Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation?

183 replies

Xmassprout · 07/11/2021 21:17

I bought some silks fans a little while ago to use for a portion of a dance routine. I've been looking online for inspiration and the vast majority of stuff I can see is connected to bellydancing.

After more investigating it seems that the fans didn't come from the origins of bellydancing but from other cultures. I've also seen that white women bellydancing is seen as cultural appropriation by many.

The routine I'm planning has no resemblance to belly dancing, the costume has no resemblance and hair and make up will be no resemblance. Would it still be cultural appropriation to use the fans?

Please don't jump on me!

IABU = don't use them, it's cultural appropriation
YANBU = use them as long as you're mindful

OP posts:
MorganKitten · 08/11/2021 21:00

A .or of drag and burlesque performers use different fans in their acts

VladmirsPoutine · 08/11/2021 20:56

Kim Kardashian and her family have pretty much built their entire fortune on cosplaying as different cultures/races, they even went so far as to have [redacted so I don't get deleted] Smile

Againstmachine · 08/11/2021 20:51

I have Russian ancestry and don't give a shiny.
You have misunderstood me, My point is not against you it's against Vlad'spoutine who I bet is neither

Motherofking · 08/11/2021 20:49

It’s not that deep. Even if you was belly dancing I don’t consider that to be cultural appropriation , more like cultural appreciation . Cultural appropriation would be if you became the face of belly dancing . For example when Kim Kardashian’s had her hair in braids the only reason why it was cultural appropriation is because she called it the derick braids . I believe Derick is a white actress who once wore those braids many years ago. However those braids had their own name ( which I forgot) and originated from Ghana . Cultural appropriation is stealing someone else’s culture or making money out of it especially when the original owners don’t. That’s my opinion on this

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2021 20:47

@Againstmachine

Someone who has a Russian name and a Canadian dish should be ignored.
I have Russian ancestry and don't give a shiny.
Againstmachine · 08/11/2021 20:42

Someone who has a Russian name and a Canadian dish should be ignored.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2021 20:39

It's bloody tedious.

It is that! And the wilful reductio ad absurdum (other spellings are available) is tiresome. So if I think someone wearing a full FN headdress to Cochinella is offensive I have to think a black woman getting highlights is too.

VladmirsPoutine · 08/11/2021 20:35

@MrsTerryPratchett Yes. And then they'll spout something like "Well my English ancestors in 1348 did xyz therefore it's not appropriation oh and Black women sometimes wear blonde wigs so nah nah nah". It's bloody tedious.

Againstmachine · 08/11/2021 20:34

Do you mean doing the appropriation Vlad?

My suspicion is that Vlad has culturally appropriated that name.

Theluggage15 · 08/11/2021 20:30

Trans people are the biggest appropriators out there so very funny to see people moaning about transphobia. Although I’ve never seen that on mumsnet just people sticking up for women’s rights.

Keepitnerdy · 08/11/2021 20:28

Education is part of the journey between appropriation and appreciation <a class="break-all" href="http://m.middleeasterndance.net/?url=www%2Emiddleeasterndance%2Enet%2Fmovements%2Fprops%2Fotherprops%2Ffans%2Ehtml#2872" rel="nofollow" target="_blank">m.middleeasterndance.net/?url=www%2Emiddleeasterndance%2Enet%2Fmovements%2Fprops%2Fotherprops%2Ffans%2Ehtml#2872

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2021 20:25

@VladmirsPoutine

It is always white women pulling these stunts then crying when they inevitably get criticised for it. Rinse repeat.
Do you mean doing the appropriation Vlad?
VladmirsPoutine · 08/11/2021 20:20

It is always white women pulling these stunts then crying when they inevitably get criticised for it. Rinse repeat.

