Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation?

183 replies

Xmassprout · 07/11/2021 21:17

I bought some silks fans a little while ago to use for a portion of a dance routine. I've been looking online for inspiration and the vast majority of stuff I can see is connected to bellydancing.

After more investigating it seems that the fans didn't come from the origins of bellydancing but from other cultures. I've also seen that white women bellydancing is seen as cultural appropriation by many.

The routine I'm planning has no resemblance to belly dancing, the costume has no resemblance and hair and make up will be no resemblance. Would it still be cultural appropriation to use the fans?

Please don't jump on me!

IABU = don't use them, it's cultural appropriation
YANBU = use them as long as you're mindful

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 08/11/2021 16:37

They are when they are part of a cliched costume of another culture which is oppressed.

But not the plaits themselves.

Plaits as part of racist cosplay.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2021 16:33

@TheKeatingFive

Plaits while hopping around with feathers in your hair and crossed arms pretending to be First Nations?

It's not really plaits that are the problem there though.

They are when they are part of a cliched costume of another culture which is oppressed. When historically white people kidnapped FN children from their homes and chopped their plaits off. Which can signify death in some FN cultures.

Maybe avoiding it if you aren't a total arsehole. I mean you can do it. It's a free country. But empathy is a thing.

UsedUpUsername · 08/11/2021 16:30

Including whether a white teenage women should wear a chinese style dress to a prom, for example

The whole ‘Chinese-style’ dress thing is another absurdity.

For one, what outsiders think of as ‘Chinese’ dress is actually ethnic Machu—not only that, it’s ethnic Manchu with EUROPEAN tailoring. Those lines aren’t indigenous—there was never anything so form-fitting in the Han Chinese tradition.

Chinese clothing revival communities do Hanfu, which is an approximation of what people might have wore before the Qing dynasty

TheKeatingFive · 08/11/2021 16:30

Plaits while hopping around with feathers in your hair and crossed arms pretending to be First Nations?

It's not really plaits that are the problem there though.

Pashazade · 08/11/2021 16:27

OP, going back to original question and if you've managed to wade through the can of worms you inadvertently opened. Fan veils are not traditional Belly Dance props, I'm guessing they are appropriated from more Eastern forms of dance. I've used them many times as a Belly Dancer, they aren't traditional, but mostly no one cares. They add to the dance form and are great fun (one of my favourite props to use) Go for it. I don't believe dance itself can be culturally appropriated, dodgy stereotypes are not acceptable and I've seen a few of those performances in my time, but if you are performing with a love of the dance and making it your own it really doesn't matter what your original culture is. Oh and as a tip, keep the fan veils moving all the time, they look awful if you let them go "dead", take your movements all the way through from the shoulder rather than the wrist unless you're doing flutter effects. Plus don't be afraid to use them closed it adds an extra dimension and making sure one is left and one right handed can make it easier.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2021 16:27

If you have got to the point of thinking ' can I use a fan', I think you need to question the entire concept you have tbh.

That depends on context. There was a good discussion about plaits on another thread. Plaits are great and Europeans had them and we can wear them. Plaits while hopping around with feathers in your hair and crossed arms pretending to be First Nations? Really really not OK.

UsedUpUsername · 08/11/2021 16:26

white Irish people still have power over Irish people of colour

Lol this is the silliness you get when you copy-paste American racial politics onto other cultures.

Naunet · 08/11/2021 16:23

OP, it seems the very first fans were potentially from Europe anyway, so I think that’s clears you from being a terrible racist person for considering using one.

www.thefanmuseum.org.uk/fan-history

Pictorial records showing some of the earliest fans date from around 3000 BC and there is evidence that the Greeks, Etruscans and Romans all used fans as cooling and ceremonial devices

Helpsortmylife · 08/11/2021 16:17

[quote peachgreen]@helpsortmylife Of course - but it's better than not doing anything, right?[/quote]
If you have got to the point of thinking ' can I use a fan', I think you need to question the entire concept you have tbh.

Naunet · 08/11/2021 16:00

@peachgreen

I think the confusion is around the word oppression. To me the word oppression in this context, refers to systematic structures, not individual behaviour. But I guess that’s not how everyone sees it.

I see what you're saying. I would genuinely be interested in reading more research about how white women historically contributed to the oppression of Black people and ditto how Black men contributed to the oppression of women - like @MrsTerryPratchett pointed out, there are notable case studies. I suspect there would be evidence to support both arguments but it's not something I know enough about to be definitive either way.

I guess I see it this way, historically speaking UK black men for example, could be accused of oppressing black women, right? However, if white men had decided that actually, black women were the best group of people ever, and they deserved all the rights white men already had, black men couldn’t have done anything to stop that, because they had no power themselves. Does that make sense?

So white women had no chance to stop colonisation, it was out of their hands. Did they benefit from it? Absolutely. But we’re they responsible for it? No.

Riverlee · 08/11/2021 15:56

Was in the theatre recently and someone had a fan.

