Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to self harm?

544 replies

Elleexxtra · 09/11/2021 12:23

Lush Paddington are giving out binders, meaning girls can self harm without any danger of their parents knowing and being able to discuss potential issues with them.

www.instagram.com/lushpaddington/

AIBU to think young girls shouldn't be groomed to hate their bodies?

OP posts:
Elleexxtra · 11/11/2021 09:28

So I'm guessing Lush would endorse breast ironing? Even though, in this article, the police said they would do something about that if they knew about it... ?

www.theguardian.com/global-development/2019/jan/26/revealed-dozens-of-girls-subjected-to-breast-ironing-in-uk

OP posts:
Whatwouldscullydo · 11/11/2021 09:24

That blog is heartbreaking.

How do we expect girls to live with their bodies when even the family place so many connotations on it.

I've said this before but I've seen it on here and on face book/twitter pages where the first response to the signs that a child is developing often perfectly normally if just slightly earlier than they would like, is not to support and prepare prepare child but to drag them down the drs , or impose arbitrary age cut offs or adult associations to things designed to deal with it.

The phrase she mentioned " becoming a woman" I hate it. I hate it so much. A child with periods and breasts is a child. They aren't becoming anything yet.

What hope do these girls have of developing healthy relationships with their perfectly natural normal bodies when parents place such restrictions and negative associations on the things they need. And the natural development of a healthy body.When adults would rather a child was uncomfortable and self conscious in an unsupportive vest than buying a bra. Or they buy a bra but don't like the moulding designed to provide cushioning and a smoother/more even outline while things are developing unevenly, so they are stuck with thin fabric instead.

And fir what reason? A parents worry men will look? A parents inability to differentiate between a bit of moulding and a wonderbra? Some idea that 9/10/11 is too young for any if it ajd the problem.is their body not societies hang ups?

We do this to girls, make them take responsibility for the men who can't control themselves and the disapproval of aduot women who do display and enhance breasts with underwear , by placing all those associations to basic functional items of clothing. All this on the shoulders if a 9 yr old. If parents cant cope how do we expect the kids too.

And then everyone's thrilled the problem is solved in a damaging way , a literally permanently damaging way in a high streat cosmetics store.

PumpkinGin · 11/11/2021 09:16

Poor girls 😥

foxgoosefinch · 11/11/2021 09:16

From the link Belle posted:

Some days, I imagine my breasts as so revolting that they must be boils full of pus, or full of rotting skin and maggots. I have intrusive thoughts about removing them myself, and these feelings have even gone so far as to make me obsessively study breast anatomy in detail. I still get glimpses of myself in the mirror or my shadow on the wall, and I’m filled with nausea and terror knowing that this is how other people see me, and that I can’t escape this body without paying thousands of dollars to have a doctor with a scalpel perform an invasive, life-altering medical procedure in which my breasts are cut from my body… and destroyed.

This is serious mental illness requiring therapy and support, not a harmful product handed out by unqualified people, which simply reinforces and entrenches the obsession! Sad

mustlovegin · 11/11/2021 09:14

This is puzzling, even more so taking into account that Lush is not a corporation, but it has founders who presumably are still in charge?

howmuchmningistoomuch · 11/11/2021 09:07

This is awful.

BelleOfTheProvince · 11/11/2021 08:44

www.google.com/amp/s/destroyyourbinder.tumblr.com/post/146632633924/i-talk-about-my-relationship-with-breast-binding/amp

This user actually describes it as self harm, very similar to cutting.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2021 08:16

As an example of the lack of information or the downplaying of negative effects, we can use the Nonsuch High School’s newsletter. The thread I posted the information from the links has been deleted (the existing one is a different one). But This is from Safe Schools Alliance.

This page contains a sidebar, added without any comment or context, titled “How Do I Bind Safely?”, with 3 links listed underneath.

A Nonsuch student clicking on A Guide To Binding Safely — Ygender will find information that tells her that breast-binding is empowering, good for mental health, and makes people happy.

The second link is a How-To guide: Binding Safely: Tips for All Body Types & Sizes | Point 5cc. This instructs girls with larger breasts in how to push “their tissue” out of the way before flattening it with a garment that is difficult to get on and should not be worn for more than 8 hours.

Both of the above links give very little detail on the negative side effects of binding, such as compressed or broken ribs, punctured or collapsed lungs, back pain, compression of the spine, damaged breast tissue, damaged blood vessels, blood clots, inflamed ribs, and even heart attacks.

