Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To report this mum to the police - let my DD ride without a seatbelt

490 replies

YourFinestPantaloons · 08/11/2021 19:53

DD (9) attends football and another mum from school (whose DD also is part of the club) offered to take them to football practice after school tonight.

I said yes, and had no reason not to trust her, I'd taken her DD before. I said shall I leave a car seat at school reception - she said no, they have a spare they will bring.

It turns out that not only did they forget the spare car seat, the seatbelt in the back (middle) wasn't working. She was giving another child a lift, meaning 4 children in total (including her 2 DC) were in the car. She made DD, as the oldest, sit in the middle in the back and drove 5 miles with no seatbelt on and no car seat.

I'm absolutely furious. I rang her after DD grassed and she said they were running late and didn't want to call me at work and couldn't think of another way to get to football, and it's '5 miles of quiet road'.

WIBU to report her to the police or should I calm down? I'm so angry, I would not be going to football if this was me, they'd have to skip a week, I can't believe she put my DD at risk.

OP posts:
1Endeavour2 · 09/11/2021 02:41

For historical accuracy......we had seatbelts in early 70s and DC never travelled anywhere unless they were done up. It's ludicrous to say mothers on this thread didn't have them as children. The research was there.

lololololollll · 09/11/2021 02:13

@YourFinestPantaloons

a seatbelt obviously doesn't prevent risk

Fuck me this thread has really reached peak stupidity.

Yes I let her cross the road but I also make her look both ways as well rather than just blindly rubbing into the road - we all try and reduce risk and anyone letting passengers travel without a seatbelt is increasing risk. SURELY you aren't so thick that you can't see the difference?

Don't bother engaging with these guys any more. I've read the full thread and it's clear they're trying to get a reaction but can't really think it's ok. Some people do that in here, for the sake of an argument. It's so odd! If they do seriously believe it's fine then god help their kids!
Almostmenopausal · 09/11/2021 01:52

@musicalfrog Yes and millions of children died as a result!!!!!! That's why Laws changed!!!! 🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️

Almostmenopausal · 09/11/2021 01:45

@Pascal80

Leave it out fgs the police have enough to do.
Do southerners really say "leave it out?!?!" I haven't heard that since Only Fools & Horses!! 🤣🤣🤣
JustLyra · 09/11/2021 01:39

the risk was tiny

Unless you were the other parent how can you possibly know?

Plus the risk was high enough she chose not to take it with her own child.

And it was with the most dangerous seat in the car to be unbelted.

Plus 60% of fatalities happen on non-motorway roads so your motorway comparison is just daft.

QuestionableMouse · 09/11/2021 01:39

@BluebellsGreenbells

You can get three seats in the back! She chose not too!

I’d give the shared lifts a miss.

Surely that depends on the car and seats in question. I can in mine, but my mum's and sister's cars there's no chance of fitting three seats.
Milliepossum · 09/11/2021 01:36

@KeepPortlandWeird

I’m with the OP.

But the police don’t have time or resources to pop round and have a word with the mum.

Once you’ve chatted to your schoolgate mum friends about it, they’ll Chinese whisper the incident to death for you on your behalf and the mum will soon end up as gossip fodder as the woman who crashed her car with other people’s kids in, unbelted.

OP, this may give you a sense of justice, and she would deserve all the snubs she gets for putting someone else’s child at risk while making sure her child was safely buckled in, as I’m sure she herself was wearing a seatbelt too as driver (even if it was ‘only 5 miles’).
ViolinAndGuitar · 09/11/2021 01:36

@MissLucyEyelesbarrow

The risk is absolutely miniscule, though. And, before anyone jumps down my throat, I work in A&E/urgent care, so have unfortunately seen a lot of dead car passengers. You have to have a sense of proportion, though. The risk of death or serious injury while a passenger in a car being driven 5 miles at low speed by a sober driver is so low as to be virtually non-existent. The fatality rate for UK child car occupants is 10 deaths per billion vehicle miles - and that includes kids driven by drunk/stoned drivers. For the OP's DD, the risk from driving 5 miles with a sober driver is around 1 in a billion. There would be a single fatality from a journey of this type about once every 150 years in the UK, at current accident rates. Almost everything else that her DD could have been doing instead - walking, cycling, playing, eating - is more dangerous.

And the numbers are low perhaps because we wear seat belts ?!

Milliepossum · 09/11/2021 01:34

I was a young child just before seat belts were compulsory, we were in a low speed crash, I was thrown sideways across the back seat and my head hit hard into the window, lucky it was closed at the time. I would never allow anyone to not wear a seatbelt in my car.

KeepPortlandWeird · 09/11/2021 01:33

I’m with the OP.

But the police don’t have time or resources to pop round and have a word with the mum.

Once you’ve chatted to your schoolgate mum friends about it, they’ll Chinese whisper the incident to death for you on your behalf and the mum will soon end up as gossip fodder as the woman who crashed her car with other people’s kids in, unbelted.

namechangecovidquery · 09/11/2021 01:26

@Fogormist you are being pedantic. It is so outrageous as another mum made the choice without consulting OP or trying to make other arrangements. Accidents happen- if the child was wearing a seatbelt they would have been secure in the middle. They were not and there would nothing to stop them hitting the windscreen. Yes it might not be likely but it can happen it it’s no-one else’s right to make that choice for your child.

People of your age didn’t wear a seatbelt as they were not fitted in cars. They are now and for good reason. The “it never done me any harm” attitude is incredibly ignorant.

