Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or is DH - Works on leasehold property

138 replies

MrsWarleggan · 08/11/2021 21:00

So, DH and I have just purchased our first home. It's a leasehold flat. We knew from our lease that we would have to ask for permission to do a full re-wire on the place. In our complete and total naivety we assumed (wrongly as it now transpires) that as the works are essential due to safety issues with the existing electrics that we could do the work and then request retrospective approval. There is absolutely no way that they can refuse as the current fuse board hasn't been replaced since the 60's and there are wires hanging out of holes drilled through walls!

We have all the paperwork but as we are not legal owners until we complete on the 12th they can't entertain a request and won't be able to until deeds are transferred which can take up to a month after completion despite then being the legal owners!!

It now looks as though we can't request retrospective approval. The application form has a "retrospective approval" section asking for dates work completed and requests copies of the electrical sign off by the electrician etc. For what it's worth he is NICEIC registered and has his indemnity insurances which would provide proof off...... However in the next breath they say in their guidance notes any works completed prior to approval would put us in breach of our lease....... So here in turn is my question.

DH is incredibly and understandably frustrated. We have 2 weeks between completion and having to be out of our rental and just wants to get the work done. He is somewhat blinded by the need/desire to get the work done before we move in.

After going through the paperwork I am convinced we will have to delay a couple of months. Live in the danger zone property with two small children and await the approval then move in to parents when work goes on.

DH is adamant he wants to continue. I don't want to spend the first 6 months of homeownership waiting for a knock on the door due to unauthorised works.

We KNOW we needed permission and exchanged contracts based on this. However, it wasnt until we exchanged and submitted our works request that we were told we couldn't do anything until we were the legal owners. Even a solicitors letter to them did nothing and the current owners (probate) refused to put the request in on our behalf (approval would be transferred) despite doing all the actual paperwork.

Has anyone had any experience of this and do I need to tell my DH to get over himself and the work will get done when we can?

Sorry for the long post.... 24 hours of pure frustration typed out on a phone!!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 23:07

Here's first 2 pages.

Or is DH - Works on leasehold property
Or is DH - Works on leasehold property
OP posts:
redastherose · 09/11/2021 22:39

@MrsWarleggan the two bits of the lease that you've posted don't actually say that you have to have consent for theses works. Can you post screenshots of the whole of the relevant clauses. From what I've read there is no requirement for consent for works of that nature. Generally the freeholder is concerned with the structural integrity of the building and safety so obviously you need consent for removing walls, altering doors and also generally pipe work for new bathrooms etc but usually you do not require consent for rewiring a flat because that's a non-structural safety issue. Each lease is different but from the page you posted there was no requirement for the freeholders consent to rewiring works.

TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 22:24

You can ask your solicitor to interpret the lease for you, but it does come down to legal opinion, so you can’t be sure your freeholder’s solicitors will interpret it in the same way.

In most cases you can’t make alterations such as rewiring and faux ceilings without the freeholder’s permission. It’s not just building’s structure at issue, also the integrity and safety, plumbing and electrics - any of this the freeholder generally needs to know about.

This is because any alterations you make to your property are likely to affect the landlord’s freehold interest. The landlord needs to know not only that the structure is sound, but that all work complies with legislation, regulations and the building is properly insured.

It’s not likely that they let tenants rewire flats without their knowledge and approval is it? If you got some cowboy in (not saying you would) - faulty wiring could set the whole building on fire.

If the freeholder gets wind of the work they could potentially get an injunction to stop it - in this case most likely until the relevant permissions are sought.

Any costs incurred on their side from legal advice, to surveyors, to injunctions etc they will likely seek to pass onto you.

As I said before this is not just about being in breach of the terms of the lease but also the terms of the mortgage - you could also face action from your mortgage company.

BoredZelda · 09/11/2021 22:17

His desire to get the job done whilst it is empty is completely blinding his better judgement

Isn’t his better judgement that having kids in such a dangerous environment is really not a good idea?

BoredZelda · 09/11/2021 22:16

Housing Association who own the building our flat is in.

A housing association sold a flat with obviously dangerous wiring and are refusing permission to have it fixed??

MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 21:08

Not building, I meant premises.

