Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is DH - Works on leasehold property

138 replies

MrsWarleggan · 08/11/2021 21:00

So, DH and I have just purchased our first home. It's a leasehold flat. We knew from our lease that we would have to ask for permission to do a full re-wire on the place. In our complete and total naivety we assumed (wrongly as it now transpires) that as the works are essential due to safety issues with the existing electrics that we could do the work and then request retrospective approval. There is absolutely no way that they can refuse as the current fuse board hasn't been replaced since the 60's and there are wires hanging out of holes drilled through walls!

We have all the paperwork but as we are not legal owners until we complete on the 12th they can't entertain a request and won't be able to until deeds are transferred which can take up to a month after completion despite then being the legal owners!!

It now looks as though we can't request retrospective approval. The application form has a "retrospective approval" section asking for dates work completed and requests copies of the electrical sign off by the electrician etc. For what it's worth he is NICEIC registered and has his indemnity insurances which would provide proof off...... However in the next breath they say in their guidance notes any works completed prior to approval would put us in breach of our lease....... So here in turn is my question.

DH is incredibly and understandably frustrated. We have 2 weeks between completion and having to be out of our rental and just wants to get the work done. He is somewhat blinded by the need/desire to get the work done before we move in.

After going through the paperwork I am convinced we will have to delay a couple of months. Live in the danger zone property with two small children and await the approval then move in to parents when work goes on.

DH is adamant he wants to continue. I don't want to spend the first 6 months of homeownership waiting for a knock on the door due to unauthorised works.

We KNOW we needed permission and exchanged contracts based on this. However, it wasnt until we exchanged and submitted our works request that we were told we couldn't do anything until we were the legal owners. Even a solicitors letter to them did nothing and the current owners (probate) refused to put the request in on our behalf (approval would be transferred) despite doing all the actual paperwork.

Has anyone had any experience of this and do I need to tell my DH to get over himself and the work will get done when we can?

Sorry for the long post.... 24 hours of pure frustration typed out on a phone!!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Zilla1 · 09/11/2021 09:59

HNRTT but depending on jurisdiction, have you asked the freeholder for a hold harmless confirmation based on a statement you will submit a formal request but for safety reasons want to initiate the work as soon as you occupy and have young children? If they are willing then it might give the assurance you need and allow your DP to commence work immediately on taking possession?

Good luck.

Leftbutcameback · 09/11/2021 09:46

Suggest you ask your solicitor to interpret it for you - that's their job!

MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 09:45

Hoping this helps make things clearer. The lease clearly states we would need permission. In first screenshot it says that we are responsible for for maintaing, repairing and replacing if necessary cables and wires "to the lessors satisfaction"

It then states further down that "without the previous written consent" in terms of pets.

The second screenahot states written application should be made in terms of the foregoing clauses ie the works. It doesn't say prior written consent must be given before we complete the works. Just that we have to apply for permission.... Either before or retrospectively......

Or maybe I'm just trying looking for a technicality or reading it how I want to read it/interperate!

Or is DH - Works on leasehold property
Or is DH - Works on leasehold property
OP posts:
Foolsrule · 09/11/2021 09:34

Just do the work the minute you get the keys. I’m sure the leaseholders would much rather that than the whole building burn down!

BackBackBack · 09/11/2021 09:23

@HopeHappy

I would definitely just put the permission in when you complete and then just start work anyway.

If they say anything just claim the electrics weren't working at all when you moved in and the emergency electrician had to start remedial works immediately to make it safe.

As PPs have said, there are lease breaches going on left, right and centre in most blocks. I'm sure if you look carefully there will be loads of flats with pets that shouldn't have them, wooden flooring when they shouldn't, etc.

Plus, with the freeholder being a local authority I'd suggest they wouldn't give too hoots either. They won't inspect it before or after the works either - they've already admitted they don't.

Re the noise, just drop a note in your neighbours' doors apologising in advance but point out how dangerous the electrics are and the urgency of replacing them to avoid a potential fire. If they want to complain to the freeholder about reasonable works to make a property safe, let them crack on!

^this.
HopeHappy · 09/11/2021 09:21

I would definitely just put the permission in when you complete and then just start work anyway.

If they say anything just claim the electrics weren't working at all when you moved in and the emergency electrician had to start remedial works immediately to make it safe.

As PPs have said, there are lease breaches going on left, right and centre in most blocks. I'm sure if you look carefully there will be loads of flats with pets that shouldn't have them, wooden flooring when they shouldn't, etc.

Plus, with the freeholder being a local authority I'd suggest they wouldn't give too hoots either. They won't inspect it before or after the works either - they've already admitted they don't.

Re the noise, just drop a note in your neighbours' doors apologising in advance but point out how dangerous the electrics are and the urgency of replacing them to avoid a potential fire. If they want to complain to the freeholder about reasonable works to make a property safe, let them crack on!

1990s · 09/11/2021 09:18

Useful advice from CorBlimey on whether court action would actually happen.

1990s · 09/11/2021 09:17

Agree that people don’t commonly get permission, from any freeholder.

But as you’ve already asked them, they now know. So plausible deniability is not an option Smile

You’ve done more than most leaseholders in that you’ve read your lease! Very worth it to know what the rules are in there.

BackBackBack · 09/11/2021 09:15

@CorrBlimeyGG

Unauthorised works can put you in breach of a covenant of the lease, which can allow the freeholder to start legal action to forfeit the lease and gain possession of your flat.

