Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that in practice sexting a person legally means consent to sex?

229 replies

ScrollingLeaves · 08/11/2021 22:05

To see why I am saying this watch Channel 4:Rape - Who’s on Trial which is on now

A woman flirted with a man in a pub.
Willingly went to toilets with him. Text messages has passed between them.
He shoved her against the wall and violently shoved fingers in her while kissing her.
He left because he heard someone coming in.
Watching CCTV it looked as though she was telling the truth ( police woman thought so).
Alleged victim very upset.

Then they found she’d sent a bra photo and a topless photo to him.
Police man said something like “you have to ask what sort of message was that giving”

Case dropped.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 10/11/2021 23:33

Oh I thought it was general rather than this case particularly.

If it's a case where he says she consented and she says he was violent and raped me. Then I'd think that forensics would help. Potentially. I mean shouldn't be ruled out.

Felix125 · 10/11/2021 23:26

I don't know much about the case, but if they agree that sex has taken place and its the consent that's contested - then the forensics are not going to help you any further.

Forensics will be able to put them in the same place, or if they have had sex, but it wont add anything to the consent part. Blood on the furniture (depending on the quantity) may show that a violent struggle has taken place if it matches with injuries and blood splatter on clothing may reveal the proximity of persons to each other when that injury occurred.

CheeseMmmm · 10/11/2021 22:40

I mean if he's saying never happened or something.

CheeseMmmm · 10/11/2021 22:40

What about forensic suggesting violence, struggle. Blood on furniture or floor.

I mean I'm no expert but sometimes don't forensics sometimes show someone was in a place they said they hadn't been.

That sort of thing?

Does semen/ DNA count as evidence?

Felix125 · 10/11/2021 18:11

I think juries need to go for this sort of trial.
They will all bring some sort of prejudice into the court with them and get fixated on stuff that isn't relevant.

As the case above - forensics would be irrelevant as they are not going to tell you anything on consent. CCTV and medical examinations would be the same, unless there are injuries.

Swimmingwiththefishes · 10/11/2021 07:53

I've just watched this program off the back of the thread. Very frustrating to watch and the threshold to take something to court seems to pivot a lot on the believability of the victim and how 'innocent' her behaviour is.

Likewise the two women in the hotel and the absolutely vile opportunist who pounced on them.

It led to an interesting discussion with my DH who a few years ago was on a jury for a rape case. Details vague so not at all outing

Young couple, both in the drugs world. Woman broke up with man when she found he'd been cheating. He lured her to his flat with the promise of her things and drugs. Then raped her.

My husband thinks the prevalence of so many crime dramas now means the expectation of evidence is high. The jury wanted forensics, cctv, medical exam...the works to prove it. The reality was it came down to consent and each persons testimony. But the jury couldn't get their heads around not having this full suite of evidence as they felt they needed 'proof' before convicting.

He also said that many male jurors were fixated on the position they'd had sex and said it wasn't a male dominant position so she could have easily got away.

He was astounded by where the conversation went and how much focus was around the actions of the girl rather than than the man...she went there willingly...they'd exchanged sexual messages post break up...she had done drugs with him....their position meant she could get away....she didn't tell any friends afterwards etc.

Sadly, I think this is a realistic snapshot of a lot of jury conversations which is why there are so few convictions.

NotMyCat · 10/11/2021 07:35

@CheeseMmmm

Was this a real case? Because if real life its very unusual.
  1. She bothered reporting (women know how it is)
  2. The police heard report and bothered doing anything
  3. It went to court? Even cases with massive evidence don't get to court
  4. Of course not guilty. Which is why I assume not real? Consent has been taken as given in court by judges/ juries in plenty situations where it's just... Eh? Even when accepted she was too incapacitated to consent. Or it was just obviously totally just no way....

If this was real I'm amazed tbh.

Yes, it was on the TV programme

https://www.channel4.com/programmes/rape-whos-on-trial

CheeseMmmm · 10/11/2021 01:42

He didn't communicate before he pushed her aggressively into wall and shoved fingers inside with no precursor though.

And I'm sure you said earlier what she did meant consent to sexual intercourse.

