Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think colleague shouldn’t be on permanent WFH due to his DW’s Covid risk?

208 replies

oober6 · 09/11/2021 10:28

As in the title really.

The world has opened up, social distancing requirements have gone, vaccines have given us all plenty of protection.

We are key workers who have worked throughout, coming into work every day. I would love to be able to WFH! It would be a lot less pressurised, and of course, no commute etc.

AIBU to think management should now be telling our colleague that he has to start coming back into work? He is healthy and fit.

OP posts:
Mybalconyiscracking · 09/11/2021 13:19

Why not mind your own beeswax OP?

BadlyFormedQuestion · 09/11/2021 13:16

@oober6

Yes, general shielding has been stopped, but doctors/consultants continue to give individual advice according to the severity of their patient's health condition, and many people have been told to continue to shield by their doctor/consultant. *@user1497207191*

I absolutely agree. That said, in this situation:

  • the DW isn't continuing to shield
  • the children go to school
  • my colleague and his DW go shopping
  • my colleague and his DW go on day trips etc

...yet my colleague doesn't think he should work in the office?! Hmm

But you have no idea what the actual reason for the WFH adjustment is. You have been told it’s because his wife has a health condition but you don’t know that for certain. It might be what feels like a public reason he feels he can give rather than the truth.

He doesn’t have to tell you anything about why he’s WFH. He might feel he needs to give a reason though because of the way everyone is being about it.

A permanent WFH adjustment is not necessarily easy to secure. There is a reason and you shouldn’t assume that you are privy to it.

Tabitha005 · 09/11/2021 13:14

I don't think you're being in the least unreasonable to think your colleague may be getting some kind preferential treatment - at least, from your account of the situation, that's sort of what it sounds like he's getting.

I'd probably be asking questions of management as to why I shouldn't be able to WFH at least some of the time. In fact, I think a lot more people who'd like to WFH at least some of the time should be making a lot more noise about it to their employers. Covid has proved WFH doesn't affect productivity, but there's still plenty of employers who automatically assume people are going to be skiving off if they allow it.

A better work/life balance, without long and expensive commutes can be so much more beneficial for both employers and employees.

Covidworries · 09/11/2021 13:12

To be fair, in most cases it has been made clear children have to be in school regardless of CEV children or family memberz. Shielded families have been completely shafted.

During shielding we werent meant to go anywhere, shielding people were even meant to avoid household members.
Now numbers are as high as ever, no social distancing, one way systems are ignored. Most people not masked. School is compulsory.

The risk to CEV hasnt changed. The hospitals are extremely busy so if we need medical care its unknown if the care will be there. And often we get to read lovely comments that its only CEV that are dying so it doesnt matter.

CEV doesnt mean they are about to drop dead with or without covid. It doesnt mean they are old. My child is CEV and should under normal circumstances live a long and full life. But if covid kills the child they will be written off as oh it was only someone vulnerble.

You can not know the full extent of the situation or whythe managers have agreed. But either way if you have issues with this take it upwith management.

saraclara · 09/11/2021 13:08

@TheKeatingFive

If he and the whole slew of his family are well enough to be out and about, here, there and everywhere - then he can get his ass in to work like everybody else

I do agree with this.

It's one thing if people are genuinely shielding. Quite another if they're living life as normal apart from working.

Yep. I changed my mind completely when I read that the whole family are out and about, going on days out and shopping (as well as the kids being in school).

It seems like only work is the problem for the colleague. Which makes no sense.

I doubt that all the posters telling OP to mind her own business would be quite so sanguine in her position. The wife can't be as vulnerable as people make out, if she goes shopping and for days out, and isn't in the third vaccine cohort.

I do get that it must be difficult for management to say no to someone who declares that his wife is CEV. But they do need to have another conversation with him if he's being entirely open about taking all the risks of life (along with his wife), bar working in the office.

UltimateBugKilla · 09/11/2021 13:05

Your way too invested in your colleagues life, what gives you the right to delve into his life like this, you don't need to know anything about him.

Take a step back!! You scratch the surface on his life and think you can pass judgment!

Your employer also doesn't have to disclose any information about what they have agreed with him either.

Complain and let your colleagues know who you are too!

SirChenjins · 09/11/2021 13:02

Make a formal complaint @oober6 - it's the only way you'll get beyond your bitterness.

