Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think revenge cheating could save marriage

69 replies

lqvender · 08/11/2021 12:40

I found out my husband of 12 years has been cheating on me for a number of years. It has been probably the most traumatic experience of my life. We've been going to couples' counselling which has helped a bit, and we are still able to have a great time together.

However, I still have so much anger at his selfishness - that he would risk all that we have. I also feel like he genuinely does not get how awful this has been for me. AIBU to think he would "get" it if I were to do the same to him, i.e. have an affair also?

I kind of know it's a really stupid idea, but I also don't think I can move passed it (and genuinely forgive him)... and I worry resentment will just build and build in me until we eventually split up anyway. I mean there are times I hate him to his core. But he's also the love of my life and I can't imagine meeting anyone more amazing... arghhh, the conflicting emotions. Sorry for the ramble!

So I just wondered if there is anyone out there who has tried revenge cheating, with the hope of restoring their marriage and creating empathy, and what the outcome was? Or if you cheated on your partner and had them revenge cheat back on you, did it give you perspective?

OP posts:
PurpleOkapi · 08/11/2021 15:27

So instead of you being hurt and angry with him, you'll both be hurt and angry with each other. If your goal is to get revenge, this will accomplish that nicely. If your goal is to save your marriage, that's a terrible plan.

DrSbaitso · 08/11/2021 15:21

At that point I think I could begin to forgive infidelity, knowing he would be broken inside like I was.

But could either of you love each other, knowing that was what you set out to do?

Do you want to feel avenged, or do you want to try to rediscover and rebuild love?

Relationships aren't supposed to be battlegrounds. If you're seeing yours in those terms, I'd say it's over, affair or not.

Franklyfrost · 08/11/2021 15:19

Even if you had an affair for years he would not feel your pain. If he felt pain it would be different from yours and there would still be your pain. You can’t balance this situation out, it can’t be fixed, he cheated on you and maybe you stat and maybe you don’t but you can’t undo or balance out the betrayal.

Malibuismysecrethome · 08/11/2021 15:19

Two wrongs don’t make a right

Kanaloa · 08/11/2021 15:18

And it does absolutely nothing to heal the damage that’s been done emotionally. Just gives him the ability to say well you did it as well so even stevens.

Kanaloa · 08/11/2021 15:17

[quote JovialNickname]Thankyou@kanaloa, I do know what you're saying. But why is she throwing away her dignity? He did that. Why is this on her?

Also much as it's not fashionable to say it these days, men think differently to women. What we might think of as dignified (say and do nothing) can be construed to a man as a walkover, pathetic. Who wants to be a doormat.[/quote]
Because getting dressed up and making him read ‘horny texts’ before you go and have sex with another man is basically a ‘cuckold’ fantasy. It’s debasing and humiliating and to be honest it isn’t even a good deterrent for him not to cheat again.

And it does not equal the betrayal of having a partner cheat on you because you’re basically doing it with his knowledge. It’s a very bad idea.

DrSbaitso · 08/11/2021 15:16

Sounds like a risky strategy, to say the least.

Without defending what he's done, I assume that he had his affair because it made him feel good, not because he had any intention of hurting you. Your revenge affair would be done entirely to hurt him and that does make a difference. It might make you feel avenged but if you really do want your marriage to work, then it doesn't seem conducive to that.

You may even find that having has an affair himself, he feels able to compartmentalise and wouldn't find it as devastating as you did. If so, in his eyes you'd have even less reason to be so distraught, since he doesn't view it as such a big deal.

If you really do want to try to save the marriage, it would seem better to look at why the affair happened - and that's certainly not to say you must be blamed - and see if that's a solvable problem. Affairs are never right but they aren't all the same.

NothingSafe · 08/11/2021 15:16

@JovialNickname

And men are basic creatures. Sometimes they have to feel things, themselves, viscerally, to really understand. You blathering on in a therapist's room will make him feel mildly guilty, attacked and a bit resentful. Doing it back, if he cares, makes him feel the pain. And most importantly, makes you an equal in the relationship. You reassert your dominance. You're not a whining pet he has to feel sorry for and make amends to. You bettered him.
This is awful advice.

1 .It only makes you an equal in that it makes you equally bad. It's about as much sense as having the death penalty for murderers - "You broke the rules of our marriage and my trust, and that is a TERRIBLE, AWFUL thing to do. I shall do the same."

  1. Unless there's a safeword or Scrabble involved, romantic relationships should not be about who's more dominant, who's winning, who's beating the other at the game. It's an unhealthy dynamic that introduces the idea of conflict between the two of you (again, consensual BDSM with proper communication excluded).
  1. OP isn't a 'whining pet' anyway. She's someone who has been hurt and betrayed, and if her husband sees her as a whining pet for needing reassurance because of his actions, she should leave him anyway.
Helpsortmylife · 08/11/2021 15:14

@JovialNickname

And men are basic creatures. Sometimes they have to feel things, themselves, viscerally, to really understand. You blathering on in a therapist's room will make him feel mildly guilty, attacked and a bit resentful. Doing it back, if he cares, makes him feel the pain. And most importantly, makes you an equal in the relationship. You reassert your dominance. You're not a whining pet he has to feel sorry for and make amends to. You bettered him.
Firstly men are fully human. This man understands English. He can well understand and see her pain. I have heard men who had affairs say how absolutely devastating it was to see the utter pain it caused their wives. If THIS husband cannot see that, then that's a fault with him and a reason not to hold onto him.

