my question is.... if you are one of those people who say these things why do you say them? No judgement just interested to hear the other side of the coin

OP posts:
Noavocado · 09/11/2021 17:41

I would never make a judgement on weight but I disagree with the healthy comment. Of course a size 10 person will have a reduced chance of heart disease, diabetes and highblood pressure. That is a medical fact.
Size 18 is unhealthy. Plus a bigger person's joints will wear much faster.

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 17:31

@JaniieJones trust me I'm fat, and I'm fine with it. You cannot tell by looking at a size 10 girl what her health is like (she could have a very serious underlying condition) and similarly you cannot tell the health of a size 18 girl just by looking at her my mum walked the camino at that size. She's 65 never been ill and fitter than most women her age. The only thing a person's weight tells you is their weight.

OP posts:
Claralaura · 09/11/2021 17:27

@Moonface123 very well said.

I also try not to comment on other people's bodies (negatively or positively) in front of my kids because even if we all ate the exactly same thing and exercised the same amount we'd still all have different body shapes.
I don't take being called fat as an insult anymore, it's just a descriptor like tall or blonde but it does annoy me when people assume to know other people's health based on what they look like.

OP posts:
SueSaid · 09/11/2021 17:23

'My body is so much more than the number on the scale, I don't care too much if people don't like my size 16 body now'

I wouldn't even consider you fat though, many women are a curvy 14 - 16 and look fit and well on it. It is when you get past size 18 and into the 20s that people really start looking very unhealthy.

Moonface123 · 09/11/2021 17:22

Some people like myself are just naturally slim . Not all slim people are obsessed with diets , starving themselves , over exercising , social media or concerned at how big others are, thats the least of my worries, l have no interest in any of that.
I have had plenty of negative comments directed at me over the years regarding my weight, but if you have a healthy self esteem, you just shake them off. Unfortunately we live in a very shallow world re physical appearance, l think the best thing we can do as parents is lead by a healthy example and strenghten our childrens/ teens resilience by encouraging them to approve themselves, not seek it from others.

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 17:14

@Udouhun i get you and trust me if I could wave a magic wand and be slim I would too but I've spent too long hating my body and yoyoing between really restrictive dieting and binge eating my whole life. A practice which has messed up both my relationship with food and my metabolism.
But now I focus on the good my body did, growing and birthing 2 babies, feeding them both for a year, being able to play with them every day, it helped me to travel all around the world and go on hiking trips and swim in the sea. My body is so much more than the number on the scale, I don't care too much if people don't like my size 16 body now. It's been really great to me and I'm lucky to have it.

OP posts:
Crossfitwidow · 09/11/2021 17:07

A lot of the replies are basically confirming exactly that though. I’ve 80% of stomach cut out in the quest to be slim, the world is a shit place when you’re fat.

Fendibby · 09/11/2021 17:06

how do you know if someone has a thyroid or other health condition? Do you ask them before or after passing judgement?

This. You can’t see a thyroid condition or any other invisible illness? I have a connective tissue disease that didn’t get diagnosed until my late teens. I went from a normal active teen to one day not being able to get out of bed to go to the toilet without crying in pain. I put on three stone in three months because I couldn’t move my body properly. I wasn’t being greedy, I wasn’t binging, I just wasn’t moving.

I’m medicated now and so I’m able to go to the gym, I’m a healthy weight and look fit. But if you saw me now compared to back then the only difference you’d notice is that I was fat. You couldn’t see that I was sick.

lazylinguist · 09/11/2021 17:05

So if a person is fat, I assume they’re lazy and eat junk food to excess

That's just ignorance. You don't need to eat any junk food to get fat. You can get fat eating home-cooked food. And there are plenty of fat people who do quite a lot of exercise. Just overeating a bit (or eating too much of the things that put weight on you - again, not necessarily junk food) year upon year is enough to make someone fat. Exercise on its own has little effect on weight, unless you're doing properly heroic amounts of it.

Udouhun · 09/11/2021 17:03

I think some people feel that the world generally needs to hear their thoughts and opinions, no matter how rude and ignorant they are. They're cunts. I will be honest and say I would hate to be fat myself but I would never judge someone who's overweight, just as I would never judge a smoker even though I would hate to smoke myself. People just have vices.

