Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation?

183 replies

Xmassprout · 07/11/2021 21:17

I bought some silks fans a little while ago to use for a portion of a dance routine. I've been looking online for inspiration and the vast majority of stuff I can see is connected to bellydancing.

After more investigating it seems that the fans didn't come from the origins of bellydancing but from other cultures. I've also seen that white women bellydancing is seen as cultural appropriation by many.

The routine I'm planning has no resemblance to belly dancing, the costume has no resemblance and hair and make up will be no resemblance. Would it still be cultural appropriation to use the fans?

Please don't jump on me!

IABU = don't use them, it's cultural appropriation
YANBU = use them as long as you're mindful

OP posts:
Naunet · 08/11/2021 18:25

@elodie77

All we can do is acknowledge and learn from the past and find the best way to move forward together.

Good. Then stop denying that cultural appropriation is a problem.

For the third fucking time on this thread, I’m not, I’ve acknowledged it exists. 🙄

One last thing re Queen Victoria, during that time she actually had less and less power as the government took control - you know, the government that women couldn’t be part of….

elodie77 · 08/11/2021 18:21

All we can do is acknowledge and learn from the past and find the best way to move forward together.

Good. Then stop denying that cultural appropriation is a problem.

TheLikesofMe · 08/11/2021 18:19

What about the African people who were sold by their own leaders to the Arab slave trade for centuries?

Are the descendants of those African leaders victims or should they be grouped with the with the descendants of the oppressors?

Naunet · 08/11/2021 18:16

??? I mean, this confirms what I said! I didn’t say colonisation had stopped, I said slavery had been made illegal.

Look I understand this is clearly an upsetting topic for you, but please stop rushing to paint me as some heartless baddie! I don’t think my question about if one systematically oppressed group can systematically oppress another, is that crazy. It’s simply just debating ideas, there’s no agenda or hate there. None of us alive today were responsible for what went on back then, not a single one of us, and I highly doubt anyone here would wish to see it happen again. All we can do is acknowledge and learn from the past and find the best way to move forward together.

elodie77 · 08/11/2021 18:06

"Victoria reigned over the United Kingdom from 1837 until her death in 1901, a period marked by the unparalleled expansion of the British Empire, including continued expansion across what's now called Canada.

"Queen Victoria presided during some of the most brutal and expansive years of colonial history — when land was stolen the most, when things like the Indian Act [were] put into place," said Niigaan Sinclair, a Native studies professor at the University of Manitoba.

Adele Perry, the director of the Centre for Human Rights Research and a professor in the department of history at the U of M, says Queen Victoria and the British Empire had an "absolutely crucial role" in Canada's negotiation of treaties, residential schools and other systems that dispossessed Indigenous people.

In reality, the Crown oversaw boarding schools and mission schools that served to separate children from the Indigenous people of other parts of the British Empire, which served as examples for Canada's residential schools.

Victoria's legacy lives on through "terrible policies of violence that we still see happening today," Sinclair said, referring to government inaction when it comes to issues like poverty, violence and a lack of clean drinking water on First Nations."

Also this:

"The Slavery Abolition Act of 1833 formally freed 800,000 Africans who were then the legal property of Britain’s slave owners. What is less well known is that the same act contained a provision for the financial compensation of the owners of those slaves, by the British taxpayer, for the loss of their “property”. The compensation commission was the government body established to evaluate the claims of the slave owners and administer the distribution of the £20m the government had set aside to pay them off. That sum represented 40% of the total government expenditure for 1834. It is the modern equivalent of between £16bn and £17bn.

The compensation of Britain’s 46,000 slave owners was the largest bailout in British history until the bailout of the banks in 2009. Not only did the slaves receive nothing, under another clause of the act they were compelled to provide 45 hours of unpaid labour each week for their former masters, for a further four years after their supposed liberation. In effect, the enslaved paid part of the bill for their own manumission.

Slave ownership, it appears, was far more common than has previously been presumed. Many of these middle-class slave owners had just a few slaves, possessed no land in the Caribbean and rented their slaves out to landowners, in work gangs.These bit-players were home county vicars, iron manufacturers from the Midlands and lots and lots of widows. About 40% of the slave owners living in the colonies were women. Then, as now, women tended to outlive their husbands and simply inherited human property through their partner’s wills."

Naunet · 08/11/2021 17:56

White women's 'victimhood' oppresses, silences and excludes women of colour

Lastly, white women are native to Europe, we are fully entitled to talk about our history of being oppressed within Europe. It’s utterly bizarre to suggest we shouldn’t.

Naunet · 08/11/2021 17:53

@elodie77

For the record my arguments are:
  • Cultural appropriation by a dominant culture is very much a problem and denying it is a form of racism
  • Trying to disassociate yourself from the legacy of colonialism and slavery, which all people of Britain benefited from (and where complicit in) and continue to benefit from is either ignorant or shows your ingrained white privilege
  • White women's 'victimhood' oppresses, silences and excludes women of colour
Ok, firstly, you mentioned slavery and Queen Victoria, so just to clear that up, Queen Victoria came into power in 1837. Slavery had been made illegal in 1833. Just an interesting fact.

Secondly, I’m not denying cultural appropriation exists, or the Britain has a history of colonising other countries, like many other countries do too, it was a popular thing to do sadly. And of course women benefited from that, I’ve already said this in a previous post.

What I was debating and interested in, is the idea that an oppressed group (in this case, women) can systematically oppress another group (colonised countries). If you say they did, (which by the way, I’m open to) then surely you have to demonstrate that they could have stopped it if they’d wanted to?

elodie77 · 08/11/2021 17:48

For the record my arguments are:

  • Cultural appropriation by a dominant culture is very much a problem and denying it is a form of racism
  • Trying to disassociate yourself from the legacy of colonialism and slavery, which all people of Britain benefited from (and where complicit in) and continue to benefit from is either ignorant or shows your ingrained white privilege
  • White women's 'victimhood' oppresses, silences and excludes women of colour
AnyOldPrion · 08/11/2021 17:44

@Naunet

The whole thing is crazy What about black men dancing a Viennese Waltz, or Europeans of any sex dancing a Samba, Tango or Pasa Doble?

The dumbest thing I’ve ever seen on this topic was an idiot white American teacher saying she was going to stop teaching Spanish because it was appropriating Mexican culture 🙄
She’s seemed oblivious that the Spanish language comes from Spain, ie, a white country.

And also oblivious to the fact that it’s respectful to learn another language and attempt to use it. Far more respectful than assuming everyone else must speak English.

Sometimes I think the world has gone collectively mad. I hope it stops soon.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 08/11/2021 17:42

Can we talk about dance?

Would people have a problem with the Polovstian dances from the opera Prince Igor, where the costumes are markedly exotic/Orientalist? Putting aside the story of kidnapping, conquest and slavery (where the Khan was the aggressor, not the "white" Russians), do the costumes spoil anyone's enjoyment? I just see exquisite dancing and hear sublime singing.
m.youtube.com/watch?v=3ye4o2T0K3w

DPotter · 08/11/2021 17:34

I think you're over thinking this.

There was a language of the Fan during the late 1700/early 1800 - possibly originating in France but certainly in common usage in the British Isles.
Use the fan

TheLikesofMe · 08/11/2021 17:32

Your AIBU is to vote if you think you should use the fan with "mindfulness". How the fuck are you going to that then?

Sharpie a big apology on your head in case anyone should come along and have a fit of the vapours when they see you gyrating with an ancestral fan?

Or are you going to give out leaflets aforehand, inviting this imaginary offended person to tell you to drop the fan and leave yourself wobbling about with a feather duster?

Or are you going to lie down prostrate and apologise for being white?

Helpsortmylife · 08/11/2021 17:30

@elodie77

Naunet I've tried to engage with you but your silliness and ignorance makes it difficult. I think it says it all really about the chronically underfunded British education system.
The only thing I ever agreed with Margaret Thatcher on is when she said this,; 'I always cheer up immensely if an attack is particularly wounding because I think, well, if they attack one personally, it means they have not a single political argument left.'
Naunet · 08/11/2021 17:29

@elodie77

Naunet I've tried to engage with you but your silliness and ignorance makes it difficult. I think it says it all really about the chronically underfunded British education system.
You’ve made no valid points whatsoever - two of your posts literally just pointed to American articles like they were relevant. Tell me how European women could have stopped colonisation? Im genuinely interested.
elodie77 · 08/11/2021 17:14

Naunet I've tried to engage with you but your silliness and ignorance makes it difficult. I think it says it all really about the chronically underfunded British education system.

