Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think colleague shouldn’t be on permanent WFH due to his DW’s Covid risk?

208 replies

oober6 · 09/11/2021 10:28

As in the title really.

The world has opened up, social distancing requirements have gone, vaccines have given us all plenty of protection.

We are key workers who have worked throughout, coming into work every day. I would love to be able to WFH! It would be a lot less pressurised, and of course, no commute etc.

AIBU to think management should now be telling our colleague that he has to start coming back into work? He is healthy and fit.

OP posts:
BadlyFormedQuestion · 09/11/2021 12:02

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also to add if the family are living their normal lives then surely he can come in to work. This fraudulent behaviour definitely creates ill will.

Unlike the mental health thread Covid is just exposure so if you don’t want to be exposed in one location it doesn’t make sense for you to go and be exposed everywhere else does it?

How does everyone know so much about his family?

And… it’s perfectly possible the thd WFH adjustment is clothing to do with covid but that’s a convenient story to give you all (since you feel that you’re owed an explanation). Maybe it’s an adjustment because of mental health issues or something else.

You just don’t know because that’s between him and whoever has agreed the adjustment (which may be above your manager, and they’ve just been told that this is the adjustment they need to accommodate).

The colleague with the adjustment is a total red herring here (and a useful scapegoat). The problem is poor management of workload.

It’s may well be discriminatory to have a situation where the management failings are causing resentment and vilification of a colleague with an adjustment.

Kitkat151 · 09/11/2021 12:02

@TractorAndHeadphones

Hmm. If WFH is allowed for one person it should be allowed for all of you. This is what you should raise with your manager!

If manager says that no because your workload will suffer say that you’ve all been doing X’s work.

But it’s still unfair if one person is allowed to WFh and others aren’t

One rule for all cannot exist iN the workplace ....not in theU.K. anyway.....People have rights....people are protected by law for having certain characteristics.......I myself am protected by disability discrimination law.....my manager makes reasonable adjustments so that I can continue to work.....yes this does mean I don’t do the same as others .....because I am not in the office I don’t know if people comment and if they do then I’m not there to hear it..my manager is great
Sausagedogsarethebest · 09/11/2021 12:00

@WildExcuses

Keep your beak out.
Some people on here are so rude!
ColinTheKoala · 09/11/2021 12:00

OP, if your colleague were self-employed, he wouldn't still be WFH. He's only doing it because he can get away with it while everyone else has to crack on

if he were self-employed he probably would do because he'd be in charge of his own work and working pattern. And if eg he needed to go into other peoples' houses he could arrange mitigations such as asking them to open windows, wear masks and keep their distance.

catgirl1976 · 09/11/2021 11:59

YAB massively U. Your colleagues circumstances are none of your business.

If you have issues with your workload or how work is being allocated to you speak to your manager.

If you want to WFH put a case to your manager of make a flexible working request.

If you just want your colleague to be dragged into work and put his wife at risk because you think Covid should be over now and a bit of Great British pluck should sort it all out and it’s not fair then I hope I never have the misfortune to work with you.

suspiria777 · 09/11/2021 11:58

@oober6 just because she isn't in that "most vulnerable" group (less than 1% of the population) she could still be extremely vulnerable. For example, my sister is in her 30s and she's still WFH and thank fuck she is, because she's had anorexia for almost 20 years and weighs less than a healthy 11 year old. (And no, she's not 4 feet tall her BMI is in the low teens).
Are you jealous because you want to work from home? Or annoyed that your colleague doesn't want to actively endanger his wife?

God, people are awful.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 09/11/2021 11:57

Normal work in my department :
Taking 999 calls, talking to distressed members of the public (often suicidal), talking to the public all day long over a 24/7 period. While being hassled to work faster by management, constantly pushed to take one more call before being allowed a break, having to ask permission to get up.
WFH in my department :
Copying abd pasting emails onto logs which you then pass to someone in the office to call back or action; work at a leisurely pace with no manager breathing down your neck; no interaction with distressed or angry members of the public as you have no phone; work whatever hours suit you.

