Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask why ppl make fatphobic comments?

434 replies

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 14:30

While out for coffee with a good (slim) friend who I love dearly, she made a nasty comment about an overweight couple sitting next to us who were enjoying some cake. Something along the lines of "I'm sorry that makes me sick, they are killing themselves". I pointed put to her that the people she was so disgusted by weren't that much larger than me, so why would she say that? She got a bit flustered and then gave various "but you carry it well" "you're tall" "you're not even that fat" I wasn't even particularly hurt just found it interesting that she would think that would be an OK thing to say especially to someone who is fat.

I am 35 and I am fat, (about 3 stone overweight(, I have 2 kids a lovely husband and a happy life. I enjoy running but also enjoy my food would I like to be slimmer? absolutely! but I am pretty happy the way I am. 10 years ago I was very slim but drank to excess smoked and was very unfit and unhealthy and I am 100% happier now than I was then.
But it got me thinking about similar comments over the years, slimmer friends who put on 3lbs complaining to me about how disgustingly fat they looked.

So I suppose my question is.... if you are one of those people who say these things why do you say them? No judgement just interested to hear the other side of the coin

OP posts:
KrispyKremeDream · 09/11/2021 21:44

Surely ideas of beauty reflect what is high status in any society - fat where food is in short supply, pallor where staying out of the sun is only possible for the rich, thinness where exercise reflects exploits at the gym and healthy eating. It isn’t instinctive.

Well, yes this is a factor. Good example being the African tribes who idolise fat women, with some being so overfed that they can barely walk. Likely comes from it being the opposite of famine.

But attraction is definitely so instinctive. Studies have shown that the facial features we consider beautiful are more symmetrical, which in turn signals strong genes. Even babies react to this and smile more at beautiful people apparently.

Many studies have shown that both sexes are attracted to attributes that signal fertility. Good waist/hip ratio in women and good shoulder/waist ratio in men, for example.

MrsJamPanMan · 09/11/2021 21:37

@KrispyKremeDream

I think repulsion at obesity is likely instinctual, like the repulsion most people get when thinking about shagging an elderly person. We are hardwired to make choices that are most conducive to furthering the human race, which is why traditional beauty concepts coincide with symmetrical features which signal strong genetics.
Surely ideas of beauty reflect what is high status in any society - fat where food is in short supply, pallor where staying out of the sun is only possible for the rich, thinness where exercise reflects exploits at the gym and healthy eating. It isn’t instinctive.
JesusIsAnyNameFree · 09/11/2021 21:33

She's clearly not a very nice person. Think it if you must, but why the fuck say it? I can't care less if an obese person eats cake, doesn't affect me. I'll even give an obese person cake if I've had time to bake for once! Probably make your friends head spin.

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 21:32

@Dontforgetyourbrolly no I don't think she would have said that because she's generally a very kind inclusive person who doesn't usually pass judgement on strangers that's why I was so taken aback when she said it.
If I see a heroin addict on the street I don't think "that's disgusting they are killing themselves:" all I think of is how privileged I am to have not found myself in that position. I can't judge them, I don't know them their background their mental health or economic situation.

OP posts:
logsonlogsoff · 09/11/2021 21:11

‘ But I think it’s also reasonably common for people to feel a similar ‘disgust’ when they see a person who is very, very thin. Is there a difference? ’
Is it common? I don’t think it is, otherwise we wouldn’t hero worship stick thin women on the covers of magazines. There was a woman at our gym who was clearly anorexic, manically exercising. I felt nothing but compassion and pity for her. Other than that I have never ever had much thought about someone who’s very thin let alone been repulsed by them.

KrispyKremeDream · 09/11/2021 20:55

I think repulsion at obesity is likely instinctual, like the repulsion most people get when thinking about shagging an elderly person. We are hardwired to make choices that are most conducive to furthering the human race, which is why traditional beauty concepts coincide with symmetrical features which signal strong genetics.