Siameasy · 08/11/2021 20:17

Also the Japanese enjoyed empire-building if you want to dress as Geisha go for it. In any case, the Japanese love things from other cultures and will probably be cancelled when N Americans realise this.
Currently, US internet using persons don’t even realise Japan tried to invade Hawaii. “What! A non-European colonial power?! Impossible. They’re meant to be oppressed victims according to me”

Xmassprout · 08/11/2021 20:16

Just to clarify, these are the fans I'm talking about

Thankyou everyone for your diverse opinions, even those just telling me to get a grip. Probably does seem really stupid to some people, I just tend to be a massive overthinker and worrier.

Cultural appropriation?
OP posts:
Againstmachine · 08/11/2021 20:05

Yep the ottomans loved a bit of colonising, and also explains the make ups in many countrys such as Albania and Yugoslavia

PlanktonsComputerWife · 08/11/2021 20:04

@Siameasy

Belly dancing is very popular in Turkey and the Ottomans were big mean colonisers so you are safe as the two cancel each other out Wink
That's all very well, but that means that given Genghis Khan's antics we can all merrily Mongolian throat marble away, and the fact is I just can't.🎻
Siameasy · 08/11/2021 20:00

Belly dancing is very popular in Turkey and the Ottomans were big mean colonisers so you are safe as the two cancel each other out Wink

Againstmachine · 08/11/2021 19:58

A lot of cultural appropriation talk is load of bollocks, a woman wearing a Chinese dress (which in reality isn't very Chinese dress anyway) isn't cultural appropriation same as a black woman dieing her hair blond and straightening it, do you think Lisa on insta is really opressing anyone

Againstmachine · 08/11/2021 19:55

What about the African people who were sold by their own leaders to the Arab slave trade for centuries?

They were still selling Africans to America as well, Black Africans were heavily involved with supplying to the slave trade through various century's.

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 08/11/2021 19:53

@elodie77

Helloise I agree with you. There appears to be, as you say, quite a crowd of Daily Mail readers on MN these days who start off spouting transphobic comments in the name of women's rights but who often also make racist comments such as denying cultural appropriation and make themselves as white women somehow the victims, who complain about 'woke culture' and someone even posted about 'benefit scroungers' here recently.
This. I loathe the transphobic element on MN, where the fuck did that come from? And do not get me started on the stealth boasting about mahoosive wages and private school ugh
HomeSliceKnowsBest · 08/11/2021 19:48

Who gives a crap? They are fans. Do whatever. Only utter arseholes bang on about cultural appropriation.

Almostmenopausal · 08/11/2021 19:29

So by that logic, a bunch of white dance students doing a Bollywood dance would be 'seen as cultural appropriation!' Hmm

What the HELL have we turned into?????

Naunet · 08/11/2021 19:12

@bigvig

Not all black people are oppressed victims - what a patronising racist view that is. What about black leaders who sold their own people into slavery. What about Arab slave traders. What about the Japanese empire builders. Not all white people benefitted from colonisation - what about Poor Irish and Italian migrants living up to 4 families in a damp cellar. What about the poor houses and child prostitutes. Stop trying to simplify human existence.
Exactly. History is nuanced. Oppression of women was HUGE, that’s half of Europe in one go, but class was also a massive oppression point, as was European countries trying to colonise each other at certain points in history!

The Irish never colonised anyone, but still get lumped in with the “bad white people”.

It’s sad, because women in almost every country around the world have been oppressed at some point, and women of all races are sold into slavery today but instead of standing united, we’re arguing about if it’s ok to use a fan in a dance. That’s why I think a lot (NOT ALL) of cultural appropriation is first world bollocks.

bigvig · 08/11/2021 18:58

Not all black people are oppressed victims - what a patronising racist view that is. What about black leaders who sold their own people into slavery. What about Arab slave traders. What about the Japanese empire builders. Not all white people benefitted from colonisation - what about Poor Irish and Italian migrants living up to 4 families in a damp cellar. What about the poor houses and child prostitutes. Stop trying to simplify human existence.