I wonder why people get miffed 🤔

godmum56 · 09/11/2021 11:56

I have been both a manager and an employee and have never understood the picking up slack thing. If you are working as hard as you should be then either you can't "pick up slack" or it requires extra hours which should be paid for or some less important stuff has to be dropped....basically if the business is running as it should be then any slack is minimal. If you are missing out on breaks which are part of your t and c or going home late/arriving early then that needs to be addressed.....but as someone who managed a very busy tightly staffed NHS service, I'd have LOVED to know where all the resource comes from to pick up slack?

TractorAndHeadphones · 09/11/2021 11:56

Also to add if the family are living their normal lives then surely he can come in to work. This fraudulent behaviour definitely creates ill will.

Unlike the mental health thread Covid is just exposure so if you don’t want to be exposed in one location it doesn’t make sense for you to go and be exposed everywhere else does it?

LolaSmiles · 09/11/2021 11:55

I know! AIBU is a strange beast, I am sure there have been similar exasperated colleague threads before which were entirely more sympathetic
I think it's because there is a world of difference between someone moaning about their colleague's situation whilst saying they're jealous and would rather WFH, and someone saying they're frustrated by poor management and poor allocation of workload.

Anyone who says they're frustrated by their managers and how workload is allocated is probably going to get support and encouragement to speak to their manager about it. Anyone who has a good old moan that their colleague should be told to come into the office because they aren't allowed to WFH sounds petty and understandably people tell them to mind their own business.

SickAndTiredAgain · 09/11/2021 11:54

If there are workload concerns, raise them with your manager in the same way you would if you were understaffed, or a colleague was on maternity leave.
The work is the issue for the manager to solve, they may choose to solve that by bringing the employee back from wfh because they realise it isn’t working, or they may choose to solve it another way. Or they may choose to ignore it because they’re a shit manager. Either way, it’s down to them, and if they choose to ignore it, then you have bigger problems than a colleague wfh, because you have a very poor manager and that always causes other problems.

TractorAndHeadphones · 09/11/2021 11:54

@mrsm43s no no that’s not what I meant.

If manager goes : everyone else must be in the office, except for X WFH. The logical conclusion is that X won’t be able to perform optimally because if he was able to while WFH everyone else should be able to WFH.

Therefore allowing X WFH should involve a discussion about how the rest of his workload will be distributed.

In many cases however everyone CAN WFH. The manager just doesn’t want to let them! Because it’s not company policy, because they have a lease on the building or whatever. This is what can cause resentment.

What has happened in the OP’s case is that manager seems to not acknowledge the impact that WFH has and this is what she should target. But the above are two general cases

BadlyFormedQuestion · 09/11/2021 11:54

It’s not just individual bad managers either. Usually it’s a culture within an organisation and managers are often hamstrung by it. Or just having questioned it.

But the very well paid people at the top should be doing their absolute best to make sure this shit isn’t happening.

BadlyFormedQuestion · 09/11/2021 11:52

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also I love how people here live in an ideal world where the perfect manager has agreed on something between them, in the best interests of the employee.

Life is unfair a lot of the time and many managers CBA deal with troublemakers as long as someone else picks up the slack.

Bad management…

Do you what, employers would prefer you to all be resenting and blaming each other other, rather than putting the blame where it actually lies.

Making adjustments for individual circumstances and balancing out the workload in a way that does not overload everyone (while maintaining colleagues rights to privacy) are management issues.

In a well managed organisation, there shouldn’t be these resentments and issues.

Meandmini3 · 09/11/2021 11:48

Raise your own workload concerns with your manager. That’s your issue.

TractorAndHeadphones · 09/11/2021 11:48

Also I love how people here live in an ideal world where the perfect manager has agreed on something between them, in the best interests of the employee.

Life is unfair a lot of the time and many managers CBA deal with troublemakers as long as someone else picks up the slack.

mrsm43s · 09/11/2021 11:48

@TractorAndHeadphones

Hmm. If WFH is allowed for one person it should be allowed for all of you. This is what you should raise with your manager!