Secondly, OP will not reassert her dominance or better him. People who lash out in pain just show that they are consumed by distress and are out of control of themselves. Its really not a position of strength.

JovialNickname · 08/11/2021 15:13

Thankyou@kanaloa, I do know what you're saying. But why is she throwing away her dignity? He did that. Why is this on her?

Also much as it's not fashionable to say it these days, men think differently to women. What we might think of as dignified (say and do nothing) can be construed to a man as a walkover, pathetic. Who wants to be a doormat.

PermanentTemporary · 08/11/2021 15:11

Tbh there are a lot of men who would find that scenario insanely hot and would want you to do it again. I think you have to start from what might help you, not what might hurt your husband.

JovialNickname · 08/11/2021 15:07

And men are basic creatures. Sometimes they have to feel things, themselves, viscerally, to really understand. You blathering on in a therapist's room will make him feel mildly guilty, attacked and a bit resentful. Doing it back, if he cares, makes him feel the pain. And most importantly, makes you an equal in the relationship. You reassert your dominance. You're not a whining pet he has to feel sorry for and make amends to. You bettered him.

Kanaloa · 08/11/2021 15:06

@JovialNickname

This is what I think I would do, if I was in a long term relationship and he cheated; and I believed he was really, truly remorseful and I wanted to keep him. Of course it only works if he loves you and would be wracked with pain at the thought of you with someone else. Otherwise you're just playing into his hands - "I've done nothing you haven't done, neither of us are blameless" - etc.

I would get ready in front of him and go out, sending horny anticipatory texts I would make him read. And the deal would be he has to sit at home, alone, stewing, whilst I meet with Mr. Fuck. At that point I think I could begin to forgive infidelity, knowing he would be broken inside like I was.

This only works if he truly loves you and would be ripped apart at the thought of you with someone else.

This is what I would do. Fuck understanding and counselling - although there's a place for that later.

Having said that it's a hypothetical situation for me, so I can't really comment. But I share the feeling of an eye for an eye x

That just sounds so toxic for both you and the cheating husband. Plus (in my opinion) it would be throwing away your dignity getting ready in front of him and making him read horny texts etc. It would just be lowering yourself and embarrassing all round. It’s also not the same betrayal as it is finding out he has cheated on you and you had no idea.
JovialNickname · 08/11/2021 15:02

This is what I think I would do, if I was in a long term relationship and he cheated; and I believed he was really, truly remorseful and I wanted to keep him. Of course it only works if he loves you and would be wracked with pain at the thought of you with someone else. Otherwise you're just playing into his hands - "I've done nothing you haven't done, neither of us are blameless" - etc.

I would get ready in front of him and go out, sending horny anticipatory texts I would make him read. And the deal would be he has to sit at home, alone, stewing, whilst I meet with Mr. Fuck. At that point I think I could begin to forgive infidelity, knowing he would be broken inside like I was.

This only works if he truly loves you and would be ripped apart at the thought of you with someone else.

This is what I would do. Fuck understanding and counselling - although there's a place for that later.

Having said that it's a hypothetical situation for me, so I can't really comment. But I share the feeling of an eye for an eye x

SW1amp · 08/11/2021 14:52

It's a really terrible idea

If anything, won't it help him minimise his actions?
Oh cheating is just something everyone does. Even my silly wife pretended it was hurtful but she went straight out and did it so it can't be that bad...

Lovinglife45 · 08/11/2021 14:47

I did this very thing and I wish I had not.

I wanted revenge plain and simple. I was stuck and frustrated. I was not in a position to move out comfortably and went around in circles. I was hurting tremendously and hated being the victim, the person something had been done to.

The ongoing lies, deceit and betrayal ran deep. This was worse than my stbxh's actions.

Once I had crossed that line I knew the love I had, had gone. I knew I could not have done the act whilst love was still there. I knew there and then that my marriage was over. It was like a light went off in my head.

The damage has already been done. You can either live with it or leave. It is an awful place to be in. I remember the turmoil.

Unfortunately I lowered myself to my stbxh's standards. I will say the OM was unattached and I made no promises to him.

NadiaVulvokov · 08/11/2021 14:44

An eye for an eye makes everyone blind.

ftw163532 · 08/11/2021 14:28

I can't imagine meeting anyone more amazing

You couldn't imagine him cheating on you for - what, a quarter of your marriage? A third? Half? All of it?

But he did.

It's often difficult to imagine or visualise how our life might play out, especially when we are in pain, but simply not being able to picture something doesn't mean it won't happen. You can't imagine a different future now but it's still possible.

Then there's the fact that a man who was unfaithful for a significant portion of your marriage - and who doesn't even recognise or empathise with the harm he's caused - is not a man worthy of being called amazing. That sets the bar very low.