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 16:59

@Findingthelight1 I'm so sorry about your sister, I cannot imagine losing a sibling and the loss it would cause.
There is no doubt that obesity can and does contribute to premature death of many people but its often a symptom of an underlying illness.... often binge eating disorder and a person with this disorder can no more "eat less move more ffs" than a person with anorexia can "just eat ffs". There are a huge amount of economic, societal and mental health factors and dieting is rarely the answer. If someone is obese they know they are obese you don't need to tell them. You can ask if they are OK, tell them that you are there for them.... but rarely will commenting negatively on their body help the situation.

OP posts:
PupInAPram · 09/11/2021 16:58

@Crossfitwidow

I assume most slim people think fat people are repulsive. If they don't say it out loud they are probably thinking it.
Erm, no they're not. You can speak for your own obnoxious views, but not for other people.
anon12345678901 · 09/11/2021 16:57

@Siameasy

Honest answer? I really dislike obesity. It looks absolutely repulsive and obese people look extremely uncomfortable just moving around. I would hate to be like that. I wouldn’t say anything but I would definitely think it. I know that some people are obese as a result of illness, injury, medication or disability. I’m aware that could happen to me. Nonetheless this is how I feel. The increasing amount of morbidly obese clothing models has probably had the opposite effect to what was intended. It has put me off of obesity even more. A relative of mine is morbidly obese and in denial completely-like most addicts of course. He will die prematurely due to his addiction. The drug of choice in his case is totally legal; sugar.
I feel the same. I'd never say it publicly either but would think it. I think the body positivity movement has glamourised obesity in a way, and not a good way. When people say the average U.K. size is a 16 happily, it makes me cringe. Getting more and more people overweight is not a good thing.
Topseyt · 09/11/2021 16:56

@WillyWollyWandy

Ok you asked.. I would never dream of commenting about someone’s weight. But I do inwardly judge people who are fat because for the fast majority of people, notwithstanding those with thyroid issues and other health conditions, there is no need to be fat. If you eat healthily and exercise, even only having a walk a day, you will not be fat. So if a person is fat, I assume they’re lazy and eat junk food to excess. They may argue that they don’t, citing gym sessions etc. However if they accounted for every calorie that goes in, and that includes finishing the kids’ dinner, the hugely calorific takeaways and wine, it would easily outweigh the output. It isn’t rocket science. But as I said, I’d never actually say this to a fat person, albeit I don’t really know any fat people. I do know anecdotally that people struggle with their weight. But some willpower and discipline should fix the issue. I also presume however, that for some larger people, there are mental issues at play which leads to comfort eating etc. No idea what the answer is. Counselling?
Don't you realise that thyroid and other medical issues which affect weight are not visible? Nor are mental health issues.

On what do you base your ignorant and ill-informed judgement?

You cannot see my thyroid and mental health issues. You wouldn't know about them at all unless you were rude enough to publicly ask me and if you had the brass neck to do that I would tell you to bugger off. My medical history is none of your business.

Us overweight people can't win. People assume that we are just couch potatoes who simply sit watching TV all day and stuffing our faces with crisps and chocolate. Not true in most cases at all. If we are out and about we can feel and see others judging away and looking us up and down even if they say nothing.

Oh, and woe betide us if we are seen in cafés, pubs or restaurants doing something as normal as enjoying a coffee/drink and a bite to eat.

It is a crime for us to eat. Apparently you are only allowed to do that if you are slim, and it provides proof that we are just lard-arses who simply eat far too much and do no exercise.

For your information, I rarely eat junk food. I don't like it much and I don't have a particularly big appetite.

MrsJamPanMan · 09/11/2021 16:54

@LaurieFairyCake

People ARE fearful of people who carry excess fat - it IS a fear based reaction.

They are terrified it could be them - they're not aware of it but they're scared.

Looking back, I had a very fat infant teacher who didn’t frighten me in the least. If people are afraid of fat, it’s obviously not innate and therefore not universal. I’m no more likely to become morbidly obese than to become a heroin addict. These sweeping generalisations aren’t very useful.
Claralaura · 09/11/2021 16:53

@JudesBiggestFan you are a legend and so am I :-) We are doing our best, we have happy kids and a loving home what more can we ask for.

I don't want my daughter to have a life of dieting and hating her body so I try not to comment on anyone else's body including my own.

OP posts:
Findingthelight1 · 09/11/2021 16:51

My sister died because she was obese. I loved her so much and I struggle every day with the loss.

I don't make fatphobic comments to people, but I do often wish I could say something - anything- that might help them to change, before it's too late. I failed to do that with my sister, and it's devastating.

I can't cope with the "fat positive" or "fit and fat" movement very well either. My sister had no other health conditions; it was her weight alone that killed her. She never thought she was in real danger, but who would, when obesity is so normalised now?