The third link, to prideinpractice.org/articles/chest-binding-physician-guide/… acknowledges that there are side effects, but goes on to suggest that the solution to this can be to remove the breasts entirely:

safeschoolsallianceuk.net/2021/05/09/breast-binding-at-nonsuch-high/

This type of minimising of the effects is very common. This is why we keep getting posters telling us we are scaremongering and that we are haters and uneducated. Because these posters either have a vested interest to not acknowledge the harms or they have only read about it superficially from a biased media.

We have the right to be fucking angry about this!

Helleofabore · 11/11/2021 07:48

Have you seen what a binder can do

To be fair. I have only ever read it and never seen images. Even on duck duck go there are no images, no diagrams.

Simply just writing the words will not get the message across to a visual generation.

And it seems there is only that one study into the negative effects of binding too. Why?

  • any study into the negative effects of breast binding would have been seen as transphobic. Just as researching detransition rates is posited as transphobic.
  • if you have read Invisible Women you will know that medicine is often misogynistic in studying female health. This is no different. The rapid increase of use has meant many researchers are not aware of the need to produce research.

But, stick ‘negative health risks for breast binding’ into any search engine Look at what you get. You can’t tell me that technology giants are not complicit here. That lobby groups are not complicit here.

No wonder these girls don’t understand the harm they do. Adults have been very careful to hide that harm.

That brings me back to waiting to be educated by Kurt and others.

To tell us exactly how they would look directly into the eyes of their 11/12/13/14/15 year old daughter and tell them that there is x% (and numbers please Kurt) chance that they will desist from identifying as trans (ALL the genders under the umbrella, Kurt that bind) and that some people think that the large proportion (we know it IS a larger proportion that desists than persists) of girls damaging their breasts is acceptable collateral for the sake of others.

And that when they reach adulthood and lament their damaged bodies and health, it was all THEIR fault because other adults decided that they were old enough to understand the risks (those that are hidden on page gazillion of the search on the internet) and have autonomy over their harmful body decisions.

I will continue to wait for that evidence that I ask for. Because Kurt has insisted numerous times that we are uneducated and need to educate yourselves.

But… can only so far produce anecdotes that have nothing to do with this cohort of young females.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 11/11/2021 07:34

However you can get binders that aren't at all damaging to health, and if these binders aren't sold then teens will use other things to bind instead, and these could be REALLY damaging

I know it's counter-intuitive, but it's not actually certain that homemade methods would be worse.

extract

What people use to bind their chests with is a very personal choice, and finding a standard “best type of binder” for everyone is unclear. One study showed that people who used commercial binders experienced increased risk for the highest number of negative symptoms from binding, followed by those who used bandages, and plastic wrap or duct tape(2).

The high amount of negative effects found from commercial binders in this study were a surprise to the researchers, since blogs and other informal resources dedicated to trans men and healthy binding often recommend commercial binders (2,4). This could be due to people wearing binders that are too small, wearing them for longer periods, or wearing more than one at a time. More research is needed, but if you choose to wear a commercial binder, do your research, read reviews online, and make sure it is the right size for you.

[bold mine]

helloclue.com/articles/cycle-a-z/chest-binding-tips-and-tricks-for-trans-men-nonbinary-and-genderfluid

Whatwouldscullydo · 11/11/2021 07:30

Would they be minimising BRAs? Ie. Not binders

Funny how thousands of women are wearing the wrong size bras all the time. Every time I've ever tried to book a cra fit it's been several days before I can get a slot. All the major retailers are usually pretty fully booked with regards to fitting appointments.

All those women and girls who need measuring and re fitting and who have realised they aren't comfortable and wearing the wrong size.

And that, is with access to the time money and location to go get professionally measured/fitted. And thats also with someone who can see u. Who can check for you. And lay eyes on you in the bra.

Yet we are supoosed to simultaneously believe that kids without access to anyone to help them.besides a stranger on a web chat or phone who only has the words of a child to go on, will somehow get the right size amd perfect fit with no one buy a mate who may also be in the wrong size having git advice from more strangers on reddit.

Its amazing how anything related to this will always be a result of the most desirable collection of circumstances. Combinations of events and luck that people just buying a t shirt from amazon don't even always get.

Lostgirl78 · 11/11/2021 07:23

The answer is for us all to go get them and cut them up in front of the shop.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2021 07:19

However you can get binders that aren't at all damaging to health

Would they be minimising BRAs? Ie. Not binders.

If you came onto this thread and said that these girls don’t know there are harming themselves, well we could talk about the meaning of self harm.

Either way, these girls are choosing to wear binders or to bind in other ways and doing this to themselves.

Either way, the harm of these binders are being downplayed. By a group who either have a vested interest, or out of ignorance because they have not looked at the product themselves and have also read the same spoonfed lies from lobby groups.

