Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to say that in practice sexting a person legally means consent to sex?

229 replies

ScrollingLeaves · 08/11/2021 22:05

To see why I am saying this watch Channel 4:Rape - Who’s on Trial which is on now

A woman flirted with a man in a pub.
Willingly went to toilets with him. Text messages has passed between them.
He shoved her against the wall and violently shoved fingers in her while kissing her.
He left because he heard someone coming in.
Watching CCTV it looked as though she was telling the truth ( police woman thought so).
Alleged victim very upset.

Then they found she’d sent a bra photo and a topless photo to him.
Police man said something like “you have to ask what sort of message was that giving”

Case dropped.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OhWhyNot · 13/11/2021 21:29

SnackSizeRaisin

That’s only true is stranger rape

What are you talking about. Have you not heard of all the excuses that men make

This was a heated discussion in 1988 when the file The Accused came out

Fucking tragic we are still having people make the same excuses and yes they are placing blame of them the women that a women would not have been raped if she didn’t xy or z

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 20:52

Given the man's actions. I'd put money on. If she had avoided it. He'd have attacked someone else. Maybe that night. Maybe another night.

And that's the problem with the protect yourself focus. Yes it helps you. But it does nothing to reduce the actual problem.

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/11/2021 19:50

man will rape because he wants to not because of what we say, wear, drink, show photo, walk a certain way, be somewhere dark and alone

That's only true of stranger rape. In this case it's highly unlikely that this particular incident would have happened if she hadn't gone into the toilet with him. That doesn't make it in any way her fault. But it was avoidable. Sending naked photos to a stranger is just not sensible. Nor is going into a private place with a man you don't know in this context. We can blame men all we like but they are not going to change any time soon.

Speakingmymind · 13/11/2021 19:47

Missing out something shameful does not of itself mean someone is not telling the truth.

No, it does not however it does call into question their credibility as a witness if the case goes to court. The prosecution will have used it to show the victim was not completely truthful in their initial disclosure. This then could be used to cast a shadow of a doubt on her recount of what happened in the toilet.

SnackSizeRaisin · 13/11/2021 19:36

I tend to agree that sending sexy pictures then going into toilets indicates a willingness to have sex. But that doesn't then mean the man can violently penetrate her. Even if she said to him in so many words that she consents to sex, it doesn't mean she consents to violence.

Surely there should be an assumption that the woman did not consent to being violently penetrated. Whether she wanted to have normal sex or not is almost irrelevant really. If there's evidence of the violence that should be a strong suggestion that there was no consent for that particular act. I mean with a theft case you start from the assumption that the car owner didn't want someone to steal the car. The onus isn't on the victim to prove they didn't want it stealing. Even if they left it unlocked with the keys in, no one would expect proof that they didn't consent to having it taken - simply because that's the default position. The same should apply to violence in sex

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2021 17:53

Speakingmymind
“However the defence will latch onto the fact she initially lied about sending him those photos“

Yes, the defence would.

To be clearer though, she didn’t lie. She just didn’t offer the information in terms of saying she sent a nude photo. She said she’d sent flirty texts. When confronted later she admitted she had sent the nude one.

Missing out something shameful does not of itself mean someone is not telling the truth. It is something that woman who really were assaulted or raped do sometimes do during the interview. That’s why being briefed and coached in advance of an interview might help.

The CCTV did show ‘before and after’ in regard to her demeanour, and should him leaving very quickly. Not absolute proof of course, but corroborative in a general way.

Defendants get a lawyer during the interview to help them not incriminate themselves. Perhaps victims need equivalent help.

OP posts:
BrocolliFloret · 13/11/2021 17:09

I haven’t seen the programme, but from what you’ve written it would be very hard to prove beyond reasonable doubt that he intended to do anything that she didn’t want.

He could have been doing what he thought women like with his fingers, but it turned out to be very painful for her, which changed her perception of the whole encounter from a sexy romp into a rape.

Not sure how violent he was, so I take it back if there was choking involved etc. But you can do a lot of damage with just a rough nail (ouch!!!)

Speakingmymind · 13/11/2021 15:08

You have a jury of 12 people who will hear:

Happy to chat and flirt with a man who approached her table and sat down
Sent him sexual photos of herself without knowing him from adam
Went to the toilets with him within a short time of meeting him

Does it give him the right to shove her against the wall and penetrate her with his fingers no, of course not. Absolutely not. However the defence will latch onto the fact she initially lied about sending him those photos and there is no proof of what happened in the toilets. Both the latter facts does create reasonable doubt.

eastegg · 13/11/2021 14:38

@CheeseMmmm

A lot of posts on here saying she went with him for sex and so what happened isn't a prob.

I don't get this.
Flirting pics etc. Is just flirting and pics, not consent to anything.
Going somewhere private isn't consent to sex. Nor does it mean she must have been intending sex. It's a bit 0-100 isn't it? Going somewhere private generally means a snog and a grope and see what happens from there. Not right we're definitely fucking. Surely? If it means consent to sex then that's a massive problem for all those who sneak off for privacy any time, anywhere.

And I don't know about anyone else but being violently pushed against a wall and shoving fingers in vagina sounds unexpected, scary and very possibly painful.

Is this really what women expect? At posh work do. Nip off with a bloke down quiet corridor. He does that straight off the bat. That's not ok. I'm surprised so many women are fine with being treated that way.

I don’t agree that in this case going somewhere private just meant going for a snog and a grope. They went to the toilets together. If it was a snog and a grope they could have done that in the club itself. In fact I suspect the vast majority of women, looking for a snog and a grope with a stranger, would choose to stay in a more public area than go somewhere very private.

The act of choosing to go to the toilets did not mean consent couldn’t then be withdrawn. But I can totally see why it lead, along with the photographs, to the decision that there was not a reasonable prospect of conviction which, we need to bear in mind, was the decision here. Not that she was not assaulted.

OhWhyNot · 13/11/2021 14:13

Yes women stop and think how your actions can make a man rape you Hmm

A man will rape because he wants to not because of what we say, wear, drink, show photo, walk a certain way, be somewhere dark and alone

AccidentallyOnPurpose · 13/11/2021 14:04

@Brieandcamembert

You can withdraw consent at any time and rape it's absolutely awful. Never ever acceptable.

I do think that people should think more about personal safety, the messages they give out and what they wear. It does muddy the water when you have led someone to believe sex is on the cards. I reiterate. You should always be able to tell someone when to stop.

Burglary isn't ok but it does happen so I lock my house and set an alarm.

And how exactly can women lock their body away?
TaraR2020 · 13/11/2021 12:16

perhaps pause to think would I send this photo to a rapist? Because you never know.....

And yet most rapes are committed by men that the victim knew and trusted.

It really is abhorrent to expect women to police the men they encounter.

OhWhyNot · 13/11/2021 12:08

About keeping ourselves safe ? We are not even safe when dead

What about the women raped by their husbands, daughters raped by their fathers, sisters raped by their brothers

It isn’t about women and girls keeping themselves safe it’s about men not raping women and girls

Many times I have been with men I thought I could trust before they decided that they could take things further how am I to blame in any of those situations (and this includes for some women and girls s professionals who we have no choice but to trust)

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2021 11:17

BrieandCamembert
“Burglary isn't ok but it does happen so I lock my house and set an alarm.“

Yes, I know what you mean, but in these cases it is a bit like inviting someone into your house, but then they steal from you.

Out of interest, I wonder what the law would do if you had left your house open, it got burgled, and the burglar was caught with the stolen goods - so there was proof of the deed. Would they get a lesser sentence on the grounds that you tempted them?

OP posts:
Brieandcamembert · 13/11/2021 10:29

You can withdraw consent at any time and rape it's absolutely awful. Never ever acceptable.

I do think that people should think more about personal safety, the messages they give out and what they wear. It does muddy the water when you have led someone to believe sex is on the cards. I reiterate. You should always be able to tell someone when to stop.

Burglary isn't ok but it does happen so I lock my house and set an alarm.

thinkfast · 13/11/2021 10:06

IMO before sexting you need to REALLY know the other person well and have 100% trust in.

If you don't know them perhaps pause to think would I send this photo to a rapist? Because you never know.....

Sexting doesn't mean consent to sex, but rapists really don't care about their victims' consent.

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 01:14

My read of Suzanne post was it was critical of current social etc attitudes. Maybe I got wrong end of stick.

Yes the men were scum. And thinking I suppose. There's also a massive issue in society with well you know what men are like. The onus is on women and girls to do all sorts of things to try and avoid being a target of dodgy men. There's really zero interest in the fact that it's the men who are the issue with what they're doing. Usually common down to that's what they're like what can you do.

Things like plying with drinks to get her inhibitions down are seen as just normal. That's shit isn't it.

There's also stuff in the news from time to time about men coming up with all sorts of shit- having a competition who can get laid most. I remember something about shag a pig..? Blokes at that uni with a rape chat. Who they wanted to attack etc. I mean it's just grim.

Law aside. As long as society in general has knee jerk reaction to scrutinise the victim, what she did wrong. See various things a girl or woman does as sending 'signals' which count as consent. If she didn't realise she was signalling then well what did she expect. I mean obviously he assumed she was up for whatever.

