Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My doctor just called me a good girl and I died a bit inside

254 replies

Wtfdoctor · 08/11/2021 16:46

I just pretended he hadn't said anything - I don't know what the actual fuck got into him, I think he thought he was being funny or charming or something and I think I was expected to smile and find it funny. But no. It wasn't funny.

He is normally a good doctor who to be fair to him has sorted out a major problem for me because he does actually listen and did blood tests to find out my issue. I generally felt very comfortable with him before this but don't know now at all if I'd feel comfortable going forward. The clinic is hormones/ fertility etc. One of the procedures he recommended I have done is a transvaginal ultrasound and I don't think I can have him do it now.

I just feel really uncomfortable and foolish when I think about it. Am I being oversensitive? I have a lot going on at the moment and wonder if I'm being unreasonable to question having him as my doctor anymore.

OP posts:
Wtfdoctor · 08/11/2021 19:32

That’s your prerogative, the alternative would be to confidently assert yourself should he try another remark or otherwise forgive and forget. It’s a healthier way to see the world.

Respectfully - that may be the healthy approach for you, it would not be for me. We are all different and things are rarely black and white. I have already been quite honest that I am emotionally vulnerable in medical contexts at the moment.

The healthier thing for me is to not put myself in a position where I feel unsafe, ie doing a TV ultrasound with him. Similarly, the healthier thing also involves maintaining the working relationship with this doctor at a level I am comfortable with because he prescribes vital meds, is very knowledgeable and I simply do not have the energy to do anything else at present.

THAT is the healthiest thing for me, so I can maintain my health as best I can with the limited amount of energy I have available to me at the moment - sorry, but we are all different, coming from different scenarios.

'Forgiving and forgetting' just sounds like it would be an attempt for me to minimise my own feelings and pretend they didn't happen - that approach doesn't work for me.

OP posts:
thepastisanothercountry · 08/11/2021 19:29

@BingoandBluey

Could he have a young daughter at home? I have to stop myself from giving cbeebies level enthusiastic praise to colleagues at work sometimes, I'm just tired and spend a LOT of time with my young dc.
This made me smile. A colleague once handed me a report they'd spent ages on - first thing Monday morning and I said absently "That's lovely, you must have worked very hard, now tell me all about it!"

OP I don't think he meant it as a sinister thing, it just sounds like a joke that fell flat on its face. If he's otherwise a good doctor, let it go or maybe when you see him tell him "You've been such a good boy I'm going to let you carry on treating me for now"

DameMaureen · 08/11/2021 19:29

@Dumbledoresgirl

Jesus, I am the least woke person I know but I would consider being called a good girl by anyone but my one remaining parent extremely belittling and creepy. I cringe whenever my boss says good morning girls to me and my coworkers, not one of which is under 40. I probably wouldnt complain or stop seeing an otherwise competent doctor, but if it was said more than once I think I would have to quietly say something to indicate a bit more respect was needed.
Have you said anything to your boss about this ?
rwalker · 08/11/2021 19:21

Probperly on auto pilot and you were a long line of people he'd seen all day .

blueshoes · 08/11/2021 19:18

I would quietly switch doctors. You know if this gives you the ick. It sounds like it does because you don't want him to do transvaginal scans.

I come from a family of doctors. I always request female doctors or nurses for gynae procedures. Don't need that power trip patronising shit.

phonetica · 08/11/2021 19:16

@1Micem0use

My midwife kept saying good girl, which I found deeply infantalising but was in too much agony to say anything
Interestingly there was a BMJ article a couple of years ago about language in maternity care and the use of ‘good girl’ to labouring women was mentioned.

I’ve seen it many times on OBEM as well and it’s just so incredibly odd, grown adult women being called good girl.

Mumofone2021 · 08/11/2021 19:11

I passed an online exam once, that we had to take in a room in a controlled environment. I was the only female there (it was a trade exam for a predominantly male profession. A high level exam)
We had two hours, I finished it in 45 minutes and scored 100% and the examiner walked up behind me and said ‘we’ll aren’t you a clever little princess’

GaolBhoAlba · 08/11/2021 19:04

@Wtfdoctor

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.
Its a disproportionate reaction. As is telling someone to eff off. Both completely disproportionate btw, not just a little.
Igneo · 08/11/2021 19:02

I think this is another example where the use of marginally sexist language belies an underlying issue of power imbalance.

I hope you are able to negotiate what you need op, while feeling comfortable with the people who treat you.

Glassofshloer · 08/11/2021 19:02

@Wtfdoctor

I will keep him as my doctor for hormone and medication management but go elsewhere for gynae procedures.

MNetters may sneer at that but I'm frankly quite vulnerable emotionally in medical contexts right now, and will not set myself up to fail by going into a situation I feel doesn't work for me like a TV ultrasound with this doctor.

