Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to self harm?

544 replies

Elleexxtra · 09/11/2021 12:23

Lush Paddington are giving out binders, meaning girls can self harm without any danger of their parents knowing and being able to discuss potential issues with them.

www.instagram.com/lushpaddington/

AIBU to think young girls shouldn't be groomed to hate their bodies?

OP posts:
PumpkinGin · 10/11/2021 20:47

@Goshitstricky thank you so much for commenting. I would be very interested in what your manager is saying. Please report back to us.

I really hope that you don’t feel attacked. I don’t think anyone has said anything negative about staff (but I confess to not having read all the posts). I know that you all are experts at your products. That was the main reason for me allowing my daughter to regularly browse your stores. She loves especially your bath bombs but also the soaps and your other products.

My concern is that you seem to provide a pick-up point for binders where underage girls can have them delivered behind their parents back. From the links I have read here, it seems that 97% of wearers experience health issues, some serious and irreversible.

I have stated before that if my daughter came out as trans and wanted to bind, I would want her to see a psychologist and a physical expert to understand better both the psychological reasons and the medical issues with this decision. I don’t expect the same person to be able to give this advice.

I also don’t expect an expert in skincare to be able to evaluate neither a (not even) teenaged girl’s mental health and competency nor the medical side effects, impact on breathing, ribs and breast tissue. Would you consider yourself qualified to do this?

I worry that this is a misguided attempt to signal “trans friendly” with no benefits for adults (who can order their own binders) but potential dangers for underaged girls. I am sorry, but unless this is clarified, I will have to find a new place to shop for my DD.

verymiddleaged · 10/11/2021 20:29

If Oxfam sold them I would be even more unimpressed because they work in a field which should have higher awareness of such issues.

verymiddleaged · 10/11/2021 20:26

A: we don't get paid minimum wage.
This is totally irrelevant to a discussion about child protection.

B: we have a shed ton of training on all our products (not saying that would make any of us qualified to deal with issues surrounding this of course)

As you say you have had no relevant training in relation to children suffering from gender dysmorphia.
Have you had training in age ID, to ensure these products aren't being sold to underage children?
C: we're not asked to aggressively sell and pester customers.
Again this has nothing to do with child protection unless you are thinking of selling binders directly.

D: Our Christmas sales are as good as ever.
We are actually talking about serious issues on this thread.
E: I can practically hear the sneer in the soap shop comments,
It isn't sneering it is just reality. My dc love lush and it does a good job of selling bath products.
It shouldn't be anywhere near potentially harmful body modification products for children.

I'm not blaming shop floor staff but some management figures should take responsibility for this mess.

SunnyDay23 · 10/11/2021 20:12

My boobs grew when I was about thirteen and I was horrified by them, just really self-conscious. It took a couple of years to get comfortable in my new body. I am so glad that binders weren’t available then.

Clymene · 10/11/2021 19:58

They are providing a space for children to get binders without their parents' knowledge or approval @Testingprof

And yes I'd judge Oxfam for selling them. Do they sell FGM tools?

Girls cannot consent to having their ears pierced without parental consent and yet this shop is selling them medical equipment that will damage their organs.

foxgoosefinch · 10/11/2021 19:57

They aren’t. I’ve looked at the post and they are providing a place where people can pick up a binder. They aren’t providing the advice gender swap (?) are. If you found a binder in oxfam would you attack oxfam?

But as Helleofabore just posted, it's clearly not aimed at over-18 people who can just order and pay for a binder and have it delivered to their house/hall of residence/flat etc., is it?

The whole idea is that it's aimed at girls who live with their parents and don't have credit or debit cards - hence the collection point and scanning a QR code as a "charity donation".

There is whole culture online of often very young girls trying to find addresses and collection points to have binders delivered to other addresses so their parents don't find out. It's a "thing", as they say.

So Lush are knowingly colluding with all of this.

334bu · 10/11/2021 19:53

Because what adult needs to pick up a binder from Lush? They would get the binder sent to their house. I would argue that this campaign is not aimed at people who would just get the binder delivered by mail to their door.