So although I would never do it myself, I could understand why others in my position might "try to help" by making comments to people about their weight.

ThisThreadCouldOutMe · 09/11/2021 16:48

@FatCatThinCat Flowers can I come and live with you?

@Noavocado thanks. My skin is as thick as my thighs Grin it takes a lot to upset me. Wink

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 16:45

@Siameasy you are absolutely entitled to feel like that. Your feelings are your feelings and we all have things we find a bit off-putting but at least you don't say things directly to them that could be hurtful.

OP posts:
Claralaura · 09/11/2021 16:43

@Mrsfrumble I completely understand that everyone is entitled to feel what ever way they want about their own body but to describe your body as disgustingly fat to someone who is double your size is not a very nice thing to do.
It's kind of like if you had a friend who had a large birth mark on her face and you had a small pimple.... would you complain to her about how disfigured you look with a mark on your face? No because it would be a bit nasty and could hurt her feelings.
I find it interesting that people don't take others feelings into consideration when it comes to fatphobic comments.

OP posts:
Siameasy · 09/11/2021 16:43

Honest answer? I really dislike obesity. It looks absolutely repulsive and obese people look extremely uncomfortable just moving around. I would hate to be like that. I wouldn’t say anything but I would definitely think it. I know that some people are obese as a result of illness, injury, medication or disability. I’m aware that could happen to me. Nonetheless this is how I feel.
The increasing amount of morbidly obese clothing models has probably had the opposite effect to what was intended. It has put me off of obesity even more.
A relative of mine is morbidly obese and in denial completely-like most addicts of course. He will die prematurely due to his addiction. The drug of choice in his case is totally legal; sugar.

JudesBiggestFan · 09/11/2021 16:42

It's insecurity and/or nastiness. I'm overweight. I've always tended towards plumpness from childhood onwards, my nan told my then boyfriend, now husband I was a 'two bottle baby' because one was never enough!
At 16 I lost loads of weight with a regime of 1,000 calories a day and gym/swimming five days a week. In my 20s and single I stayed at a size 10-12 through fad diets, lots of exercise and the motivation of going out on a Saturday night 'on the pull!'. I was totally aware of what I ate and focused on how I looked.
Then I got married, had three kids, became terribly ill with ulcerative colitis and now take high doses of steroids while juggling a full time job with three sons. I'm a size 18. Am I happy at that..no. But my life is relentlessly hectic, I feel constantly fatigued, I have given up alcohol, dairy, red meat to try and control my symptoms. My kids are happy, healthy and incredibly social and sporty, my husband and I are still very much in love, I'm a senior manager in a large organisation, my house is clean and tidy with no outside help, I keep up with a wide circle of friends and family, I still swim twice a week and walk every lunchtime. I'm a fricking legend. Some people self medicate with alcohol in an evening, lots of people in fact...I eat too many crisps and too much vegan cake with friends. Is it ideal...no. I know I would be healthier slimmer, but it is a constant battle for me. One day I'll have the time to focus on me again and I hope I will get down to that elusive size 12. But no-one is perfect. Those that judge would be wise to reflect on their own weaknesses.

Eltonsglasses · 09/11/2021 16:40

Some people are arseholes, sounds like your friend is one of them. I once ended a friendship which I thought was really good until we went away for a weekend together and all she did was bitch about other people. I have no time for that. This don't about weight it's about your friend thinking she is better than other people. Unfortunately if you have to resort to bringing others down it just shows you are definitely not a better person.

SeaOfGalilea · 09/11/2021 16:40

While being overweight should never be considered "fine" or "healthy", I don't see how making unkind comments about people's weight helps in any way... If anything it just demotivates people even more. I also don't like false flattery and wouldn't tell an overweight friend "oh you're not fat". Best just not to comment on people's weight at all.

DeadButDelicious · 09/11/2021 16:37

They like to think it's because they 'care about health' but it's not. It's because in their mind, fat is one of the worst things a person can be.

It is a failing, a flaw and these people have disappeared so far up their own backsides that they feel like fat people need to be told ad nauseum about how terrible and awful being fat is because fat people are stupid and don't know that being overweight isn't great.

If you are fat, you are only ever allowed to be miserable about it. And if you dare to be happy in your own skin or not actively trying to lose weight or enjoying a nice cake or whatever and not wandering around in a burlap sack, then you are promoting obesity and solely responsible for the obesity epidemic.

Personally I'd much rather be fat (and believe me I am) than the sort of person who makes value judgements based on a persons weight or appearance.