So in that respect meeting someone who equals or surpasses him wouldn't be all that difficult or remarkable.

that he would risk all that we have

He didn't place the same value on it as you and was therefore less concerned about potential losses, that's why. These are not the actions of a man who values and respects you, or who values your shared life.

He also likely calculated that it wasn't a risk - you haven't left him but are focused on extreme and desperate ideas to keep him. Thus far he appears to have calculated correctly.

I think you know all that though and that's part of why you're so angry.

It's fair enough to be in shock and denial trying to minimise or explain away his actions as you grieve - because even if you stay you've already suffered a loss that can't be undone - but please don't hit the self-destruct button too. You don't deserve that.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 08/11/2021 14:23

Nope.

Just divorce.

You'll never trust him again anyway.

Sorry.

thepeopleversuswork · 08/11/2021 14:22

2. Controlling our partner to 'prove' their fidelity is not healthy, nor is the same as trusting them. So you can have all the access to his phone or his diary you want, but the point is that you take it on trust that they won't be unfaithful, not that they physically don't have the opportunity to. How could you possibly ever know whether they were being faithful because they wanted to, and not because they were unable under the watchful eye?

This. This is the standout thing for me. You can't trust him so what is the point of staying with him?

You see so many threads where a partner may/may not have cheated and people pile on to say "you need to get access to his phone" or "he needs to cut contact with her".

By the time you've got to the point of having to do surveillance on your partner's electronic communication the horse has well and truly bolted. A marriage is dead by that point.

Just leave with your dignity and self-esteem as intact as it can be.

NewBeginning39 · 08/11/2021 14:21

Infidelity is so painful, I’m sorry you’re going through this.

There’s a site/forum called “Surviving Infidelity” which is definitely worth a look. Excellent info and support from people who have/are going through it.

www.survivinginfidelity.com/

Revenge affairs/ONS are generally not a good idea. You currently have the moral high ground…hang on to it Flowers

scarpa · 08/11/2021 14:16

restoring their marriage and creating empathy

What has been broken when one party has cheated is your trust in him. You don't mend that by breaking his in you, by being all the things you're so angry at him for - selfishness, breaking the bond between you.

Hurting someone back when they've hurt you is not a rebalancing exercise like you think it is, it's the anger telling you you want them to feel as bad as you do. But bringing everyone down to the same level of hurt and anger is not the same as working to bring yourself back up.

I understand why you're so angry, I understand why you want him to hurt too. But either he does, and then you've done nothing but prove your marriage is now a moveable tool to be disregarded if it can be used to hurt the other in order to make a point, or he isn't hurt, and you've got further heartache to come.

I'd leave, if I were you. But if you're not going to, the biggest work that can be done here is on yourself, and how you feel.

You have to accept that:

  1. You can't prove a negative i.e. you will never, ever be able to fully know he's not cheating again, unless he never leaves the house, doesn't have a phone or access to the internet, etc. And you'll never be able to prove that he won't cheat again - even if he doesn't for a decade and you somehow had proof, he could still do so in future.
  1. Controlling our partner to 'prove' their fidelity is not healthy, nor is the same as trusting them. So you can have all the access to his phone or his diary you want, but the point is that you take it on trust that they won't be unfaithful, not that they physically don't have the opportunity to. How could you possibly ever know whether they were being faithful because they wanted to, and not because they were unable under the watchful eye?
  1. So a certain amount of uncertainty is always going to remain. That one day, he might have to go away for work, and you have to be able to go to sleep at night not assuming he might be up to something. That you can't - and shouldn't - check his phone's whereabouts on Find My iPhone, or whatever. Because then you don't trust him anyway. You have to be able to fully, properly believe that you can get settled and have a good night's sleep and that he isn't doing anything wrong.

Can you do that? It's a very, very hard thing to do - especially when someone has managed to conceal a years-long affair from you. If you truly think you can trust him again properly, without proof or certainty, then good luck and keep up the counselling. If you don't, do yourself the biggest favour you'll ever do and end it now, because the need for certainty will send you insane, and make you bitter and resentful (trust me!).

Kanaloa · 08/11/2021 14:15

I wouldn’t do this, all that does is lower you to his level. Then rather than you standing on principle he can say ‘well you also cheated.’

thepeopleversuswork · 08/11/2021 14:13

I don't think it will work tbh.

You may think you've matched him blow for blow but cheating on him won't deal with the fundamental lack of trust in your marriage or the resentment.

I have to say I think once you've got to this point the ship has sailed. I think you will only find closure and self-respect by moving on altogether. You say he is the love of your life but he clearly doesn't feel the same.

I think you will eventually get to the point where you realise you no longer love, respect or trust him and you should focus your energies on getting to that point, rather than tying yourself up in knots trying to punish him.

LaBellina · 08/11/2021 14:11

It might only prolong the marriage temporarily but will not save it.
You’ll never be able to trust him again after what he did and that’s the real issue. A temporary feel good revenge plan won’t give you the long term satisfaction to deal with that.