Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to delay 7yr old DD getting ears pierced until she’s 12

207 replies

Whosthebestbabainalltheworld · 07/11/2021 19:12

DD (7) went to a birthday party today where one of the girls got her ears pierced as a birthday present. Cue the inevitable.

I’ve said not until she’s 12. Am I just totally not with it? I don’t have any massive objections, but I was about that age myself and being totally honest, I think they look a bit cheap on small girls - and for saying that out loud I’m sure I will burn in mumsnet hell.

OP posts:
Glitterblue · 07/11/2021 21:38

DD asked to have hers done when she saw others with them around that age and we said no. She's now 11 and says she might never want them done - so I'm glad we said no back then!

Opal93 · 07/11/2021 21:37

I got mine done when I was 8 after weeks and weeks of pestering. When I was 12 I wanted my top of ear done, my mum said no so i done it myself with a safety pin! No idea how it didn’t get infected and it’s still ok now! I always liked the idea of getting one of my sons lobes pierced as a toddler but decided against it as there’s no way in hell he would leave it alone and he would probably have caused an infection. My friends daughter got her two year olds done and had to take her to a&e because she pulled her earring out and ate it! But 7 is old enough to have the sense to leave it alone and understand they need looked after and cared for properly. It’s totally up to you though. If you would prefer to stick to 12 as the agreed age or reach a compromise , maybe 9 or 10. I would suggest getting it done at the beginning of summer holidays and then they will be healed in time for school starting, as I don’t agree with them being worn in school as a safety risk

DowntonCrabby · 07/11/2021 21:35

As a parent you can do literally whatever you want, we didn’t bow to the peer pressure for ear piercings, suggested at 11 we’d be ok with it, DD ended up delaying until 13 and “ALLLLLL” of her friends were done by then. She’s about to have a second hole done this weekend approaching 17 and we now see it as she can choose for herself.

I agree it’s got to be about looking after the piercings themselves so 7 too young but maybe 12 is a tad too old.

I don’t think cheap/tacky is a shitty/judgemental attitude I think holes in tiny children is abuse though.

museumum · 07/11/2021 21:32

I wasn’t allowed till 13/14 and I was MISERABLE about it in the first years of secondary. I felt like such an odd one out and was so so upset about it.
I don’t have girls but if I did I would allow it the summer between primary and secondary.

Coronado2 · 07/11/2021 21:29

@DroopyClematis

The trouble with having piercings at a young age is that earrings cannot be worn during PE. They have to be removed by the child.

Some schools may give a plaster to cover them but you'll get parents saying that it's unfair, or that it hurts to remove the plasters, etc... ( despite the pain of the piercing!🙄)

Older children are more likely to be able to remove their piercings.

Our school don't make you remove them for pe. Small studs are fine..
ohtwatbollocks · 07/11/2021 21:29

My daughter had hers done in August, she's 8 and she doesn't look cheap! She's looked after them impeccably well and they've healed beautifully.

PuzzledObserver · 07/11/2021 21:25

I think they look icky on little children. I think that’s because I associate adornment with sexuality and therefore not appropriate on prepubescent children.

MrTulkingIsFeelingHorny · 07/11/2021 21:23

OP, I agree that they look cheap, and I judge parents who let young children have their ears pierced (or, worse, inflict it on their young children).

YANBU.

StrychnineInTheSandwiches · 07/11/2021 21:21

@Kite22

I'm not a fan of earrings on little kids, but in my opinion a sensible 9 or 10 year old is old enough to decide. I've no doubt someone will come along and say they'd ban their child from earrings until they're 16, and I sincerely hope they get a lovely rebellious child who sticks two fingers up at that level of control

and that says more about you than people who do not want to give consent for their child to be pierced.

obviously it's about me. it's my opinion. that's how this works.

I do think people saying they'd ban their child from getting their ears pierced until they're 16 sound ridiculously controlling.

DramaLlllama · 07/11/2021 21:20

DD’s school do not allow earrings until they start high school so thankfully this conversation will be easily shut down on our house. But I agree with you OP. Even without the school rule, DD would have to wait until the summer holiday between primary and high.

Kite22 · 07/11/2021 21:20

I'm not a fan of earrings on little kids, but in my opinion a sensible 9 or 10 year old is old enough to decide. I've no doubt someone will come along and say they'd ban their child from earrings until they're 16, and I sincerely hope they get a lovely rebellious child who sticks two fingers up at that level of control

and that says more about you than people who do not want to give consent for their child to be pierced.

plantastic · 07/11/2021 21:18

I'm tempted by 16 for the consent reasons mentioned above. My mum said 13 to me- they were done with a gun and never even, and were manky all the time for years. I never wear earrings now. The holes are closed i think.

I'm not anti piercing (I also had my nose, eyebrow and labret pierced, properly with a needle) but i don't wear any piercings now and if I'm honest would rather not have the scars. 16 is old enough to comprehend that and for me not to take the decision for them.

couchparsnip · 07/11/2021 21:18

DD got them at the end of year 5, so 10.5 years old. She could manage them OK by herself at that point.
It's easier to get them done over the summer holidays without school PE lessons to manage.

Dddccc · 07/11/2021 21:13

Its tacky on young kids i was 16 12 id about the right age

Namechange12312 · 07/11/2021 21:04

I let my oldest DD get hers pierced age 6 - she had been asking for 2 years straight and I figured it’s her body and she clearly wanted them. We watched videos of children getting theirs pierced so she was aware it would hurt and discussed how they needed to be cared for. She looked after them herself (under supervision) and was quite capable of taking them in and out for PE etc.

Cue my youngest DD asking for hers at 6 too. I did let her without too much thought as her sister had been fine but I do wish we had waited. She isn’t as confident in caring for them and has never once taken them out as she is too frightened.

In a nutshell, its very child dependant and if you don’t feel she is ready then that’s fine. If it’s because you personally have age 12 in your head for no good reason then I think that’s a bit mean imo. I expect a lot of her friends will have already had it done by the time they leave primary (my mum made me wait until I was 13 and I was the last of my friends, and remember feeling quite embarrassed about it!).

FlyingPandas · 07/11/2021 21:04

YANBU OP.

Age 11/12 (basically the summer holidays before starting secondary) makes far more sense.

Tbh round here it would be pointless getting them done any earlier as earrings are just not allowed at our primary school. Any child coming to school in earrings is made to take them out and put them in an envelope until home time.

Chelyanne · 07/11/2021 21:04

We let our eldest get them done at 10 and I regret it now, was done with gun. I will encourage the other girls to wait until they are 18. Eldest now wants her nose doing but I've told her not until 18 which just over 2 years away.

frogswimming · 07/11/2021 21:02

Do you have to remove tiny studs for PE? I'm sure when I was at school you were allowed to leave them in.

I had mine done at 12 or 13. I'd be happy with any age after 10 if they ask.

My Spanish friend told me the nurses actually do it in the hospital where the baby is born there. Earrings are a traditional new baby present. So yabu to associate it with trying to make children look older.

I think its fine on little girls but I personally couldn't be bothered with the faff of looking after my dd ears and I'd rather wait till she actually wants it and asks me. I probably used to think it was tacky but I'm much less judgemental nowadays.

zoemum2006 · 07/11/2021 20:56

My rule was once you have left primary school.

You need to be able to care for your ears independently before you can have them pierced (in my opinion).

BonesInTheOcean · 07/11/2021 20:56

@hopingbutlosing

Not expensive??

Did you mean to be dense? It's bloody obvious what the op means

I'm sure we all actually know what the OP means, but it's not a nice way to refer to a 7 year old.

She wasnt referring to an actual 7 year old, just the fact of piercing their ears.
Echobelly · 07/11/2021 20:53

Oldest had theirs done for 8th birthday, having asked for them - I think they look a bit tacky on kids who are clearly too young to ask for it themselves, but I'd say 7+ they can understand it and it looks OK. But if you want to make 12 a rule, that's up to you.

LuaDipa · 07/11/2021 20:50

Yanbu.

Dd (13) wanted hers piercing at that age, also because a girl in her class had them. I put my foot down and said no but I would consider again when she moved up to secondary school. Now she lives in baggy, boyish clothing and would be mortified to have something so girly adorning her. I would wait until she’s old enough to know what she wants long term.

TeachesOfPeaches · 07/11/2021 20:50

I had mine done was I was 7 months old.

PanicStationsAhh · 07/11/2021 20:49

YANBU at all, they do look horrid on primary aged children imo. It also links in for me with the constant drive to make young girls into mini adults: crop tops, make up, heels for small children whose feet are still growing, etc. My young DDs are not adults, I don't let them act or dress like them so why would I let them have piercings?

honeylulu · 07/11/2021 20:44

Define "cheap" please

I assume in the "poor white trash" sense. HTH

To those asking why 11-12 makes more sense than a younger age:
More likely to be Gillick competent.
Long summer holiday between primary and secondary for healing.
More likely to be able to remove for OR unassisted.