Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Staying with family with 13 month old, who is right?

154 replies

spicysausages · 08/11/2021 13:01

Debating this with a family member.

ILs invite you to stay for a week with 13 month old. 13 month old has a huge appetite and has slight delay with gross motor skills and the medical advice is to make sure the 13 month old eats well (amongst other things). Parent of 13 month old says to ILs that she is happy to cook for 13 month old as she knows what they like and it is important that they eat well.

Problem 1: ILs think that children of guests should be fed by hosts, that it is rude to dictate what your 13 month old eats and rude to not just eat whatever hosts provide and they are quite cross about the idea of adult guest eating with them, happily, but cooking separately for dc. Use of kitchen is not a problem, it is a question of principle not practicalities

Problem 2: ILs have bought spicy sausages and 13 month old has not yet ever eaten chilli or paprika, ILs think that spicy sausages are appropriate, parent does not

Problem 3: Parent of 13 month old tends to cook up stews and then liquidise and to feed this to 13 month old along with finger food. ILs think that any spoon feeding at all at 13months is tantamount to emotional abuse because it is treating the 13 month as younger developmentally than they are, and that the bit about slow gross motor skills is nonsense, a 13 month old will feed themselves enough with finger food

Who do you think is right for each of the problems?!

OP posts:
tattygrl · 08/11/2021 13:50

Essentially I don't understand why anyone would want to dictate to you how to feed your child while in their home; when I have guests I want them to feel comfortable and secure, and free to do their own thing. Me enforcing my opinions on them isn't high on my priority list. Therefore imo YANBU.

TulipsTwoLips · 08/11/2021 13:50

I think it's rude to dictate what someone staying with you has to eat.

girlmom21 · 08/11/2021 13:49

@spicysausages

Same inlaws complained that a parent of a 3 year old was cutting up grapes for them, telling them grapes were not a chocking issue, only peanuts were, so I do think ILs are slightly U generally.
Or just uneducated? When we were having baby no.1 the hospital offered antenatal classes and a grandparents evening where grandparents were given loads of information (the same as us really) about what is and isn't safe and it was obviously very different to the advice they were given 30 years ago
Moonshine11 · 08/11/2021 13:46

It's never been an issue at my parents or ILs to make my DC separate food, they offer to do it or help.
I wouldn't like it either Op and think ILs are being unreasonable on that part.

Unless dr has said blend his food, his motor skills will develop when trying to eat himself.
I would give him a spoon at the same time and encourage the use of it.

tattygrl · 08/11/2021 13:46

@MLMshouldbeillegal

Why are you blending food for a child who is over a year old?
I assume this is related to the delayed motor skill development mentioned?
KatharinaRosalie · 08/11/2021 13:45

No random relative without medical degree will be dictating or even having opinions about when and what I will feed my 13-month old baby.

And yes my DC2 was like some described on this thread who would eat anything. On the other hand, if 13 month old DC1 would have been given only spicy fingerfood, he would have starved. Kids are different and just because one was chomping down wasabi-covered spare ribs does not mean all of them can or should do it.

stingofthebutterfly · 08/11/2021 13:43
  1. I think it's rude to ask if you can prepare something completely different for your child. Recipes can be adapted to work for children of any age. I think providing your own microwave meal would be more acceptable than you cooking from scratch in their kitchen.

  2. Spicy sausage may not be appropriate for a 13 month old, depending on it's firmness and heat, if the child has never eaten spicy foods before. It may also be absolutely fine. Only you know this.

  3. A 13 months old doesn't need anything blended. Mashed, yes, but blending food isn't giving them the opportunity to develop the muscles needed for chewing and speaking. Of course their gross motor skills will be delayed if they're not given the opportunity to use them.

AliasGrape · 08/11/2021 13:43

Both sides a bit unreasonable really.

I've never insisted on cooking separately for my DD when staying with family, though I've offered to and tend to do her breakfast/ sometimes lunch if it's easier depending on what else is happening that day. I wouldn't offer to cook their own dinner though if we were going to be eating dinner together - my family are mostly foodies and into cooking/ hosting so I can see they'd find that a bit odd. Having said that everyone who has cooked for us/dd so far has been really concerned to find out what she might like, what she can/ can't have and offered alternatives/ extras even when I've said its fine she pretty much has the same as us.

So I can see why the in laws preferred to cook for everyone (though if it were me and a new parent wanted to do it themselves I'd let them crack on) but also think it's weird they're so insistent on the dc eating something their parent doesn't think is suitable.

At home I'm careful about salt content, sugar, making sure its balanced etc but I tend to let that slide a bit if we are away especially if someone else is cooking.

I'm surprised the DC hasn't had any spices or paprika by 13 months and don't think that combined with the liquidising will be doing them any flavours in terms of getting them to eat a wide variety of foods down the line,and think if the child is having finger foods as well as the liquidised stuff they are clearly capable of eating food that isn't in liquid form. Liquidised/ blended stews etc make me feel quite sick though just the idea of them and I wouldn't want to eat them so wouldn't feed them to my DC, but then she took to weaning really well and didn't need that so we were lucky there and I recognise it's a parenting choice and if you think it suits your child best then you know best. Again, if you were in my house I'd let you crack on without comment but I'd privately probably think it was a bit daft unless your child couldn't eat food any other way.