Fogormist · 09/11/2021 01:17

Just compare risk - the risk of driving your young family on a completely unnecessary day trip 100 miles away at high speed on the motorway and back. Against the risk of a slow 5 mile drive on a safe road without a seatbelt.
Why is 2 so outrageously dangerous you want to call the police, and 1 is absolutely fine?
OP is being ridiculous and has a nasty vengeful streak.
People of my age spent their whole childhoods being driven in cars with no seatbelts in the back. It's not a good idea, but spending 10 minutes without a seatbelt isn't a death sentence. Get a grip.

namechangecovidquery · 09/11/2021 01:09

I genuinely do not think the OP is overreacting at all!

I would be annoyed about them even forgetting the car seat. To then drive with a child in the middle with no seatbelt on is downright dangerous. It was not her call to make. Someone doing a favour or returning one does not meant they get to make that call for someone else’s child. Notice she didn’t have her child sit on the middle!

Pointing out a seatbelt doesn’t prevent risk is ludicrous- it significantly reduces the risk of death or injury and a collision while unbelted is not comparable to crossing a road or climbing a tree.

Fogormist · 09/11/2021 00:54

@YourFinestPantaloons

a seatbelt obviously doesn't prevent risk

Fuck me this thread has really reached peak stupidity.

Yes I let her cross the road but I also make her look both ways as well rather than just blindly rubbing into the road - we all try and reduce risk and anyone letting passengers travel without a seatbelt is increasing risk. SURELY you aren't so thick that you can't see the difference?

I'm not thick at all, thanks, and I therefore think OP is treating seatbelt wearing as a religion rather than as one measure taken to reduce risk. In this case, a slow 5 mile drive on a quiet road, the risk was tiny. If you drive in a car, there is always some risk of an accident. If OP is this worried about risk, she should absolutely not be allowing her child to drive in a car unless it is absolutely essential for her to do so. Does she drive on the motorway for a few hours to take the family on holiday? Drive her child to activities every afternoon? Those many many hours in the car - completely unnecessary - carry a significant risk of an accident, and wearing a seatbelt diminishes the risk of serious injury or death, but doesn't remove that risk. Why so absurdly worried about this occasion? Why completely unworried about all the unnecessary driving?
musicviking1 · 09/11/2021 00:42

I'd be furious. I have experienced something similar. Never allowed them to travel or go for playdates with that family again. My children were still in highback carseats/booster at age 9, one of my children was small for their age at 9 so needed the carseat.

Member869894 · 09/11/2021 00:40

If this was a one off incident it really wouldn't bother me. I think you are massively overreacting

YourFinestPantaloons · 09/11/2021 00:37

a seatbelt obviously doesn't prevent risk

Fuck me this thread has really reached peak stupidity.

Yes I let her cross the road but I also make her look both ways as well rather than just blindly rubbing into the road - we all try and reduce risk and anyone letting passengers travel without a seatbelt is increasing risk. SURELY you aren't so thick that you can't see the difference?

OP posts:
Fogormist · 09/11/2021 00:32

Biscuit Your reaction is ludicrously over the top. I think a lot of people would have made the same decision. The risk - on a quiet road and driving slowly for only 5 miles - was tiny.
Do you ever allow your DD to cross a road? Or to walk on a pavement? Or, God Forbid, to climb a tree? Why do you allow your DD to sit in a car at all, as a seatbelt obviously doesn't prevent risk, and most trips are non essential?

Cheeeeislifenow · 09/11/2021 00:14

Get some guts & advise this parents that they have done the wrong thing. Don’t make frivolous calls to the police because you want to give a parent a “shock”

Op has already said she has spoken to parent, op has said she is not going to the police. Op is rightfully and justifiably angry.

Strokethefurrywall · 09/11/2021 00:02

Get some guts & advise this parents that they have done the wrong thing. Don’t make frivolous calls to the police because you want to give a parent a “shock”

This. FGS we get it. She shouldn’t have done it. But the whole “I couldn’t live with myself if it happened to another child…” is disingenuous.
You’re pissed because she put your kid in danger so just bawl her out over the phone like a normal person, there’s no point rising an army of angry Mumsnet strangers.

Jesus Christ.

smoko · 08/11/2021 23:57

The police are there for actual emergencies & serious issues.

What a waste of police time! OP admits she wants to do this to give the lady a scare. This is not good use of police time.

Get some guts & advise this parents that they have done the wrong thing. Don’t make frivolous calls to the police because you want to give a parent a “shock”

People complain the police take too long to get there but look what idiocy they have to deal with on the daily!

DancingQueen85 · 08/11/2021 23:55

You're massively over reacting. My younger brother regularly travelled in the boot when we were kids, if we had other people in the car.
Your daughter is fine, no harm done. Don't let her travel with this parent again.

Wheelz46 · 08/11/2021 23:49

I find it horrifying that people are questioning why a 9 year old still requires a car seat! 🤦‍♀️

The parent should have made alternative arrangements when she realised that the seat belt wasn't working, if that meant staying at school with children until alternative arrangements could be made, then so be it. She was extremely irresponsible, if she thought it was safe, why didn't her own child sit in the seat with the broken belt!

No child of mine would be setting foot in that car!

Cheeeeislifenow · 08/11/2021 23:49

APart from @BlameItOnTheBlackStar .... who did the same thing today...and is proud of it

Lots of other posters too.
I have accidentally left boosters in the other car etc, however I would make the judgement call for MY child only. My 8 year old would go without the booster.
I cannot believe the amount of people on here who think that this was fine. If there had been an accident, would it still be okay?

CCC11 · 08/11/2021 23:42

I would be upset and not let her take your daughter again but surely that's a bit of a step to far to want to report her. If you have ever travel on a bus, you don't wear a seat belt on there so who will you report that too. Bus drivers don't particularly drive top safely either but I'm sure the mum, who by the way was doing you a favour, would have driven carefully.