LobsterNapkin · 10/11/2021 01:38

@CheeseMmmm

Your view is that men can assume consent to... Whatever? Based on things that are not explicit consent to anything.

Normal men behave... Normally. Assume nothing see how it goes. Same as women.

The idea that a man can read consent by whatever. And then can do whatever. And the woman needs to verbally withdraw consent (that she had no idea she had given) is really retrograde.

Because in fact in general. Most men don't assume anything in a casual sexual encounter. It's a two way thing.

A PP said when he heard someone coming he legged it out the pub. That doesn't scream nice bloke no issues does it.

I'm not sure what you are actually saying here, but it doesn't seem to be much like what I said.

No one has said anyone can assume consent to anything.

Several people have said that after sexting, and heading off to the toilet, many or even most people would see that as initiation of a sexual encounter.

I suppose if people change their minds about something, or find it isn't what they intended, they could withdraw consent without saying anything. But it's likely to less effective than, you know, actually communicating.

CheeseMmmm · 10/11/2021 01:28

Your view is that men can assume consent to... Whatever? Based on things that are not explicit consent to anything.

Normal men behave... Normally. Assume nothing see how it goes. Same as women.

The idea that a man can read consent by whatever. And then can do whatever. And the woman needs to verbally withdraw consent (that she had no idea she had given) is really retrograde.

Because in fact in general. Most men don't assume anything in a casual sexual encounter. It's a two way thing.

A PP said when he heard someone coming he legged it out the pub. That doesn't scream nice bloke no issues does it.

LobsterNapkin · 10/11/2021 01:22

@ScrollingLeaves

Midlifemusings “That doesn't change the fact that no means no - but I don't think it is strange for either party to start to touch the other person's body after a mutual rendezvous in a pub toilet.”

Yes, the thing is though, in this case, it wasn’t ‘starting to touch’ and it was instantly unmutual. He shoved her against the wall hard, put his hand around her throat, kissed her in a violent way, pulled her tights down and put his fingers in then stopped suddenly and left when the other man came in.

This woman who by her own account had been flirting and wanting to be with him for kissing was left extremely distraught.

Something bad happened in there. Why would she have flipped from liking him to trauma for no reason?

Because it wasn't nice or enjoyable. That's the only reason there needs to be. She felt unsafe.

But that doesn't make it assault. If she'd told him to stop and he didn't that would be assault no question. But it only seems to have taken a very short amount of time and there was no chance for much more to play out.

A lot of young women think this kind of anonymous sex will be fun and exciting. It's part of the culture of going out and drinking and hooking up, they see it on tv and in porn possibly too. Very few find that it really is fun. The men are not devastatingly expert lovers. They themselves aren't ready for sex in the sort time available so it's likely to be uncomfortable. It can quickly become scary because they don't know this person who is stronger than they are and there is no trust.

That kind of scare will be traumatizing whether there is an assault or not. And maybe there would have been in this situation, but events interfered so it's not clear.

CheeseMmmm · 10/11/2021 00:42

Was this a real case? Because if real life its very unusual.

  1. She bothered reporting (women know how it is)
  2. The police heard report and bothered doing anything
  3. It went to court? Even cases with massive evidence don't get to court
  4. Of course not guilty. Which is why I assume not real? Consent has been taken as given in court by judges/ juries in plenty situations where it's just... Eh? Even when accepted she was too incapacitated to consent. Or it was just obviously totally just no way....

If this was real I'm amazed tbh.

ScrollingLeaves · 10/11/2021 00:11

Midlifemusings
“That doesn't change the fact that no means no - but I don't think it is strange for either party to start to touch the other person's body after a mutual rendezvous in a pub toilet.”

Yes, the thing is though, in this case, it wasn’t ‘starting to touch’ and it was instantly unmutual. He shoved her against the wall hard, put his hand around her throat, kissed her in a violent way, pulled her tights down and put his fingers in then stopped suddenly and left when the other man came in.

This woman who by her own account had been flirting and wanting to be with him for kissing was left extremely distraught.

Something bad happened in there. Why would she have flipped from liking him to trauma for no reason?