Exactly, this is obviously aimed at minors.

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 19:52

Which instantly involves the staff. Whoever hands it out will be asked the questions and expected to take any abuse/tears/tantrums/complaints etc that arise as a result of this.

GreyhoundG1rl · 10/11/2021 19:52

C: we're not asked to aggressively sell and pester customers
So you take it on yourselves to do this? Don't pretend it doesn't happen, please...

Testingprof · 10/11/2021 19:49

@QueenSue

I can practically hear the sneer in the soap shop comments But Lush is a soap shop. Bath products are your speciality. You shouldn't be selling binders.
They aren’t. I’ve looked at the post and they are providing a place where people can pick up a binder. They aren’t providing the advice gender swap (?) are. If you found a binder in oxfam would you attack oxfam?
Helleofabore · 10/11/2021 19:44

Because what adult needs to pick up a binder from Lush? They would get the binder sent to their house.

I would argue that this campaign is not aimed at people who would just get the binder delivered by mail to their door.

Clymene · 10/11/2021 19:40

@Goshitstricky

I work in Lush. I can honestly say our customers are not predominantly young girls.

I haven't heard about this latest binder thing, I'll ask my manager about it tomorrow and see what's what.

Just to be clear though,

A: we don't get paid minimum wage.
B: we have a shed ton of training on all our products (not saying that would make any of us qualified to deal with issues surrounding this of course)
C: we're not asked to aggressively sell and pester customers.
D: Our Christmas sales are as good as ever.
E: I can practically hear the sneer in the soap shop comments, we (like many high street stores) have regular customers who will come in for a chat or comfort or human contact. I can think of many customers who we have helped to get skin/hair issues under control which has helped MH. We're not all the monsters who just want £££ as we're being made out to be.

This study didn't collect data on children visiting your store but the vast majority are very young. Nearly 40% are under 25%. If children were also included in the analysis, I'd say it was nearer 60%.

Lush's target market is ostensibly 18-30 year old ABC1s but I'd argue that a lot of their campaigns and advertising is designed to appeal to children.

Like this partnership.

AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to self harm?
Elleexxtra · 10/11/2021 19:38

@Goshitstricky
I'm not sneering by calling it a soap shop, I'm pointing out it's not the place to hand out binders

I used to love lush, I took my kids there and the staff were unbelievably kind and lovely to them

My family run a local shop which is very community driven so I know there is more to it than selling

I've shopped at lush for myself so I know it's not just girls who use the products

But I'm also a mother with mother friends who knows that girls are very much a big demographic who buy and get bought for

OP posts:
BloodinGutters · 10/11/2021 19:36

@ToykotoLosAngeles

The expectations that Lush put on their staff are grim.

mitheringsfrommorningside.wordpress.com/tag/lush-cruelty-free-kisses/

This is from 8 years ago!

Most of whom are younger women. Especially the staff working later on Saturdays when drunken men will be out to take advantage of this.
ToykotoLosAngeles · 10/11/2021 19:35

Sorry, missed this was on page 6 but I am still so cross.

ToykotoLosAngeles · 10/11/2021 19:34

The expectations that Lush put on their staff are grim.

mitheringsfrommorningside.wordpress.com/tag/lush-cruelty-free-kisses/

This is from 8 years ago!

BloodinGutters · 10/11/2021 19:32

@Goshitstricky

I work in Lush. I can honestly say our customers are not predominantly young girls.

I haven't heard about this latest binder thing, I'll ask my manager about it tomorrow and see what's what.

Just to be clear though,

A: we don't get paid minimum wage.
B: we have a shed ton of training on all our products (not saying that would make any of us qualified to deal with issues surrounding this of course)
C: we're not asked to aggressively sell and pester customers.
D: Our Christmas sales are as good as ever.
E: I can practically hear the sneer in the soap shop comments, we (like many high street stores) have regular customers who will come in for a chat or comfort or human contact. I can think of many customers who we have helped to get skin/hair issues under control which has helped MH. We're not all the monsters who just want £££ as we're being made out to be.