Stop the minimising.

BloodinGutters · 11/11/2021 07:09

@emma342

Having read up on binders since my last post, I'd like to retract what I said about binders being healthy as they can be damaging to health. However you can get binders that aren't at all damaging to health, and if these binders aren't sold then teens will use other things to bind instead, and these could be REALLY damaging. I stand by everything I said about this use of the term self harm
Did you read all the research on the links on this thread?

The exact brand lush are promoting is the one that 97% of all wearers report health problems, including breathing so badly restricted they pass out, broken ribs, nipples detaching from breast tissue and chronic pain.

So a shop with zero medical training and zero safeguarding training is going to provide girls, who can not get these sent to their house, who can not get these binders exchanged if they aren’t correct fit, with the exact brand that causes all the above harm.

Thefartingsofaofdenmarkstreet · 11/11/2021 07:04

@emma342

What do you mean self harm??? You know, girls actually self harm. All the time. Cutting and burning and scratching, etc. Wearing a binder is not self harm. Do you know what a binder is? It's for your breasts, so for if girls want their breasts to look smaller or if non-binary teens born female want their breasts not to be visible. It's not self harm, binders that are made and sold by actual shops are designed not to restrict breathing or cause any health problems. If these binders aren't sold, teens do things like wrap bandages tightly round their breasts instead, which is harmful and unhealthy. Binders don't harm the teens in any way, and I actually find it offensive that you're using the term self harm to describe girls choosing to wear binders, as girls actually self harm, my daughter actually self harms, and I almost died from actually self harming. Please do your research.
How is painfully squashing your breasts so that they cant grow properly not self harm? Have you seen what a binder can do, how much it can actually flatten the breasts? That is physically impossible to do without harming the breasts over time. And what about getting your healthy breast tissue chopped off completely, self-harming or not? If not, why not? Because a surgeon has done it for you?

Also, how come 'non-binary' for males like Owen Hurcum means dyeing your hair green and sometimes 'femmeing up' by wearing a skirt, but for girls it means making possibly painful and irreversible changes to your body?

Whatwouldscullydo · 11/11/2021 06:57

Alcoholism is still alcoholism whether you drink a 600 pound bottle of 200 yr aged whisky a day or you sit on a park bench with a 6 pack of special brew having not showered in 2 weeks.

Its still drug addiction whether you shoot up with heroin or take too much of your dr prescribed pain killers.

Amd it's still self harm whether u use a rusty razor blade u found at the back of your grandma's cupboard or you buy a binder from someone who owns a website witg smiling happy people on it.

The form.with which the harm.takes place makes no difference .

That's what they all say. Mentally ill people who are in denial will say that their behaviour doesn't count as X because its different some how. Or someone has managed to convince you it's different somehow.

The end result is the same. The body is harmed. Doesn't matter how it happened. The fact ot may or may not be less harm than something else or some other way , doesn't mean its not harm either.

5 paracetamol at once is still an overdose . You may well be absolutely fine as a result but its no less an overdose than taking 10 or 20.

emma342 · 11/11/2021 01:07

Having read up on binders since my last post, I'd like to retract what I said about binders being healthy as they can be damaging to health. However you can get binders that aren't at all damaging to health, and if these binders aren't sold then teens will use other things to bind instead, and these could be REALLY damaging. I stand by everything I said about this use of the term self harm

emma342 · 11/11/2021 00:59

What do you mean self harm??? You know, girls actually self harm. All the time. Cutting and burning and scratching, etc. Wearing a binder is not self harm. Do you know what a binder is? It's for your breasts, so for if girls want their breasts to look smaller or if non-binary teens born female want their breasts not to be visible. It's not self harm, binders that are made and sold by actual shops are designed not to restrict breathing or cause any health problems. If these binders aren't sold, teens do things like wrap bandages tightly round their breasts instead, which is harmful and unhealthy. Binders don't harm the teens in any way, and I actually find it offensive that you're using the term self harm to describe girls choosing to wear binders, as girls actually self harm, my daughter actually self harms, and I almost died from actually self harming. Please do your research.

334bu · 10/11/2021 23:45

Purgatory there are really no words are thereSad

Pawprintpaper · 10/11/2021 22:24

@autisticMNer

My daughters have autism. In the increase of over 5000% of girls being referred to Tavistock, 35% are already diagnosed with autism. Compared to less than 1% of the general population with autism. Girls Will autism are just as disproportionately represented in the thousands of detransers out there

NC but regular poster, and apologies for a far too long post.