Helloise · 08/11/2021 15:56

OP your thread has turned into a really useful tool to reveal the blatant, ignorant racists - very handy!

peachgreen · 08/11/2021 15:55

I think the confusion is around the word oppression. To me the word oppression in this context, refers to systematic structures, not individual behaviour. But I guess that’s not how everyone sees it.

I see what you're saying. I would genuinely be interested in reading more research about how white women historically contributed to the oppression of Black people and ditto how Black men contributed to the oppression of women - like @MrsTerryPratchett pointed out, there are notable case studies. I suspect there would be evidence to support both arguments but it's not something I know enough about to be definitive either way.

peachgreen · 08/11/2021 15:53

@helpsortmylife Of course - but it's better than not doing anything, right?

peachgreen · 08/11/2021 15:52

@TheKeatingFive Yes, you're absolutely right - there are other power imbalances in those scenarios (which are, on balance, a bigger concern in Ireland) that aren't related to skin colour. Like you say, bringing Ireland into it is sort of an irrelevant distraction to the discussion at hand (although absolutely an interesting one).

Helpsortmylife · 08/11/2021 15:52

Apologies, I should have been clearer - I meant check with the relevant group. I actually was going to add about MN not being a great place to ask as it's overwhelmingly white, iirc

The relevant group? But how is that even possible? Ethnicities are not hive minds, any more than women are. There will be different views within an ethnicity on pretty much everything. Including whether a white teenage women should wear a chinese style dress to a prom, for example. Even in the unlikely event that each ethnicity were to set up a board where one could bring one's questions of ' is this appropriation?' to, they would still only be reflecting the views of those on the board.

Naunet · 08/11/2021 15:50

@peachgreen

And no, a group without power cannot oppress another group.

I get what you're saying, but surely that depends on the tool of oppression. White people - including women - can oppress people of colour. Men - including black men - can oppress women.

It’s really irritating to try and have an adult conversation about this and continuously getting called racist for it, even though I’ve said nothing racist.

I didn't call you racist?

Now days, yeah, absolutely, but historically? I think not.

I think the confusion is around the word oppression. To me the word oppression in this context, refers to systematic structures, not individual behaviour. But I guess that’s not how everyone sees it.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 08/11/2021 15:47

@VincaMinor

If you're English i"d play it safe if I were you and stick to Morris Dancing only.
Just don't wear a boater hat and tuxedo. That would be Maurice dancing.
TheKeatingFive · 08/11/2021 15:43

but white Irish people still have power over Irish people of colour.

As an Irish person, this feels like a distraction from useful argument, because until very recently there were almost no Irish people of colour.

A more interesting reflection on power dynamics in Ireland would be to look at oppression of Catholics by Protestants or the wholesale oppression of the travelling community. All white.

As for present day Ireland, I'd have a hard time justifying the view that Irish travellers have power over Irish people of colour. That wouldn't reflect the reality or historical power dynamics here at all. It would be a silly and irrelevant distraction.

Naunet · 08/11/2021 15:40

@elodie77

not relevant to the UK at all, we’re different countries with different histories.

Colonialism not relevant to the UK at all? Hmm

What are you talking about? American links about American politics or history are not relevant to the UK. I made that very clear.
VincaMinor · 08/11/2021 15:38

If you're English i"d play it safe if I were you and stick to Morris Dancing only.

peachgreen · 08/11/2021 15:35

Good god, white Eastern Europeans have been oppressed forever, by people of all sorts of different races. And closer to home, wasn’t Ireland colonised by the UK for hundreds of years? They were just as oppressed as any other colonised people, no?

Well again, there's a hierarchy. I actually live in Ireland and have an Irish daughter, and yes, absolutely Irish people have been oppressed by a colonising British force, but white Irish people still have power over Irish people of colour.

UsedUpUsername · 08/11/2021 15:34

@jcyclops

Is wearing the tribal headdress shown here cultural appropriation? Is it only so if it is made by a big organisation making big profits or if you wear it to a music festival where drugs are consumed? Is it only OK to do it with permission of or in association with a member of the tribe? Why do members of the tribe sell such things as souvenirs to visitors? Who is it oppressing?
Sezane was selling a really cute blouse with some tartan-clad Scottish people in a really cartoony style (something you’d expect to see on a shortbread tin)

How DARE the French try to profit from Scottish culture!

peachgreen · 08/11/2021 15:31

Oh my goodness, the arrogance in this! You clearly see yourself amongst the judges and arbiters of what is and is not acceptable for others to do.

Apologies, I should have been clearer - I meant check with the relevant group. I actually was going to add about MN not being a great place to ask as it's overwhelmingly white, iirc.

peachgreen · 08/11/2021 15:31

And no, a group without power cannot oppress another group.

I get what you're saying, but surely that depends on the tool of oppression. White people - including women - can oppress people of colour. Men - including black men - can oppress women.

It’s really irritating to try and have an adult conversation about this and continuously getting called racist for it, even though I’ve said nothing racist.

I didn't call you racist?