OP posts:
MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 20:55

In terms of permanent changing the integral structure yes, by moving the height of the building up or down. It's a 1st floor flat. This is a floating ceiling which will not have any impact on the ORIGINAL height, as the original height will still be there.

I'm honestly not trying to be difficult and as I've previously said I very possibly may be interpreting to fit out situation!

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 20:29

Clause 19 is clear OP.

MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 20:21

@TatianaBis

The housing association upon asking the question state they need to review our lease to see if we need permission.

We know we need permission however our lease does not state that permission must be/or should be prior or retrospective (screenshots the lease in previous posts).

A technically? I don't know.

OP posts:
PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/11/2021 20:10

And that is precisely why we don't speak to our freeholder unless we have to!

TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 19:57

In the unlikely that the managing agent does not find out about works involving rewiring of whole place + new ceilings; they will find out when OP applies for retrospective permission for something they specifically told her needed prior permission.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 09/11/2021 19:49

@TatianaBis

Your DH is being very stupid. To put in a new ceiling - that has to be signed off before you start. If the freeholder doesn’t like what you’ve done, or even just make an example of you, they could make you rip down the ceilings and redo.

You are going to get yourself in legal trouble which could end up being very costly. Can you really afford that?

How would the freeholder know? Mine doesn't know anything we've done since we moved in and I won't be telling him. The only times we did ask him he was so rude I now refuse to speak to him and let DH deal with him.
Szyz2020 · 09/11/2021 19:40

@MrsWarleggan

I have sent numerous pictures to the Freeholder. I mentioned to them that the previous owner would have been in breach of their own lease for not keeping electrical wires and cabling up to a safe standard and she replied "Well, we wouldn't know that as we don't just walk into properties to check"
OP, you answered your own point here, generally speaking. The freeholder doesn’t have a clue what happens behind closed doors in your flat. Don’t engage with them wherever possible! That doesn’t mean you can rip out windows or supporting walls mind.
MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 19:21

@TatianaBis

I know. I am so stressed out about it. His desire to get the job done whilst it is empty is completely blinding his better judgement.

I just don't know what to do. I just can't get through to him the seriousness of it and possible outcomes.

He is just assuming that we will do the work, they will be happy with it, grant retrospective approval and all will be well. 😔

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 09/11/2021 19:00

Your DH is being very stupid. To put in a new ceiling - that has to be signed off before you start. If the freeholder doesn’t like what you’ve done, or even just make an example of you, they could make you rip down the ceilings and redo.

You are going to get yourself in legal trouble which could end up being very costly. Can you really afford that?

MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 18:51

We popped down there today just to have a measure up, as we are so close to completion current owners just let us have the keys and met our downstairs neighbour. Really lovely lady. I said we were her new neighbours and she was really happy and excited for us. We mentioned that we would be doing electrics at some point and we apologise for any noise or disruption. She said no need to apologise at all and that they only had there's done earlier on in the year and knows what a pain it can be. She told me all about out the other neighbours, ones above us are sub-letting from their mum/in law 🤔. DH went up and knocked on their door after I left and introduced himself. She was very friendly and was excited about another family moving in. He mentioned the proposed works and apologised for the noise and her response was "I have two kids, they will drown it out" another one has 3 greyhounds and the other two are young families. All privately owned. She asked for my mobile number so she can add me to the leaseholders WhatsApp group. 😊

DH still adamant he wants to carry on with the works. I'm trying to get the legal ramifications across but must admit I am wavering. He spoke to the electrician we want and he said he's more than happy to write a covering letter to send off with a retrospective approval application detailing the appalling set up as it stands and that putting a floating ceiling is was the easiest and least invasive course of action as opposed to hacking away at the existing ceiling.

I just don't know!!!!

OP posts:
1990s · 09/11/2021 18:18

@CendrillonSings

Your first lesson in leasehold ownership - never, ever, ever contact the freeholder unless there’s literally no other choice. So what if your new neighbours had heard a week of noise after completion? If you don’t let them in then once it’s done there’s no proof of anything. My old lease had a clause that I would be in breach if I didn’t have all the windows in my top floor flat externally cleaned every 30 days!

Reader, by that standard all eighty flats in the block were in permanent breach of their lease…

Agreed, going forward adopt this approach!!

It’s a bloody tricky one. I think considering they’ve said do not engage contractors etc, and adding the concrete ceiling situation, you’re going to have to wait until you’ve got permission.