And once COVID is over you could make similar complaints about colleagues who come in late, or who take longer lunch breaks than they should, or who go out for cigarette breaks, or who make long personal phone calls, or who have 'collaborative meetings' with colleagues over coffee while they chat about their families, or who don't answer as many emails as you, or any of the myriad of other things we all experience in the actual physical office. You'll feel so much better for it.

oober6 · 09/11/2021 12:57

Yes, general shielding has been stopped, but doctors/consultants continue to give individual advice according to the severity of their patient's health condition, and many people have been told to continue to shield by their doctor/consultant. @user1497207191

I absolutely agree. That said, in this situation:

  • the DW isn't continuing to shield
  • the children go to school
  • my colleague and his DW go shopping
  • my colleague and his DW go on day trips etc

...yet my colleague doesn't think he should work in the office?! Hmm

OP posts:
Nero2021 · 09/11/2021 12:56

Bit odd that you apparently know the ins and outs of his wife’s exact health status down to what vaccines she’s been offered, them taking their kids on days out etc Confused

His personal family circumstances are none of your business. It also comes across as though you are jealous of him for having a vulnerable family member which I’m sure isn’t a hill you want to die on, unless of course you regularly get the hump when people worse off than you are given circumstantial privileges to make their lives easier.

user1497207191 · 09/11/2021 12:56

@LaurenKelsey

I’m older now and retired, so all of those frustrating (and in retrospect, often petty) work situations are behind me. I’m not trying to be preachy; I just know that I would have been much happier if I had always focused on my own role and responsibilities and let everything else slide right off my back.
Indeed, a much healthier outlook to concentrate on your own position/work and not dwell on others. If it bothers the OP so much, they're free to get a different job.

It's what I did when I was expected to cover for a pregnant colleague who my employer wouldn't replace/cover with a temp. I covered her maternity leave, but when she decided to come back part time only and the employer still wouldn't provide a replacement/temp for the hours she no longer worked, I got another job and handed in my notice.

UltimateBugKilla · 09/11/2021 12:55

Its between management and the employee, keep your nose out of their business!!

Summerfun54321 · 09/11/2021 12:55

Please please please can people wait until the booster programme for high risk individuals has finished before posting stuff like this. It’s fake news that everyone is fully vaccinated and protected right now. Loads of us with health conditions have waning immunity and are facing high covid rates at a time when no one gives a shit about us or our circumstances. Just let us finish getting our booster vaccines before you start slagging us off.

oober6 · 09/11/2021 12:53

@DaphneDeloresMoorhead

Normal work in my department : Taking 999 calls, talking to distressed members of the public (often suicidal), talking to the public all day long over a 24/7 period. While being hassled to work faster by management, constantly pushed to take one more call before being allowed a break, having to ask permission to get up. WFH in my department : Copying abd pasting emails onto logs which you then pass to someone in the office to call back or action; work at a leisurely pace with no manager breathing down your neck; no interaction with distressed or angry members of the public as you have no phone; work whatever hours suit you.

I wonder why people get miffed 🤔

This is the kind of difference that exists between WFH and non-WFH in my office.

Flowers to you @DaphneDeloresMoorhead, you are amazing.

OP posts:
user1497207191 · 09/11/2021 12:53

@Hiddlestom

YANBU, this would wind me up too.

We require a minimum of 4 team members (out of 10) on site every day, so we have a rota so we take it in terms. Apart from one woman whose child is ECV (but still attends school!!), who says in order to minimise any additional risk, she wants to WFH, so she's not on our rota.

She gets to drop her kids at school every day at 8:50 and be home by 9am to log on, thereby saving herself the cost of breakfast club that she used to have to pay when we were in the office, and she takes "lunch" at 3-4 so she can collect her kids and bring them home and give them a snack, then works 4-5pm (with her kids in the house). So she saves herself the cost of after school club too. I pay £60 a day in wraparound care for my kids because I'm in the office - if I was allowed to WFH I'd be £300 a week better off!!! So no wonder she wants to keep wfh, but it feels so so unfair.

So you'd prefer to have your own child with ECV then would you?

Their child might go to school, but do you know if any special precautions are being taken by the school to protect the child?

MrsTulipTattsyrup · 09/11/2021 12:53

@Hiddlestom

YANBU, this would wind me up too.

We require a minimum of 4 team members (out of 10) on site every day, so we have a rota so we take it in terms. Apart from one woman whose child is ECV (but still attends school!!), who says in order to minimise any additional risk, she wants to WFH, so she's not on our rota.

She gets to drop her kids at school every day at 8:50 and be home by 9am to log on, thereby saving herself the cost of breakfast club that she used to have to pay when we were in the office, and she takes "lunch" at 3-4 so she can collect her kids and bring them home and give them a snack, then works 4-5pm (with her kids in the house). So she saves herself the cost of after school club too. I pay £60 a day in wraparound care for my kids because I'm in the office - if I was allowed to WFH I'd be £300 a week better off!!! So no wonder she wants to keep wfh, but it feels so so unfair.

Her child deserves an education. This should be the highest priority for all children, even if a risk comes with it.

After that, it’s the right thing to do to minimise all other risks as much as possible. The fewer chances someone vulnerable has to encounter the virus, the less is their chance of contracting it.

Would you prefer to be allowed to work from home because your child has a high possibility of becoming seriously ill or dying? Or would you rather have a healthy child and do your work from another building instead?

LaurenKelsey · 09/11/2021 12:51

I’m older now and retired, so all of those frustrating (and in retrospect, often petty) work situations are behind me. I’m not trying to be preachy; I just know that I would have been much happier if I had always focused on my own role and responsibilities and let everything else slide right off my back.

SirChenjins · 09/11/2021 12:50

Yes - so unfair she has a child who is ECV.

FFS.

LyricalBlowToTheJaw · 09/11/2021 12:48

If this colleague is not being as productive as their colleagues because they are WFH, then it's an issue and it is the posters business.

The problem with this is that even if we were to accept the controversial statement that the wfh would become OPs business in this scenario, she doesn't actually know that the wfh is what's making the colleague less productive. It's an assumption. She only knows that he is less productive and is also wfh. There are other potential explanations for this. As other posters have pointed out, there could be any number of reasons for this adjustment and the wife could be a cover story. That sort of thing happens all the time in workplaces.

So for that reason, the advice OP has had that the wfh isn't her business is correct. The part that's her business is her increased workload. It serves her interests much better to focus on that. It doesn't actually help OP to agree with her that she's in the right to make assumptions about things that really aren't actually her business.

Alternatively OP, if it's really important to you to be able to wfh, that's completely valid and for many people now is a good time to be job hunting. Quite likely it's going to be easier to start a new role with wfh established straight off than it is to try and do it in your current job. You have every right to see what's out there.

Hiddlestom · 09/11/2021 12:46

YANBU, this would wind me up too.

We require a minimum of 4 team members (out of 10) on site every day, so we have a rota so we take it in terms. Apart from one woman whose child is ECV (but still attends school!!), who says in order to minimise any additional risk, she wants to WFH, so she's not on our rota.

She gets to drop her kids at school every day at 8:50 and be home by 9am to log on, thereby saving herself the cost of breakfast club that she used to have to pay when we were in the office, and she takes "lunch" at 3-4 so she can collect her kids and bring them home and give them a snack, then works 4-5pm (with her kids in the house). So she saves herself the cost of after school club too. I pay £60 a day in wraparound care for my kids because I'm in the office - if I was allowed to WFH I'd be £300 a week better off!!! So no wonder she wants to keep wfh, but it feels so so unfair.

CompensationStreet · 09/11/2021 12:46

Oh do mind your own business, it’s nothing to do with you.

RobotValkyrie · 09/11/2021 12:45

Envy is a nasty trait. But envy of the few "perks" some people get to compensate for misfortunes such as ill health/disability (be it their own, or someone they care for), is the nastiest of all.

Do you also begrudge other people's blue badges, motability car, or carer allowance? Flexible working arrangements such as work from home are just one among many reasonable adjustments that employers are bound to consider by law under the Equality Act. You throwing a hissy fit about it is neither here nor there.

user1497207191 · 09/11/2021 12:44

@Crunchymum

What condition does your colleagues DW have *@oober6*?
That's confidential personal information protected by the data protection laws. The employee in question will have discussed the matter with the employer/HR dept. But if the employer divulges it to other employees, they are in breach of the data protection laws.
BonesInTheOcean · 09/11/2021 12:42

@Crunchymum

What condition does your colleagues DW have *@oober6*?
that has nothing to do you OP or you or any of us.
user1497207191 · 09/11/2021 12:42

[quote Whereismumhiding3]@oober6

Yanbu to be fed up if you are picking up slack from your wfh colleague who isn't even CEV himself! But if he has agreement of managers then it's down to them.

"Shielding has been ended now. "

Absolutely. Shielding for CEV patients themselves was paused on 1st April 2021 (& shielding was paused twice in 2020) and CEV population were advised to follow same precautions as everyone else from 19th July 2021 onwards

I'm CEV group. A key worker. HCP. I attend work same as my colleagues. PPE is available. I can see how it is difficult to understand how a partner of a CEV person qualifies more than CEV people themselves, however we don't know status of his wife's health and it may be nothing to do with COVID restrictions and more to do with caring for a sick relative [/quote]
Yes, general shielding has been stopped, but doctors/consultants continue to give individual advice according to the severity of their patient's health condition, and many people have been told to continue to shield by their doctor/consultant. That's completely different from the government advice that entire groups of people were recommended to shield during the worst stages of the pandemic.

Simonjt · 09/11/2021 12:34

We had a colleague kicking off because another colleague works from home fulltime, his wife has had a bone marrow transplant. Oddly enough the colleague wasn’t keen on the idea of her own partner being ill enough to allow her to work from home fulltime.