When has anyone suggested the employees are monsters?

Now the company: cruelty free kisses, lush going naked, that’s fucking predatory and sexual harassment

Whatwouldscullydo · 10/11/2021 19:25

We're not all the monsters who just want £££ as we're being made out to be

No one thinks your the monsters.

You are however another example of how this predominantly affects the working class ( of which many of us are ) . You have had something put on u , that you are not qualified to talk or advise about , without the pay top ups relevant to the medical professionals/counsellors etc that right now you will be expecting to be, expected to sort in a short 10 minute visit what drs friends and family have missed/failed to do for years and there will be nothing, no insurance, no revision training class class be sent to and no security to protect you from anyone who kicks off be it concerned parents or a kid upset their binder doesn't fit.

Personally I'm pretty worried on thise fronts fir the staff too. This would not have been part if the job description when u applied and those expecting u do do this are safe and away from it all in theor offices

QueenSue · 10/11/2021 19:23

I can practically hear the sneer in the soap shop comments
But Lush is a soap shop. Bath products are your speciality. You shouldn't be selling binders.

purpleboy · 10/11/2021 19:17

@Goshitstricky

I work in Lush. I can honestly say our customers are not predominantly young girls.

I haven't heard about this latest binder thing, I'll ask my manager about it tomorrow and see what's what.

Just to be clear though,

A: we don't get paid minimum wage.
B: we have a shed ton of training on all our products (not saying that would make any of us qualified to deal with issues surrounding this of course)
C: we're not asked to aggressively sell and pester customers.
D: Our Christmas sales are as good as ever.
E: I can practically hear the sneer in the soap shop comments, we (like many high street stores) have regular customers who will come in for a chat or comfort or human contact. I can think of many customers who we have helped to get skin/hair issues under control which has helped MH. We're not all the monsters who just want £££ as we're being made out to be.

I don't think anyone is sneering because your a soap shop, more because your soap shop is no where near qualified to assist with these issues as you yourself have said. In fact I see posters sticking up for the staff in case of any potential repercussions.
ToykotoLosAngeles · 10/11/2021 19:15

C: we're not asked to aggressively sell and pester customers.

Oh? You must work in the one and only branch that doesn't require staff to follow customers around, ask ridiculous open-ended questions and start smearing moisturiser on customers who stand still for long enough.

purpleboy · 10/11/2021 19:14

It's horrifying really that a company unrelated to these issues are providing a. Service behind parents backs. I mean what other scenario can you think off where this wouldn't raise massive red flags?

I'm pleased to say it's been picked up by the papers (even if it is the mail)

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-10181729/Lush-comes-fire-offering-chest-binder-collection-service.html#article-10181729

Goshitstricky · 10/11/2021 19:12

I work in Lush. I can honestly say our customers are not predominantly young girls.

I haven't heard about this latest binder thing, I'll ask my manager about it tomorrow and see what's what.

Just to be clear though,

A: we don't get paid minimum wage.
B: we have a shed ton of training on all our products (not saying that would make any of us qualified to deal with issues surrounding this of course)
C: we're not asked to aggressively sell and pester customers.
D: Our Christmas sales are as good as ever.
E: I can practically hear the sneer in the soap shop comments, we (like many high street stores) have regular customers who will come in for a chat or comfort or human contact. I can think of many customers who we have helped to get skin/hair issues under control which has helped MH. We're not all the monsters who just want £££ as we're being made out to be.

Elleexxtra · 10/11/2021 18:57

@334bu
@Helleofabore

Completely understand, I just don't want the PSA to be lost Grin

OP posts:
bestcattoyintheworld · 10/11/2021 18:50

So we're adopting the breast destruction techniques that take place in some undeveloped countries. Great. What about FGM, that might as well be next, although I suppose puberty blockers which have permanently damaging effects on the body are not much better.

What's the definition of child abuse again?

Swipe left for the next trending thread