Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most people have forgotten about Afghanistan rather quickly

62 replies

KrispyKremeDream · 07/11/2021 22:23

Not really intending this as a guilt trip thread. I was just reading about the shooting of the Afghan women’s rights activist Frozan Safi this weekend and it occurred to me that I’ve not seen any discussion on here for weeks now. It was always going to die down and become accepted but it seems a bit sad that it’s disappeared off the radar so quickly.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2021 17:43

@PickUpAPepper

It was always going to drop off quickly, the U.K. and its media does not encourage interest in the world outside Sad. Nor in much else beyond buying shit to be honest.
Which media do you read / watch / listen to?

Out of interest

PickUpAPepper · 08/11/2021 17:43

@Elephantsparade

I used to learn about historical events and wonder how they happened. How other people sat by and let things go on. But as Ive got older Ive realised more and more that most people have minimum power or no power to change things. Then your brain sort of has to compartmentalise it or you go mad.
That’s true, we don’t have much power to change things even in Britain: and women seem to have no power anywhere to change men.
PickUpAPepper · 08/11/2021 17:39

It was always going to drop off quickly, the U.K. and its media does not encourage interest in the world outside Sad. Nor in much else beyond buying shit to be honest.

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2021 17:16

Talking about it on R4 now

Bit noisy here so not catching all of it

BigWoollyJumpers · 08/11/2021 15:05

Afghanistan is tribal in nature, they have no real national identity that takes priority and so no matter who is nominally in power, there is always a group resisting. The Taliban was the resistance when the US backed Afghan government ruled. The US backed Afghan government never really ruled all of Afghanistan, just the major cities and a few suburban areas. Over 55 million Afghans in rural areas were still ruled by the Taliban at the height of the US occupation

Absolutely. I have learnt so much from recent Afghani friend. The majority of Afghanis are subsistence farmers, illiterate, lack any education other than religious. They have no knowledge, nor interest, in the outside world, they only know of their current plight. The majority of those whom we hear from are from the cities, better educated, with an understanding of how the rest of the world lives, and what is normal and natural democracy. The Taliban have always had their power base in rural areas, and little or nothing is ever going to change the culture of those areas unless the tribal leaders say so, which in the majority they side with the Taliban.

toastofthetown · 08/11/2021 13:40

I haven't forgotten what's happening in Afghanistan. Same as I'm aware of what's happening in Yemen and Zimbabwe and Belarus and Xinjiang and Venezuela and Somalia and Haiti and North Korea and I could go on. Sadly for much of the world there isn't much happiness or any peace likely to be found in the near future. Outside of new circumstances (such as UK and US withdrawal from Afghanistan) or another developing story it ceases to be newsworthy and drops off the radar. I feel so helpless, but I'm not sure there's anything I can do about it.

eurochick · 08/11/2021 12:58

You are not wrong, OP.

However I am aware of a big project by a number of law firms to get judges out of Afghanistan and to safe countries. Many would have imprisoned Taliban fighters before they retook power and are now in danger.

fhghg47777ad · 08/11/2021 12:18

I am currently doing research on it and writing a book about it. Yes, people have moved on. I wouldn't like to speculate but would hazard a guess that this is at least in part due to the fact that the West (US) have essentially got out without caring too much about the aftermath. So I assume that there is plenty of political pressure on the media etc to simply move on. There's also COP26 and a myriad of other things going on internationally to focus on instead. Politicians only give interviews on things they would like to shed light on and highlight, the media will mostly report on things that sell or are 'news' - major Western international f* ups are not high on the agenda. In the actual fact, it was the same after 2014 when the US did a substantial withdrawal of its troops under Obama. Bu yes no one likes to be reminded of a failure....best not think about it

Cyw2018 · 08/11/2021 11:42

My friend, who is very politically active, said that on some things you just have to step away and stop reading the news articles otherwise the horror combined with the powerlessness will destroy you, and the current situation in Afghanistan is one of those times. I think sadly she is right.

Obviously if you are in an actual position to have any chance of fighting for individuals out there or for policy change (although that seems impossible) then please please keep fighting, but for the rest of us, it is a truely heartbreaking fact that there really is nothing we can do to help women, girls, families and allies of the West trapped in Afghanistan.

blackcurrantjam · 08/11/2021 11:39

Yanbu Sad

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/11/2021 11:39

There is a resistance though, the National Resistance Front, they will forever try to fight back, they just need the support.

Afghanistan is tribal in nature, they have no real national identity that takes priority and so no matter who is nominally in power, there is always a group resisting. The Taliban was the resistance when the US backed Afghan government ruled. The US backed Afghan government never really ruled all of Afghanistan, just the major cities and a few suburban areas. Over 55 million Afghans in rural areas were still ruled by the Taliban at the height of the US occupation.

“Support” would be selling arms and one lesson we have all learned by now is the selling of arms is profiteering off conflict and only results in more civilian deaths. In addition, to the Afghans foreign support taints the receiver and they are then viewed as “puppets” of the foreign power, especially if they win and end up ruling. There is always a new resistance in the wings waiting for their turn.

I think all we can do is have unlimited asylum for Afghans so that the people who manage to escape have places they can emigrate to legally. Depopulating the area may be the best way to collapse the Taliban.