I have autism and I think if I was a teenager/child today I would be described as having dysmorphia and would be put on the transition pathway, very likely given puberty blockers. I really struggled with puberty and body changes and I still don't feel comfortable about my breasts even in middle age. Menopause was an incredible relief. Even after years of counselling and soul-searching, I'd have a mastectomy if it was safe and easy, and I think if I was younger I'd identify as nonbinary.

I don't see myself as trans or nonbinary for two reasons. Firstly I can see how autism has affected the way I see my body and made puberty and periods particularly hard to deal with, mainly because I find change and sensory issues difficult. Secondly I was lucky enough to grow up in the era of second wave feminism and have seen the personal as political for as long as I can remember, and I've always had an awareness that my issues with the physicality of womanhood are connected to the wider difficulty of being a woman in a patriarchal, sexist society. My discomfort is part of a much wider issue of women changing themselves to fit in with social expectations and pressures, whether that's to be more feminine (breast implants, hair removal) or, in the case of binding, to try and opt out of those expectations.

Only someone with no political awarenes could see breast binding as all about personal choice and feelings, when it's absolutely plain that there are larger issues at play. You just have to look at two points that have been raised here again and again: that far more girls than boys are identifying out of their biological sex, and secondly the expectations of being trans are clearly different for MTF than FTM so that a pp can say that 'transmen do not want breasts' when it would be transphobic to say something like 'transwomen don't want to have beards.'

So, that's a longwinded way to say that this is very much an issue that everyone in society is entitled to discuss and feel concern about, particularly those who are involved in safeguarding children, including all parents. It is not just a personal issue for the individuals concerned.

The other huge issue here is mental health support and the glaring inappropriateness of a service for teens with major MH issues being offered in a shop by people with absolutely no MH training or safeguarding awareness. To me Lush is a particularly awful choice because I've had the experience in more than one branch of them deliberately taking my young daughter aside from me and putting products in her basket without my consent, and this has happened to so many people I know that I believe they must train staff to do this.

Finally, I feel very strongly that whatever reasons are behind issues like binding and identifying out of womanhood, the common help would be putting a lot more resources into good quality mental health care for children and young people, not the shamefully underfunded services we have now. This would help girls who just need a lot of support to get through adolescence, but would also help those who do end up transitioning. If Lush cares about the girls it profits from, a better way to demonstrate that would be to donate some of their profits to young people's mental health services or good quality research into understanding dysmorphia.

Brilliant, thoughtful post. Thank you
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 10/11/2021 22:21

Yeah. Me too.

For those using a screen-reader, here's the text.

I think I broke my nipple
That's the only way I can think to explain it.

I've been using chest binders since 2018, some safe and some not. My current binder is from gc2b, and it's getting worn out and less effective. As a result, I've had to shove and squish my chest tissue more and more every day just to make it so my binder can actually work. I often end up with crushed nipples, but usually it's better when I take it off at the end of the day. Last night I was sitting at my computer, and for whatever reason I touched my right nipple. It felt... loose? It's still attached to my body and I still have sensation in it, but when I pinch it, it feels like the top part of the nipple isn't connected to the rest of the breast. There's no pain, it just feels loose and, for lack of any better term, flaccid.

A million apologies if this isn't the right place to post this. I chose this sub because I'm positive it has something to do with binding and the fact that I was manhandling things. I just want to know if this is something serious that I should get looked at, I don't really want my nipple to fall off.

(edit: formatting)

foxgoosefinch · 10/11/2021 22:13

Oh my god purgatory I feel nauseous and need a lie down after reading that! Shock

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 10/11/2021 22:10

I've seen a lot of references in this thread to nipple damage, and I think I now know what's being referred to.

Wouldn't you know, it involves the exact brand of binder that female teens will be able to obtain from this branch of Lush.

AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to self harm?
PurgatoryOfPotholes · 10/11/2021 20:56

They aren’t. I’ve looked at the post and they are providing a place where people can pick up a binder. They aren’t providing the advice gender swap (?) are. If you found a binder in oxfam would you attack oxfam?

As I used to work in an Oxfam, sorting and pricing donations, I would be very unimpressed if such an item got put on the shop floor.

Charity shops have to comply with legislation. We could not sell electrical items without having it safety tested. We could not sell secondhand soft toys that didn't have labels confirming that they comply with EU health and safety legislation. We couldn't sell secondhand water floatation devices like children's armbands in case there was damage, because we could be responsible for a child drowning.

Selling secondhand binders never came up while I was there, but I think the answer should be a big nope!

Skatastic · 10/11/2021 20:52

This is literally my worst nightmare come true. My kid is trans and has caused an unbelievable amount of arguments about wanting a binder, and he would seize on this given half the chance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread