Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cultural appropriation?

183 replies

Xmassprout · 07/11/2021 21:17

I bought some silks fans a little while ago to use for a portion of a dance routine. I've been looking online for inspiration and the vast majority of stuff I can see is connected to bellydancing.

After more investigating it seems that the fans didn't come from the origins of bellydancing but from other cultures. I've also seen that white women bellydancing is seen as cultural appropriation by many.

The routine I'm planning has no resemblance to belly dancing, the costume has no resemblance and hair and make up will be no resemblance. Would it still be cultural appropriation to use the fans?

Please don't jump on me!

IABU = don't use them, it's cultural appropriation
YANBU = use them as long as you're mindful

OP posts:
ABCeasyasdohrayme · 09/11/2021 13:16

I totally agree with that post @elodie77. Not virtue signalling at all, just facts.

elodie77 · 09/11/2021 13:01

Go on, Alfonso, why virtue signalling? Do you think I have no skin in the game? Unpick my post and explain what you disagree with and why.

AlfonsoTheUnrepentant · 09/11/2021 12:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Helpsortmylife · 09/11/2021 11:58

@Impier

This whole conversation is utterly, barking mad, with people tying themselves in linguistic knots trying to justify their own internal bigotry. It's fascinating.
The thing with comments like this, is its impossible to know which side you are talking about. Either side can, I am sure, feel justified in looking at the other and finger pointing with this.
Impier · 09/11/2021 11:56

This whole conversation is utterly, barking mad, with people tying themselves in linguistic knots trying to justify their own internal bigotry. It's fascinating.

Xenia · 09/11/2021 10:06

I wonder who can have a monopoly on the work suit for men in that case. Perhaps we can start only allowing British people to wear it to work if their ancestors are from the right place.

These kinds of things which divide us up rather than join us always tend to be a bad thing.

oldwhyno · 09/11/2021 09:29

"cultural appropriation" is almost always bullshit and it can usually fuck right off.

We live in a modern multi-cultural society. A true melting pot. People need to get over it.

So YANBU = use them as long as you're mindful

PlanktonsComputerWife · 09/11/2021 09:18

I don't know. But the notion of cultural appropriation does seem rooted in monoculturalism.

I see a place for criticising Lego and Disney for exploiting Māori and Pasifika culture for figurines, that awful Moana movie and so on.

But haranguing people for exploring dance forms? How is that not an anti-culture stance?

UsedUpUsername · 09/11/2021 09:15

@peachgreen

But the modern world has been overwhelmingly shaped by white colonialism

Wow, what a myopic worldview. The Mongolian invasions alone changed the face of the East and Central Asia along with parts of Russia and Eastern Europe. The end of the Islamic Golden Age was due to Mongolian destruction—big implications that are still felt today.

India, too, was massively impacted by Mongolian invasions (Mughal dynasty lol).

In more recent times, Japanese colonialism brutalised East Asian countries, it still impacts East Asian relations to this day! (Ask any Chinese person how they feel about Japan’s apologies for
their wartime atrocities, it’s still very raw even as it is almost out of living memory)

Doesn’t stop Japanese girls from wearing ‘China dressu’ and not caring about Japanese soldiers bayoneting literal babies in Nanjing and elsewhere (and nor should they, they have nothing to do with their ancestor’s sins, it’s purely a political matter at this point).

Moreover, I’ve never heard any Chinese person complain about cultural appropriation by the Japanese. For one, the Japanese have appropriated Chinese culture from time immemorial, and from their POV it’s completely natural to rip off their ‘superior culture’.

On the other hand, they do get big mad when Japan is credited with something they actually invented, which tends to happen quite a lot 😂

Heidi1976 · 09/11/2021 09:01

Genuine question - why are we so open and fluid with constructs such as gender but apparently culture is off the table?

DillonPanthersTexas · 09/11/2021 08:52

The grievance industry needs feeding this morning it seems.

gogohm · 09/11/2021 08:44

@Helloise

I get what you are saying which is why I have no issues wearing my kimono as it's a gift from my Japanese friends mother, real silk!

