Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think a soap shop shouldn't be encouraging young girls to self harm?

544 replies

Elleexxtra · 09/11/2021 12:23

Lush Paddington are giving out binders, meaning girls can self harm without any danger of their parents knowing and being able to discuss potential issues with them.

www.instagram.com/lushpaddington/

AIBU to think young girls shouldn't be groomed to hate their bodies?

OP posts:
Doubletoilandtrouble · 09/11/2021 19:39

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

QueenSue · 09/11/2021 19:28

misandry on MN these days is absolutely abhorrent
Okay that made me snort Grin
There have always been men compaining about this site. In fact, some men had such big problems with it that they sent a swat team to the founder, Justine's home.
Now that is actually abhorrent behaviour.
www.theguardian.com/media/2015/aug/19/armed-police-mumsnet-justine-roberts-swatting-attack-hoax-call

BloodinGutters · 09/11/2021 19:14

@CityMumma78

KurtWilde I think you’ll find that the vast majority of people on MUMSNET are parents with a very real and genuine concern over the safety, health and well-being of their children. Binders are physically damaging, end of story. The good people of MUMSNET are well within their rights to discuss this and raise concerns without being accused of transphobia which is clearly your only argument!!
The good people of mumsnet should be a copy righted term!

It’s awesome!!

user1471447863 · 09/11/2021 19:01

@Helleofabore 5 out of a friendship group of 7 is a scary statistic. Too many organisations are pushing this agenda onto confused and impressionable children. Rather than saying we will help you change who you are they should be saying it's normal to be confused or unsure of who you are & we will help you discover, understand and accept who you are.

(many) Teen girls have always had a rebellious/self destruct/cry for help/attention phase - remember when they all had eating disorders/self harmed/teen pregnancies/then they were all gay/ then bi and now being trans (and half a dozen other letters of the BLT alphabet) is the thing. Organisations should be helping them through this phase of their development not promoting harmful body damage.

lazylinguist · 09/11/2021 18:54

One of the most important things to a trans person is passing as the gender they identify as.There are some people on this thread who could do with educating themselves.

I think you'll find most of the women on this board are pretty well educated on these matters. Some people seem to use 'poorly educated ' as a synonym for 'does not agree with me'.

Affirming very young women in their desire to do something which will damage their body and health, and which they will probably regret, in the name of 'passing' is incredibly irresponsible, not least because they are very unlikely to pass anyway.

FortunesFavour · 09/11/2021 18:49

Haven’t been in this rank smelling shop for years anyway and I’m not surprised to see they are continuing their corporate strategy of pushing gender identity politics rather than focusing on selling soap. This is a company that couldn’t give a shiny shit. about ethics or the welfare of their customers. Hope they get sued for their irresponsible promotion of this harmful practice.

CityMumma78 · 09/11/2021 18:45

KurtWilde
I think you’ll find that the vast majority of people on MUMSNET are parents with a very real and genuine concern over the safety, health and well-being of their children. Binders are physically damaging, end of story. The good people of MUMSNET are well within their rights to discuss this and raise concerns without being accused of transphobia which is clearly your only argument!!

Elleexxtra · 09/11/2021 18:44

they've gone through and deleted all of the critical comments. Dissenting voices expressing concern have no place in the narrative.

This is worth remembering, it distorts the narrative

OP posts:
CampagVelocet · 09/11/2021 18:41

@CityMumma78

I have been following this all afternoon and seen that the comments on their Instagram post are overwhelming negative yet anything that goes against this narrative is being deleted!
Yes, they've gone through and deleted all of the critical comments. Dissenting voices expressing concern have no place in the narrative.
Helleofabore · 09/11/2021 18:40

@Helleofabore

It is not so unusual Eishet when you start to have conversations with some mature male transitioners who like to ignore completely or to downplay the significantly higher negative health effects that medicalised transition has for females compared to males.

Once you start a conversation about it, they will bring in their supposedly healthy adult trans men friends and will continue to ignore the research into puberty blockers and their known effects on female bodies when used for precocious puberty. And the known effects of testosterone to the female body. Including the atrophy that leads to very early hysterectomies and the recent health studies indicating that very early dementia is an known effect of early hysterectomies.

Those people who are advocating for puberty blockers and early access to cross sex hormones often ignore these already well documented effects.

The fact that they are complicit in sexist discrimination on the basis of different health risks in what they are campaigning for, is uncomfortable to admit.

Young females are being let down because of institutes such as GIDS and their proven extremely poor record tracking. They have been let down because of 'no debate' blocked discussion for so long about the rapid and overwhelming increase in the young female transitioners. They have been let down with the constant dismissing of detransitioners, their stories and their numbers.

And they are being let down because activists continue to campaign, not for young females to accept their bodies (like the mature males get to keep their penises), not to rapidly improve mental health care to allow exploration of this cohort's mental health needs to treat underlying comorbidities (because that could constitute as 'conversion') but for young females to aspire to flatten their breasts in the same style of relief as cutting and food control.

TLDR: young females who have poor mental health about their bodies, should be receiving intensive mental health care to assist them with accepting that whatever their 'gender' their body shape is acceptable and they should accept their natural body shape. Not be handed binders and told, falsely, they are harmless.

To be clear MNHQ, I do mean SOME.

We know that not all trans people are campaigning for this. We even have had them post often on our threads.