Dontforgetyourbrolly · 09/11/2021 20:53

Everyone is entitled to their opinion
If your friend was watching someone chainsmoking would she say its disgusting they are killing themselves? Or drink people swigging from bottles of vodka?
I think you were hurt as you felt she was directing those comments at you . Was she insensitive? Yes . Is obesity killing peope ? Yes . But equally if you did not like or agree with her opinions you're right to challenge it.

Bancha · 09/11/2021 20:47

There seems to be a lot of judgmental comments about people who might experience a feeling of ‘disgust’ or feel repulsed by someone who is very, very overweight, irrespective of whether they actually say anything off the back of that feeling. Which feels a little unfair in this context as they are answering a question honestly. But I think it’s also reasonably common for people to feel a similar ‘disgust’ when they see a person who is very, very thin. Is there a difference? If you feel a sense of disgust when someone is very overweight, do you feel the same when you see someone who is emaciated? Or are they two different things? If so, why? I’m curious.

BruiserWoods · 09/11/2021 20:43

Also, my mum would never admit this, but when I've been fat (after starting a new job I piled on a good bit and I didn't have the energy to address it I was getting up to speed and worrying about that) I think my Mum couldn't understand that it wasn't FOREFRONT in my mind. The fact that I could be putting my weight second to learning the ropes was simultaneously baffling, threatening and I think although she'd never admit it, admirable.

My mum and went on a cruise a while ago and my mum was telling my daughter and me about the dessert buffet. She took pictures and everything look gorgeous. She told us so proudly I had had a tiny mouthful of that one and a tiny taste of that one.

My DD and I were laughing that her pleasure came from RESISTING.

BruiserWoods · 09/11/2021 20:39

My mum is like this and it's a TERROR of losing control.

At times I've been fat and she's been unbearable to me, reminding me every minute,but unlike her, i knew I could just decide to address the issue when I was ready. She'll still comment even when I know that I'm fighting fit (for me). She thinks my fighting fit should be leaner.
She is very repressed and never really feels anything, not even the fear of losing control if that makes sense.

Severntrent · 09/11/2021 20:35

And most religions have something to say about a duty to look after your body (and not judging I know!), which has sort of resonated with me when I've read about it.
Although I think in reality we live in a culture where snacking, access to high calorie food is everywhere and this is where half the battle is.

Asthenia · 09/11/2021 20:34

I might be in the minority here but as a fat person I simply do not care what strangers think of me. Good, be repulsed by me being out in public. I will carry on living my life regardless 🤷🏻‍♀️
What I DO care about is being treated with respect, as everyone should be.
I appreciate not all fat people have my mindset though, and that this thread will be very upsetting for some. Personally I’m not surprised in the least by some of the responses. People hate fat people - especially fat women. I’ve been fat my whole life so have had plenty of time to get used to that, but I imagine it’s pretty shit when you’ve been slim and have put on weight for whatever reason only to find out that you’re generally treated much worse when you’re fat.

Severntrent · 09/11/2021 20:32

What I mean is, that I don't look at an overweight person and judge them because I have no idea what's going on in their lives and their size has nothing to do with me. But if I'm honest with myself I do think that it's not great when people get morbidly obese for no reason other than overeating. But I'd imagine that this is quite a small group.
I'm sure other people would judge me for some reason or other. I'm just trying to answer the OP's question, although as I said I wouldn't judge or comment about an individual.

Claralaura · 09/11/2021 20:25

@BaconAndAvocado what a beautifully kind little girl you're raising. Definitely gives me hope for future generation.

OP posts:
Severntrent · 09/11/2021 20:23

Wow - there’s a lot to unpack there isn’t there!? You don’t judge individual fat people but you DO judge ALL fat people? You know that makes no sense.
No I judge people who are fat because they eat too much and don't exercise. Not those who have a medical condition or some emotional problem or genetic predisposition to being overweight. And that is because I think we should look after our health.
Of course people who are obese can be spiritual. Just because I feel we have a moral duty to look after our bodies doesn't stop anyone else from having whatever beliefs they want. Not sure why it would?

BaconAndAvocado · 09/11/2021 20:19

@Onlyabean

I have the opinion that years from now, commenting negatively about a person's appearance, including weight, will be viewed with the same horror that some of those seventies sitcoms are now when displaying racism or sexism.