Any action for essential works done safely would fail. A court will not enforce a clause that is unreasonable, and a clause that delays or prohibits vital works is unreasonable.

Get on with the work OP. I've had a leasehold for nearly twenty years, and I've learned that you engage with the freeholder/ management company as little as possible. No one gets permission for internal works.

Agree. As long as you aren't taking the piss knocking down walls, keep quiet.
BackBackBack · 09/11/2021 09:13

Leasehold is a money spinner full stop. I sold a leasehold flat and had to pay £300 to the managing agent as an admin fee so that they could send an email to the solicitors confirming that I was up to date on my charges and didn't owe any ground rent Hmm

I would go ahead with the work. When you notify the freeholder (after the fact) send a short covering email to them stating that your electrician advised that the state of the wiring was dangerous, and required immediate rectification to remove a fire risk. Nothing more required - don't send war and peace, don't feel like you have to get into lengthy explanations and send pictures, because they won't care. All that's needed alongside the covering paperwork and NIEIC cert is a warning to them that it was a danger that needed to be sorted as a priority.

Grumpycatsmum · 09/11/2021 09:03

What @CorrBlimeyGG said

TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 09:00

No one gets permission for internal works.

Whether that is reasonable depends on the terms of the lease.

If a lease states no internal works should be carried out without consent then you’re in breach of the lease whether or not freeholder/managing agent is aware.

When you come to sell the buyer’s solicitor will look for lease breaches and you will be required to resolve them before sale - otherwise the buyer may be liable to fix it.

This doesn’t apply to the OP as she will be looking to get retrospective consent ASAP - but that could be expensive.

TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 08:52

Any action for essential works done safely would fail. A court will not enforce a clause that is unreasonable, and a clause that delays or prohibits vital works is unreasonable

The clause itself is not unreasonable and is standard on leases. The court is unlikely to allow forfeiture in this case, but that’s not the point as OP could get herself in legal hassle with the freeholder and the mortgage company nonetheless.

CorrBlimeyGG · 09/11/2021 08:50

But do speak to your new neighbours first. Let them know what you're doing and a time frame for the work, and give them your number in case of any problems with noise.

CorrBlimeyGG · 09/11/2021 08:46

Unauthorised works can put you in breach of a covenant of the lease, which can allow the freeholder to start legal action to forfeit the lease and gain possession of your flat.

Any action for essential works done safely would fail. A court will not enforce a clause that is unreasonable, and a clause that delays or prohibits vital works is unreasonable.

Get on with the work OP. I've had a leasehold for nearly twenty years, and I've learned that you engage with the freeholder/ management company as little as possible. No one gets permission for internal works.

Wilkolampshade · 09/11/2021 08:43

I'd stop sending everyone pictures of everything pronto and go quiet OP (keep them for your own records obviously), submit application on day of completion and crack on. NO-ONE is going to come knocking and if they do you have the pictures.

Leftbutcameback · 09/11/2021 08:36

Housing associations are not public bodies, but are not for profit organisations. They will want to protect their assets (the block) but the actual terms of the lease wil determine what happens if you don't get consent. Your solicitor should be advising you on this. Not people on a forum who haven't read the lease. You usually pay an additional fee for leasehold conveyancing so ask the solicitor to advise on risks and consequences.

1990s · 09/11/2021 08:33

Yeah the fee is standard.

I only have experience of local authority and private freeholders, can’t help with housing authorities I’m afraid.

The reason that local authorities are more likely to follow the rules is that as they are a public body type thing they have to adhere to rules, and they have teams of people who monitor/reply to issues/changes etc.

If housing authorities are similarly publicly responsible it may be the same.

(Not described that all very well OP, sorry words not coming today!)

TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 08:32

The mortgage terms will state that the freeholder notify them of any breach of lease within x period - often 28 days.

TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 08:31

Just pray we don't get into trouble with either the freeholder or mortgage company.

You will get into trouble with both.

Leftbutcameback · 09/11/2021 08:28

Hang on, it's not a local authority. It's a housing authority. That's what OP has said. Totally different organisation. OP can you confirm - your last answer was confusing.

I don't think that fee is high really, certainly not compared to the cost of the works.

1990s · 09/11/2021 08:11

I imagine what the freeholder would say in this situation is that as there is a safety issue you’d need to apply for the correct permission as soon as you legally owned the property and then get the work done in good time.

They would give no shits if that inconveniences you and means you need to move out while it happens/it’s more convenient to do before that.

FWIW I think what you want to do is totally right, but like I say, if anyone is going to enforce action on breaking a lease term, it’s a local authority.

TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 08:07

Unauthorised works can put you in breach of a covenant of the lease, which can allow the freeholder to start legal action to forfeit the lease and gain possession of your flat.

You would be liable for any legal costs your landlord incurs in that scenario.

You would also be in breach of the terms of the mortgage that stipulate you stick to the terms of the lease.

MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 08:03

@1990s

Yes local authority. A well known nationwide housing authority.

@Leftbutcameback

For what we want to do it's £150 admin fee.

OP posts:
1990s · 09/11/2021 07:50

The trouble you’ve got here is who your freeholder is: local authority right?

Common sense is frequently not applied, and while a private freeholder would look at the safety element and not bother about you “breaking” the lease like lots of others have said, local authorities are more likely to follow protocol rather than sense.