OP posts:
Midlifemusings · 09/11/2021 23:01

@HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule

While I have no experience joining men in toilet cubicles at bars - I can certainly see that once in the cubicle hands start to roam. I can a woman reaching down for the guy's dick without explicitly asking if she can touch him.

As an adult who was sending sexy topless pics and agreeing to join someone in a toilet - I can't see that person being so naive as to think the purpose for that would be a chaste peck on the lips.

That doesn't change the fact that no means no - but I don't think it is strange for either party to start to touch the other person's body after a mutual rendezvous in a pub toilet.

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 09/11/2021 22:45

Oh apologies, *a couple (for the sake of accuracy)

HollyandIvyandAllThingsYule · 09/11/2021 22:44

I can see how the man might ‘slip a few fingers in’ (UGH) but I cannot see how he can legitimately think he’s entitled to do so, nor how he can think she definitely wants that just because she’s flirted and sent him some photos!

No.

KrispyKremeDream · 09/11/2021 22:17

I don't think there can be much confusion if a woman is saying stop. Anybody who claims they had sex without realising she didn't want it is most likely being dishonest unless the woman laid there and said nothing. Even then most guys would sense something off and ask if she was ok.

However, after some steamy messages, photos, and a mutual trip to the toilet, I can see how the man might press against and kiss her whilst slipping a couple of fingers in. This could happen within just a few seconds.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2021 22:06

@onceandneveragain
That is a good analogy

OP posts:
onceandneveragain · 09/11/2021 21:53

There was an AIBU the other day about someone who'd put an item on gumtree/fb marketplace or something and someone had arranged to buy it, however last minute OP realised she still needed it so had to message the buyer to say sorry she was no longer selling it, and buyer was a bit annoyed and shirty.

There were lots of people saying OP was U, however nobody suggested that since she had sent someone a picture of the item and initially agreed to sell it, that the buyer would now be fully entitled to come round to her house and forcibly take it from OP, even though OP had changed her mind, and in fact it would be OPs fault if the buyer did break into her house and steal the item. Strange that.

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 09/11/2021 18:27

This "he said/she said so it's hard" thing is bullshit. It always gets trotted out as some kind of gotcha moment! The vast majority of rapes are he said/she said. There's rarely CCTV, witnesses, audio etc. Internal examinations only prove sex took place. Bruises ,wounds,lacerations are explained as "she liked it rough your honour". Even when there is proof it's either explained away or the rapist's circumstances come to play. His reputation, his future, his remorse, his depression/alcoholism/career/family. A rapist is a perpetual victim.

We live in a country where "i tripped and fell" was literally used as an excuse for an innocent verdict. Our judicial system and society lets women and girls down and gives free reign to predators.Whether the victim is 5 or 50, a virgin or a prostitute, a cleaner or a lawyer, a woman in a swimsuit or one in a parka, a runner in a park or a mum at home. They're all free game.

ScrollingLeaves · 09/11/2021 17:31

The other question is whether, even if it had been decided that consent to sex had been implicitly given (on the basis of flirting. Photo, and going into the toilets) had consent to violent sex also been given?

OP posts:
MysteriousMonkey · 09/11/2021 16:16

It's not consenting to anything imho

MyButteredBread · 09/11/2021 16:08

But is it the same as not bring allowed to say no to any sexual encounter thereafter? Does that just mean a blanket, across the board, yes - forever?

Journeyofthedragons · 09/11/2021 16:03

@notanothertakeaway

This seems to be modern version of wearing a short skirt = asking for it
Flirting, sending suggestive messages and topless photos and then going into a pub toilet with a man aren't really the same as wearng a short skirt.
picklemewalnuts · 09/11/2021 15:57

I feel as though the drive towards quick casual sex disadvantages women in particular. I mean, it does men no favours, and along with porn harms their ability to build strong, emotionally intelligent relationships. Women are actually endangered by it though, in my opinion. If this, currently normal, behaviour is seen as tacit consent, then women have lost the opportunity to withhold consent.

How can we have a situation where women are expected to, but cannot, demonstrate they withhold consent?