SammyScrounge · 09/11/2021 08:41

Poor OP. She only asked about a fan.

Pottedpalm · 09/11/2021 08:35

Little Chinese girls excelling in Irish dancing? Fine by me . Just who are they to ‘ask permission’ from?
The whole thing is bloody ridiculous, in my opinion. Wear braids, belly dance, have a teepee in your garden. One world; on the way to being a beautiful melting pot of races and cultures.

TheKeatingFive · 09/11/2021 08:12

I’m sure everyone knows the difference between being offensive about other cultures and just borrowing things in appreciation.

Quite. I don't think I've come across an example of problematic behaviour that wasn't simply racism (or very occasionally fraud).

There's no need for an additional term that mostly serves to tie people in knots over perfectly innocent practices.

Guavaf1sh · 09/11/2021 07:56

The people who bore others to death with cultural appropriation bolox are almost always the most unintentionally racist people there are

Cheeserton · 09/11/2021 07:50

Pretty much the entire world 'culturally appropriates'. The constant self-flagellation in the west around this is such total nonsense. It's not a white thing, nor a black thing, nor an Asian thing. Enough with this bollocks. We all are influenced by other cultures and always will be.

Theluggage15 · 09/11/2021 07:42

I’m sure everyone knows the difference between being offensive about other cultures and just borrowing things in appreciation. The middle class policing of this subject is just patronising.

Kayo123456 · 09/11/2021 07:04

I’m from a belly dancing culture and would not be fussed at all in fact happy that other people appreciate the culture. I know your choreograph’s not belly dancing but I’d love to see it!

Draggondragon · 09/11/2021 06:15

Do what you want to. CA isn't an actual real thing, just another wokery malarkey.

silentpool · 09/11/2021 05:54

I'm pretty sure most cultures agreed that keeping cool was a good idea, so you'll be fine, OP. Cultures have been nicking good ideas from each other for ages - I see it as a compliment, rather than a problem - unless it's mockery or disparagement.

UsedUpUsername · 09/11/2021 05:35

@VladmirsPoutine

It is always white women pulling these stunts then crying when they inevitably get criticised for it. Rinse repeat.
Whine more.

This bs will only stop, btw, once we ignore irrelevant opinions like the above.

MrsTerryPratchett · 08/11/2021 23:24

@IreneIddesleigh

Do what you want, or don't, if you're too worried about what someone else might think. The trick is to recognise that cultural appropriation is a stupid concept. Ignore people who take it upon themselves to police such silly things as bellydancing, fan dances, and which hairstyles are 'allowed' for which races/ethnicities.
You think there's no issue someone dressing up as a caricature of another persons culture. Maybe throwing in some offensive stereotypes while they're at it.

For my cultures that would be ginger haired Jock in a kilt saying och aye the noo and two handed drinking. Maybe a Polish person stealing jobs? Irish all in green saying diddly dai. And going on about leprechauns. Ha fucking ha. I suppose if you're only English it's a bowler hat and tea and crumpets so not quite as shit.

But if you're Jamaican or Indigenous and all that's depicted is the lazy shitty stereotype you might get a bit peeved. Can you think what that might be like for a second?

IreneIddesleigh · 08/11/2021 23:00

Do what you want, or don't, if you're too worried about what someone else might think. The trick is to recognise that cultural appropriation is a stupid concept. Ignore people who take it upon themselves to police such silly things as bellydancing, fan dances, and which hairstyles are 'allowed' for which races/ethnicities.

PlanktonsComputerWife · 08/11/2021 22:43

Rudolf Nureyev in excerpts from Le Corsaire, in an undeniably Orientalist outfit, in a French ballet based on an English poem.

Is this costume problematic? Nureyev was of Tartar stock, therefore Turkic- does that change the answer?

You'd have to be a maniac to want Nureyev to put a top on, either way, wouldn't you?

m.youtube.com/watch?v=mFOCsmx6UMw&t=56s