SarahJeffers341 · 08/11/2021 13:42

IL’s being totally unreasonable. It’s your child and you decide how to feed them. Nothing to do with them! I would not stay somewhere I was made to feel like that.

Blinkingbatshit · 08/11/2021 13:41

I’m also surprised at some of these responses. Your request to feed your baby food they’re used to is not unreasonable. Their concern should have been making you welcome and comfortable - I’d not go again!! My kids were fussy babies and I used to take frozen meals for them with me when we stayed places and just heat up in the microwave - no hassle for anyone.

Suspicioussam · 08/11/2021 13:41

I am surprised at the responses too. I'd hate to stay somewhere with family where I felt so judged! My toddler is so fussy, but he still needs to eat. It would be rude if you had asked them to cook separate meals but you're cooking them yourself, and the child is only 13 months old, practically a baby.

MysweetAudrina · 08/11/2021 13:40

This is how it would go in my house. X likes y food, do you mind if I prepare some food for them separately? No, of course not, go ahead.

And it wouldn't matter what age X was.

spicysausages · 08/11/2021 13:39

Also just in case relevant, dc was right at the edge of milestones in terms of gross motor skills. They only started to hold head up alone at 5.5 months for example. No other SNs, just to do with muscle strength.

OP posts:
gogohm · 08/11/2021 13:39

@spicysausages

The grapes thing is a bit generational, I didn't cut them up by 3, nor did nursery - my kids are now young adults. I've seen 6 , 7 year olds with cut up grapes, bit ridiculous, you have to teach them to bite into them, where do you draw the line?

EllaDuggee · 08/11/2021 13:37

Your in laws are unreasonable , they should let you do whatever you need to to keep DC fed and happy. As DC's grandparents I'm surprised they can't see that, they sound controlling. Don't go or book an airbnb to stay in instead.

spicysausages · 08/11/2021 13:36

Same inlaws complained that a parent of a 3 year old was cutting up grapes for them, telling them grapes were not a chocking issue, only peanuts were, so I do think ILs are slightly U generally.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 08/11/2021 13:35

I wouldn't stay somewhere where I couldn't fully cater to my toddlers needs, but at the same time I would encourage my child to eat the food provided first, as we do at home anyway.

gogohm · 08/11/2021 13:34

Bit of both here. But I'm bordering on the il's side. At 13 months unless health reasons they can eat normal food, no need to liquidise and mine certainly ate chilli, curry etc from about 10 months. One of mine had significant delays too. It's good for youngsters to eat with the adults too

spicysausages · 08/11/2021 13:34

and not even letting them try stuff that other people have cooked just seems unnecessary and like you're holding them back a bit no, no, as I said dc were sitting with family and eating finger foods and whatever was offered to them by whomever, the blended food was on top of that, to make sure they were getting enough food, and only because they really love blended food.

OP posts:
maras2 · 08/11/2021 13:31

I wouldn't let anyone tell me when, how or what to feed my kids.
Then again none of my family, in laws included would have been rude enough to do so. Advice was always welcomed though.
Same applies now with my children and grand children.
I may give advice if asked but they are the parents now and not mine nor anyone else's place to insist on which type of food or feeding.

Thehop · 08/11/2021 13:31

I’d think parents and medical staff knew best and make my kitchen available to parents as they saw fit! I’m hosting family guests, not being asked to take on full time care.

Starcaller · 08/11/2021 13:30

I absolutely think in-laws were BU. But I also think that you're perhaps making life more difficult than it needs to be. At 13 months old, even with some gross motor issues, blending and pureeing food and not even letting them try stuff that other people have cooked just seems unnecessary and like you're holding them back a bit. It sounds like harder work than it needs to be, I suppose. I think most kids get hangry, DD certainly has a big appetite, but allowing them to feed themselves wherever possible is important, IMO, for teaching healthy eating habits.

spicysausages · 08/11/2021 13:30

In relation to spicy sausages, it is a long story but basically 13 month old trying spicy sausages would not be a problem, the problem was that it was proposed as being a casserole and the only dinner to be made available, other than other bits and pieces I cobbled together, and I said that I wasn't sure it was a good idea. DC trying new foods is fine, but a bit risky as the entire meal.

OP posts:
Flapjak · 08/11/2021 13:28

I wouldnt stay. What type of family member doesnt let you feed your baby (13 months is still a baby( how they need to be fed. Its hard enough as a parent getting them to eat without ignorant and controlling inlaws forcing spicy sausages into the mix. I have been trying to get my kids to eat spicy food for years and they will not eat it.

spicysausages · 08/11/2021 13:27

@TabithaTiger

Really surprised at some of these responses. If I had a grandchild, I'd want my DIL to do whatever she felt best to make sure the child. was happy and well fed. It makes absolutely no difference whatsoever to In laws.
Thank you! I am slightly surprised at some of the answers too, I just cannot imagine being bothered by what a mother fed their 13 month old at my house! In fact, I'd prefer a guest to cater for their 13 month old.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread