Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to self harm?

544 replies

Elleexxtra · 09/11/2021 12:23

Lush Paddington are giving out binders, meaning girls can self harm without any danger of their parents knowing and being able to discuss potential issues with them.

www.instagram.com/lushpaddington/

AIBU to think young girls shouldn't be groomed to hate their bodies?

OP posts:
Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 10:50

I've worked in jobs with a high level.of social responsibility. As do many others.

Anyone who has sold age restricted products will know that companies take that stuff extremely seriously. Not only do police send in underagers to test the waters ,companies internally also do. You canose your job for serving alcohol to a 20 yr old. Because although they are old enough you still failed because they are under 21/25 or whatever the companies cut off is.

There are huge fines both to individual staff and the companies for breaches of proof of age policies and breaches of the regs around children/infants on the premises.

There are limits in chemist's etc for the amount if paracetamol you can buy.

How on one hand Do we have so many restrictions and guidelines and yet this is allowed. Wheres the responsibility here? Who's taking the hit on the outcomes? I worry for the girls obviously but also the staff back up. They have been placed on this position against their will.

Anyone who has worked in retail knows it doesn't matter of they were served by a manager in a shop in Manchester they will still come raging and screwing at a cashier in the local outlet in Luton.

Will the staff be protected here from the rantings of furious parents who come storming in?

BloodinGutters · 10/11/2021 10:46

@KurtWilde

Why do you not believe trans people should be able to access professional assistance?

I do. And very trans person I know has thankfully now been put on the correct path for transitioning. But do you have any idea how many years people wait for that professional assistance? Why do you think they take things into their own hands? Because the waiting list for the GIC is so long, that's why.

You didn’t answer my post about this.

Waiting times for diagnosis of adhd are years and years.

Cocaine is chemically pretty similar to ritilin, just stronger. So while waiting it would be fine to self medicate with it? Or medicate children with it??

BloodinGutters · 10/11/2021 10:44

@Elleexxtra

To be fair to posters objecting to the term self harm I think they have a point.

The term is traditionally associated with a very deliberate act, the effects of which are well known to the person doing it. It has very emotive connotations.

Binding is marketed as something else, something positive, and even though I consider it harmful and the harm is being done to the self I don't think the motivation is the same.

Maybe it should be AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to use harmful binders?

Severally restrictive diets, like water fasts and juice fasts and 500 calories a day, are marketed all over social media as self care.

But they are self harm.

We need to use factual language to name a problem to be able to address it.

Binders sound cutesy in the same way self care cleanses appeal vulnerable young people.

We need to call it what it is.

FortunesFavour · 10/11/2021 10:40

Whatwouldscullydo - you are so right. I believe these organisations will get their comeuppance though: it’ll be the scandal of the next decade as the law suits multiply holding them to account for riding roughshod over the law. Might be a bit expensive on the gardening front but I’m up for it!

Helleofabore · 10/11/2021 10:39

I am going to wait, though, to be educated as to why any adults think it is acceptable for a store popular with girls under 16 to be involved in being a collection point for a hinder that is known to be harmful.

And educated why a particular group of girls are considered acceptable collateral damage for the sake of others.

PumpkinGin · 10/11/2021 10:24

Elle, I completely agree. Can all the trans discussions please pop over to the special board?

@KurtWilde and @Stompythedinosaur , I wrote a long post about how I was concerned about the ability of children to make this decision and how I thought that professional support was essential.

I also outlined that I thought parental involvement was key.

Would you mind reading that post and let me know why you think a soap shop should distribute something which apparently can be harmful? To young girls? Behind their parents backs?

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 10:22

Amd I'm.sorry but some of these activist people and organisations need to take some responsibility here.

Lying about suicide stats

Lying about effects of medication

Confusing children avout their sex and eroding boundaries.

Government funded ti the tuned of hundreds of thousands of pounds and wheres the money going?

Paying staff to harass peope on twitter and calling the police every 5 mins iver biological fact tweets and trolling MN having a go at women who disagree.

None of its getting invested in health care is it. That's where their priorities lie..point proving and bullying.

Not trans people.

Elleexxtra · 10/11/2021 10:19

Just to reiterate as this thread has taken a predictable turn...

This isn't about denying anything to trans people. Binders are cheaply available for any that want them, we know this. The internet exists.

It's about concern that young girls are being encouraged to try harmful practices by a soap shop.

OP posts:
MonsignorMirth · 10/11/2021 10:19

@KurtWilde ? Kurt!
I'm starting to think you're deliberately ignoring my posts. Is it because you can't answer the one question I have asked or because you're prejudiced against agender people?

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 10:16

People take controlling their pain into their own hands should we make heroin legal?

Just because a service is deficient , not helped by blocking progress every step of the way by people who claim to be on the side of trans people creating nore patients than the service can keep up with, doesn't mean that the solution is to turn a blind eye to dangerous stupidity. Wheres the recourse? How much money out of Alice the Saturday girl student do you think you will get when you end up disabled and unable to work? Do you think there's any insurance in leave to cover the costs of their damage ?

MrsWooster · 10/11/2021 10:14

@Stompythedinosaur

Come on, claiming a 12 page thread about how trans teens shouldn't be allowed free access to commonly used items to support them in presenting as the gender they identify with isn't anti-trans is about as disingenuous as suggesting your concern about this issue is about self-harm.
Items to support them in presenting as male gender are haircuts and chaps’ pants, minimising sports bras and baggy T-shirt’s. Not binders which destroy breast tissue and inhibit breathing, offered via a trendy soap shop.
Elleexxtra · 10/11/2021 10:14

@HoardingSamphireSaurus

I am not sure I'd buy into that Elle it is what it is. Giving it a different name, separating it off from an other act designed to harm the body isn't helpful. That it happens over a longer period of time doesn't change that. And marketing has nothing to do with medical reality.
Sure, I agree that it is harmful

I'm just sympathetic to the pp who pointed out that self harm is quite specifically used to describe certain behaviours.

I think it actually highlights the problem.. people who self harm generally do it in secret, knowing they are harming themselves but feeling a need to do it anyway.

Wearing a binder is seen as a "good thing" by young girls desperate to fit in to friendship groups so the true harm is masked by all the glitter and rainbows.

That's the problem, it's not about distressed young people knowingly harming themselves in secret to relieve mental pain, it's cynical marketing to young girls (and for those who actually are gender dysphoric, surely it is irresponsible to blithely hand out harmful equipment with no proper support).

And I agree with a pp horrified at the idea that non-dysphoric girls must be collateral damage.

None of this is acceptable for any of our young people who deserve so much more care, all of them.

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 10/11/2021 10:13

But do you have any idea how many years people wait for that professional assistance?

Yes. Because we are up to date.

Still looking forward for those links to evidence to educate us all though.

KurtWilde · 10/11/2021 10:12

*every not very

KurtWilde · 10/11/2021 10:12

Why do you not believe trans people should be able to access professional assistance?

I do. And very trans person I know has thankfully now been put on the correct path for transitioning. But do you have any idea how many years people wait for that professional assistance? Why do you think they take things into their own hands? Because the waiting list for the GIC is so long, that's why.

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 10:06

Binding is marketed as something else, something positive, and even though I consider it harmful and the harm is being done to the self I don't think the motivation is the same

Its never just a binder though is it. How many risky behaviours can a person display before we move from viewing it as something being done to cause yourself harm?

Whats the magic number here? Binder = not deliberately causing harm. How about Binder +not telling people you are female?

Or binder+ sex info withholding +entering into spaces meant for males increasing your risk factors of being hurt/assaulted?

Binder +lying about sex+ male spaces + not spending time outside with your friends in the sunshine exercising

Etc

Wheres the point it crosses over ?

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/11/2021 10:04

I am not sure I'd buy into that Elle it is what it is. Giving it a different name, separating it off from an other act designed to harm the body isn't helpful. That it happens over a longer period of time doesn't change that. And marketing has nothing to do with medical reality.

MonsignorMirth · 10/11/2021 10:02

[quote Beamur]Page 9. Charleyparleys post spells out the evidence of harm. If you only read one post, read this one.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4396710-Lush-Binder-Collection?pg=9[/quote]
Page numbers and links to page numbers don't always work because there are different ways that users can set up their page settings (I recommend 100 posts per page!)

Elleexxtra · 10/11/2021 10:00

To be fair to posters objecting to the term self harm I think they have a point.

The term is traditionally associated with a very deliberate act, the effects of which are well known to the person doing it. It has very emotive connotations.

Binding is marketed as something else, something positive, and even though I consider it harmful and the harm is being done to the self I don't think the motivation is the same.

Maybe it should be AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to use harmful binders?

OP posts:
Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 09:56

Not sure why the harm done to themselves by people using binders can't be described as self harm. even the manufacturers of the bloody things outline the potential for damage

Personally I think its like sex. If you cant talk about it openly with the appropriate language you aren't mature enough to be doing it.

Of you refuse to acknowledge the seriousness and are offended by medically accurate language and need things explained to you In sugar coated as like you do with a toddler then you should not be deemed capable of consenting.

Beamur · 10/11/2021 09:54

Page 9. Charleyparleys post spells out the evidence of harm. If you only read one post, read this one.
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4396710-Lush-Binder-Collection?pg=9

HoardingSamphireSaurus · 10/11/2021 09:54

Not sure why the harm done to themselves by people using binders can't be described as self harm. even the manufacturers of the bloody things outline the potential for damage.

If hiding breasts accepting the likelihood of tissue damage, broken ribs etc isn't self harm then what is it?

That it is a relatively new phenomenon doesn't change what it is.

Beamur · 10/11/2021 09:50

Maybe you should read the responses and see why some people think that it is. It's not just being randomly thrown in without justification.

Helleofabore · 10/11/2021 09:49

Choosing to do something to yourself that is known to be harmful to alleviate mental pain is ‘self harm’.

Binding has been proven to cause damage and health issues.

FFS, a young female had a nipple fall off in their binder and talked about it on social media the other day.

Stop downplaying the risks associated with using binders.

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 09:48

And nor dies giving everything sone cutsie name to allow People to disassociate from what's actually being done.

Top surgery is a double mastectomy ajd binding is still causing harm to your hreast tissue ajd breaking ribs