Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends 10yo DD hitting my 1yo DS.

37 replies

star8 · 08/11/2021 14:46

Hi everyone.
Need to write this out for some outside opinions. I have a best friend I've known for 9 years. Her dd was 1 when we met. Been through tough times together so a valued friend. Her DD however has for many year had anger issues both in school and home with problems with hitting peers and cousins. She is 10. Ive always been a bit wary of her and know that she can be sly with hittingas she has pushed my Ds1 when he was 1 but alwys when no one looking or around so I am hyper vigilant. So DS2 is one now and friend and DD visited. I have camera in room and had a feeling to be extra aware. She didnt know monitor was on. DS2 playing with her excited. He cant talk yet. I saw her roughly grabbing him. Wasn't 100 percent clear. She then came to room we were in to check what we were doing. Sort of scoped out the surroundings. Went back to room and i saw she went to top bunk and stepping on DS head with 1 foot. I was livid and shouted out for friend to go deal with it. The AIBU is i feel this will now cause a wedge between is as friends as although she told her off she thinks her dd will not do it again. I don't trust her and my instincts always made me hyper aware when she was around my Ds. It the calculated hitting and targeting the ds that cant talk that freaks me out. Ds1 is 5
Sorry its long I just can't get over it. It happened a few months ago.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AutumnLeaves21 · 08/11/2021 18:19

Hang on…so he walked past, she put her dangling foot on his head as he walked by? With no weight behind it? Did it hurt him?
Difficult to say if she did it maliciously but it paints a different story to the OP which read as if she stamped on his head.
That said, the other things alone would be enough for me to not want this girl around my toddler.

BobLemon · 08/11/2021 18:18

As others have pointed out, and you have acknowledged, you left your baby with a kid you had “bad vibes” about. I voted YABU for allowing this to happen.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 08/11/2021 17:50

The issue of blasé dismissal is an interesting one considering the OP is blocking any mention of her part in this.

She knew the older child's history but left her alone with a non verbal small toddler.

A monitor isn't a babysitter and things happen in a flash. No responsible adult would leave a toddler with a dog, breezily expecting a monitor to keep the child safe - why would the OP think a monitor would protect a toddler from an older child with a known pattern of aggressive behaviour!

star8 · 08/11/2021 17:47

I agree I do take responsibility in it too. I should never have allowed even a minute of her being alone. Definitely haunts me still. I defo think we wont b friends for much longer. We msg here and then on whatsapp but its very short and not how it was. I remember being 10 and knowing exactly what i was right and wrong.

OP posts:
TrashyPanda · 08/11/2021 17:40

The mothers blasé dismissal would have annoyed me almost as much as her daughters deliberate behaviour.

Sounds like the child needs serious help. This is not normal behaviour.

LittleGwyneth · 08/11/2021 17:35

You can still be friends, but see each other without the children. Keep it to socialising outside of either of your homes. Though to be totally honest I don't know if I would want to...

PurpleOkapi · 08/11/2021 17:34

Of course YANBU for not wanting her child to hit your children. But YABU for allowing it to happen in the first place. You knew about her child's issues, and left her unsupervised with your own children. Why? No 10-year-old wants to play with a 5-year-old and a 1-year-old anyway, so why on earth would you ever have allowed this particular 10-year-old, with known issues, to go off into a separate room with your children?

If you can't or don't want to arrange ways to see her without your children being there, or you're just too angry to maintain the friendship anyway, that's fine. But YABU to act as though it's entirely her fault when it's clear neither of you thought anything was going to happen. Protecting your children is ultimately your job, not hers.

star8 · 08/11/2021 17:19

Defo sounds like she has serrrrious issues. I have also seen a lovely side to her too. I have known her since she was 1 so I dont want to say she is all bad. But yeah that is neither here nor there anymore. Just bad vibes so knew to watch her.
Just to answer a few question... no not her dull weight on him. She was sitting on top bunk feet hanging down and feet on his head as came by.
I had camera on and monitor was being watched by me for that minute hence my speedy response.
Even so.... the girl is must definitely not allowed near us. I'm their mum I protect them like a lion. This aibu was more to gage if i was right in letting the friendship fizzle and alot of you agree with me.
Thanks for the replies x

OP posts:
esloquehay · 08/11/2021 16:55

Did I read this right: your 1 year old was In a room alone, unsupervised on a bunk bed?
🤯

Youdoyoutoday · 08/11/2021 16:53

That's deranged! Did she actually put her full weight on his head?
I'd be telling your friend her daughter needs help and quick and I wouldn't give a fuck if the friendship survived or not!!

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 08/11/2021 16:51

10!!!!
She sounds like a psychopath.