If manager says that no because your workload will suffer say that you’ve all been doing X’s work.

But it’s still unfair if one person is allowed to WFh and others aren’t

I 100% disagree with this.

It is perfectly reasonable (and legally required in some cases) to make adjustments to working practices in order to accommodate different people's circumstances.

E.g. we don't say "because a pregnant woman gets lighter duties, everyone should do lighter duties" or "because the person in the wheelchair gets to use the customer lift instead of the stairs, we should all be allowed to use the customer lift" etc.

It is reasonable for people to make adjustments for specific staff because of their circumstances, which is what is happening here.

TheKeatingFive · 09/11/2021 11:48

If he and the whole slew of his family are well enough to be out and about, here, there and everywhere - then he can get his ass in to work like everybody else

I do agree with this.

It's one thing if people are genuinely shielding. Quite another if they're living life as normal apart from working.

Thewiseoneincognito · 09/11/2021 11:47

OP things may have ‘opened up’ but we are far far far away from it being ‘safe’ for certain people. Shielding has not ended for everyone so I would gently suggest you enlighten yourself a little bit more on your naivety on issues regarding the current Covid situation.

I think overall it’s a case of mind your own business. If you can not manage your work load then you should speak with your manager, the WFH colleague is not your concern.

BadlyFormedQuestion · 09/11/2021 11:46

@TheKeatingFive

The double standards and unfairness is pissing me off enough that I'm job hunting.

People are being very naive if they think this isn't causing resentment. Good luck with the job hunting.

As is so often the case, people are misdiagnosing the problem.

The resentment is not being caused by some people being able to WFH. It’s being caused by poor management.

That’s the problem and it’s endemic.

TractorAndHeadphones · 09/11/2021 11:46

@IamtheDevilsAvocado

If you are going to raise it with manageme t be VERY clear about what is your stuff.

What your colleague's health status or his family is stuff all to do with you. It could be because of her or his health.

I'm in exactly this position... I'm ECV my GP has said if I catch covid I'm at risk of dying. I look OK.

My partner has been wfh for 20 months... Some of his colleagues are in... Some are irritated....partenrs boss has told partners team, he is not breaking confidentiality over reasons for him wfh.

It does not impact his work at ALL... In fact he works through his commuting time.

But if WFH doesn’t impact his work at all - why can’t everyone WFH? I suspect this is the source of OP’s frustration.

It’s not thé colleagues fault, it’s management and she’s looking at it the wrong way. But if everyone is forced into the office for performance reasons then logically the person at home is getting away with less work.

In which case management should still bear the brunt and hire a temp or whatever (not dump it on the OP).

oober6 · 09/11/2021 11:46

@GiantHaystacks2021

Tough crowd in here tonight. YANBU. At all.

If he and the whole slew of his family are well enough to be out and about, here, there and everywhere - then he can get his ass in to work like everybody else.

I know! AIBU is a strange beast, I am sure there have been similar exasperated colleague threads before which were entirely more sympathetic. Wink
OP posts:
WeAllHaveWings · 09/11/2021 11:44

[quote oober6]@BadlyFormedQuestion he has been very open about it actually.

I just wonder when the end point is?[/quote]
For your colleague "the end point" isn't when you decide.

He and his manager have had a discussion and come to an agreement which is non of your business.

Your ONLY issue is the impact it has on you, and if you do have an issue with that impact speak to your manager about it and see what can be put in place to resolve it.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 09/11/2021 11:44

Tough crowd in here tonight.
YANBU.
At all.

If he and the whole slew of his family are well enough to be out and about, here, there and everywhere - then he can get his ass in to work like everybody else.

HitchhikersGuide · 09/11/2021 11:43

I think that we need to just get on with life or accept that some are so badly propagandised into insanity that they will never be able to rejoin the world and perhaps employers need to make adjustments to enable wfh forever where possible. A sort of two tier Covid society?! Might make it less stressful for everyone?!