Helleofabore · 09/11/2021 18:39

There are some people on this thread who could do with educating themselves.

Actually, I think that the person here who needs 'educating' is you. We are talking about children here. Girls. Females under the age of 18.

Helleofabore · 09/11/2021 18:37

@KurtWilde

The outright transphobia and misandry on MN these days is absolutely abhorrent.
Please do report transphobia. MNHQ will not let that remain standing at all.
Elleexxtra · 09/11/2021 18:35

@KurtWilde
This isn't about trans people who absolutely should get the health care and support they need, whatever that means for them as an individual.

This is about a SOAP company pushing harmful trendy binders on teenage/preteen girls, most of whom are not actually trans

OP posts:
MonsignorMirth · 09/11/2021 18:35

@MonsignorMirth

They bind so they can wear T-shirt's and tops and pass better as men How are you defining "men" here, specifically *@KurtWilde*? For breasts to be at all relevant, your definition must include some notion of male-sexed bodies. Think, if you can, about how transphobic this is and how it conflates sex and gender in a transphobic way.
Can you answer this, *@KurtWilde* ? How are you defining "men" ?
IslaPineappple · 09/11/2021 18:35

Wow. I'm going to give them a miss for all the Christmas presents I usually buy there

FourTeaFallOut · 09/11/2021 18:34

Transphobia and misandry for caring about the physical well-being of girls and the cascade of unintended consequences when a soap company decides to treat gender dysphoria to hit the right marketing vibe? ConfusedHmm

War is peace.
Freedom is slavery.
Ignorance is strength.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 09/11/2021 18:32

KurtWilde

Ah, the illusion of choice in a patriarchal society. Young women used to choose to apply lead to their faces, too.

Do you know what feminism is for? Well for me, it's always been about supporting people born female to resist the social pressures on them to change their body. No-one needs a self-styled "rights" movement to support them to change their body- patriarchy and capitalism dothat. I want young female people to have as much freedom as male people do to live in their bodies as they are.

Helleofabore · 09/11/2021 18:30

It is not so unusual Eishet when you start to have conversations with some mature male transitioners who like to ignore completely or to downplay the significantly higher negative health effects that medicalised transition has for females compared to males.

Once you start a conversation about it, they will bring in their supposedly healthy adult trans men friends and will continue to ignore the research into puberty blockers and their known effects on female bodies when used for precocious puberty. And the known effects of testosterone to the female body. Including the atrophy that leads to very early hysterectomies and the recent health studies indicating that very early dementia is an known effect of early hysterectomies.

Those people who are advocating for puberty blockers and early access to cross sex hormones often ignore these already well documented effects.

The fact that they are complicit in sexist discrimination on the basis of different health risks in what they are campaigning for, is uncomfortable to admit.

Young females are being let down because of institutes such as GIDS and their proven extremely poor record tracking. They have been let down because of 'no debate' blocked discussion for so long about the rapid and overwhelming increase in the young female transitioners. They have been let down with the constant dismissing of detransitioners, their stories and their numbers.

And they are being let down because activists continue to campaign, not for young females to accept their bodies (like the mature males get to keep their penises), not to rapidly improve mental health care to allow exploration of this cohort's mental health needs to treat underlying comorbidities (because that could constitute as 'conversion') but for young females to aspire to flatten their breasts in the same style of relief as cutting and food control.

TLDR: young females who have poor mental health about their bodies, should be receiving intensive mental health care to assist them with accepting that whatever their 'gender' their body shape is acceptable and they should accept their natural body shape. Not be handed binders and told, falsely, they are harmless.

BlackAlys · 09/11/2021 18:29

@KurtWilde

The outright transphobia and misandry on MN these days is absolutely abhorrent.
Report it if you see it.
Welcometothejingles · 09/11/2021 18:27

www.persuasion.community/p/keira-bell-my-story

Read this.

KurtWilde · 09/11/2021 18:26

The outright transphobia and misandry on MN these days is absolutely abhorrent.

CityMumma78 · 09/11/2021 18:25

I have been following this all afternoon and seen that the comments on their Instagram post are overwhelming negative yet anything that goes against this narrative is being deleted!

KurtWilde · 09/11/2021 18:24

@EishetChayil

Funny how transwomen can keep their knobs and call them "lady dicks" but young transmen have to flatten their breasts and have double mastectomies.
They don't HAVE to, they CHOOSE to. Just like a transwoman chooses to grow breasts through hormone therapy, and go through other forms of feminisation that can be painful and uncomfortable.

One of the most important things to a trans person is passing as the gender they identify as.

There are some people on this thread who could do with educating themselves.

BlackAlys · 09/11/2021 18:22

And for anyone on this thread who thinks these are harmless, I taught a trans boy last year who was unable to sit comfortably at a school desk, was unable to walk the school site and do PE, was on constant pain and breathlessness, because of wearing a binder.

I reported it so many times to safeguarding - this child was in dire straits with breathing most of the time, but was met with a shrug and a 'what can we do'? attitude. Safeguarding crawls all over our pupils with ED's or pupils that used to 'cut', but this is seen as allowing pupils to express themselves.

FFS I despair.

BlackAlys · 09/11/2021 18:19

@EishetChayil

Funny how transwomen can keep their knobs and call them "lady dicks" but young transmen have to flatten their breasts and have double mastectomies.
Indeed.
Swipe left for the next trending thread