I would be really clear with my "friend" that her child was not welcome in my home ever again. She could have killed or hospitalised your baby.
I am not sure i could be friends with her going forward. The minimisation and dismissal of the danger and seriousness of what her child did is quite shocking.

TotallySuper · 08/11/2021 16:38

Wow the DD sounds very calculating and a bit psychopathic Confused I'd be very concerned and I think it's a shame the mum isn't doing more for her. It sounds like this could escalate quickly if she was given given the chance. However I have just read an article where a 16 year old lured a 12 year old into the woods and stabbed him 70 times so maybe that's put me in this mindset!

Evesgarden · 08/11/2021 16:33

She sounds disturbed OP.

Obviously keep her away from your kids but I would really consider that something has gone wrong with this child - this isn't a parenting issue. Older children dont naturally hurt babies - regardless of their lax parenting.

SolasAnla · 08/11/2021 15:30

Sorry but you are at fault here too. You both knew that the child can act out and be violent.

You were aware that the child is more careful around adults.
You and your friend decided to allow the children to play outside your direct supervision.

Rather than putting safeguards in place by having an honest conversation and saying the child remains in the same room as you, you both ignored the issue until it resulted in the child hurting your child.

You can both be polite and loose the friendship or be honest and place firm boundaries about limiting how your children interact with each other.

If you don't want the child around at all be honest about that too, that way your friendship may survive as friendly ear.

BeardieWeirdie · 08/11/2021 15:17

That evil child would never be near mine ever again.

SVRT19674 · 08/11/2021 15:16

Obviously that girl has issues and also obvious her mum is burying her head in the sand. A friend of mine was an aupair in the 90s in England to an American family whose elder daughter had these issues. So much so that the youngest sibling was living with grandparents in the States, after a series of "incidents". My friend left as soon as she could. She fell and twisted her ankle and said kid would bump into her leg on purpose, she enjoyed inflicting pain, and seeing others scared. I wouldn´t like to meet her as an adult.

flippertyop · 08/11/2021 15:15

This is unbelievable and unacceptable wtf - no ten year olds should be behaving like this

BurntO · 08/11/2021 15:13

Don’t let your kids come between your friendship. They shouldn’t be having unsupervised play for a start if you are aware she has issues. Arrange activities without the kids too if possible.

SoniaFouler · 08/11/2021 15:13

That is absolutely awful. I could understand if the child was 3 but not 10. The friendship doesn’t necessarily have to end (like meeting up when her daughter is at school) but absolutely NOT when the daughter is around. Even if you’re there supervising. How horrible. And how horrible for you to have witnessed it too.

AnneLovesGilbert · 08/11/2021 15:12

Keep your children safe.

You could try meeting up just the two of you but the friendship would be over from my POV by her minimising.

Her DD is as at the age of criminal responsibility and there’ll be serious consequences soon enough that your friend will have to deal with.

Awful situation.

star8 · 08/11/2021 15:12

Spot on. Minimising it with that comment was like wtf. She defo wont be around my children ever or in my home. Or out in fact. Believe me guy i am not trying to make my childrens safety 2nd to a friendship. No way jose.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 08/11/2021 15:11

Why are you leaving a 1 year old in a room with a child who you know is violent and aggressive?

The child should know better but Jesus Christ - any harm he comes to is on you.

titchy · 08/11/2021 15:10

Knowing what you do, why on earth are you leaving them all unsupervised? Frankly you shouldn't be leaving a 1 year old unsupervised anyway, regardless of other children that are there.

Beamur · 08/11/2021 15:09

She deliberately stepped on a 1 yr old head? That's very worrying. She sounds as if she's very disturbed in some way, that's very odd behaviour.
Despite your friendship and some sympathies for your friend and this girl, I would be extremely wary for your children around her. I very much doubt she is learning to stop these behaviours unless she is getting some help.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 08/11/2021 15:08

I am not sure whether this needs to be the end of the friendship. I'd be disappointed in the 'shes learnt her lesson this time's though, it's really dismissive and illogical to think a 10 year old with a history of violence anger and unresolved issues that multiple people are trying to help her with, will not do this again. I think that's what would upset me the most, I'd have preferred her to be honest and not minimise the extent of the issues. On the other hand this is probably a very difficult time for her and she is probably worried sick about her daughter and the effect of her behaviour on her own friendships like you. So I'd try and be understanding.

I think I'd say that it's best to keep meet ups where you can keep an eye on both children eg the park or if one of you has an open plan house bring all the toys into the room and have a dont leave the room rule. If she says her daughter wont do it again I'd just say that we don't know that for sure and you woudlnt be able to enjoy their company if you were worried about her son being hurt