That’s your prerogative, the alternative would be to confidently assert yourself should he try another remark or otherwise forgive and forget. It’s a healthier way to see the world.
AutumnAlmanack · 08/11/2021 18:59

He was just trying to put you at ease and comfort you. Why do people have to analyse everything. To be honest, I'd love it if a doctor, dentist or nurse said this to me - makes you feel comforted and cared for.

WeDidntMeanToGoToSea · 08/11/2021 18:58

Even as an ill-judged joke, this goes way beyond the acceptable. It's effectively saying 'I have the power to choose how much pain I cause you with this and I will choose (this time) to spare you some pain because you have been compliant (thus far)'.
I'm wondering if the big-needle product is cheaper and his thinking is going along the lines of 'she's having such a rough time and has done so well in this so I'll take the budget hit/get the flak for prescribing the pricier one' (obv I don't know exactly how the funding works, as I don't live in the UK, but where I am this sort of thing might be an issue). But it's come out with a completely different (and frankly horrible) emphasis.

IIWY, OP, I'd have to raise it at your next appt and see how he responded.

GingerScallop · 08/11/2021 18:58

So true about the standards on Mumsnet. Perfect hags with perfect lives looking for other perfect people in every sphere of life

GingerScallop · 08/11/2021 18:55

@Wtfdoctor

I will keep him as my doctor for hormone and medication management but go elsewhere for gynae procedures.

MNetters may sneer at that but I'm frankly quite vulnerable emotionally in medical contexts right now, and will not set myself up to fail by going into a situation I feel doesn't work for me like a TV ultrasound with this doctor.

only you can make the best decision for your care. Hopefully you get a better doc
Wtfdoctor · 08/11/2021 18:49

I will keep him as my doctor for hormone and medication management but go elsewhere for gynae procedures.

MNetters may sneer at that but I'm frankly quite vulnerable emotionally in medical contexts right now, and will not set myself up to fail by going into a situation I feel doesn't work for me like a TV ultrasound with this doctor.

OP posts:
rc22 · 08/11/2021 18:47

If a doctor had, for example, advised me to get more exercise and I returned to my next appointment and said I'd been running four times a week, I would take 'good girl' as meaning 'well done.' But in the context you've described, it's not quite appropriate.

RobotValkyrie · 08/11/2021 18:44

As you're such a good girl, I'm going to prescribe X which is a smaller needle and hurts less

Sounds like a sadist on a power trip.

Seriously, what kind of answer does he expect?
"Oh no, I've been a bad bad girl, could you please prescribe me the one with the big hard needle instead?"...
Or "Thank you for your infinite generosity, oh graceful provider of relatively pain-free life-saving drugs"?

As a rule of thumb, if a comment:

  • makes the recipient uncomfortable
  • does not call for any particular answer or reaction (and in fact, it's hard to think of a suitable answer/reaction)

Then odds are:

  • it was said for the benefit of the speaker, not the recipient
  • it should never have been said out loud
Wtfdoctor · 08/11/2021 18:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

oakleaffy · 08/11/2021 18:36

Jeez let it go.
If that is all you have to complain about, you are extremely lucky.

I did have a very inappropriate comment and action done by a male GP which I should have pulled him up on.my youthfulness got in the way.

“ Good girl” is a bit patronising, but it isn’t harmful.

Conran3 · 08/11/2021 18:31

I say it to my friend all the time..it wasn't meant in a creepy way if you ask me. My GP has said it to me many times over the years and Im 53!
Some people say it and some people don't, there's nothing underlying in it. I think you are being a bit silly.
I doubt your doctor would risk his huge salary just for this! It's purely part of his personality for heaven's sake.

Lotusmonster · 08/11/2021 18:30

@VainAbigail

I’m not sure that this is something to write off a great doctor for.
^^this.
Evangelo · 08/11/2021 18:27

Congrats OP, you've just discovered he's not perfect, like everybody else. Hardly the crime of the year to say what he said. You can read anything you want into it, I doubt that was his intention.

There are actual issues to get worked up about - this isn't it. I agree with pp, this is 'wokery' gone wrong and YAB completely ridiculous.

TheAverageUser · 08/11/2021 18:23

As in the joke is in the faux patronising comment because you're an adult and can handle a big needle but he's being considerate.

^ that would be how I would have taken it.

MoMuntervary · 08/11/2021 18:21

Crikey me. I wouldn't have batted an eyelid at this. 'Good girl' could be used to belittle and patronise but unless he was accompanying the phrase with actions e.g. dismissing and minimising your health concerns, then I would just assume a joke to put you at your ease. I don't imagine he would use the same language with a man but I can totally see a female HCP doing the same with a male patient (and think I have).

Evangelo · 08/11/2021 18:20

Omg get a grip!! It's clearly meant as a joke 🙄 bloody hell this wokery needs to end.

Agreed! All I see here is drama, making a mountain out of a molehill and over-reacting!

I'll suggest stepping away from mumsnet a while to get a bit of perspective. Making a big deal about nothing.Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread