Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think colleague shouldn’t be on permanent WFH due to his DW’s Covid risk?

208 replies

oober6 · 09/11/2021 10:28

As in the title really.

The world has opened up, social distancing requirements have gone, vaccines have given us all plenty of protection.

We are key workers who have worked throughout, coming into work every day. I would love to be able to WFH! It would be a lot less pressurised, and of course, no commute etc.

AIBU to think management should now be telling our colleague that he has to start coming back into work? He is healthy and fit.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
godmum56 · 09/11/2021 16:48

@OverTheRubicon

"godmum56
I have been both a manager and an employee and have never understood the picking up slack thing. If you are working as hard as you should be then either you can't "pick up slack" or it requires extra hours which should be paid for or some less important stuff has to be dropped....basically if the business is running as it should be then any slack is minimal. If you are missing out on breaks which are part of your t and c or going home late/arriving early then that needs to be addressed.....but as someone who managed a very busy tightly staffed NHS service, I'd have LOVED to know where all the resource comes from to pick up slack?"

"Really? So if a team member was off sick then did all their tasks not ever get done, or did people not have to stay a bit late / do less well on their main jobs / rush all day / skip lunch, in order to ensure that the right service ran? Most of us have, and that's what picking up the slack looks like.
It's fine if it's a day or even a week, but far too often, it's okayed for someone to WFH full time, or drop a day, or not do certain tasks (often due to a reasonable adjustment for disability) - but without adjusting the tasks required of everyone else. That just breeds resentment as well as people quitting or going off with stress."

nope. we were a community service. If someone was off sick and any part of their caseload was urgent then non urgent appointments got rescheduled. Referrals got triaged as they came through the door (not door really, by phone/mail etc). around 2/3 of them were non urgent and these would have to wait for longer. If people worked longer than their working day they got toil so working longer didn't help. Breaks were used for phonecalls/other admin. Longterm sickness was a real issue because we had no agency budget and anyway it was just about impossible to rely on finding agency qualifed rehab staff.

SickAndTiredAgain · 09/11/2021 15:55

@FictionalCharacter

So the problem isn’t that he’s WFH, it’s that he’s slacking, and taking the piss by going for day trips and shopping when he’s meant to be working? That isn’t a WFH issue, it’s an issue of bad management and supervision. Really pisses me off when WFH is abused, it gives homeworkers a bad name. I’ve been doing it since last March and have been equally or more productive as when I was in the office. And I’ve worked the same hours.
I read that differently, I don’t think he’s going on day trips during work time, OP was using it as an example of how he is happy to be out and about generally.
Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 09/11/2021 15:48

Was initially feeling you were being unreasonable until I read the bit about them being out and about. YANBU.

RuggerHug · 09/11/2021 15:14

@FictionalCharacter

So the problem isn’t that he’s WFH, it’s that he’s slacking, and taking the piss by going for day trips and shopping when he’s meant to be working? That isn’t a WFH issue, it’s an issue of bad management and supervision. Really pisses me off when WFH is abused, it gives homeworkers a bad name. I’ve been doing it since last March and have been equally or more productive as when I was in the office. And I’ve worked the same hours.
FinctionalCharacter I took that to mean 'they have left the house so he can come to work'. If they're not in a bunker then it can't be that bad(according to OP)
RuggerHug · 09/11/2021 15:13

Hey OP, would you be happy to wear a mask all day in work and have the windows open to make it safer? Because if you adjust your expectations for what's happening you might get somewhere.

RavingAnnie · 09/11/2021 15:12

It's none of your business.

FictionalCharacter · 09/11/2021 15:11

So the problem isn’t that he’s WFH, it’s that he’s slacking, and taking the piss by going for day trips and shopping when he’s meant to be working? That isn’t a WFH issue, it’s an issue of bad management and supervision.
Really pisses me off when WFH is abused, it gives homeworkers a bad name. I’ve been doing it since last March and have been equally or more productive as when I was in the office. And I’ve worked the same hours.

LondonJax · 09/11/2021 15:11

As the mother of a son who has a congenital heart condition I have sympathies all round to be honest. DS didn't have to shield when Covid struck as he isn't on medication ('just' had a few heart procedures since birth to manage his condition).

When the kids went back to school after lockdown, DS did too. My manager (I work in DS's school) arranged for me to work solely with DS's year group so we could keep his (very large) bubble intact.

Now everyone's back to 'normal' we're still careful. We do go out but we go to places that we can book or we happily walk out if it gets too crowded. We'll go to the cinema but we book aisle seats on the cross aisle walk way so we're not surrounded by people if it's busy. Same for the theatre - we try to get seats near the front or very back and on the aisle. We don't go to restaurants now that are 'turn up and squeeze in' and we won't be going abroad for a while. DH has been lucky as his company is offering various WFH options and he's taken advantage of that. Most of his department have and it's working well. As DH has to travel from one end of the country to the other if he goes into the office (his office is literally 500 miles away - redundancy meant no choice for where the next job was) he's asked and got one week in the office, three weeks wfh. He WFH for seven years when DS was born so he's very used to remote working so there's no problem with work ethics.

Although DS is back at school and we're back at work, we still try to mitigate the chances of getting Covid as much as we can. It's possible to go out and still be vulnerable. Sometimes things have to be done but some things that keep you sane or are enjoyable, have to be looked at for risk if you have a vulnerable person in the family.

Ultimately OP, you have a point to take to management that you're all sinking under the weight of being one person down physically. You don't have a say in whether this person should return and saying the family go out or the kids go to school makes no difference - it's the risk/benefit of those things that matter to a vulnerable person. Going out for the day helps with mental health but may take a degree of planning to keep safe. The kids have to go to school. A partner WFH takes away some of the extra, unnecessary, risk.

But you have a right to have all hands on deck so management either have to find the person different work, employ someone to help you or work something else out. No one has a 'right' to work from home but some people need it in order to carry on, are worth it to the company and your management obviously feel this person falls into that category.

Don't bring up 'his wife does this or his kids does that' as that just comes across as nosey and bitter. If his absence is causing problems for the team, that's what needs to be addressed. Stick to that.

TravelLost · 09/11/2021 15:00

And can you redistribute the added stress and pressure?

Alicetheowl · 09/11/2021 15:00

Actually, it's definitely not a good idea to draw attention to your colleague's shortcomings when WFH if you want to WFH. That just means it's less likely you will get to WFH. Maybe even say how well your colleague seems to find it. Maybe put together some evidence that people are more productive WFH.

Is it even necessary for people in your industry to be in the office? I get there might be places like Job Centres, high street travel agencies, banks etc that need a core staff to deal with people walking in, but not that many.

TravelLost · 09/11/2021 14:59

@dannydyerismydad how are they going to redistribute work that can only be done f2f though?

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 09/11/2021 14:54

You have no idea what his circumstances are. It's only in the last couple of weeks my Mum has been told to stop shielding but not to have people in the home, get anyone she's near to take a LFT etc. It isn't over for everyone

billy1966 · 09/11/2021 14:52

YANBU OP.

Management need to sort something out because picking up extra work in those circumstances long term is not fair and I wouldn't be happy.

Coyoacan · 09/11/2021 14:52

I'm glad you got a pasting OP. I seriously dislike people that spend their time worrying if a colleague got slightly more than they did and they usually do it in cases where it is absolutely no skin off their nose.

dannydyerismydad · 09/11/2021 14:49

It sounds like they are a kind and supportive employer to this person, taking into account everything that may affect their wellbeing. It's a great shame more employers don't look at the full picture in this way.

However if other team members are suffering, then that is a separate issue to to be addressed by redistributing workload and tasks.

Lavender24 · 09/11/2021 14:45

I can understand why it's annoying for you. I think a lot of people have milked things during the pandemic so they can enjoy perks such as working from home for longer. I know a few.

LakieLady · 09/11/2021 14:45

But it’s still unfair if one person is allowed to WFh and others aren’t

It's not unfair unless their circumstances are the same, and in this case, they aren't.

TravelLost · 09/11/2021 14:41

@LakieLady but the OP is not working in that sort of environment when you have loads of meetings and can wfh just as well if not better than in the office.

That’s a different situation altogether

Valenciaoranges · 09/11/2021 14:41

You have no idea what is going on in this person’s life. I’m currently absent with very poor mental health and my colleagues have to cover for me. I would hate to think they are making negative comments about why I am off.

hotmeatymilk · 09/11/2021 14:40

Have you tried minding your own business?

TravelLost · 09/11/2021 14:39

I agree with you @oober6

The fact colleague us wfh has an impact on you and your colleagues.
Neither them or DW are shielding (they wouldn’t go in day trips etc…)

He has no reason to still be wfh.

The other fair way would be to allow you and your colleagues SOME days wen you can wfh too. And see him back in the office with the same entitlement as you (let’s say one day a week?)

Hope478 · 09/11/2021 14:37

Mind your own business, really.

If you think you are doing more work than you're contracted to, take it up up your manager.

LakieLady · 09/11/2021 14:31

@Overthehillandfartaway

I think those saying ' What's it got to do with you' and ' you're just jealous' have a point to some degree , but it's not as simple as that.

Many industries are now suffering with an unequal seemingly random WFH policy that is causing resentment.

If this colleague is not being as productive as their colleagues because they are WFH, then it's an issue and it is the posters business.

I work at a university and it has transpired that colleagues who are fighting tooth and nail to WFH are doing the bare minimum , so effectively doing their jobs, but at this time of year colleagues in work are putting in a huge effort to get students registered and started on courses , which is what is needed for whole process to function.

Put it this way their are two scenarios playing out in work places across the country.

  1. People working from home, doing what needs to be done as bare minimum, then doing childcare, house stuff, taking the dog for a walk etc.
  1. People in work, doing what needs to be done, then helping colleagues, being proactive and basically doing what most people did before lockdowns and WFH for roles previously not done in that way.
And in many workplaces, there's a third scenario playing out:
  1. People WFH, managing the same workload as before and very efficiently.

Presenteeism is a load of nonsense. I've been able to more than double my caseload by WFH and not travelling to F2F appointments.

ShinyHappyPoster · 09/11/2021 14:27
  • Do you want to be able to work from home - are you jealous?
  • Or are vulnerable people hampering your fantasy that everything is fine and back to normal despite the Covid figures?

^^ which is it OP? Hmm

Because all your posts say much more about you than they do about your colleague.

Nocutenamesleft · 09/11/2021 14:19

I’ve got a very rare illness which means any bug. Could kill me

Do you realise the stress of living with something like that? That a sickness bug could mean my life grow up without a mother

Sheesh. Open your eyes. The world isn’t just about you. We’ve forgotten in all of this to look out for others. I’d for sure look out for someone if they told me that.