Naunet · 08/11/2021 17:14

@elodie77

It was men who colonised other countries, women didn’t hold any power themselves, so surely it wasn’t possible for them to oppress others? Discriminate, sure, but men were responsible for oppression and colonisation. So why must women be held accountable for the things men did?

You claim that women played no part in colonialism and oppressing other countries which is just rubbish. 'Women had no power' Hmm Queen Victoria?

By the way, you said I was denying history, this quote doesn’t show that, in fact it shows the complete opposite, that I acknowledge the history of colonisation. Maybe rather than jumping to outrage at anyone who doesn’t follow the new Approved Group Think, read what I actually wrote and mean.
Naunet · 08/11/2021 17:10

@elodie77

It was men who colonised other countries, women didn’t hold any power themselves, so surely it wasn’t possible for them to oppress others? Discriminate, sure, but men were responsible for oppression and colonisation. So why must women be held accountable for the things men did?

You claim that women played no part in colonialism and oppressing other countries which is just rubbish. 'Women had no power' Hmm Queen Victoria?

No, that’s not a claim, it was a question, that’s what a question mark means. And if you’re trying to say that because one woman became Queen by default, women as a class weren’t oppresses/held power, you’re being ridiculous.

By the way, I find it ironic that on a thread about cultural appropriation, you were trying to claim American history as the same as British. Isn’t that cultural appropriation too? We do not have the same culture or history as America, it would surely be appropriation to pretend we do?

elodie77 · 08/11/2021 16:58

It was men who colonised other countries, women didn’t hold any power themselves, so surely it wasn’t possible for them to oppress others? Discriminate, sure, but men were responsible for oppression and colonisation. So why must women be held accountable for the things men did?

You claim that women played no part in colonialism and oppressing other countries which is just rubbish. 'Women had no power' Hmm Queen Victoria?

Redcart21 · 08/11/2021 16:57

As a female POC, get a grip

Naunet · 08/11/2021 16:52

@elodie77

Naunet You should acknowledge and not try to distance yourself from the toxic legacy of colonialism in your country, which exploited other countries and benefited from slavery. The denial is just breathtaking.
Where have I denied that? Im very aware of British history thank you. All I’ve said to you is that American history and politics is not British history and politics. Sorry that offends you 🙄
TheNoonBell · 08/11/2021 16:52

Every culture borrows stuff from other cultures without it we wouldn't have made it out of the primordial forests and most of would never have eaten anything cooked as we wouldn't be able to use the next tribes new fangled fire. Farming and weaving would never have spread to europe 6000 years ago from the middle east.

Just think about that and then realise how utterly stupid this whole "cultural appropration" nonsense is.

Stop being so mock sensitive and start enjoying what other cultures can offer.

Helpsortmylife · 08/11/2021 16:50

@MrsTerryPratchett

If you have got to the point of thinking ' can I use a fan', I think you need to question the entire concept you have tbh.

That depends on context. There was a good discussion about plaits on another thread. Plaits are great and Europeans had them and we can wear them. Plaits while hopping around with feathers in your hair and crossed arms pretending to be First Nations? Really really not OK.

OP was never claiming to be an ethnicity other than her own Confused

That's totally irrelevant here!

elodie77 · 08/11/2021 16:48

Naunet You should acknowledge and not try to distance yourself from the toxic legacy of colonialism in your country, which exploited other countries and benefited from slavery. The denial is just breathtaking.

PolkadotsAndMoonbeams · 08/11/2021 16:43

or Europeans of any sex dancing a Samba, Tango or Pasa Doble?

The paso doble originated in France, based on the music from Spanish bullfights, so that one's probably ok!

To be honest, the international-style samba, tango etc danced competitively were codified so long ago (by Europeans) that they're functionally a whole different dance that shares a name and some rhythms.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2021 16:42

@TheKeatingFive

They are when they are part of a cliched costume of another culture which is oppressed.

But not the plaits themselves.

Plaits as part of racist cosplay.

Well yes, clearly. Which is what I said Hmm