On this thread loads of. Well her actions clearly spelt out consent to sex.

But did they spell out. What sort of sex? With/ without condom? And signal that he did not need to take into account anything about what she might or might not want. Like. Just dive straight in. Shove, neck, fingers. She's consented! To... Anything he might do? That's not good at all.

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2021 00:47

“Suzanne999
I really think the only way a charge could have been brought would have been if she’d been shouting at him to get off and someone had witnessed that and was willing to stand as a witness. And who is going to think of that when they’re shocked at what some man has done to them?“

His mouth was on her mouth, one hand on her throat, his other in her private parts, she was pinned against the wall she was in shock …..all in seconds of going in there. No chance to shout. (Then the other man arrived and the assailant stopped suddenly, and made a sharp exit out of the toilets and out the pub.)

Plus a common reaction is to freeze rather than scream and fight. Another girl in the debate said that’s what she had done when she was raped.

CheeseMmmm
It does seem that the “being too drunk to consent” becomes you were drunk so you just forgot you consented, or now you just regret you consented.

There was a case about four years ago where two postgraduate rowers got hold of a fresher girl. They filmed some of what they were doing and whatsapped their film to a friend. The defence said she’d just been drunk enough to lower her inhibitions then regretted it afterwards. The were acquitted.

At the very least, even if she had consented, which was very much in doubt, what sort of scum of the earth were those men to take advantage of a younger girl in a new environment in that way and use it as boast fodder?

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 00:32

Suzanne- yes.

The fact that things that happen outside of the actual incident are seen so widely in society as signalling consent. Just... Generally. Is embedded very deeply.

What if he had throttled her?
Slapped her?
Pushed her into cubicle and immediately forced way into anus?
Etc etc.

Loads say well she was signalling consent. Or consent to sex. But what specifically?

She's sent pic gone in bog etc. So before they've even kissed/ touched each other it's natural that he would assume consent to... Anything?

CheeseMmmm · 13/11/2021 00:27

There have been so many cases where the outcome is that the court accepts that it was reasonable for him to... Well it's assume isn't it... Consent.

Situations where saying yep totally can see that he would have thought that.

Situations where it's so obviously unlikely that she would have.

Also recent case where it was not in doubt that she was too incapacitated to consent but somehow she did. Judge comments or whatever called it said. Yep can't be sure she didn't consent even though by law she couldn't.

The sleepwalking cases as well. Yes he did it. But his defence is asleep. So situation is yes she was raped but also nothing to be done about that legally.

I mean it's not working for victims of sex offences. And now as baroness or similar who did report said. In practice rape is decriminalised.

Suzanne999 · 13/11/2021 00:27

The CPS wouldn’t have progressed the case, and the police have to reach a certain threshold of certainty before they can go to the CPS.

I also found the programme upsetting. The young woman in this case said she was flirtatious but she obviously didn’t expect the man to do what he did, and she didn’t consent to it. But by sending the photos and by going into the gents toilet it could have been argued that she was implying willingness.
I really think the only way a charge could have been brought would have been if she’d been shouting at him to get off and someone had witnessed that and was willing to stand as a witness. And who is going to think of that when they’re shocked at what some man has done to them?

ScrollingLeaves · 13/11/2021 00:17

“CheeseMmmm

That doesn't make sense to me.

When people die you have murder, meant to kill. Or manslaughter, didn't mean to kill or was reckless with result death.

Not sure if any other examples think probably.

With that there is the harm done. Death. And then also whether the person who caused to meant to or not.

Why with this is it about whether the man thought ok fine, with no consideration of harm done?”

That is an interesting point.
The harm goes on for years too.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 12/11/2021 23:39

That doesn't make sense to me.

When people die you have murder, meant to kill. Or manslaughter, didn't mean to kill or was reckless with result death.

Not sure if any other examples think probably.

With that there is the harm done. Death. And then also whether the person who caused to meant to or not.

Why with this is it about whether the man thought ok fine, with no consideration of harm done?

Journeyofthedragons · 12/11/2021 23:30

Why is the law about the man thinking consent (and we know from life and plenty court cases that what they see as, and sadly juries often accept as, reasonable to assume consent is frankly bonkers).

Rather than showing reasons they were sure she consented

Because in English Law the prosecution has to prove the defendant is guilty of a crime not the defense proving the defendant is innocent.

Innocent until proved guilty.

CheeseMmmm · 12/11/2021 23:15

Why is the law about the man thinking consent (and we know from life and plenty court cases that what they see as, and sadly juries often accept as, reasonable to assume consent is frankly bonkers).

Rather than showing reasons they were sure she consented.

And why is the harm to the woman not involved?

Why is his view of whether consent more important than hers?