MarshaBradyo · 08/11/2021 11:32

There’s a hard barrier all the funding has stopped as it can’t go to Taliban

International funding was very much relied upon and the country is running out of food

I just wanted to check figures so a Google came up with

Prior to the Taliban takeover, 80% of the Afghan government's budget was funded by the U.S. and other Western donors. Forty percent of its GDP came from international aid.

ftw163532 · 08/11/2021 11:27

@LadyAria

There is a resistance though, the National Resistance Front, they will forever try to fight back, they just need the support. They don't have that though because the world is currently in a fine line of accepting the Taliban but they need time to do this and so the resistance doesn't get the coverage it needs. It'll just be another showdown like before. World superpowers fighting it out in a no man's land they've decided should be Afghanistan and the poor civilian casualties mean nothing...
By support, do you mean weapons? Isn't decade after decade of pouring weapons into Afghanistan to support various resistance movements what caused this mess in the first place?
SeaOfGalilea · 08/11/2021 11:23

There's also been almost no mention in the media (I'm looking at you, BBC) of the persecution facing the Christian minority in Afghanistan, where being a Christian leaves you with 3 choices: keep your faith secret, flee or die. Being a Christian under the Taliban rule is simply not allowed, and Christians from a Muslim background may even be sectioned in a psychiatric hospital (as leaving Islam there is seen as a sign of insanity), or punished by death. Beatings, torture and kidnappings are routine for Afghan Christians, and converts to Islam are often killed by family members. Their deaths usually occur without public knowledge. The Taliban have been checking people's phones to see if Bibles are downloaded onto them, and lists with the names of Christians are being circulated. This is especially sad considering that Christianity in Afghanistan dates back to 2 AD.

LadyAria · 08/11/2021 11:15

There is a resistance though, the National Resistance Front, they will forever try to fight back, they just need the support. They don't have that though because the world is currently in a fine line of accepting the Taliban but they need time to do this and so the resistance doesn't get the coverage it needs. It'll just be another showdown like before. World superpowers fighting it out in a no man's land they've decided should be Afghanistan and the poor civilian casualties mean nothing...

ftw163532 · 08/11/2021 11:14

@Elephantsparade

I used to learn about historical events and wonder how they happened. How other people sat by and let things go on. But as Ive got older Ive realised more and more that most people have minimum power or no power to change things. Then your brain sort of has to compartmentalise it or you go mad.
I think this is it.

The world is filled with horror that for the most part none of us can do anything about. That's not for lack of caring.

NotMyselfWithoutCoffee · 08/11/2021 11:11

What can we do? We tried to help these people, they didn't want it hence the taliban rule.
Also we have our own problems with brexit etc, people going hungry in our own country, we can't help everyone.

LadyAria · 08/11/2021 11:10

It's depressing and upsetting. There was a recent case where 6-8 children, little orphans ranging from 18 months to about 8 were found dead from starvation. I'm Afghan and every day I feel an insurmountable guilt, the guilt that I got away and I'm safe living here whilst those back in Afghanistan are suffering this way.

Then you get the Taliban propaganda and some news channels showing them in a positive light which is a hard pill to swallow when we know their true evil nature.

Those children have been on my mind ever since, the fear in their last moments, I can't begin to fathom. The world has well and truly failed Afghanistan, no country or its people deserve anything like the catastrophic events that have happened there through this proxy war...

To be honest, a lot of Afghans have been campaigning to be heard, but at the same time for the sake of our mental health, quite a lot of us have shut down from it a bit, it's all too much to take and see, especially when we are not heard and cannot do anything about it.

The little girls being sold to disgusting filthy old perverts as wives is difficult to take, those dirty filthy men could have helped by just giving the damn money instead in that time of need. But that desperation meant those families had to sell their girls, the money will run out but the hole left by their daughters will never be replaced.

My heart feels heavy every day from all this.

KrispyKremeDream · 08/11/2021 11:08

I can't see any resolution either tbh. There's no way the general population have the means to overthrow the Taliban no matter how bad things get. In fact, as time goes on peoples ability to stage resistance will get worse as the focus becomes basic survival.

OP posts:
Elephantsparade · 08/11/2021 11:04

I used to learn about historical events and wonder how they happened. How other people sat by and let things go on. But as Ive got older Ive realised more and more that most people have minimum power or no power to change things.

Then your brain sort of has to compartmentalise it or you go mad.

Gardenlass · 08/11/2021 10:56

I haven't forgotten about them, their lives are sheer hell at the moment. I can't imagine how awful it must be with a Taliban government. But there is nothing that I can do about it. If there was something I could do, I'd do it, but there isn't.

HarrietsChariot · 08/11/2021 10:55

It's natural that people and the media have moved on from Afghanistan. We all know that human rights abuses will be taking place, girls will being denied an education, people will be getting shot for playing music (Greta Thunberg would no doubt add "blah, blah, blah"). News is very much here today, gone tomorrow, not for the people affected by it of course but for the people who read or watch it.

What do you actually want to happen? Being reminded of something over and over doesn't bring change. Do you want the US to re-invade? How would you persuade ordinary civilians to reject the Taliban and harder interpretations of Islam? As far as I can see the only way to make Afghanistan more westernised is for there to be troops on the ground and a proper war to elimate anyone who doesn't share western values. Is that acceptable? Many would say not.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/11/2021 10:54

I don’t think it’s a lack of caring per se.
It’s more that we cannot do anything to intervene and the fact that it’s not even safe for foreign press in Afghanistan so all we get are Taliban propaganda announcements

Yet another sensible post, Plan
We all know the situation's appalling, but there's only so much we can do when too many Afghans actively wanted this shower running the place. We've already spent so much in lives and money trying to make a difference, got no thanks for it, and if we interfere again we'll still be eveything that's wrong

Never mind though; there'll doubtless be an appeal for cash to help them, and that'll all end up in the hands of the Taliban too

Littleducks · 08/11/2021 10:52

There was a hugely distressing thread about girls from poor families being sold.... Maybe in feminism.

PlanDeRaccordement · 08/11/2021 10:45

I don’t think it’s a lack of caring per se.
It’s more that we cannot do anything to intervene and the fact that it’s not even safe for foreign press in Afghanistan so all we get are Taliban propaganda announcements.