I can see us gasping in shock at it in the future. I hope so at least.

This. My DD aged 13 is very quick to admonish someone if they are seen to be “fat-shaming” another person. Nothing to do with her size, she’s slim, she finds finds it unacceptable. Her friends are the same. Very refreshing and hopeful.
KrispyKremeDream · 09/11/2021 20:10

@TeeTotaller1

I had a comment from a friend about another friend that was overweight apparently 'she's costing the NHS thousands', this was from someone who smoked 40 a day and drank a bottle of red wine a night. I told her she was a hypocrite She really couldn't see it Confused
To be fair though, the government actually make a huge profit on smoking tax. Plus didn't research recently find that most skinny smokers are still healthier than obese non smokers.
GrouchyKiwi · 09/11/2021 20:09

We're trained into it, for whatever reason, and yes, mostly about women. Whether it's because women are supposed to be slim and attractive, or we're judging people for (we assume) being gluttons, it's taught to us from a very young age by the media we consume and the people around us.

I've spent a few years trying to train myself out of it because it's horrible to be so judgemental.

KrispyKremeDream · 09/11/2021 20:08

@Playingoutinthedark

Everyone on MN lives off salads that last for millenia. It's the most fataphobic place I've encountered. This will go down well.
I don't believe this for a second! Look how frothing any thread criticising fat people gets.
DeadButDelicious · 09/11/2021 20:04

I think the body positivity movement has glamourised obesity in a way, and not a good way. When people say the average U.K. size is a 16 happily, it makes me cringe. Getting more and more people overweight is not a good thing.

I don't know if I'm just being dense but I really, really don't see how telling people it's ok to love their body, no matter the size, is a bad thing and I REALLY don't get how obesity is being 'Glamourised' either because as a fat person, the kind of fat many people on this thread are 'silently' Hmm judging, I see no one aspiring to have a body like mine, quite the opposite actually. A body like mine is quite possibly the worst possible thing they can think of for themselves.

But you see, the way I see it, my body has propelled me for almost 40 years, it has born my children and I am DONE hating it because it's fat. Hate is not going to help me change it but maybe loving it could? Worth a go.

HappyDays40 · 09/11/2021 20:00

I don't comment at all TBH oyher than to complement people. Its just shit even passing comment.

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 09/11/2021 19:52

I'm a yo-yo dieter and I know how hard it is to stay slim if you are genetically programmed to be fat. The slightest overeat - I'm talking, e.g. a slice of toast - takes me ages to 'undo'.

So, no, I don't judge fat people. Many of them won't actually be eating any more, or exercising less, than slim people.

Noavocado · 09/11/2021 19:52

@CounsellorTroi OK I understand what you mean. Sorry I misunderstood you. I'm around the same BMI at the moment. I thought you meant size 18plus. You are not very overweight.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 09/11/2021 19:47

When people direct a fattest comment at me I rush up to them, grab their hand and say thank you, thank you so much. I had NO idea I was fat until this moment. They generally think I'm nuts and back off.

Mummy1232016 · 09/11/2021 19:46

@logsonlogsoff

‘ I dont judge individual fat people because who knows why they are fat, but as a group, I do judge people who are fat because they eat too much. But I think we have a moral duty to look after our bodies so I judge other people who dont look after their bodies too. I try to keep healthy and I'd be disappointed in myself if I fell too far off the wagon of healthiness. Not sure about the basis for this moral duty - it's just something I feel - but its something about keeping healthy so you can make a contribution to society or do your best, and maybe there is a spiritual/religious element too.’

Wow - there’s a lot to unpack there isn’t there!? You don’t judge individual fat people but you DO judge ALL fat people? You know that makes no sense.
So is it ONLY slim people who get to be spiritual because of their dedication to morals that the tubsters don’t have, or do fat people get a bit of spirituality too?
I don’t judge fat, or thin, people but I do struggle
With the dense, the superior and the snobbish.

Not forgetting not making a contribution to society Confused
Swipe left for the next trending thread