Ugh. Leasehold is shit sometimes. But mostly it is fine!

TakeYourFinalPosition · 09/11/2021 11:18

@MrsWarleggan They own it, though - even as executors - so it would have been standard and pretty easy for them to request permission for works, and then that approval could have passed to you (presuming your lease allows that).

I think the electrics you'd get away with despite them classing it as "major works" for safety reasons; but you won't be able to argue that drilling a concrete ceiling isn't notifiable to the freeholder - they have a duty of care to the other leaseholders - so that muddies the waters substantially. Essentially they'd have the same defence as you - safety.

It might be worth trying the freeholder again?

It's tough, because some freeholders have crazy clauses but never enforce them; and you'd be fine. But some don't, and you'd be in breach of your lease, which means legally it's a pretty open-and-shut case - especially as they can prove that they told you of the requirement beforehand, and therefore you can't argue that you had no idea that you needed consent to go ahead. It'd be slightly less risky, legally speaking, if you'd never contacted them from that regard.

Has your solicitor advised you on their legal opinion on proceeding?

I really feel for you. Our first buyer wanted to re-do the electrics here as he intends to let it out - he sent us the details of what he wanted to do, we passed them to the freeholder, it was pretty easy. Sadly he couldn't get a mortgage offer so it didn't matter in the end, and our freeholder is pretty reasonable, but they are hot on compliance and they'd have kicked off if he'd done it without permission; so we helped try to get that for him. We also had a viewer who wanted us to ask permission for her to keep a cat here, but in the end we didn't accept her offer, so we didn't have to do it... but it is a standard thing to do.

If you google the freeholder, does anything come up about other people's dealings with them? You could maybe try and find an actual person there to contact individually and see if they can help with your case?

MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 10:49

@TakeYourFinalPosition

Also the sellers didn't live there. They are executors. Its a probate sale and it's been empty since February when it went on the marke

OP posts:
MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 10:47

@TakeYourFinalPosition

But as far as the freeholder is concerned the electrics are classed as a major change too. The ceiling is reinforced concrete which would mean drilling through it to get to the existing cable work. It will be 2mm joists and a suspended plaster board ceiling.

OP posts:
TakeYourFinalPosition · 09/11/2021 10:31

I’d do the electrics without permission and apply for it retrospectively on safety grounds…

But you can’t change the ceiling height as part of that. You will absolutely need permission for that, it will count as a major change, and if they’re anything like ours; they’ll follow the guidance to the letter and want a surveyor report about the risks of ceiling changes and how it could affect upstairs.

Is it an option to split the works and do the urgent safety works now, and the rest once you’ve got permission?

To be honest, we’d have applied for permission for our buyer to do this - I’d be a bit worried that your seller wouldn’t. It suggests they know that there’s going to be issues… have you already exchanged? If not, I’d make that a condition of exchange. Not that they get permission, but that they at least start the process off for you.

CendrillonSings · 09/11/2021 10:27

Your first lesson in leasehold ownership - never, ever, ever contact the freeholder unless there’s literally no other choice. So what if your new neighbours had heard a week of noise after completion? If you don’t let them in then once it’s done there’s no proof of anything. My old lease had a clause that I would be in breach if I didn’t have all the windows in my top floor flat externally cleaned every 30 days!

Reader, by that standard all eighty flats in the block were in permanent breach of their lease…

Zilla1 · 09/11/2021 10:25

Sorry to hear that, OP. Hope it works out.

MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 10:09

@Zilla1

We asked, they refused to even speak to me because I couldn't pass the security questions. Even with a letter from my solicitors 😔

OP posts:
MrsWarleggan · 09/11/2021 10:06

She did. She's been aware of what we want to do as we put forward and access of undertaking which was denied right at the very start. In her property report she said we may have to ask for permission (confirmed via lease of course) but then said we should contact the freeholder directly, which we did.

Freeholder: Yes you do need permission, here's the application form, don't do any works prior to receiving the licence. Don't engage with any contractors. Oh but there is a part of the application where you could do the works and ask for permission afterwards, just make sure you send us the completion certificate and photos... Ooh but don't do it like that as you will be in breach of your lease"

It's about as clear as Boris Johnsons concious!

OP posts: